SECRET SONGS Reaction: Atlanta, GA (Night 1)

Here in December 2024 😢…. The tour is over… so grateful for this time capsule

Becky Tucker

So funny watching this now after the girls were present for this song being included in the mashup in Australia and then also mentioning the other 2 songs in the mashup from their outro ranking!! <3 :)

Talia Adams

I was at this show!! We were well fed!!

Jules

"Now dive away" 😂😂 I love you ladies & your infectious enthusiasm. It's infectious!💜💜

Angie Armatis

This was my night!!!!

Andrew Woodham

As a MetLife girl I was punching air she did this in Atlanta, this was the best of the best 😭😭🥹🥹

Leanne22

I was also there along with half the people in the comments and prior to the show I hadn’t watched the reaction to snow on the beach so I wasn’t familiar with her talking about her friends’ new albums, plus I saw that the National had been on Jimmy Fallon the night before so I knew they were most likely not showing up. And the ONE SONG out of EVERY POSSIBLE choice that I wanted more than anything was Coney Island. It was literally the moment of my life. I’m getting a tattoo of a Coney Island bench soon to commemorate.

Kristina Key

I was there for night one ATL and I am so glad I recorded Coney Island because my brain blacked out. I was already having a big moment with Coney Island again the whole month leading up to the concert.

asquared13

not you guys predicting next shows secret songs

Hanna Kulla

i really don't know how i survived this but i want everyone to know that my mom and i carried our nosebleed section for tosotd. it made my life

Amyisaswiftie13

I was there for night one in ATayL and we won for sure! Superior surprise songs!

Kailia

https://discord.com/invite/qwQhvmSckX here if you havent joined it already! its a membership benefit

Michelle Pittman

PUT IT ON THE DISCORD PLSSS

Michelle Pittman

BONNY! I was row 4 right behind her for coney island and filmed the whole thing on my camera 😭 how do i get it to you??

Kristen

the other side of the door was on my list of MUST HAVES AND I GOT IT 😭 i’m still recovering. all too unwell.

Kristen

Close! 😜

Jentallygirl

Omg I don’t know what they were yet but I’m so pumped to see your reply 😆😆😆👀👀👀

Jessie

Jessie wins

Hannah Alyssa

She is so watching your videos !!!! 💕

Shawn carni

She is watching your videos no doubt in my mind after what she just said!!

Tiffany williams

I would be superior for her to do a Rep song alongside High Infidelity cos of the subject matter…like perhaps alongside Getaway Car? 👀

Jessie

Iconic songs!! I’m vibing she will play A Perfectly Good Heart this weekend, she’s loving Debut at the moment 💕

Sonya Payne

I felt so incredibly lucky to have been apart of this and blubbered like a baby the entire night

Jayluxx

The director was accused of SA and Taylor no longer wanted to be associated with him or give him any money/promotion. All of the footage from the Red tour was never released

RuthGA

Why was the red tour never released? what happened?

Juliana Martinez

Would love to hear in more detail your thoughts about the symbolism and visuals and what she's trying to tell us!

Juliana Martinez

I was there last night and the crowd was amazing and she seemed soooo happy. I couldn’t believe how amazing it sounded when everyone sang TOSOTD. Y’all I still am processing last night. So many visuals on the cat walk you don’t see on TikTok videos. She seems to be trying to say a lot. So much symbolism. After I saw things I really changed my perspective and thinking, but I won’t get into it. My personal opinion I feel like she is burning down the Lover house in order to move forward in her life. I wouldn’t be surprised if she took some pretty bold moves in the future. She was AMAZING! It’s so obvious how much she loves her fans and her music.

Layla4124

The thought just occurred to me--Taylor never lets us down, but we never let her down either. All those people knowing all the words to TOSOTD, a deluxe edition song that never got any radio attention and that she has never played live before, must have been really meaningful and emotional for her.

MarkH

In case the sound issue happens again tonight I would recommend looking for a Live on Instagram instead of TikTok. I was able to find one last night that sounded great!

Hannah Senninger

I do wonder if she just wakes up that morning and is like… I’ve decided I’m gonna play _____ song. And does it, because she is just that iconic

Maggie Tindall

I was there 😭😭😭

Maggie Tindall

Bon & Em would die with that combo

Joe Weaver

She has so many. The combinations are endless

Joe Weaver

this was an illegal pair of songs, I’m actually so upset it wasn’t my show😭

Amanda H

I really think that she's paying extra love to Fearless and Red in the secret songs because they are the two that have already been rerecorded and also because they are the two tours that we don't have full tour videos for. Fearless was cut into a documentary which was great but we missed a few songs and theatrics and then we all know what happened with the director of the red tour, so she was never able to release the red tour. I have a feeling that she is saving the vault tracks for a vault tour after all the rerecordings are done OR that she's saving the vault tracks for international dates.

RuthGA

Agreed! I love finding out the surprise songs along with Bon & Em so hopefully no more spoilers! 🤞🏼 thanks queens!!

Shondi

That makes so much sense!

