SECRET SONGS Reaction: Cincinnati, OH (Night 2)

i bought patreon this month. i’m watching all your videos and reacting like it’s happening rn and i can’t believe it. love you guys and the fact that you actually got ivy!?!!!!

Oliwia Smug

Sending my deepest sympathies to you for this horrible tragedy that happened over a year ago.

Breezy Bumbles

Ohhhhhhhh noooooooooo god damn. 😭😭😭🙅‍♀️

Breezy Bumbles

Reading this comment knowing they got ivy warms my heart immensely

Buttercupzi (wilma)

Emily looking at the camera speechless will always make me laugh

Julia toniato

the way that this happened and then you guys manifested ivy at one of your shows, i love to see this

pearcemcmahon13

YOU EVENTUALLY GOT IVY!!!

Phil

who’s gonna tell these little chickens they get to hear ivy

Ava Joyce

I came back here after they got IVY!!! 🫶🏻

__nochampagnejustproblems 🥂

Watching this knowing what we know now!!!!!!

Sophie kelly

Coming from the future to say that you indeed manifested “you’re losing me” 🤌🏼🤌🏼 superior!!!!

Margarida

Hearing you guys in this video say the saddest part is that Taylor "Isn't listening to you guys" and you're hoping you'll get "You're loosing me" ..... knowing what we know now after melbourne.... YOU MANIFESTED this life girls <3 Taytay IS listening!

Ida Just

i love the way this video ended, im sorry for y’alls loss, but i loved ‘ok, fuckin bye’

Ellison Hughes

She was dying to get call it what you want over with 😭😭

Jake Austin

She really said “No Bonnie No Crime”

Jacob

It's a good thing Bonny didn't know at this time that they were going to get Stay Stay Stay. We may have lost her permanently in the pit of despair!

Mark 857

You guys handled this so well, better than i would have expected 😂I sobbed when she played Coney Island and I missed it 😭

Leanne22

I am so sorry that this happened to you. I was hoping for you to get ivy for the show that you were going to see.

Gabriella Cibran

The way Bonny manifested IVY 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Laura

She just did Dorothea 😭😭😭 I'm so sorry 🥺

Kent

“Now go stand in the corner and think about what you did”!

Cowboy Like Evaaannn!!

Yes, I really really hope Taylor will play Ivy again on tour... I like seeing Emily and Bonnie happy because they bring such happiness to us. So if Taylor does repeat, I do hope she will at the concert Emily and Bonnie attend.... Sending out best wishes and happy thoughts to "The Girls" as my husband likes to refer to Em and Bon - "The Girls" .... it is an endearment because he knows that I think of Em and Bon as internet friends.

Lisa Kell

I mean am I the only one that thinks the secret songs will reset for the international leg of the tour? I mean she is definitely going to play it again on tour

Lydia

We want you gals to remain safe and sound.

Lisa Kell

You guys spent many, many videos saying the concert date you are attending. If Taylor would have saved Ivy for that date, It would have endangered you. Think about it. IF Taylor HAD saved Ivy for the show you guys are attending, she would have been painting a red bullseye on your backs... indicated that you have her ear. Which brings more danger than you realize. Taylor can afford high-end security, you cannot. And there are enough crazies out there that would try to 'get to you' solely because you were important to Taylor - enough that she granted your request.

Lisa Kell

I'm devastated for you guys, but also ending the video with just "fucking bye" made me laugh way too hard for way too long. Apologies for laughing at your misery.

Katie

I’m so sorry ladies 😞 I was so certain Taylor had seen your TikTok request! I know someone else in the Discord was manifesting Ivy (blasphemy 😆) for this date so at least someone got their wish! Sending love! Enjoy Roma!

Annika

immediately thought of you guys 😭 i feel your pain ciwyw is in my top 5 of all time and i was supposed to be there but instead i sobbed in a movie theater while she sang it 😭😭😭

Jess

The second I heard it the day of, I thought of you all ❤️😓 love you guys!!!

Bri26

good luckkk :)

alden

you girls are so cute in your no makeup, messy hair and nighties <3

Maja Gunhold

She'll simply have to repeat Ivy in you girls show 💔

Lissa

Rewatching this and it breaks my heart for you guys all over again. My niece and I are still hoping to get tickets for a Santa Clara or a LA date. Luck has not been on our side so far.

Denise Graves

I felt horrified when I saw the news! Maybe she’ll play it again for you gals 💞

Ursula

I have no idea why but the *TWO HOURS LATER* SpongeBob time card absolutely sent me 😂

Erik Danielson

omg I'm so sorry for u guys💔

Robin T.

Thoughts and prayers! This was me when I found out as well. I hope Italy makes up for it and that she plays something superior for you in a few weeks! ❤️

Abbi Reineccius

How you guys felt about ivy was how I felt about Maroon being played 2 weeks before my show 😭 but Call It What You Want was such a slap in the face to you both after still grieving over ivy 😭😭😭

Jenna Aguirre

I'm sooooo sorry :(

Dani Peña

bonnie just demonstrated the power of gut instinct...

Farah Canicosa

fuckin' bye <3

kayla ramoutar

Literally the second I heard she did "ivy", I thought of you. I was like "Oh, they're gonna be broken" 🧡

fortaylormore

Sorrows. Sorrows. Prayers.

Kimi Dowling

I’ve been on holiday and just caught up! I’m so sorry! It was my birthday july 1st and I cannot believe she did that to Bonny! Like wtf it really felt personal, and what’s worse is I have a coworker who was at that show and I am not happy for her lol..anyways my hope is that Taylor makes it up for you guys when your show comes and you never know maybe she’ll do Ivy for you in one of your Australia days! Love you enjoy your holiday in Italy! Check out the village of Pienza in Tuscany if you have time it’s so cute! 💕

Catherine (YOYOK stan)

Feels wrong to heart the video, but see it as a heart of support not liking your pain 💔

Naomi

It was incredible 😭

Rachel

It hurt to watch Emily’s face! I felt bone crushingly ill 😷 I’m so so so so sorry! Awwwww and Bon Bon with callbit what you want! Sending lots of love my Aussie Queens. Enjoy Rome!

devin dear

Same!!! I felt so blessed, I wasn’t sure what I did to deserve her giving me that 🥲

k80scorner

Yes, I love this idea of ranking the secret songs nights!!

Yoel (YtReX)

I appreciate that this hurt for you guys but you really should be so grateful that you're getting to go to any shows at all!! I've missed out on tickets to the Aus shows and watching the shows at all now is a little heartbreaking. You have SO MUCH to look forward to with all the shows you're going to, so I find it hard to feel too bad for you 😂

Rose Ellen

Yesssss fully agree, her alone and on piano, IDWLF was actually so beautiful and I rewatch my video often 😂 I am totally jealous of I bet you think about me!!! I would have been stoked for that one! I sincerely hope she comes out with some kind of doc, for tour of course, but something with ALL the secret song performances. They are just soooo good I need to be able to watch them all on repeat! Matter of fact an acoustic album made up of all those performances that I can download on Apple Music would be phenomenal 😂

Amanda Watts

Nice, I understand that. Thanks for responding!

