[NSFW] COMPASS OF TRUE LOVE - CHAPTER 35

Chapter 35: If you told me a month ago that I’d ever get fucked by my girlfriend while my other girlfriend gets fucked by my future girlfriend…

-Sephie-

Her hot breath still lingered on my ear when she closed the gap and gently bit at my earlobe. An involuntary yelp escaped me and Cassie giggled softly before moving further down, kissing along my neck, collarbone, breasts, belly, pubes and then finally… my thighs? What? No no no! Cassie you’re supposed to-

She planted a kiss right on top of my clit, cutting off my entire thought process. “Mmmm” I moaned needily. One of my hands wandered down to her head and gently nudged her against my slick pussy.

Her lips met my clit again and this time her tongue flickered out afterwards, flipping against my sensitive nub, trailing around it. Short waves of pleasure tingled through me and I started grinding my hips against Cassie’s mouth.

“Fop mowin fow mof!” she mumbled into my folds, the vibrations of her voice teasing out another loud moan from me.

“Fuck, Cassie! Oh please ‘talk’ more, that feels amazing!”

Cassie fought against my grip on her head and separated from my pussy to shoot me an annoyed look.

“I said: Stop moving so damn much!” She slung her arms around my legs, pinning my lower body in place and moved back to my dripping wet slit.

Her tongue ran across my folds, parting them only the tiniest bit and a very faint moan hummed out of Cassie as she savoured my juices for the first time.

From the other side of the wall, Nydia‘s own muffled moans cried out again, accompanied by loud smacks of flesh against flesh and the creaking of their already strained bed.

Cassie was spurned on further by the moans from my other girlfriend and began fucking me in earnest. Her tongue pushed in between my lips, moving past the threshold separating her from being on or being inside me. She explored my insides thoroughly, licking against my slick walls, searching desperately for any spots that tickled a stronger reaction out of me.

It didn‘t take her long to find some and her hands were soon straining against my thighs, fighting against my involuntary shakes and quivers.

„Fuck Cassie!“ I moaned out. „Yes! Right there! Mmm!“ More and more of that familiar warmth shook through me, rising further and further up my body with every shake that rocketed through me.

On the other side of the wall, we could hear Nydia growing close to orgasm as well, her cries of pleasure growing louder by the moment.

„I‘m- fuck! I‘m close Sephie!“ Nydia moaned shakily, spurning Cassie on even more. She brushed her tongue against another sensitive spot and curled it around there, welling up wave after wave of pleasure within me.

I could feel the orgasm rising, just as Nydia‘s moans became entirely unstable. Cassie‘s grip on my thighs loosened and I began rolling my hips against her beautiful face. Her eyes darted up towards me, first a warning look, but then they quickly warped into a coy glimmer, as if she was trying to eyefuck the orgasm out of me.

It partially worked, I shot towards the edge faster than before – the rare confidence in Cassie‘s gaze definitely did something for me – but Nydia was still there before me.

„Fuck! Sephie I- I can‘t- hold it!“ Cassie became frantic, no doubt panicking and trying her hardest not to ruin the moment Nydia had so carefully set up. Gently, I cupped her head again and pushed her further into me once more, grinding my lower lips against her upper ones. Her right hand let go of my thigh entirely and darted over to my abandoned clit. She brushed against it at first, but then immediately shifted to rub and pinch it slightly, at the same time pressing her tongue in against the most difficult to reach spot within me.

I let out a yelp of surprise, pain and pleasure at the same time. My back arched up again, my leg muscles spasming – turning the grinding of my hips into uncontrolled rutting – warmth flooded through me and coalesced into a strong powerful wave that shook out every fibre of my body. The orgasm tore through me, erratically moaning and crying through that peak just as Nydia was starting to climb off hers.

With one final moan, I collapsed on the bed, breathing heavily. My eyes trailed down between my legs, finding Cassie‘s smug, lust-filled face resting on my abdomen, glancing up to me with an enraptured look in her eyes.

I trailed my fingers through her messy brown hair and slowly drew her up towards me until her head rested on my chest.

“That was amazing, Cassie,“ I sighed, brushing through her hair and twirling one of her renegade locks between my fingers.

Her smug look turned into a genuine smile as she hugged me close.

„What about you Nydia?“ I asked in a slightly louder tone to get through our shared wall.

There was silence for a moment, then, another voice answered in her stead. „She passed out I think?“ Shyleen piped up.

My face immediately went crimson red. I had completely zoned out just who had been responsible for coaxing out those orgasms out of her this entire time. Oh gods all the images were now flitting through my already lust addled mind… With a shake, I steadied my thoughts again.

„W- well. Seems like she‘s had a good time then,“ I replied, formally sounding.

A duo of giggles, one from my chest and the other from the other room, rose up and I buried my face in Cassie‘s hair in shame.