Mia Morgan

DEATH BY SECRET SONG 😂 omg

Brandon N

I had't even considered that! :o

Mia Morgan

I love how she sounds playing Coney Islad live, her voice sounds different somehow and it is beautiful. My show is coming up in a few weeks and I am getting so antsy about what the secret songs will be!

Mia Morgan

Yes, I know that. That reason would make sense but they said it was her hometown and it isn't.

Abrielle Wright

It would be ILLEGAL to do High Infidelity & Getaway Car together 😂

Lively_Ash

Agree! Even though I did find out about these ones before, I always wait to react to the clips with Bonny and Em!

Hannah Stiff

First of all. DEVASTATED that I wasn’t there for Coney Island and TOSOTD 😭 Second of all: What if she did Getaway Car this weekend with High Infidelity or on Sunday bc the MET Gala is on Monday!!! That would be illegal! 🐍

Hannah Stiff

no but she was living nashville when she wrote 15 after meeting abigail

Maggiemayyy

This was amazing but I swear other side of the door and dear reader would have been the perfect combo imo

Laura Donovan

I was so excited to hear Coney Island! Beautiful performance! Also, have you guys listened to Aaron’s broken records podcast interview? He talks about working with Taylor a fair bit (maybe ~12-15mins total in the hour, mostly in the first 30 mins) and I think everyone here would enjoy it! https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PIl7jgNhbzo&t=35s&pp=ygUNYWFyb24gZGVzc25lcg%3D%3D

River

I was at her 15th show for Rep Tour (in London) and she did Fifteen so I think she will again!

Katie K

Omg yessss! Wasn’t it an incredible one to be at?! I feel so lucky to have been at that show. Although it is a lot to think that she was already over in the UK by the point of tour during Rep and we still don’t even know when she’ll be here for Era’s!

Katie K

I was at the same show! I think you’re right with both.

Sam

Highly recommend watching on Instagram live for the next two nights if this sound issue persists. For whatever reason, the IG sound was soo much better than TikTok! Love these videos 💛💛 Thank you

Kenna Galloway

I think she’s doing so many fearless and red songs because she has like 25-30 to get through on those albums! She’s got to do like 5-15 to catch up to rep and 1989’s track list number 😅

Lish Marie

You know now that she has done Coney Island solo maybe she might do one of the Ed collabs solo? Next Friday is his new album release so that could be a potential prediction for next weekends secret songs?? Maybe Run?

Katie K

QUEENS BONNY AND EMILY: can you please not put the song title in the email/video caption? Let’s keep it at maximum surprise 🎉 these videos are how some of us find out about the surprise songs so please and thank you 🥲

Tracy

It’ll kill the crowd

Catherine (YOYOK stan)

i’m living for these reactions every week !! and omg plz don’t talk to me about coney island and tosotd, i’m so unwell and still processing this crime 😭 i’m gonna be so upset if she doesn’t do high infidelity tonight

Maggie

I'm not sure if you guys have tried to watch the lives on Instagram, I've found they are a lot better quality and don't glitch/have audio issues! :)

Hannah Hart

loving the separate reactions each night, it's so much more fun !!

aiyla

I’m convinced that tonight we’re getting High Infidelity and Fifteen. Not only is it April 29th but it’s her 15th show of tour! I was at her fifteenth show of Rep tour and Fifteen was our surprise song and it was EVERYTHING!! 😭🫶🏻 Anyway that’s my prediction, I think I’ll be shocked if she does anything else.

Katie K

if she DOESN'T do high infidelity this weekend, i'll cry bc it's so perfect

aiyla

Today (April 29) is the 30th anniversary of my parents divorce being final, after my dad was unfaithful. He was also a stoner, so when I saw the title High Infidelity on the 3am tracks back in October, I joked to my husband that it must be about my dad, and I about died when she named April 29 in the song! Anyway, I’ll be devo if she doesn’t do High Infidelity at tomorrow’s show!!

Kelsey

Dear John and WCS are my dream SS combo! Would be 💀 forever.

Kelsey

I thin high infidelity might be added to the setlist, so this way she does it on april 29th but also it's cheeky

Dorka

I predicted coney island too and no one believed me she would do it alone and I'm happy I was right haha

Dorka

Guyyyys, she can't play rep song ... it's to emotional for her ... we can't expect that from her ... all the song she is picking for secret songs say a loooot about what she's processing ... ❤️

Jasna

Guys ilu, but please don't write the songs in the description. Really wanna react with you! <3

Marte Guldal Bramness

Look for the TT video of what the Atlanta crowd did for her during champagne problems! Superior tribute for our queen!!!

Ally ❤️

I would like to recommend an Instagram live tomorrow night!!! tik tok has been messing with the sound and instagram usually sounds okay!! theres a twitter that will post any instagram lives

Jo

I'm done! How dare she sing The Other Side Of The Door and I'm not there?! 😭 Atlanta got so lucky 💕. Thank you besties, I love reacting to the secret songs with you 💗

Iga W.

Omg I just died as listening to her sing this in the context of the break up and joe always being represented by sunlight (daylight) her repeating the sun goes down is absolutely gutting

Kitkat13

This was my night and it was the BEST experience of my life. Best secret songs, superior stadium with the circle screens, and the best crowd <3.

