NokiMo
Carlie & Ange
Carlie & Ange

patreon


Your Lie in April Replacement!

As you guys know, we recently finished Your Lie in April so another slot in the schedule has opened up! We're going to be running a few polls in the next week, so just because a show is not on this poll, does not mean it wont be on one of the other polls! Please keep it civil in the comments.
If these options lose, it does not mean they cant feature again! 

Comments

please at least try to search up for anime called Clannad. For sure this anime will be one of your favorite if you liked your lie in april.

Just Anime

I'm hyped for avatar, but when it comes to sports for some reason Ace of the Diamond is my favorite

Arkh

High key want them to watch Tokyo ghoul so Ange can cover the opening

Raijin

Insane take

Antique-Item

Fate fans unite

Laylyvfavv

I also agree on Zero then UBW! I see some saying the other way around and I feel like that spoils too many big things in Zero

Cap

Coz they don't have much isekai experience 😆

FGK

Yes, start with Fate Zero , then UBW. Not enough people have reacted to Fate Zero, but its such a good show!

Jordan Hamilton

I think all the Fate series should be considered . Great animation, great story.

CHB1025

crazy take

Cap

You're just listing Isekai

Cap

yes but this is an anime channel

souma shou

Yes I agree Overlord is a must watch, I cant wait for you guys to watch it!

Adam

Nothing is a must watch but I did like overlord. i personally prefer frieren over it though but I don't know if they would like it as much.

Dune

oooh yes I agree 😁

Felyne

Overlord, for me, is still a must-watch regardless. That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime as well 😁 and maybe Saga of Tanya the Evil.

FGK

lmao

JadonTheEternal

character depth is when characters constantly cry

Yang

If you put together the amount of cut content and left-out details from the Overlord anime, it would be entire books. The LN's depth dwarfs both Frieren and ReZero.

Nymph

I think it's a little extreme to say Overlords character depth is anywhere near Frieren or Re:Zero. It's a fun show though but a pretty standard Isekai

Cap

Nvm

Kaycee

I really hope you will react to Overlord this year. It's kinda a must-watch ♥ World building and character depth like Frieren, dark like Re Zero and lots of theories to be made throughout the series! :D

Felyne

Does anyone know how soon they start posting their reactions to a poll winner? Just curious when avatar will actually start being uploaded. Thanks!

Kaycee

I do love avatar. I also hope you get to parasyte eventually though. It's a good one!

William Brummett

@noya22 @Carlin James SEE! Their latest youtube vid? I convinced them! Thank me One Piece fans! just kidding ;)

josephocenada

@noya22 @Carlin James SEE! Their latest youtube vid? I convinced them! Thank me One Piece fans! just kidding ;)

josephocenada

avatar is a great choice.

MARTIN DIVIRGILIO

Season 1 of Avatar is trash, but seasons 2 and 3 are classics, so just hang in there.

Norrin Radd

I can't tell you how excited I am for you to watch this show, it is my favorite show all time and is ranked 7th on IMDBs top 250 shows all time. I don't mind setting these huge expectations because I am that confident you will love this show. Season 1 is a lot of setup for the best payoffs ever, that being said season 1 is of course also amazing. I watched atla live as a kid and over 50 times through since and off of any 1 quote I can name the episode name and number it was said in as well as who said it. So you could call me a super fan :) oh and btw the 1st and 2nd episode aired together, even on reruns they were aired back to back so I would recommend watching them in the same sitting if you can. Thanks so much again!!

Noah Hoorn

OP manga is good, anime is garbage affffff

noya22

ATLA is the only answer here

Dan Reed

jeez, I'm not saying One Piece is not great before episode 151... arcs were still great even after the live-action (episode 46+) try to watch boldcast, when lindsay continously sobbing in episode 86... and they're blown away at the climax of an arc (episode 126) all praises = absolute banger, from end-to-end it's fckn incredible, best episode so far or the best episode ever, lindsay can't see how that episode can be beaten, etc... just saying that 151 is the episode that someone will sunk real deep into the series

josephocenada

lmao exactly - one piece takes wayyyyy too long to get good

Carlin James

thanks for your input

Carlin James

oh god

noya22

Imagine having to reach 151 episodes just to realize how good a show is lmaoooooooooooooo bruh

noya22

I’d love to see Parasyte reactions but Avatar is a great show too.

Jesus Rocha

my dress up darling, first short show then move onto ATLA so we can enjoy both? <3

Thanash Lee

Please no. They'll just regret commiting to watch Naruto. Just like how BOLDcast keep dissing Naruto/Kishimoto as a bad example of writing every time. They should do One Piece instead. If they managed to reach at least episode 151, they'll be blown away by how good it really is.

josephocenada

Naruto isn't one of the options

Waver

honestly - you guys should just do Naruto - Hunter x Hunter was great - Naruto is long but you can skip out on the fillers that have nothing to do with the story - Naruto will bring you lots of views as it's one of the most popular anime of all time and it'll take you a year or so to finish it.

Carlin James

these shows are all really good but avatar is a must watch in my opinion

Cookieninja

Bling-Bang-Bang-Born!!

Kere Jibi

any chance you guys try One Piece anime like how BOLDcast is doing it currently?

josephocenada

ATLA best cartoon of all time

Quincy

If you haven't watched Avatar, girl, it's time, one of the singlemost brilliantly written pieces of media in the last decade, there's a reason why so many people love it

Patrick Wotton

ATLA is amazing.

V D

ATLA should win this. No questions asked

Marcake

As much as I’d love to see parasyte, it’s gotta be avatar

Josh

Dam, I hate the YouTube algorithm, never showed me their One Piece reaction, I think they would love Vox Macina.