MC

Omg I also have fallen in love with the IDWLF performance, it feels so different on piano 🥺. And I agree, I’ll neverrr get over her doing Clean and death by a thousand cuts together. Especially so early on in the tour! I went Atlanta N3 so I got I bet you think about me and how you get the girl. I was happy with them, neither are my stan songs but both very solid 😊

Melanie Hughes

This duo was superior, I’m so sad Ivy won’t be played at the Santa Clara show now 😭 Fun idea I had though, when the tour is over (or US part of the tour?) you guys should rank the secret song duos best to worst!

Allison

i don’t think it ruined it… there’s definitely a bittersweet feeling for me because she played 2 of my faves the show right before mine and 2 the show right after, so ofc there’s disappointment in that, but i was still so overwhelmed and grateful just to be there. there were sooo many good memories made and while i wouldn’t have chosen the surprise songs i got, i know when i look back on it there’s a thousand other moments i’ll hold onto and treasure!

Katrina Kauffman

I am curious, did not getting the surprise songs you wanted ruin or tarnish the show? A lot of people said Taylor swift was over because of night one in Cincinnati. I guess they say that after every show maybe?

MC

as someone who was at Cincy N1… I am almost as upset as you guys 😭

Katrina Kauffman

BTW, if I got to choose, I would have LOVED wonderland and Haunted. Or wonderland and long live.

MC

The moment she said Ivy, I thought of you guys and how bummed you’d be. I assume that is what this video was. Raw disappointment. I hope Rome is cheering you up. I got Mirrorball and Tim McGraw at the 1st show. They are not my favorites but I didn’t think about it because it was all new and overwhelming and it was sooo awesome getting sooo many songs! After seeing the anxiety, happiness, anger and disappointment people have been going through wondering what then finding out what songs they were going to get, it seems the 1st show might have been the best one to be at. I like Ivy and Call it what you want, but those are not my favorites either so I would not say Cincinnati night 2 won. So I guess my point is there are huge fans at every show and one persons favorite can be another persons… “Eyes Open”. (I don’t dislike that song). I am loving hearing all the different songs at each show. I hope you get some songs you like but I really think you will enjoy the show anyway.

MC

I was a Tampa N1 attendee too. Hi!

Emzies

I hope you had a grand time!

Emzies

<3<3

Ursula

This was me on the clean+death by a thousand cuts night 😵

Renee Parker

4:54 Emily’s bombastic side eye 😂

Grace Jackson

this is exactly how i felt when she played haunted and it was the night before my show😐 I WAS ILL

mallory mccann

no because its the way I immediately started praying for u guys when I heard Ivy AND Call it what you want

Lara buso

Please upload another video to let us know you’ve survived this.

Emzies

I THOUGHT OF YOU GUYS IMMEDIATELY 😢 condolences!!!

ChloeThePayne

Cincinnati night 2 really won. I’m sorry 😢

Grace Jackson

Girl calm down

Aaron M

I was at the show last night and can confirm that the combination of all 3 surprise songs was absolutely illegal! I feel very lucky to have experienced it in person 💜

Katherine Adams

Call it what you want was my number 1 surprise song on rep!! I'm soooooo sad!! And so sad for you guys for Ivy!! Definitely not a good night for us XD

tatiana

MY CONDOLENCES 🪦💜

Arturo

Why? Are you not allowed to express opinions here?

Julia George

i thought about you guys immediately

brendan

I saw she had performed Ivy and I gasped and immediately thought of you guys. I’m sorry 💕 praying she resets the secret songs for international Swifties.

Krystal Ortega

My delusional ass self was really thinking for a minute "well maybe on the night of their show she'll do it again and surprise them after making them think she was unaware of their request when really she knew all along" but that is like the highest level of delusion :( :( :(

Maria Battaglia

I love you guys, but you must understand you did this to yourselves out of never-ending fantasy. You could hope, sure, but to make it such a be all and end all when there was never more than a .2% chance she would save this for your show, or even then, was a recipe for disaster. She played Daylight the other night to honor a fan's direct request to play the song for her deceased brother. So, forget Tik-Tok or Patreon. Make a direct appeal. Also, there is always Australia.

Jim Lent

Heartbroken

Renee Albert

I’m so sorry I felt I had betrayed my besties when Aaron came on the stage to play ivy… I almost had to overt my eyes. And call it what you want?! AND Gracie? I mean, truly must have done something right in another life. So sorry you weren’t here to witness

Grace Jackson

Completely agree with this. It’s one thing to clown about “losing” a song; quite another to be angry or hateful.

BrooklynSwifty

Love y’all 💜 P.S. seeing this tour for the second time in Kansas City on Saturday. I can send some solid recordings of the secret songs to your mods if needed. Hang in there! But also…she could hypothetically reset and do Ivy in Australia. Just saying. 👀

Craig McKibben

Give Brae the Emmy for best performance in a guest starring role

Jason H

taylor really chose VIOLENCE last night to play two of my top songs from their respective ALBUMS. i also feel personally attacked

Juliana Martinez

Ugh I was so sad about this for you guys😩 still some superior songs left for you!!!!

Christina

Ugh the SCREAM I let out on that pairing for all of our sakes! Literally the most devastating of losses. HOW DARE SHE!? WITHOUT US!? THE NERVE!!! And in random Ohio of all places 😂. What did they do to deserve that!?

Sam Obrien

besties I am SO SORRY, I saw photos during the show that aaron was there and I immediately got this pit in my stomach thinking "is tonight the night they lose ivy" praying she resets songs for international dates and sings ivy in australia for you!!!

Julia Fisher

that was the rudest, most illegal combo so far LIKE WHAT

Julia Fisher

YES like can’t she combine better! 😂😭 I was at Chicago N2 and got you all over me and I don’t wanna live forever… in the moment I was just so bummed out that the second one wasn’t even an album song, and I don’t love the first one, but I admit after the fact I’ve fallen in love with the IDWLF performance and wish I would have appreciated it more when I was there 🥹 and I was also at Houston N3 and got cold as you and begin again. I do like those songs but they’re not in my top 50 lollll. This whole time my ultimate jealousy show was death by a thousand cuts & clean (both top 5’s for me) but tbh I think last night topped it considering the Gracie performance. That is my literal dream, I LOVE Gracie and love that song

Amanda Watts

I hope she reset the surprise songs outside US. You may not get Ivy this july but who knows? you might get it in your AU show. I love Ivy but i wouldn't mind losing the song for you.

GIE

I feel incredibly sorry for you both, I was at both Cincy shows and I’ve never felt more blessed 🥲😭

k80scorner

I’m glad I was there, but the way I IMMEDIATELY thought of you guys the second she said the song title.😭

Kelly Vance

i’m so sorry for your loss….. but so glad i was there

Jess Davis

It was cleansing tears and I was glad to have the release. They mean a lot to me and I knew this would affect them a lot. But i appreciate your words!

Literally Natalie

i love how we are all reacting like someone has died lol😭

cat

It was a horrible night! Call it what you want is my FAVORITE SONG. Ivy is your favorite :( terrible losses!!!