Diamond Thomas

She was born and raised in Pennsylvania...She didn't move to the Nashville area until she was a teenager, so I wouldn't consider that her hometown.

Abrielle Wright

I WAS THEREEEEEEEEE AHHHHHH CONEY ISLAND WAS IMPECCABLE😭😭😭 AND EVERYONEEEEE WAS SCREAMING TOSOTD

Christian Roberts

I was soooo lucky to be there OH MY GOD

Nicholas Carson

Before I've even gone to sleep. It was only 10 pm. Love it.

Joe Weaver

That would be awesome but I was also thinking she might do Fifteen in Nashville since its her hometown and Abigail might be in the crowd

Kylee Newberry

Yes, they are doing one.

Joe Weaver

I'm expecting I Bet You Think About Me and You All Over Me in Nashville to be honest, same as That's When for example, since the ft artists are actually from there? I guess those would be our best bets for vault songs

Jess.

lol just heard Em say the same thing.

Cody

in miss americana, she also comments about ME! sounding sadder than she expected it to when played on the piano... i simply need both that and gorgeous asap

angel

Can you imagine if she gives us a concert video of the tour. But a bonus that would be amazing would be all the bonus songs as 1 video

Cody

nick

Man i really wanted y'all to hear the Coney island arrangement! If the sound is bad just search for another even if the picture is bad. I'm sure y'all did but just a suggestion

Vanessa

Yes! It will be on Youtube in a few hours :)

Chats & Reacts

Omg I would die for fifteen that song holds a special place for me literally went through the exact thing so relatable

Kirrily Lewis

Forgot to comment last week about Dorothea. Also love it you’re not the only ones. I sing it to my baby girl

Kirrily Lewis

Iconicccc surprise song combo! Will you be reacting to the alcott???

Amanda

Even before breakfast for me today! Thank you!

Krystal

I think tomorrow is her 15th show so I hope she does Fifteen and High Infidelity!

Abrielle Wright

I got SO LUCKY

Nicholas Carson

A SUPERIOR SECRET SONG COMBO

Jas

Before I watch, I knew the moment she mentioned the national that us Coney Island stans were screwed lol

Jennifer Lopez

Agree! Tiktok audio was awful tonight but Instagram had a great stream

Rachel F

Thank you so much! You got this uploaded quickly tonight and we appreciate it.

Aloha Record Sargent

we live for itttttt

Chats & Reacts

I honestly was expecting for her to do coney island even if she did it alone. Same way I'm expecting high infidelity for night 2

Katie LaFave

awww you are so welcome YAY

Chats & Reacts

try and look on instagram for better live streeams

Matthew Biegler

AMELIA OMG YOU WON BESTIE😭

Chats & Reacts

Also @erastourlive on Twitter gives constant updates on what streams are working on different platforms! You probably already know that but just in case!! ♥️

Christine Violet

ohhhh good to know thank you!

Chats & Reacts

Thank you for uploading this fast! Offensive secret songs 😭

Léa

I WAS DYING!! THIS WAS SUCH A GOOD SHOW!!!

Chelsea

I saw these on YouTube and after the first chorus of TOSOTD, she said something to the effect of “you guys know this song! That makes me so happy.” The crowd was loud! So good!

maura

I am soooooooo unwell TOSOTD is in my top three, I cannot believe I wasn’t there to witness it live and I cannot believe all the streams were such bad quality 😭😭

Alyssa

I don’t think it was the stadium that made the TikTok livestreams sound weird, I think it was the connection. I found an instagram live thanks to some swifties and it was clear.

Lucero Castillo

I just cried a lot bc I wasn’t there

Sara Medina

THIS WAS INSANEEE

thegirlwithabook

I found the Instagram live sound was soooo much better!! Just fyi for future streams! ♥️

Christine Violet

“that’s the kind of heartbreak time could never mend” was written about not being at the shows where your stan songs were sang for the first time ever 😭

Ava Jeffs

I WAS THERE. IT WAS SO ILLEGAL & I DIDN’T SURVIVE

Amelia Phelps

Thank you for uploading this so fast, my layover in New York it’s better because of you guys

Zai Moyano

the other side of the door was my number 1 hope for my show and im so sad about this:(

Parker McFarlin

Atlanta really won!! TOSOTD AND CONEY ISLAND in one night is too superior and illegal

jc (indy n1)

it’s actually a lot you are reacting every night for us ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Alex Fraser

sooooo glad i stayed up late

Q Pond

I can’t wait!!!!!

jc (indy n1)

YAYYYYYY

Shyla Hoffpauir

like wtfffff both of these choices tonight were absolutely not okay 😭😭

Dominique Smaldino

ICONIC REACTIONS TIME

jc (indy n1)

That's fast. Eastern Time Zone is amazing.

Joe Weaver

this is what I've been waiting for the past few hourssss!!

Paul Zhang

OMGGGGGGG

jc (indy n1)

ITS TIMMEEEEE TONIGHT WAS SO ILLEGALLLL

Q Pond