Steven Cavanagh

My suggestion would be Heavenly Delusion (Tengoku Daimakyou) - a travelling adventure that gives you small pieces to put together.

Deatheye

either ATLA or My Dress-Up darling would be amazing

Jerni9

Would also definitely recommend apothecary diaries at some point, it's a really good show and I have a feeling you'll both enjoy it. :)

Tisi

I’ve seen barely any reactors reacting to Delcious in the Dungeon maybe since it’s so new and a bit niche? But I think you guys would enjoy it. It’s comedy/fantasy/cooking meets dnd, among other things 😆

Kat

Love this show as well. Hits in the feels for sure

Kat

I would love if they reacted to any of these 3! I really liked Skip and Loafer as it feels different to others in its genre.

Kat

It would be interesting moving forward if you would give us the kind of show you want to watch. For example, a comedy/slice of life/drama/sport... It would make giving suggestions for a poll easier. I'm super interested to see what the other polls will have! :) Shows I'll never stop recommending: - Castlevania (this is in EN - 4 seasons) - Kotaro lives alone (1 very short but impactful season)

Belinda

If y'all do avatar after the book one. I'd love for y'all to watch the Netflix live action version and critique it.

MinstralPain

Yeah avatar being so long should replace a long series like hunterXhunter.

MinstralPain

They have One Piece live action done on their youtube and full lengths here on patreon if you're sub to the tier! :)

Guts

OMG PLEASE DO AVATAR

Italo

I would suggest for future reactions, The Legend of Vox Machina & Live action One Piece.

Steven Cavanagh

They would love Mao Mao and the mysteries

Hoa Trương

What if put the anime from the OPs you reacted to in the polls instead? So react to more anime OPs 😁 I'd like to have more choices honestly.

FGK

I REALLY hope they pick up on all of the Apothecary Diaries recommendations and add it to their next poll. If it weren't for Frieren it would likely be my AOTY.

Stonewielder

i would love for them pick up another comedy anime like saiki k but seeing people recommend apothecary diaries, im here to support that recommendation too!! the three shows arent really my cup of tea but hope they enjoy whatever theyre watching next!

honey senpai

Again I like all of these the only one I didn’t watch fully is parasyte but i think it’s because i was too young to fully enjoy it. Hope you still have “the apothecary diaries” on your radar. Cheers

mellon 100

Tbh think they will at some point pretty happy that it has a good backing in their comments. I think the only problem is the description of the anime why they aren’t instantly hooked on the idea

mellon 100

pls be Parasyte !!!

Maximilien Leymonerie

Hi! Is there any chance you would react to Hazbin Hotel? There's only 8 episodes so it's not too long but the music is really good in that one :)

gemini

I you want to watch avatar, I would recommend to watch the anime instead.

Enora

Can you watch apothecary diaries as well

kim odejar

Parasite is the top s tier of that list

Clément Creton

i think ATLA and My Dress-Up Darling are great. ATLA will win this poll. For variety i think there should only be one longer completed show at a time to prioritize on ongoing shows. I haven't seen Parasyte yet but it sounds like i should.

J G

lol so I can't say shit about it. based, gigachad.

ShadowQrow

Yeah I changed my vote to that. I don't remember a lot of details of the show but looking at it now, it took 1 second to get to a wtf moment worth seeing the reaction to. I should accept I've seen as much ATLA as I ever need to see.

Daniel Wallace

I think the most practical approach is to react to My Dress-Up Darling first since it only has 12 episodes. If you do 3 episodes per week like Your Lie in April, then you'll finish MDUD in a month, then you can start Avatar which is a long series. This way you'll appease fans of both series.

Astor Lefflinker

I'd love to see more people watch this show

Javier

It just comes off as a little rude imo because it’s their channel and their content they decide to react to in the end of things.

Floch

watch "March comes in like a lion" please! I promise you two would absolutely and utterly adore this show!

KLC

Love both of these! I'm still waiting for Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun season 2 😩. If we're going romance, I'd like to throw Skip to Loafer in for consideration, as well! Probably my favorite light-hearted romance slice-of-life of recent years. It's shoujo at a glance but is actually seinen.

Mysbis

same lol

bebe

these will most likely feature in the hxh replacement poll

wicecakes

Been waiting for Avatar <3

Anthony Richards

Damn I want all of these but ATLA is the obvious choice here

Ari

I think that helps the animated show tho. I started rewatching it again after the live action come out, and that make me want to see Carlie and ange react to it.. So in my case, and maybe other people, I am more inclined to vote for ATLA since the live action is out

Nigatsu

Agree

Adan Aban

Honestly shocked Dress-up darling is even considered

Waver

Parasyte won't win :( sad I hope it will comeback on another poll

Pohiko

agree

noya22

I agree. Juggling too many action shounens can feel fatiguing. Same as trying to watch multiple sports anime at once

MrYinYang

Finish HxH b4 yall start...lord have mercy

Brother Nature

Ohhhh god not the last air bender

Brother Nature

it's been years but here i am still waiting for another season 😭

apothecary maomao

👆 how to like this multiple times

apothecary maomao

one piece (one pace version)

stevenj0e

Someones used to getting their way. Really funny coming from someone wanting adult-focused content..

Scimitar

Good suggestion!

slahser

parasyte is goated, and short

Κώστας Βασιλειάδης

Parasyte already losing... :[

Tristan Scholtens

I'm not sure what you're referring to. Perhaps the moment when Rudeus is alone in his room? But then again, when there's an intention it's not a problem. When you talk about a subject, you can either just suggest it, or show it head-on. And it's understandable that some people don't want to see certain things head-on. Just as you might not want to see realistic violence in a war film, whether there's a point or not. It all depends on one's sensibility.