Emily Christine

guys i CANNOT express the GRIEF i feel for you … i’m so so so so soooo sorry, i’m genuinely devastated on your behalf 😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔 im so happy you guys are in beautiful rome now and have the gorgeous city to get your mind off of it and i know that of course, you’ll still have the best time everrr ever EVER at your show on the 29th, love u girls so much, really soooo sorry for the loss of ivy😭😭😭💔 taylor truly truly needs to be sent to jail 🥲💔

farah abed

My first time to comment, but I just had to on this one. I wait to find out the surprise songs by watching you girlies reacting to them. However, I was scrolling YouTube and just saw the words Ivy night night 2 and said "Oh NO!" outloud. Immediately came over to look for ya'lls video. :( I had convinced myself that the Queen was watching you ladies and saving Ivy for you. 😑 I hope she does something else super special for the show you guys are attending! Love your videos and hope you have a fabulous holiday despite this. ❤

Lauren Edwards

WE LOVE YOU GUYS! GO HAVE A SPRITZ!! I screamed BONNY and EMILY NOOOO and my mom was like "is that the australian girls" and then we both grieved all night...I just hope you know how many people in here are so grateful for you girls and truly are so happy you have created this community for us all to talk and experience this tour together...manifesting HARD for a repeat and I wont give up on this mission

Ava Jeffs

i had myself so convinced that she had seen your requests and was waiting to play ivy for you. my mom and i were texting each other like “noooo no no, poor bonnie and emily”

Autumn Atencio

Offensive illegal night. Viva Rome era!

aubrey

i was GRIEVING too i left cincinnati YESTERDAY MORNING i should’ve stayed agsjsgsjsh. so sorry for you both but you’re gonna have the most fun vacation ever and there’s always your Australia shows!!!!

Ava Joyce

I'm sorry you're disappointed. I know y'all are mostly kidding but remember you get to see Taylor 3 times coming up and that is 3 times more than most. Love y'all 🫶

mckenna

Besties I am sooo sorry when I found out i immediately thought of y’all 😭

Marie Guidry

There were so many people in the livestream I watched mourning for you guys! I’m so sorry 😖

Jordyn

I literally threw my phone across the room and screamed "NOOOO BONNY AND EMILY" 🥺 I'm so sorry for your loss ❤️❤️❤️

Emily Melzer

She prob let Aaron pick the song he wanted to play in his hometown

Mal

After I lost getaway car, no loss ever hurt the same. You guys will get through this. Thoughts and prayers. Stay strong

Ashley

Go have fun in Italy today!

Lisa Kell

I IMMEDIATELY thought of you guys

Katie Weavil

Oh noooooo!! I just happened to see Taylor’s post on instagram where she actually mentions the songs she played last night and I immediately was like, oh no! The girls are going to be devastated! I rushed over here to see your reaction. I’m sorry! The audacity, Taylor! So rude. Lol I hope she makes up for it in some fashion for your show. 🤞🏻

Whitney Mercer

I"m sure she'll reset the secret songs when she leaves the US.. maybe you'll get them in Australia!

Samantha Million

thought of you guys immediately when I saw the secret songs, I'm so sorry🥺❤️

ak

It’s just a song :)

Tracy

i was NOT expecting that i’m so sorry guys

Cameron D’Ettore

You know what? This happened bc yal are gonna get the MOST SUPERIOR ILLEGAL SNTV vault track like Castles Crumbling or Timeless secret song come July 29!!!! *knock on wood* My heart did involuntarily sink to my stomach for you today, but you gals are True Blue incredible leaders in this fandom and exemplar Swifties; I know Blondie’s got something truly superior for you in store 💜

Samantha Orlando

She played my favorite song, Red, 2 nights after my concert. That hurt.

Joshua Siegel

INSTANTLY thought of you guys😓😓 I hadn’t fathomed “ivy” until I started watching your channel. It really is one of her best songs ever💔 We love you two though!!!! Hoping for “You’re Losing Me” for you both💕

Jenna Grimando

this will be me if she plays long live and i’m not there.. when she announced the eras tour ALL i wanted to hear was long live. she could’ve done a 3 hour interpretive dance routine and i wouldn’t have cared as long as i got to hear my favorite song played 😭😭😭

Sarah Ratzloff

i would have felt the same way but she played the other side of the door and im an anxious girly to say the least so i was happy for that and then she played coney island which as special because my friend that came with i had just turned to a swiftie a few months before the show and it was her first song she really fathomed the lyrics for. so just try to find the good reasons for the songs you got and also im sure that a lot of the song in the setlist would have been the best ss you could have gotten as well and it was garenteed you got to experience them

Amyisaswiftie13

i litea;;y almost cried last night for you guys (period thingsss) because i was so sure she was saving it for you guys. yall better get your fav sn vault song and another fav to make it up

Amyisaswiftie13

i really hope in whatever movie/doc we get about the eras tour she give us a little bit of an insight on HOW she chose this songs? like why certain song on that location and pairing?? because the math aint mathing

MF SS

I’m so so sorry you guys!!!! Also it seems like you didn’t know I Miss You, I’m Sorry so I highly recommend listening to Gracie’s music before her first proper album it’s some of my favorites and you’d really like it. After holiday, and SN era of course. 💕

Hannah Stiff

Also, eat all the gelato and drink all the wine you need today, girls. We love you!

Laura R

You are God’s favorite!

Ally ❤️

Also, “Okay… Fuckin’ Byeeee.” I appreciate this addition to the urban dictionary ❤️

Ally ❤️

I saw it was ivy last night and immediately went “noooo” because I thought of y’all and then saw it was also call it what you want, my all-time favorite song 😭😭😭😭 (I got clean and the DBATC bridge x3) just so heartbroken

Tricia

I was there last night and thought of you guys immediately💔

Maya Klein

I immediately thought of both of you last night. I am so sorry. I screamed and said out loud oh no Emily and Bonnie will be so sad and disappointed.

RuthGA

I don't know if it's just me, but, when I went to my show and was a little disappointed that I didn't get any of my stan songs during the SS portion, I felt weird about it. Like I almost wonder if I would have gotten to enjoy the show more purely if I had avoided all show spoilers and gone in cold--but like how could I have possibly avoided spoilers. Idk, I just felt bad that I was upset about not getting my stan songs when there were months between losing out during the presale and actually getting tickets as Ticketmaster slowly reached out to people when I was devastated that I truly thought I wasn't going to get to go to the show at all. I'm not trying to make anyone feel bad for the way they feel about losing their stan songs. I just have a lot of rambling thoughts about my experience and hope it makes sense to someone else. Anyway, I feel your pain, and, Bonny and Emily, I really wanted her to play Ivy at your show. I'm so sorry. If it's any consolation, I was very pleasantly surprised when I went to the show that there are lots of visuals and details that I hadn't seen in any tiktoks. I'm excited for you to experience them, and I still hope you get some truly superior surprise songs during your show.