„You don‘t understand!“ I whispered to her. „She‘s so… big and intimidating and sexy and big and-„

She cut me off. „Yeah, yeah. Big woman hot, I understand.“ Her eyes tailed off slightly and a soft blush settled on her face. „Oh gods do I understand,“ she added, almost voiceless.

„Is that a blush I see on your face, Cassie?“ I whispered directly into her ear. „Are you having naughty thoughts again? I can‘t help but notice that one of us is still entirely unfucked…“

Her breath hitched and she let out a soft eek, which I promptly used to take over entirely, pushing myself up and throwing the timid girl on her back. I pinned her down into the mattress, letting my eyes crawl over form. The just-so-confident girl now looking up at me, meekly, expectantly.

„Do you want me to touch you, Cassie?“ I asked. I needed her assurance, remembering how she spiralled out about this exact same scenario earlier.

Her own eyes tailed up and down my body, finally flicking back up to look me in the eyes. Biting her lip, she nodded lightly. „I- I definitely want it,“ she whispered.

I smirked down at her, then slowly began pulling up the loose off-white shirt she was wearing. She helped me get it out from under her and I proceeded to sling it over to the other clothes on the dresser.

My gaze fell back on her now-naked breasts. I gently traced my fingers over her curves, neck, across her collarbone, the side of her chest, down to her hips and resting on her thighs. Her boobs were bigger than Nydia‘s and mine, but her hips were much thinner than the ones of my other girlfriend. She all made up for it with her thighs, though. Not only were they thick, they were muscular from all those hours riding as well.

I grasped the inside of her left thigh firmly and squeezed the toned flesh. Cassie squirmed slightly and one of her hands darted in between her legs, covering her yet-to-be-uncovered womanhood. I trailed my fingers back up, lowering my head next to hers as I grabbed onto her breasts.

„You like this, don‘t you?“ I whispered into her ear. „Being putty in my hands?“

She moaned softly as my hands kneaded her chest, inching closer and closer to her nipples. Just as I was about to touch her hardened nubs, I pressed my lips against her neck and began sucking fiercely. Then my fingers pinched and rubbed against her nipples. The sudden assault from so many directions pitched her moans loudly, crying almost as much as I did when she was eating me out.

To be fair, she had never been touched like this before, I assumed.

Her legs wrapped around me while I worked away at her neck and breasts, her hips beginning to grind against me.

„S- Sephie! Please!“ she moaned.

With a pop, I released her neck, leaving a prominent hickey – revenge for the spattering of fainter ones she left on my chest. I also released one of her breasts and let my hand crawl down her lithe body, slowly, enjoying every inch as her breath became more and more rugged, expectant, yearning.

„Please!“ she squirmed again, pressing her crotch into my leg. „I- I‘m so horny, please Sephie fuck me!“

I couldn‘t hold back the wide grin splitting my face and let my voyaging hand trail down between her legs, pressing against her pussy through the soaking wet panties. Her eyes almost glazed over and she threw back her head as the pleasure of my first touch coursed through her.

„Well… since you asked so nicely,“ I whispered in her ear again, watching my hot breath tingle against her skin.

My fingers, with their newly gained expertise – thanks to Nydia‘s lovely excessive stamina, deftly snuck into her panties and ran through her folds in one fluid motion. Cassie shuddered and let a series of shaky moans out, the hand between her legs grabbing onto mine and pressing it more strongly against her needy core.

I rested my thumb against the hood of her clit, carefully pushing it upwards until I could feel the sensitive button underneath it. My index and middle finger parted her folds once more, this time pulling them apart properly. She shuddered and whimpered even more, her cheeks flush and her eyes filled with lust. She tried to say it, but she couldn‘t find the words, only moans and whimpers escaped her lips. I still knew what she wanted from me, though.

I pressed my middle fingers against her entrance and slowly, carefully, pushed in, splitting her open possibly for the first time ever – I wasn‘t sure how far she‘d explored with her own fingers or toys before this.

She was so soaking wet there was no resistance at all, though her tunnel was already clenching down on me. We were only just beginning and she was already close.

I started circling my thumb over her clit, timing it to the slow pressing of my fingers inside of her pussy. Flashing another smirk at her, I lowered my lips to her lonely breast, not waisting a second to claim her nipple with my mouth.

Her body shuddered more and more, her pussy clenching down on me so hard I felt like she wanted to crush me. She moaned, loudly and shamelessly, crying my name as she approached that blissful edge.

My fingers found the spot I was reaching for, pressing against it like a button. Cassie contracted around me, arching her back upwards once before crashing down onto the mattress and spasming out of control. I held her firmly, pulling my fingers in and out of her as she rode out her orgasm.

After a full minute of cries of pleasure, she finally slumped into the bedding, arms and legs wrapped tightly around my body.

„I think I love you,“ she said hoarsely, in between heaving breaths.

I buried my head in her chest. „I think I love you, too,“ I whispered back.