GTB

🤓

ThaDoubleB

Or Magi, underrated anime imo

Heinrich

None of these, rather more HxH xD. Although, huge Avatar fan

Heinrich

Cringe

Thilde

Because the fan service is way over the top at times? And Carlie doesn't seem to be the biggest fan of that. Just based on their reactions in the past🤷‍♂️ There are much better rom-com animes out there they could watch

Thilde

I'm all for the boobage 🤣

Ordinary Guy

Two recommendations of mine would be my OG fave Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun or Girl's Monthly Nozaki-kun, it is light-hearted comedy that subverts conventional anime romance tropes and it is just absolutely hilarious 🔥. The other is a recent favourite called The Apothecary Diaries, it has historical intrigue, politics, excellent character writing and it is just beautifully animated💮🔎

Carol Yu

OMG yes!!! Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun is just absolutely hilarious and it is criminal that it hasn't gotten a second season.

Carol Yu

There's no sexual acts between minors until episode 22 and it it's not really animated and it's pretty much forced upon the main character, or at the very least consensual. Since you said you couldn't watch past episode 5, I don't know how you would know about that or you just classify nudity and some touching as an sexual act, which is weird. You can be uncomfortable with that kind of material and it is fine and that's it.

すもも麻子

There has been no word or valid sign that it’s been in production. They weren’t prepared with how popular the show was and they released it once completed. Going to guess that if they release s2 it’s going to be when completed and not completing episodes while releasing every week. Especially at the quality s1 was at and sign all the other shows recently duck there sit up because of that system

JIMBO

Death Note too.

FGK

I don't know if you guys have already watched this, but one anime that you guys would love is assassination classroom. And if I'm being honest this might be another anime the ange cries too ;)

Krocz

Kdrama please Fiery Priest.

FGK

Do a Korean movie reaction. Midnight runners please.

FGK

Fan service early can be hard for some people, But after that the show only gets better.

Daaylen Watson

Sign of affection is good

Mango

Fanservice is often used unnecessarily, although sometimes it can contribute to a narrative or characterization. I wouldn't say it has no place in MDUD as we are seeing from the perspective of a teenage boy after all, but because it's used excessively most of it feels unneeded.

Javier

would LOVE for them to react to Skip and Loafer actually

apothecary maomao

Erm I disagree, I saw the people who react to the show on YouTube and it’s popular for sure. I do think the show takes it time to progress the story and narrative but a lot of crazy things does happen in the show for sure. The show is currently on season 3 and the previous 2 seasons are 13 episodes each. So it’s very easy to watch imo my opinion. But I do respect ur opinion cuz some of my friends have said the same as u. I have also read the light novel so ik what’s coming next and it’s epic that’s why I highly recommend

mohamed rafee

Please do another Korean Drama🙏🙏🙏 Definitely recommend Moving or Sweet Home, for a change of pace.

Carms

surely dress up darling gets a s2

Valandril

yeah i dont think its a fun show to watch people react to. it has a few wow moments but besides that its gonna be a bit of a drag

Valandril

Facts brother !

Nethzil

Korra is way better from start to finish (except for season 2 that was a mistake)

Nethzil

I second that

Nethzil

Fanservice is never needless. Especially not in cute shows.

Nethzil

As others have said, while My Dress-Up Darling has a cute story the needless fanservice really brings it down. I'd recommend other romance anime such as Skip and Loafer, A Sign of Affection or Loving Yamada at lvl 999 first.

Javier

I've simply shared my opinion without attacking yours and been attacked twice. You're entitled to think what you want, but this patreon page is a weird place to spread your negativity and agenda. I really don't care and I'm done feeding you. Feel free to come back and get the last word, and keep brigading the rest of the comments as well! Whatever floats your boat.

TakKi Pie

I've rewatched it plenty of times as well. It's a guilty-pleasure Rom-com. Not every show needs to have a complex, thought-provoking storyline, and each character going through an Eren or Thorfinn arc. Sometimes you just want to enjoy some "plot" and funny, wholesome content to boost your serotonin.

MrYinYang

Valid point

HansCent

Dang, judgey as hell, my guy

Aaron Griffin

Voting for ATLA! barely seen it so watching alongside your reactions will be a great chance to get into it. Dress Up Darling a tad too ecchi/fanservice-y for me considering the young highschool setting but to each their own, I know the show has a lot of fans. If you're looking for an easy but also hilarious watch, may I suggest 'Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun' 😁

apothecary maomao

Glad you like the imperialism apologia. Not surprising. Suppose you also missed how the writers accidentally wrote racist dogwhistles into the story, too.

Elli

ATLA is great and Parasyte is great. They can be great at the same time.

Gabriel Barott

Personally I think these shows are not the best to combine in to a single poll. - ATLA is good, but nostalgia is a big factor too on why people recommend. It is a bit slow on a lot of episodes - MDUD is good, the fanservice not sure if carlie would enjoy - Parasyte is good but once the story sinks in it can feel the same throughout the series

Valkyr

Well the protagonist is shown how he should be, someone who is looking down cuz he is smarter than everyone else and he doesn’t feel emotions or doesn’t know how to express them. I think he’s the kind of character I like in a psychological show/character. The show is rlly good and I recommended this show cuz it’s very different from the other shows they have watched till now. Kaguya sama was a show they typically don’t watch as well but turned out well. But I hear u, I think the character is meant to be polarizing and should be a slow burn

mohamed rafee

Ok, but I’m not only talking about the MC. I’m talking about a literal child performing sexual acts and it being animated.