Laura R

so sorry guys!!!! the second i heard on the livestream she was gonna play ivy i immediately thought of you guys💔💔💔

Allee Weathers

Okay, first, thank you for the iconic new rtitle: “A Perfectly Good Fucking Heart” i love you both so and as heart broken for you. I felt this way when she did evermore on Friday. It’s my favorite song of Taylor’s - my #1… I was hoping for it at Seattle N1…I know, I know…. 😔

Ally ❤️

So sorry for your loss💔💔💔 I was equally as unwell as you guys 🥲

Jaden

I texted all my friends saying how sad i felt for you. They don’t watch your shows but i didn’t care i was like MY GIRLS OH NO

Shannon Gilhooly

I’m so so sorry ❤️ once I saw it was ivy I immediately thought of you, and CIWYW, very offensive night, possibly not the good kind of offensive. Love you guys so much

Candice Rossi

I was crushed when she started playing Ivy but I was almost more upset when she played Call It What You Want, especially for Bonnie’s sake. Of all the Rep songs, this was the last one I thought she’d do. Why did Cincinnati get so blessed!

Yasmine Z

WHY TAYLOR :(((

Rons

IVY AND CALL IT WHAT YOU WANT. I won’t recover

Audrey Pratt

I couldn’t even fathom what was happening while I watched

Audrey Pratt

I feel your pain, this is how I felt when I lost sparks fly, but then I ended up getting another one of my stan songs at my show so I'm hoping it works out for you guys. stay strong <3

Aleesha Milligan

Sending deepest condolences, I believed that July 29 was Ivy day! I’ve even been telling my family that it’s your day. Ivy today was uncalled for. Please, never stop believing that Taylor loves you both. She’s just very busy. One day she’ll sit down to watch all you vids and realise the mistake that was made. Your love and support of Taylor is not in vain. Enjoy Rome biatches 😘😘

Cara M

I was there and immediately i thought “oh my god Bonnie’s gonna be so sad” hahaha I’m so sorry for your loss

Rachel

I was there and I had so many mixed feelings when she said IVY. Happy confused kind of feeling. Love you guys. My heart does break for you.

Justyne Redd

As soon as she said it I thought of yall and was like "NOOOOO NOT IVY!" I'm sorry for your loss

Tatyana

I'm so sad for you girls, I wanted her to play Ivy at your show.

Katrina

She started playing Ivy and I said out loud to my 10 year old daughter “Oh no! My friends are going to be so upset!” And then had to explain that you weren’t people I knew. 😂

Melanie Kluger

I saw that she did Ivy and immediately thought “The girls are going to die”

Ashlyn Smith

brae apologizing to you guys :'( i hate that bonny already knew what was coming

sam funk!

No like…. I cried for you. I can’t believe this

Katie

im so sorry girlies😭 but dont be too depressed, you'll get great songs i know it!!

charlie

As soon as she started playing it I was like "oh. Oh no. Damn it. Poor Bonny. Poor Em." So sorry for your loss guys

Val Flores

the way I immediately thought of you once she said ivy ?!?!

סבי שליו (4-ש)

I was with my 8 year old niece when I saw it was Ivy and I scared her with my visceral NOOOOOOO!! So sorry guys 🥹 Manifesting You’re Losing Me & Dorothea for July 29th ✨✨✨

Vick Wagner

i literally drove 5hrs yesterday morning to Cincy just to stand outside the stadium to hear the show because i could feel it in the air that it was going to be an offensive pairing tonight 🥲 the second ivy started playing i thought of this video. i’m so sorry!! here’s hoping she flies Aaron to Australia and resets for those dates!!

Kristen

The fact that call it what you want used to be a guitar song but is a piano song now after her and joe broke up is OFFENSIVEEEE

Sophie Callaghan

I really am so so sorry. The moment i heard it was ivy i immediately thought of you. Sending love and prayers to you right now and I hope you get to hear ivy during your Australian show.

Laura Wylie

Maybe she's just psyching you out and on July 29th she'll be like "Bonny and Emily are here with us tonight, I was just kidding with you guys, here's Ivy" 😂

Liam Mcfarlane

😭😭😭

Alice

i immediately thought of you guys when watching the livestream, sending you love today <3

sam funk!

my first thought when I woke up and saw the surprise songs was EMILY AND BONNY!!! mourning for you guys today, enjoy rome tho <333

Nayara De Iuliis

I'm sorry lovelies ❤️ the love chat when this happened exploded!

Rissy (Taylor's Version)

Ow besties, I'M SO SORRY YOU LOST IVY!!! Literally the first thing I thought of last night was you guys, I couldn't believe it was actually happening! 😭😭 manifesting an extra superior duo for your night, and your Australia shows!!!

Ileana Isabel

I wish for the both of you that she plays Ivy again on July 29th 🙏🏽 you two manifested this in every single video you posted , i hope someone would at least show Taylor how heartbroken you two were . mother cant simply do that 😭 OFFENSIVE! ILLEGAL!

shilaakadar

my heart broke instantly and thought of you all lol

Hayden

When I saw it on Twitter last night, I was so sad for y'all all I could think was "Oh nooooo poor Bonny and Emily when they see this they're going to die" 😭

Alyssa Wehr

People in Tess’s live stream (myself included) were mourning on y’all’s behalf last night. I am SO sorry!! I just cannot believe Bonnie’s intuition was spot on!

Hannah

I’m so sorry! I was there and all I could think about was ohhh noooo she needed to save this one for you guys!!!!

Lish Marie

I agree, she plays the most superior combination of songs together and it’s not fair 😭 now I’m curious what surprise songs you had 🤭

Melanie Hughes

I just want to know what you girls did to tic off Taylor, because clearly you are being punished. Truly, my heart broke for you as soon as I heard her say the word Ivy....I literally gasped out loud and then screamed on your behalf. Sending you three virtual hugs!

Candy

i'm so fucked up by this!!!! i don't know if i can forgive her for doing both ivy and call it what you want without me there !!!!!

Giovana Faillace

I'm so sorry girls!!! But I trully believe she will reset the secret songs once she finishes the US leg of the tour, so I'm manifesting Ivy for your show in Australia ❤️

Patrícia Silva Ramos

i was scared for this reaction 😭

madison martin

I’m so sorry guys! We were trying to find a way for Ivy to disappear as a SS last night, but it was impossible to turn back the time… Go on and eat all the good Pasta! Sending you all the good energy for your Songs on July 29th hopefully they will be SUPERIOR 💜

Zai Moyano

Watching Emily get her heart broken was devastating!!! Then Bonny, lending all of her support to ‘Em….only to be crushed herself!! Lord, how do I get through this day???? We will be fine, but not OK!!!

Rhonda Bush

What if she was like « I'm only cryptic and Machiavellian 'Cause I care » and then plays Ivy AGAIN only for you on July 29th guys 😭

Sarah Jade

I’m so sorry friends! As soon as Aaron came out, I got worried. 🥹🥹🥹

Ashley Grady

Please treat yourself to a frightful amount of pasta and gelato and soak in the glorious Italian atmosphere today girlies

Laura Donovan

I really think once she gets to California she will repeat many of the favorites before leaving the country💛💛

Lively_Ash

I'm ill

Ana Luiza reis de noronha

ivy and call it what you want?? she needs to stoppppp!!!!! so sorry for you guys, hope she gives you long story short or right where you left me

Mia Gregorio

Saddest react ever. So sorry this happened just weeks from your night. Manifesting something equally superior for then!

matty67106

IMMEDIATELY i thought of y’all last night. so sorry for your loss girlies 💜

Emily Dickey

THE LITERAL 2 MOST PLAYED SONGS ON MY SPOTIFY EVER OF ALL TIME THIS IS NOT FAIR!!!!! love u both sm I am right there with you

Brook Harrison

IM SO SORRY YOU GUYS!!! I literally feel very much betrayed by last night’s surprise song combination, it’s like my 2 stand albums AND my absolute favorite song of them both. I was in Tampa night 1 and I mean I’m grateful for speak now and treacherous BUT BUT BUUUTTTT I deserved ivy and call it what you want 😂😭 it’s like the night she sang dear John and daylight (I’m so sorry but I’m not happy for any of the people that were there🥲)

María José Gutiérrez

Jaclyn, I was there in the stadium and when I tell you i screamed NOOO and found it almost impossible to enjoy it for that reason!

Catherine Crawford

IM SO SORRY, this was my hometown show and as soon as she said Ivy I was like, “Oh no, Bonnie and Emily’s song!!” 😂 I don’t know how I survived last night

Lauren Gramling

OMG as soon as I heard the secret songs I thought of you guys but especially Bonny as she’s a rep girlie! For ‘ivy’ I thought it was a MISTAKE, surely she couldn’t do that 😅🥲 “I hate stanning this woman, because she breaks my heart”— SAME Em, Same!! Last night I was ‘hate-watching’ (not really) the secret songs but I had to tune out of TS content after because it hurts so much that she’s doing all that for some shows while I’ll never be able to see her live 💔

Miantsa

woah your premonitions at the start were spot on😱 That combo of songs was pure heartbreak...

Dhanushi P

I watched the livestream last night and as soon as she said ivy I gasped and thought of you. So sorry for this loss!!

Sara Brannon

Maybe their Patreon isn’t the best place for you?

J R

The first TikTok i saw this morning was her playing ivy and i immediately yelled “but Bonnie and Em!” Sorry for you guys. I hope you get some gelato to feel better!

Jaclyn Loschiavo

My heart broke for y’all tonight. BUT! Your show will be iconic I know it. And you never know with her it’s like, songs you didn’t know you needed because you’re there and she’s HER. I knew (we all knew) Aaron was going to be there for at least one of his hometown dates and I REALLY REALLY WANTED, well firstly- it to be at my show lol, and second, long story short or peace (would have died for Ivy but was manifesting for y’all’s show! also it’s an Aaron, Jack, Tay song so I thought they would save it or it would just be her when it happened!). I was in Cincinnati for night 1. I can’t tell you how I dropped to the floor in shock and tears and cry sang my way through evermore with her. Never fathomed her doing it without Justin so it was not on my radar. I thought we were going to get a rep song on piano after I’m only me when I’m with you which I also cry sang myself through just out of sheer nostalgia even though l rarely listen to that song. Evermore was so unreal I can’t even explain. Never knew I needed it that much and your show will be the same way. You’re going to get No Body No Crime as an extra for suuuuure which will just like, absolutely slap!! and who knows!! She could play Ivy again! You’ll get at least in Australia I just know it.

Audrey Snider

I love that Bonny the cancer queen not only felt beforehand that the vibe was off but didn’t question afterward that her intuition had been telling her something. Feelings are her superpower💪🏻🌸

J R

As soon as she said Ivy, I immediately thought of all of you!

Landon Talbott

I am so sorry!!! She can make it up to you two by giving you the hat at your show 😉

Christine

As an Ivy stab myself, my heart just BREAKS for you guys 🩷 so unfair and she better redeem herself at your show!!

Ariel Powell

Emily: does not compute Brea: Genuine shock Bonnie: heartbroken scream.

Green Wolf Gaymer

I have a mantra I turn to often - keep my ego out of it. I was worried last reaction when you guys were saying about the fans, for the fans etc … I was so worried that when she did something out of sync with our ego’s version of how things should go, we’d be beyond disappointed. I am so deeply sorry you missed Ivy. Taylor has so many internal & external reasons and forces and thoughts and influences. Please do not take this personally. Love and understanding and serious mama-empathy from Ohio. You girls rock.

JC S

I... I never see the secret songs I always come here first... I can't believe she did. I truly... Wow... So sorry girls 💚

Analice

Bonny's face when Taylor announces Aaron and they're all excited and she goes "😨wait...I don't like that" I died🤣🤣🤣🤣 I'm so sorry for this loss girlies, but that part made me laugh🤣

Michelle Akin

I’ve never been more scared of Emily than during those first 30 seconds of Ivy 😳… A tough day girlies, thinking of you 💚

Courtney

if you liked i miss you i’m sorry you should totally react to gracie’s first ep ‘minor’ !!! it’s the one ep of hers you haven’t done :)) and it’s highly illegal

aiyla

As an I miss you I’m sorry, ivy, and call it what you want stan, this was a tough night lol

Fahmeen

I’m worried that her fans getting so emotionally invested in her surprise songs means she won’t do that ever again. That her future tours will just have a set playlist with fewer surprises. She’s enjoying our enthusiasm, but there are so many times she can read “I’m done with TS” on the internet and it stops being fun or funny. I met someone at Pittsburgh who was at the Nashville show for the Speak Now TV announcement, but was actually disappointed because of the surprise song choices weren’t any of her personal favs. What? She’s putting on a 3hr show! Enjoy it!!

M3L

this night was the most superior of them all so far, we got IVY with AARON, IMYIS WITH GRACIE AND CALL IT WHAT YOU WANT

aiyla

as a really old gracie fan and swiftie, i'm actually not able to fathom

aiyla

Absolutely. What a powerful statement Rachel.

Julia George

I was there. Just got home and can’t sleep. The dichotomy of emotions I felt at the same time was unbelievable I felt unbelievably overjoyed but I knew what this meant for you guys and was also devastated at the same time. However, she did mess it up. I think on purpose for you guys, so you might be able to hear it.

Loren Payne

love you guys so much was thinking of you guys all day after the show 😣😢stay strong maybe we can manifest dorothea 🥺

karisa

HER DOING IMYIS WITH GRACIE WAS TOO MUCH LIKE SORRY I AM SO UNWELL BC OF THAT

aiyla

I was watching it live and my heart broke for you. I somehow got it in my head that y’all would really get it at your show. I’m so sorry! So many hugs and kisses to you.

Brittany DeLara

Bonny, your intuition is wild. I have nothing else to say !

Adélaïde K

My heart dropped for you when I found out it was ivy, I’m so sorry for your loss😣 sorrows, sorrows, prayers💔

Madeleine O'Connell

I saw so many TikTok comments on the live mentioning you two - the community is with you guys 💕 couldn’t even watch this whole video lol. I lost my #1 song (WCS) the weekend before my show and it was utterly gut wrenching. Love you both, enjoy Rome and take some time to process - still plenty of amazing songs left ♥️

Ben Houtz

They are allowed to be disappointed. Don't take it personally.

Rachel

gelato won't cure your depression, but it will certainly help

mad

I live in germany close to some old churches and I just literally thought "should I go light a candle for your souls?"