Gabriel Barott

Code geass for sure

Antique-Item

Foreal

Antique-Item

I don’t like my dress up darling because it’s objectively not good. It does have high quality art. The animation isn’t high quality by any means, and the writing is extremely poor which is why it’s objectively bad.

Antique-Item

Avatar is such an awesome show

Kevin Campos

would have been nice to have some older animes like Code Geass

Salman Mohammad

I would like to see your reaction to dbz abridged

Spectrum

Keep your bitter negativity to yourself, thanks. There's a vote for a reason. LOK has one weak season and 3 strong ones. Both it and ATLA are good for different reasons, with different themes.

TakKi Pie

Maybe you won't like it in spite of that. No work can please everyone. But I just wanted to be clear about the fact that unlike other anime that sexualizes for fan-service, that's not the case with Mushoku. And again, I haven't even mentioned the cultural differences and translation problems that mean some people sometimes misinterpret Mushoku. edit : And to be fair, there are also Mushoku fans who make silly comments to justify or make acceptable Rudeus' behavior. They completely miss the intentions of the author, who clearly presents the behavior as problematic.

GTB

Bro just got ratio’d on Patreon💀

Reid Dawson

@Gabriel Barott > "I don't see how child sexualization is a fun watch" It isn't. That's the point. You're not supposed to appreciate that part of Rudeus. I have a question: in a movie, series, anime or whatever when you see one character kill another...do you tell yourself that it's a glorification of murder? That it's fun to watch? It depends on the treatment, right ? Violence is extremely present in stories. And it's far from always relevant or moral. Some stories use it as entertainment (which rarely causes controversy, by the way). Other stories show violence because there's a point to it, because it makes narrative sense. The same goes for anything to do with sex. There's nothing wrong with integrating sexualization into a story when there's a point to it. Some stories show a character's violence to valorize them, others show their violence to show their flaws. Rudeus' behavior at the beginning is shocking. It's done to shock, to show the bad sides of the character. There's never any valorization of Rudeus when he acts like this. At the start of Mushoku, Rudeus is shown for what he is: he's a mess. A traumatized, socially/humanely disconnected, morally screwed-up person. Episode 1 ends with Rudeus vowing to do better in his new life. That's the starting point.

GTB

I just watched this show myself I personally can’t say it fits the type of shows they typically watch. I mean, it is a little vulgar at times… and it’s high school girls. Bit of a weird one. I also don’t see the protagonist as very likable when he sees every other character in the anime as “an object to be used”.

Reid Dawson

Oh Asssassination Classroom too! But people don't react to it often. I might be the only one :'/

Trisha Sablan

I'll also wait for the next poll like MHA, Black Clover, and such but I truly just want them to enjoy watching what they prefer and I know these shows were great too!

Trisha Sablan

AVATAR OMG

Maanas Gopi

Ur not wrong🤣, but ange is based as well so he will like it

mohamed rafee

Because it's excellent!

Elli

Why wouldn't they enjoy it? It's a hilarious, and heartwarming show?

Elli

Yea, watch the good show so you can get to the mediocre, imperialism apologia that has one good season!

Elli

I'm guessing you never watched all of ATLA if you think it's "kiddie"

Silver

korra is mid tho. atla is the only one worth reacting imo

souma shou

based

souma shou

Ugh kiddie time for Avatar, I guess. That's one slot I won't be partaking in. VERY sad that you put something more adult-focused like Parasyte up against a show that a lot of younger people grew up with like Avatar. It literally never even had a chance to win.

The Great Santini

Exactly. Why are they replacing a 1 season show with a Nickelodeon epic such as Avatar? Both Parasyte and Dress Up are shorter shows that would have filled that slot nicely.

The Great Santini

Ok, I appreciate the insight. I might give it another go then. It’s just that off rip it seemed super edgy and didn’t look like it was going anywhere else. Glad to know that it doesn’t stay how it is.

Gabriel Barott

AVATAR ♥️♥️

pan dan

I have seen my dress up darling 17 times now, idk why but i cant get enough of it

Puddin Cup

oh no if ATLA won, i might stay longeeeer~! and here i thought ill be leaving after Haikyuu lmao

myel

I’m so sad at the lack of Parasyte votes, Such a fun anime and I would be hype to see their reaction to that show. Avatar is good but a much longer series, Hope parasite can be busted out first before starting a several season journey.

Daaylen Watson

i just unsuscribed bc haikyuu ended, if ATLA wins i'll suscribe right back

Jjj.

@Gabriel Barott > Then they're not light novel readers, or they've been lying to you. I know from experience that Mushoku has some pretty crazy detractors who go so far as to lie about knowing the story just to say it's crap and dissuade others from getting interested. From season 1, Rudeus evolves a lot in terms of relationships with others (including women, that is). Not completely, but he's already come a long way from where he started. A major event triggers another big evolution in season 2. Anyone who has actually read the light novel can't deny the character's incredible change over the course of his new life (his youth is only a small part of his adventure). Bearing in mind that he'll never be the perfect man. None of Mushoku's characters are. It's about those characters who struggle against their flaws, whatever they may be, with successes and failures. Nothing is ever black and white. It's this human struggle that is the main point of this work, through various themes: fatherhood/motherhood, family, death, rejection, sexuality, trust, mourning, the value of life, communication, depression, slavery, love, marriage, war, obligations, royalty, betrayal, etc... Remarkably well written. But it talks about sensitive subjects that some feel shouldn't be talked about...like Rudeus' deviances at the beginning.

GTB

Not really interested in all 3 of them. I will wait for the next poll

Ashley hui

I await the the day they react to the creme de la creme of anime: Monster, Shinsekai York, Legend of the Galactic Heroes, Berserk...but for now I'm voting Parasyte 🔥

Kaiser the Elitist

You can assume I'm dumb based off of a few messages on a patreon post where I'm being pretty reasonable, but that just makes you look like the dumb one. Not saying you are, because I wouldn't say that over a reply.