Nin

Girls, go get some good ice cream. You deserve it

Sara _

i’m 99.999% certain she’s resetting the surprise songs when she does international dates so there’s still a chance!! 😭

leo

there was just something in Taylor's coffee this morning that made her go "you know what? I'm gonna fuck things up"

Nin

Omg my heart sank, I’m so sorry 🙁

Gustav Lucas

As Rep and evermore being my two fav albums, I feeeeel the pain. I immediately thought of you guys when she started ivy 😭 and ciwyw on piano was completely uncalled for- what did Ohio do to deserve thisss

Maggie

Bon don't say that, she does love you, she said so, remember?

Nin

I can literally see Emily's soul leave her body

Nin

i was instantly crushed

leo

I'm way too nervous, someone hold my hand while I keep watching, god I hate that I went on instagram this morning and know what's gonna happen

Nin

First ting I thought when I saw she played Ivy💔 so sorry for you guys

Amanda Olsson

My heart skipped a beat for you when Taylor said "Ivy" 😰😭 Hope Rome makes your day better! 🫶

Elisabeth Maria

as soon as I saw she played Ivy I texted my gf and a friend about how I'm not ready to watch your reaction because I might cry with you, feel hugged tightly, loves

Nin

I am so sorry guys 😭😭 enjoy Rome to recover!!

Federica

Oh my heart broke for you guys when I listened to these secret songs live. Ivy and CIWYW were an illegal combo. Hopefully by the time she comes to Australia she'll have done a reset as she's already performed my stans songs too - can only hope :)

montanasherie

Sad for you guys. After a hellish week to actually get tickets to her show here in Australia- she can play whatever she wants and I’ll love it. Entirely unrelated topic- am I insanely late to the party on the Harry Styles Easter egg in the Bejeweled music video? I watched “Don’t worry Darling” for the first time today and died when I watched the Dita Von Tesse scene in the martini glass.

Helen Dunham

She said Ivy and all of your fans all over the world gasped in dismay on your behalf. Since you are in Rome I hope you spent the day eating yummy food until you felt better.

Tracy Peterson

I'm going to melb night 1 and honestly I think we all deserve this

Hayden Brice

the 1th of July is officially a mourning day in this community :(((((((

maya zutra

She was like the loving mother we all needed after this night

alex

I’m so sorry guys 😭 I was 113% she would have seen your TikTok and saved ivy for you 😭🧡 maybe she’ll play ivy on your Australian show, I hope she will!! 🙏🏽

Franzi

Just woke up!! Haven’t even watched this yet but I knowww and OHHHHH girls I’m SO SO sorry 💔😭💔 but that was an amazing night, that really was a Bon & Em night! Hopefully being in Italy will help console you. Go out and eat ALL the pizza, pasta and gelato for comfort. Love you two! You’re going to get something absolutely offensive for your tour night I just know it!!!! ❤️😘

Katie K

I am so sad for u😭 i know how heartbreaking it is, Im a rep and maroon stan and god it hurt losung maroon and anytime she did a rep song I cried. I know ppl online scream ohhh just be grateful she even does this bla bla but I think it is perfectly reasonable to be sad over losing the posibility of hearing ur fav songs that u hold so deep in ur heart live, especially if its ur first taylor tour. So u go ahead and be sad little chickens!!! 💔💜💔💜💔💜💔 praying she will repeat it for u!!!! i love u guys, enjoy italy and we will seeeee uuuu next week for SNTV 💜💜💜

raheel

Hopefully, you will get other superior surprise songs!!

Julia

I agree when you miss out on tickets and I have no chance of seeing her you, don’t give a shit about secret songs anymore

Julia George

The immediate PAIN I felt for you both. Just think maybe speak now vault songs will have some of your new favourite songs and she could play those 🥹🥹🥹

Raven Patzner

Omg no way that’s so sweet 🥹😅

Chats & Reacts

Read the Room I am an aunt to an 11 and a 10-year-old, who are bereft that they will not get to see Taylor. I love watching and supporting you both. As soon as I heard this song, I felt for you both. Knowing that you are about to see her in the US and more than likely Sydney and Melbourne, that was a really hard video to watch. “We were joking” I am sorry for your loss. My 11 year old niece, and 10 year old niece just watched this video and they didn’t get it.

Julia George

Bonny had the gut feeling right in the beginning.. some big losses incoming.. so sorry for you guys 🥺🥺but I’m sure she will find a way to make up for this on July 29th

alex

I like truly feel that pain, this will be me when Last Kiss is played. I understand with my soul, and evermore last night!! “This woman can go stand in the corner and think about what she did” Ivy was for you chickens!

Alana Ashley

About to watch this heartbreak 🥺 all I’ve thought since this afternoon is that Taylor >>>simply must<<< have something absolutely superior and offensive and unfathomable in store for you on July 29th … it’s the only acceptable explanation 🙏🙏🙏

Laura (in my eras era) 🫶

they won't be happy for you Ryan hahaha

Shawn

you are evil hahahahaha

Shawn

when i first heard ivy a while ago, i totally cried and thought of you guys and told myself ‘they’re on a vacation right now, no’

Maria Fatima

Watch her playing Eyes Open and A Perfectly Good Heart on July 29th xD

Roxyy

Sorry for your loss 😭😭😭😭

Kimberly

i was there and as soon as i heard her say ivy i almost collapsed. i was praying for this one all day and it was all i was talking avout

ryan

I actually attended cincy n2 and when she announced she was singing Ivy my heart dropped. I immediately thought of you both, and how close your show is… THEN she played CALL IT WHAT YOU WANT and i truly knew how much pain you both would be going through. Show was amazing 💜

Katie Skrovan

SAME, made me so emo for Gracie 🥹

Nele

I feel for you guys! Really tough, and it feels personal, just like missing out on tickets felt this week. :(

Leilani Willcox

I'm so sorry for you guys, I really thought she would do it for you on July 29th... Manifesting already she plays a new offensive duo on your day

Carlos Rabell Trullenque

"I miss you, I'm sorry" was the first Gracie Abrams song I heard many years ago and I fell in love with her right that second. Seeing her play it with Taylor Swift in this giant crowded stadium made me soooo emo for her 😭🫠❤️

Nele

My heart also broke for you both when I saw Ivy was a secret song tonight. Sending my love 💛

V Babida

I saw this earlier and waited hours for this reaction. I want you to know I literally cried no for you xoxo

Iona Paterson

i was literally screaming no

jo

Naaaaaaaur 😭 Thank god Brae was there for emotional support

Nele

The fact that this was spoiled for me on Instagram but I refused to believe it until I saw this. I swear I trauma blocked it from my memory

Taylah Louise

After the INSANITY of lucking out and getting tickets for Melbourne night three, after 20+ hours in the Ticketek lounge, over two days, I’ve found a new peace with the secret songs. She can play eyes open and I’ll bloody love it! 😂😂😂 P.S eat all the pasta, drink all the wine. 💕

Jo

Not Bonny saying she feels scared in the beginning 😭 I wish you a smooth recovery!!!

Petranka

all jokes aside so sorry for you guys 😔💔 manifesting long story short/dorethea/long story short

Daisy

Yes, and "You're Losing Me'. Maybe even "Cornelia Street" on guitar. It's the most superior thing ever.