Gabriel Barott

I still don't see how MrYinYang's response alleviates what I stated.

Gabriel Barott

can you elaborate on that? I think its themes and writing are worthy of an adult show as well. what exactly do you think makes it "garbage if you're underage"?

Martina

I'm not sure why people are acting like Avatar will take ages for them to finish? They get through episodes pretty fast compared to some reaction channels.. I like Parasyte but as for My Dress-Up Darling, I'm not sure they would actually even enjoy it? Maybe I'm wrong

Thilde

I don’t know if it’d win a poll, but man, I’d love to see them react to Run with the Wind 🥹

Mysbis

If you cant read MrYInYang comment already explaining some of the reasoning as to why people like the series I would just assume you are too dumb to understand most things in the first place.

L.C.

The hype for the live action is not good at all. In fact the live action is getting more hate than anything else because it is so garbage. I dont know where you get your info from but even if you simply look up the ATLA live adaptation reviews almost every single video and post about it is shitting on ATLA.

L.C.

Imagine being so upset over a reaction channel poll that you leave 3 comments whining about it 💀💀 go outside bro

Thilde

From what I've been told about Mushoku from manga readers, is the MC doesn't get any better.

Gabriel Barott

Hunter03, that's just wildly untrue.

Gabriel Barott

L.C. why don't you elaborate a bit. I don't see how child sexualization is a fun watch.

Gabriel Barott

you missed the meat of the show which starts at episode 8. The uncomfortable moments early in the series show the flaws of the MC which are meant to be improved on. I don't think you gave it a genuine try. It's ok, not every show needs to be appreciated by everyone.

MrYinYang

Avatar because then you can watch Korra.

TakKi Pie

Would love for you guys to watch classroom of the elite! It’s totally different show than what u guys have watched before. It has an amazing story and protagonist!

mohamed rafee

Animation and art to not make an anime great. The animation and art just enhance the experience, but rather what's happening in said animated scene is what makes or breaks it.

Gabriel Barott

YES FRUITS BASKETTT

Hannan

honestly all 3 in the poll are must watch for me. the poll results are exactly the way i feel. you should eventually watch all 3 100%

Valandril

i rewatched avatar with my gf who had never seen it and she absolutely loved it. its so freaking good. it gets a lot more mature over time aswell

Valandril

It’s even worse cause I think they had/have a MHA poster on the wall behind them 😭

Danny C

It's so wild to me that they STILL haven't seen MHA. Hopefully it pops up on a poll in the future.

Trav

Voting for Dress-up Darling sheerly because the reactions are bound to be wild. Avatar's great once it gets going, but I'm kinda burned out on it.

Trav

potato potato /joking/ thx for the correction!

LIA

They should watch Orange or Erased too

LIA

2nd that. yu yu hakusho the goat

smokes

Avatar would be really fun! A lot of great messages and characters.

Mason D.

Avatar's not too shabby. I'm eager to watch that along with you. I hope your fans one day convince you guys to watch yu yu hakusho. You would truly enjoy that.

rryutie

FUUUCK i want to see the my dress up darling reaction then avatar avatar is so much longer MYDUD is 12 eps

JIMBO

Avatar is a slow burn by today’s standards, but by the end of the journey, I’ll be DAMN SURPRISED if it is not in your top ten shows of all time. It’s quite close to perfect as a ‘kids’ show can get, with themes and characters that stick with you well into adulthood and beyond.

Champion Bescos

I know? I said I put I Want to Eat Your Pancreas up there those two in terms of a great movie. They should enjoy it, if they enjoyed the other two.

Stray

no one asked

Stray

If we will be doing it that way, my dress up darling is more weird showing high school girls naked and half naked. And most romcom is set in middleschool/seniorschool so what’s your point?

tracee miasco

They've seen silent voice and your name already

Danny

only good show

Hunter03

non of this seems interesting imo

Manuel Eduardo Diaz Cabrera

MC is weird the whole anime and show is about middle school lovers nah

Hunter03

Dress up darling is the my hero academia of romance animes

Hunter03

My favourite anime is 86 I thought we had similar taste after forcing em to watch 86 , I was wrong.

Hunter03

I watched it last year, I watched everything because everyone said it gets better. It was an huge waste of my time.

Hunter03

Isn't the show a thirst trap? Mc is weird too.

Hunter03

it also is garbage if u aren't under 18

Hunter03

Classroom of the elite, D-Gray man, the girl next door spoils me rotten and blast of tempest are my recommendations. Most people would prefer these to a bald idiot who needs auto pilot to function and dress up thirst bait. Parasyte won't win unfortunately so we need people who "lock in".

Hunter03

i would love parasyte, kinda sad it aint getting the love it deserves even though its so good, avatar is nice too tho but yeah...

Majoz

You could think about this the reverse way as well though. They could just do it after because it's so quick.

Gabriel Barott

All of the options are bad tbh. Parasite is the only decent one avatar is the most overrated show of all time. Give us more options to vote on.

Hunter03

im not sure if yall have already decided which shows are going in the polls but id love to see yuri on ice get a chance :] excited to see what comes next for yall!

storm (kasey) !

So crazy I was literally thinking yesterday that I'd love to see y'all react to it

Z

The writing and storytelling in Avatar is soooo amazing and top tier I would die if you guys watched it

Z

Parasyte is Seinen, Dress up horny rom com, some genres simply have bigger mainstream appeal and it's fairly new, compared to decade old Parasyte, so recency bias plays a role.