Lin Gill

The way that color drained from Emily’s face 😭I’m so sorry y’all.

Laura M

In solidarity, I have decided not to speak to Taylor Swift today, cause that was just too much🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲

Chloe

You guys are the first thing I thought of when I saw! I’m so sorry 🫶

Selene

Comiserations :(

Seán

the way my heart dropped when i saw ivy being played. so sorry for you girls 😭💔

Ella Whitaker

I really thought you guys had it! 💔 side note I’m clowning over the fact both secret songs played this weekend, Evermore and CIWYW, both reference November?…

Bianca

My fiancé randomly said “oh she played Call it What You Want. Something with Gracie Abrams and Ivy tonight”. The gasp and NOOOOOO that came out of me. My dad asked “oh is that what you wanted to hear” Me “no. Well yes. But my friends did more. But I love those songs. And I don’t actually know these girls. But uggggggg. I’m so sad for them” And then fiancé said “and Aaron came out “ And I told him to F off 😂

Ashley Summers

The duet with Gracie was so heartbreakingly beautiful I caaaaan't

Maya

Manifesting 'Long Story Short' for you for July 29th!!!!!

Jessie

awwwww girliessss!!! sorrows, sorrows, prayers! no but seriously when I was watching I thought of you guys immediately! So devastated for you both

Sarah Gainsford

Taylor went all in on the offense tonight 💀 I'm so sorry for the loss of ivy, but I'm hoping y'all get the must superior songs for your show in a few weeks ❤️

Teemu Juutilainen

Thoughts and prayers 🫶😭💔 I’m so sorry for your loss Manifesting You’re Losing Me for July 29th

Jack B

No but I was absolutely SURE that she saw your TikTok and will play Ivy July 29th

Karolina

the way emily was basically speechless after taylor started playing ivy🥲🥲 im sorry guys😩 i hope you guys get awesome surprise songs on your show🫶🏻

Kate Herrera

You may still get another superior song!! You don’t know, maybe it was a blessing in disguise.

Karolina

also, you look so cute in your nighties

Dorka

I'm so sorry I thought of both of you the minute I heard Ivy.

Cardigan

Cannot express how devastated I am for you both </3 As a fellow aussie I am CLINGING to the hope that she will reset for international dates - after all she has more international shows than she does US. Praying for ivy melbs night 1

Sofia

Immediately thought of y’all 😭 Fingers crossed she resets and plays it at an Australian show y’all go to! 🤞🏻

Meech

So sorry 💔💔 when I read it I went NOOooooooo poor Bonny and Emily. My heart breaks for you guys! And CIWYW too?!?! What a combination. 😫

November Flush (Sam)

Sending my deepest condolences.... this a deep loss. A tragedy. Taylor has blacklisted herself just a lil bit 💀💀💀🤣🤣

Emily Hopkins

Sorrows, sorrows, prayers 🥲 I am so sorry for you guys, this night definitely was a frightful night for most of us. You will hear ivy at Australian shows I am sure of it! Manifesting great songs for you on July 29th!

Joanna Kowal

My deepest condolences 💔

Carla

😭😭😭 no words 🤗🤗🤗

Meg Hollingworth

OH NO!!!! Im so sorry loves ❤️

Renee

I so thought she was saving ivy for your show 😭 when I saw the list I said NOOO YOU'RE EARLY IT'S NOT THE 29TH 😭 I hope y'all get amazing songs at your show and hopefully somehow it, even slightly, eases your 💔

Hannah Kennedy

The way I ran here when I heard about the songs. My deepest sympathies besties 😭 Fingers crossed she‘ll reset for international dates and you‘ll get Ivy 🫶🏼

Miriam

You are the strongest of swifties. You can get through this😭😭

Natalie Buckner

I begged for them to do “right where you left me” when Aaron walked out but the moment she said “ivy??” my jaw dropped and I yelled “NO!” as my husband was driving Then CIWYW came on… oooof I’m so sorry

Candice Plendl

I love Bonnys psychic powers! She felt it coming didn't she?

Maya

💔💔💔💔💔

Natalie Buckner

Rip <3

Bobhog

but i mean… at least we live at the same time as taylor fucking swift? that’s something to be grateful for right? but goddanmit not fucking ivy

cat

BONNY take it back to being grateful we have secret songs at all. 😅🐓🤍

elizabethjulia

i didn’t expect to cry watching this????? like seriously i feel so bad for you guys

cat

I'm so sorry girls :'(

Dorka

I’m so sorry besties😭 the way my heart broke for you two when I first heard it 🥺 fingers crossed that she’ll play it again in SC or AUS!!!

Tefi Riveros

Truly sorry for you guys. My deepest condolences.

Emmie Kruger

I am so so so sorry. I was outside the stadium Tay Gating cuz I couldn’t afford tickets but I had a suspicion that since Aaron was from Cincinnati he would be out tonight but I DID NOT expect Ivy! My friend was recording us reacting to Aaron walking out and the secret songs and I was losing my mind and then she said Ivy and the first thing out of my mouth was, “Chats and Reacts is gonna hate us!” I was shook. I honestly expected and was hoping for Renegade (cuz I wanted you to have Ivy) especially because Big Red Machine is named after the Cincinnati Reds cuz the band is from Cinci. But alas, my heart breaks for you. And then CIWYW. I said, “Oh no they might kick me off Patreon for this. They’re gonna be so mad.” Never in my wildest dreams did I expect this combo/trio. I’m glad I got to hear it (even though I was outside the stadium, not witnessing it) but gosh I wish she’d saved at least one of them for you! I wanted Long Story Short or Renegade, but I never expected to be blessed in a way that made you so magnificently cursed. Please forgive me! I didn’t manifest it, I swear!

Christiana Somers

I don’t normally Comment , but when I saw the song lust I ran here to send my condolences . No friends no! 💔💔

Michelle Lela

When I saw how happy you guys were when the video started, my heart broke for you because you didn’t know what was coming

Kayla Smith

Bon I even said to my wife... as a Rep stan like me... this day would break you... IM SO SORRY.... go drink that wine and eat alllll the pasta gals!!!! Im right there with you....

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

My heart broke for you when Taylor said ivy 😭 I’m so sorry!!!! I hope you guys enjoy Italy though and eat all the pasta 🍝

Susie

I‘m so sorry for your loss 🥺 Just get drunk today and eat a ton of food, hopefully it will make you feel better

Jessica Seimen

This was the most painful selection!!!

Fernanda Ardiles

When I saw the song list for today, I knew this was going to be incredibly devastating for everyone who wasn’t there

RoyceT227

It’s not even that she played “ivy” but then followed with CIWYW that as a C&R fan hurt the most, really hope she gives y’all the 22 hat now then 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

Kevin Rodriguez

I need this put into a tiktok or some form that taylor can see so she can understand... like *joking* but also you girls deserved ivy and it felt so close to being a reality. I'm so sad.

elizabethjulia

Call it what you want is my ivy 😭😭😭 tonight was the worst night ever

Fatimah Alnaseri

Back after watching and as expected, painful and difficult to watch, though overall I thought Bonny took it way better than I thought (on camera at least)…so anyways Eyes Open and A Perfectly Good Heart on July 29th confirmed? 🤡☠️

CoreyIsSus

With Aaron too like she didn't even go easy on you 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ so sorry for your loss wow :( I feel like there's no way she wouldn't reset for int dates!