Sydonis

yeah haha, I don't think very many people have seen it, which is a shame!

Martina

for me, ATLA is objectively the best but I also love Parasyte lol

Martina

I don't consider the opinion of anyone who likes attack on trash

L.C.

Also no I doubt they have seen enough anime to be even mildly comfortable sitting through the few scenes that show how scummy the characters are in the beginning.

L.C.

Gabriel your takes are ass

L.C.

Lol it's okay to have wrong taste

happyfairyjerry

Before being interested while watching, there's being interested to watch or not. That's what I was talking about. I'm not judging the quality of the show. I know Avatar is very popular, and maybe it's really good. One day, when I'm in the mood, I'll probably give it a try ;). I give you the same advice: one day, give Mushoku a second chance. The uncomfortable scenes of the first episodes are part of the writing. This man full of trauma and deviances will try to become a better man (which is literally what the Japanese title means); and you don't change overnight. A deeply human story that doesn't hide human flaws. No bad guys, no good guys here, just humans with their qualities and flaws in a harsh world. Many themes are dealt with, some of them very difficult indeed. That's the whole point.

GTB

Why not?

Floch

SECRET TUNNEL

Floch

Is anything and everything that you don't agree with harsh? Lmk what you think I said was harsh.

ShadowQrow

No way! I was not expecting to see avatar on here any time soon. It’s AMAZING. it’s technically for “children” but all ages of people can enjoy its amazing story and writing.

Floch

Same. Avatar blah.

Jonathan Soronen

I love avatar, but this sucks. It's so much less interesting than the other 2 options and you could finish both of them in less time than it takes to watch avatar.

Steven

Avatar!!! If you guys haven’t watched it at all. Your in for a treat. A complete master piece

VesperQuartz15

I think Slime would be a better choice in the same genre for them

Dion meijers

kinda sad seeing parasyte last, hopefully you'll still be able to watch it sometime in the future! would love to rewatch it

cherry park

Pls no avatar 😭

NamlessMonster

Hands down Avatar, one of the best cartoons ever made. Starts of very child friendly and simple but gets better with each episode.

Nethzil

My Dress Up Darling would make for hilarious reactions for sure, Parasyte is so freaking good but ATLA is just it. I know for a fact that you'd love the lore and the characters !

Sarcaamstic

If you want more tear jerkers, Here are a few for future reference. Angel Beats, Clannad, Anohana, Plastic Memories

Eric Quan

ATLA isn't good?? That's a concerning take.

Gabriel Barott

If you haven't watched Avatar, you won't know you're interested till you watch it. I swear it's 100% better than it might appear on the surface.

Gabriel Barott

Don't think they're quite ready for Mushoku Tensei yet

sankro

This anime is so uncomfortable. Dropped it after 5 episodes.

Gabriel Barott

Parasyte fans, The time to get together has arrived, we must unite against the ATLA fans, let's vote for my dress up darling to win the elections

Adan Aban

Would love for you guys to watch classroom of the elite! It’s totally different show than what u guys have watched before. It has an amazing story and protagonist!

mohamed rafee

Mushoku Tensei would be great

Victor Oliveira Dirienzo

Give it a chance. It's genuinely one of the best written animated series of all time. Including anime

Danny

Avatar is very good but not keen to rewatch it…rip!

Aaron Wright

LOL this poll won't even be close. Avatar is SO popular. Especially with the new live action coming out. The hype is at an all time high. Not complaining though. I've been rewatching some episodes here and there. Hopefully they also do Korra after.

Danny

my dress up darling is really enjoyable, especially past the first ep! It has a good mix of friendship and self worth and romance, it’s cute and sweet! and obviously the dress up part which is really fun :D plus its not very long so you can move onto the other choices pretty quick!

# vivi

One of the times I am truly spoiled for choice. I like all these shows, i don't care which wins.

Joe B

I hope Made in abyss gets put back into the polls in the future

SanteRip

You felt this way because its fan-service is here for no narrative reason. It tells nothing. And remember that Marine is 15yo. I felt much more uncomfortable in front of My Dress Up than in front of Mushoku.

GTB

no need to be harsh :)

Roidistan 07

If ATLA does not win, I am going to be singing leaves from the vine for weeks. :(

Amrith

Avatar is really good. Also only 60-ish episodes long

this is one long ass username

Holy terrible selection. None of these are good reaction shows. yiykes

ShadowQrow

@Carlie & Ange , I hope it's not put with a tough competition in the poll xd

Mango

Come on guys please lets not do Avatar 😿

Roidistan 07

There are many, many more interesting anime to watch before My Dress Up Darling, which is just "fine". Even in the romance genre, there are many that are much better. What's more, this one heavily sexualizes 15yo girls, for no narrative reason. I have no problem with that in a story, when it serves an artistic or narrative purpose. But with My Dress Up, it's so random...discomfort guaranteed. Much more so than in the case of controversial anime on this subject, where the narration deals seriously with the subject. My vote goes to Parasyte. (never watched and not very interested in Avatar)

GTB

hmmm damn but if i have to choose, i would just go for AVATAR i was shocked at first after mistaking it as LA lmao. if it is animated one, omg just go for it please.

bebe

Another poll, another chance for My Hero Academia to not be chosen :') Avatar or Parasyte would be awesome though!

Danny C

Avatar the last airbender was my childhood! I hope it's the winner because the show is awesome!

Amaryllis

So glad to see parasyte on this polk

Layman's Outlook

As others have mention ATLA is a pretty long commitment and I think it's best to go with a shorter anime that way everyone kinda wins. It won't take long to watch my dress up darling or parasyte then you guys can move on to ATLA

William Le

All these seem like great choices! (Voted ATLA cause it's a 10/10 without a doubt lol) A super short anime that's really great that I recommend is OddTaxi

Carlos Cantu

Agreed. After the good cry that was A Lie in April, they need a good laugh.

H-Bomb 24

Of course I've seen Avatar. I voted for My Dress Up Darling because I enjoyed it and I wanna see their reactions.

H-Bomb 24

I'm not even going to bother dignifying this with a response. This is the perfect example of the adage regarding assumptions.

Smash Bran'Discootch

same tbh. love the concept, but the ecchi-fication of the highschool girl lead was...a lot to handle 😅

apothecary maomao

I think My Dress Up Darling is really good here not because of its fan services, nor the rom-com part, but it actually gives some insights to the anime culture in Japan. (Of course all the other stuffs are good too)

Jason

Please consider Run with the wind and Fruits basket😭❤️

Frida BØ

There's two amazing shows here and then there's my dress up darling. People voting for it obviously haven't seen avatar or parasyte

happyfairyjerry

My Dress Up Darling is such a cute story, as long as you're okay with some WELL ANIMATED fan-service popping up, as it were. Avatar is a classic, so I'm sure that's going to get decent votes but isn't that series like 61 episodes long? Definitely one to watch, just seems like it's going to take up a spot for a while. Parasyte is full on body horror, which ain't my bag of chips. My vote goes to My Dress Up Darling. It's got a cute story and I think watching you two react to some of the racier scenes would make for some hilarious content!

Kabukibear

My dress up darling is doomed to fail against Parasyte and ATLA lol kinda unfair but the 3 shows are good, My vote goes for ATLA

Ecodude

If its the cartoon I am more than happy to see your reactions. I am so glad its the cartoon please never waste your time with the netflix adaptation trash.

L.C.

Also there is this super underrated anime Run with The Wind which is only one season but I think you guys would love it. I can already see Calie's teary eyes reacting to this show lol

Tony Zhao

why?

ONEEIGHTEEN

ya same..

ONEEIGHTEEN

no hate to avatar. i just haven't seen it. so i wont be watching those reacts :(.

ONEEIGHTEEN

It has 11 episodes

Stonewielder

Not as a replacement suggestion. But rly keen to watch you guys reacting to Bungo Stray Dogs one day! It is abstly next level!!!!

Tony Zhao

ATLA HYPE

DalyDose

Anohana in the future would be cool, its only 8 episodes

LIA

Avatar is truly one of the TV 🐐’s I would give anything to watch it again for the first time

Daniel Molina

I had such a wierd experience with my dress up darling, the story is cute but the fan-service was so... weird that it made me feel dirty. I didn't like it. (Not a dig at anyone who did, just my opinion)

MelanieRS

All right I’ll rewatch Parasyte by myself

Salahadine Abaine

My dress up darling would be the perfect replacement.

Cédric Chabert

I hope this is either sarcasm or about my dress up darling ( although it's not that recent, my guy) because Avatar is wining and it's hard to get anything older than show lolol

MelanieRS

I'm here for My Dress Up Darling!!!!!!!!

Ordinary Guy

I guess I have no choice but to be a patreon for longer if you react to Avatar 😭💜 Also, hoping for Apothecary Diaries to be on the next poll 🙏

Bibi

I hope one day you guys will react to Psycho pass 😔

Rigo Rojo

This is such a coincidence because I'm literally re-watching ATLA the animated version on Netflix rn!!!

Meg

Doomed the second avatar was in the poll 😭 Dress up darling too good and short, could finish it first and then avatar which is longer

Ribss

I WILL BE READY TO VOTE WHEN THIS HAPPENS 😭

apothecary maomao

It was worth a shot my dress up darling but I’m afraid the avatar fans are too strong stand proud

Jamel Cornish

I hope My dress up darling wins the vote! This is a short anime to binge and have a great time!

정빈 이

Lots of good choices! Looking forward to the winner! I want to suggest Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica as a future poll contestant. It’s incredibly iconic and a short watch too.

Leah

Even if My Dress Up Darling loses (and it probably will against Avatar), I hope you'll keep it in reserve for a future reaction.

H-Bomb 24

It's not "objectively not good", if anything it's closer to objectively good than bad due to it having high quality art and animation, but art isn't objectively anything, that's the point. You just don't like My Dress Up Darling, and that's fine, just say it lol

JadonTheEternal

I like all of these shows, so I'm okay with any of them tbh. It's honestly tough to pick.

JadonTheEternal

My vote goes to My Dress-up Darling. I think Carlie & Ange are gonna love the show. Time for them to experience a proper ecchi/fan service anime. Quick 12 episode show, with a potential Season 2 some time in the future

MrYinYang

Well guess I'll change my vote then!

Frosstbyte

God I hope my dress up darling never wins

Алта

I'm sure Avatar will probably win due to popularity (not to mention the Netflix series just came out), and I'm okay with that, honestly. But I would L.O.V.E. to see them watch My Dress Up Darling, if for no other reason than how HILARIOUS it would be. 🤣

H-Bomb 24

Mushibugyō, Nura: Rise of the Yokai Clan, Code Geass, Guilty Crown, Dusk Maiden of Amnesia, Spice and Wolf. These are some of the older animes that really worth a peek.

Jonathan

My dress-up darling being over Parasyte is insane. I voted for Parasyte (The Masterpiece) simply because I knew ATLA would win as it should. But my dress-up darling is objectively not good so I'm surprised it's being polled.

Antique-Item

What do you mean you haven’t seen ATLA?! How??

Justin S Tuisamoa

I prefer to watch them react to shorter shows

Raul Velazquez

man, I get avatar because it's genuinely that good. But Dress up darling over a master piece like parasyte... Damn ! Some ppl do be always thinking with their genitals.