Hannah Walls-Scott

Crying already!!!

Evb223

I’m so sorry. I thought of you guys right away 🥲

Taylor Wiens

I’m so sorry girls 🥲🩵 this was me when I lost the Great War I totally understand I’m sending you extra hugs today

Giulia

THERE IS HOPE she messed it up on purpose

Catalina Borreani

what is there too say… she really said fuck all of you who are not here tonight !!!!! so sorry girls💔

Catalina Borreani

That was so uncalled for they have every right to be upset they didn’t get the song they wanted, just because someone has the chance to go to a multiple show it doesn’t mean it’s their fault others didn’t get a ticket you’d do the same if you could. They’re always nice and supportive of everyone. Show them the same respect.

Giulia

Nooooooo help this is heartbreaking

VadersPetPig

Awwwww, Sweet Darlings!!!!! I legitimately CRIED, like…tears streaming down my face cried… when she played Ivy because of you two. Doubly hard (esp for you Bonny) when she played CIWYW. I’m so sorry. So, so sorry. We are sitting with you in this grief. 💔💔💔💔 Sending you love!

Literally Natalie

Sorry for you guys !! (but maybe T felt too much pressure and couldn’t let you think you could actually request songs, even with your stature impact and community..)

EricLeCuriste

omg it's even worse hearing your beginning convo... your swift instincts KNEW. tragic.

elizabethjulia

I LOVE YOU GUYS IM SO SORRY

Morgan Murdock

I am so sorry 😞 😭 but Speak Now is not far away...💜💜💜

Shona Marks

WHAT IF A SPEAK NOW VAULT TRACK BECOMES UR FAV SONG AND THEN SHE PLAYS IT AT UR SHOW HAVE HOPE!!!

Grady Goodman

i’m so sorry guys, when I saw it I immediately thought of you and got so sad

Giovanna Sicchio

OH GIRLS I AM SO SORRY 😭😭😭

Samawi A

Okay I have to add you guys are genuinely upset and I feel better about my dramatics too when I’ve missed out on my die hard lol, I legit cried tears over the Gracie thing tonight that was my dreammmm 😂 and I also went to two shows and all four secret songs sucked, I know I know I’m grateful to have been there but I was soooo bummed out to not get one good one lmao. She needs to break it up!! She knows what we love, why does she always choose two meh songs together and then two really amazing songs together come onnn 😭

Amanda Watts

crying for u . she messed up btw after u paused it!!!

Grady Goodman

I am so sorry, you guys. Ivy is my favorite song too, I felt this one in my bones! Sending hugs.

Natalia

she won’t sing what you want she’ll sing what you need 😭

speedyceviche

IJBOL

james

So uncalled for! it’s so shit and sad not everyone got tickets but it’s no one else’s fault 😭 you have every right to be upset but as if you wouldn’t go to as many shows as you could if it was possible?

Hannah13

“what is taylor gonna bless us with today??” oh honey more like haunt us 😭😭😭

cat

My heart is heavy for you, I am very sorry 😥

Tegan Bassett

oh my god i’m scared to watch this

cat

On the plus side, on pretty much EVERY video I saw of this performance there was several comments in regards to you both. You guys are really something special and people recognize that and it's beautiful. ✨✨🫶

Daisy Ramirez

em’s face i can’t 😭

Roe

I’m so sorry 😔😔

Camila Bastos

Elisa Salievski

💔😭

Alba

I'm so sorry we lost ivy and with Aaron?! I'm sending you both a big hug! 💞

Iga W.

idk how i’m i suppose to keep going with life after this night

sammi snyder

so sorry for ur loss besties

Selena

i don’t understand how how she thought it was okay to 1. sing ivy WITHOUT you in the audience WITH FATHER AARON 2. bring out grAcIE abrams and harmonize to the gods 3. proceed to play call it what you want (my stan rep song) ALL ON THE SAME NIGHT ARE YOU KIDDING ME this was a personal attack

sammi snyder

I immediately was unwell. I'm so so sorry for your loss besties 😭

Daisy Ramirez

Thought of you guys instantly 😭😭 Also, the thumbnail represents the horror I imagine you guys experienced 😫

Yasmin

My heart is breaking for you girls I am so sorry

Zosia Dabrowski

I haven't even watched this yet.... but when I watched it live... I actually cried for you....

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

i am soooo sad. found out at work and pretty much had a meltdown it was humiliating

Anika W

y'all were all i could think of when i heard the word ivy. emily im so sorry babe

Logan Roberts

I will never be OKAY after this, gracie is my second fav artist and to hear TAYLOR singing my FAVORITE GRACIE SONG oh my god and then Ivy and call it what you want as salt in the wound??? I AM CRYINGGGG

Amanda Watts

“I feel scared. Why do I feel scared?” Minutes before disaster. 😭😭😭

Alexis

im deeply sorry you didnt get ivy :( i was at this show, it was so superior and something i will never forget, forever grateful 🥺🤍

Bradley Truitt

just opened the video - seeing you so jolly in the beginning and already heartbroken for what is about to happen 😭😭😭

Rachel Gresser

i can’t even talk about call it what you want yet…

Kristen G

I SCREAMED BONNYYYYY!!!! whilst sobbing for us allllll😭!! WITH AARON!!??? like why!!?? no! just NO!!! I SEE HER NEXT WEEK!!!! i am not okay.

Kristen G

The thumbnail!!! (the thumbnail says it all...)

Courtney D

I can't apologise enough for your loss. Thoughts and prayers with you.

elizabethjulia

heart dropped when i saw the tweet of the first surprise song 😭 so sorry babes, it’s a different kind of pain fr

ari

i’m so so sorry for your loss 😭

Lachlan Davis

The way I ran to this video

Amy

When she did Ivy, I literally went “oh no Emily and Bonnie 😭” but maybe she’ll do it at the Australia show 🤞

Veronica Key

Also, hearing taylor sing I miss you I'm sorry on a live stream was the greatest loss I never knew I could lose

Gabriella _

I immediately thought of yall when I heard 😭

Kendra Roberson

Poor ladies I feel so sorry. We are in this together! Please stay strong. Love you love you love you so much.

Benson

I instantly thought of you guys , I’m so heartbroken for you 💔

Cj

I'm so sorry for your loss, sending all my love

Gabriella _

Call it what you want is my most streamed song of all time, I am grieving along side you queens 😭😭😭

Claire Webby

The second i saw it was ivy i thought of you guys, my condolences 😭

Nevo Alsberg

Rip 😭😭😭😭😭😭

Alicia Bowie

We’re so sorry❤️

Ramell

IM SO SORRY

Autumn Glidden

my mind immediately went to you all when I heard ivy…. sincerest condolences. thoughts and prayers 😭😭😭

Natalie Kelley

🥲

S.C

Ladies I’m so sorry 😔

Floran

oh no it’s time

Q Pond

we lost soo hard tn

mum & sun

rip 🪦😔

Jeremiah Bell

Oh god

CoreyIsSus