Matthias

ATLA should be replacement for somethinf like HXH, I think.

Pleinee

No. Now. :'( <3

OctaviusLee

Ive seen parts of it when I was a kid. Very hard to remember details though! And i never finished it.

Carlie & Ange

Man, recency bias go craaaaaaaazy

Smash Bran'Discootch

Blue Lock eps 1, 2 & 3 are all coming this week! Probably a little later in the week tho

Carlie & Ange

I have such mixed feelings about the tourney style polls! It gets my hopes up for certain shows! Then I see the competition…

RPSiege

OMG AVATAR😭😭😭 I’m so excited

beannieswife

LET ME HEAAAAR your voice Parasyte gang👀🤭

Sammie

My dress up darling It has few chapters. Finished could be started Avatar They're both great but I prefer my dress op darling, Marin the best waifu😂

Enrique 99

:( I want them to see everything

StackCanary

ATLA is pretty long compared to My Dressup Darling so I just feel like it would be better to tackle that real fast while it's current and then go to something slightly older and longer, lol. ALSO WHERE IS THE BLUE LOCK UPLOAD.

OctaviusLee

ATLA is a pretty big commitment, gotta vote for My Dress Up Darling first since its only 12 eps

FTN Chicken

It will feature on one of the upcoming polls! 🙂

Carlie & Ange

We're all here.. Avatar can wait 🤣

Pitou

If they've never watched ATLA, I mean thats a must

Raden

:( I want them to see Nanachi

Maxime Goettelmann

Apothecary Diaries ❤️ I don't think they'll watch it because it's not so popuiar in the Western world - it's crazy popular in Japan, tho. I don't mind because they're watching Frieren which I find kinda similar, but Apothecary DIaries is still my favorite

Martina

Migi time?

Araragi Senpai

What happened to made in abyss which were in the previous poll? :/

StackCanary

Omg!!! You guys.. 🥹💘

Pitou

Parasyte is legit one of the best out there. Hope it can pull through!

CastSenpai

Where is the Parasyte gang at????

Le Le

That will feature on an upcoming poll! 🙂

Carlie & Ange

Since Ange said he's seen ATLA before had to vote for dress up darling

Frosstbyte

My dress up darling is nice and short. Do it first, then avatar.

Tactless91

I’m aware

Malik Ford

Only one I've watched is My dress up darling so vote goes there lol xd. I've seen some clips of Parasyte in tik tok and it kinda looks nasty ngl XD Meanwhile waiting for Apothecary.

Mango

ATLA is very wholesome and extremely well written.

Gabriel Barott

ATLA OMG! I'M SO EXCITED Literally in my top 3 shows of all time.

Gabriel Barott

I feel My dress up darling is basically the show for you ahahah

SilverWind

Oh man y'all killing me putting ATLA (one of my all time favs) against Dress up Darling! I'm tempted to voted for dress up cause it's short and your reactions would be absolutely hilarious! But I won't be disappointed either way!

Kunj Shah

I will vote for my dress up on every poll it shows up on

zzip711

Made in abyss

ωαям вяєαժ

Black Clover or Classroom of the Elite should be next.

ivan reyes

You guys would REALLY love My Dress Up Darling!

Ján Nič

Parasyte for me since its shorter.

DemoniCross

it HAS to be My Dress Up Darling!!

abzuu

I was hoping you guys do dangers In my heart. It’s ranked very highly MAL. Season 1 is 8.2 while season 2 is 8.8. Season 1 is ranked lower in MAL because the MC acts weird for the first 3 episodes but after that it will grow to become one of the most wholesome and cute romcom you’ve watched if you stick through it I bet my life on it I hope it will be in the next polls

tracee miasco

You guys should check out the anime movie, I Want to Eat Your Pancreas. If you haven't already, I put it up there with A Silent Voice and Your Name.

Stray

Not sure if others mentioned it yet but Would love for you guys to consider Ranking of Kings for future reactions!!

Gooner Wolf

My dress up darling for sure

ChmpagnShadw

It’s good too but

Malik Ford

What about 🫴 Alice in Bordeland S1 & S2? It's crazy intense..♣️♦️♠️❤️

Pitou

Parasyte is a must!

DRACO

While ATLA isn’t the kind of show you guys normally watch, it is a genuine fun time. Can’t wait to see what else will come up on the polls too!

Stormageddon Thomason

Avatar. Its perfect

𝑳𝒐𝒓𝒆𝒍𝒆𝒊 ♤

Im a huge My dress up darling fan but i know Avatar the last airbender is one of those series that should be watch, is just not a Nickelodeon/Kids show.

Edward Chireno

All of these are so good…why!!…

Baren Nerab

Baguette Avatar is the best

baja

We need some positive now my dress up darling

Malik Ford

100% please watch Avatar! It’s perfect 🥹🫶🏻

Katherine Claire

The danger in my heart should be there

Sanju

Parasyte!!!

Tristan Scholtens

ATLA is ❤️

Alexis

Parasite is objectively the best but I also like avatar 😭😭😭

Alejandro Garcia

oh damn, Parasyte is amazing but I can't not vote for ATLA! yes it's a kids show but it's so damn well written, I'm sure you guys will love it. I wouldn't mind you reacting to the live action either!

Martina

Parasite is the best show in this list don’t lie to yourselves.

The Great Santini

Ooo I hope it’s parasyte! Love a good seinin

Moody

My dress up darling 🥹

Malik Ford

ninja kamui

obito6ix

Anything other then avatar is the wrong choice

Francisco Cintron

Parasite best

Zinc Young


Related Creators