Original Version of Chapter 2 from 2017

Hey all, this is a freebie/bonus for all my lovely patrons. When I wrote the first chapter of Toxic Attraction in 2017 (Then titled The Roommate) I quickly wrote the second chapter to it and....put it on the shelf for several years. 

I wasn't happy with where second chapter went and didn't want to rewrite it. Ultimately I feel like I jumped the shark a bit and ended up writing more as a reader than a writer -- wanting to see the action happen! I did not have an outline at this point in time.

So take this chapter for what it is, a scrapped piece from a novice writer who is/was still learning their craft. Consider everything here non-cannon to the current storyline.

-------------------

Legacy Chapter 2:

The next day Sarah and Dan were like newlyweds. They talked about the intense session from the previous night but neither spoke of the new game that they had played, even though it was all they thought about. They didn’t see Lester for the rest of Sarah’s visit.

Over the next several months Sarah and Dan both eagerly anticipated her visits to Chicago. The distance was difficult on their relationship but when she visited the sex was incredible. The game of being listened to while they made love turned both of them on immensely. If only they knew that each and every time that the coupled reunited, Lester was in fact not only listening but watching them. Hearing them bring him and their neighbors into their fantasies.

The game slowly progressed and evolved. Morphing from someone listening to their sessions to someone happening to see them. On the nights that Dan knew that Lester was working, he would leave the bedroom door slightly ajar, revealing the fact to Sarah right before one of her orgasms. But Lester never worked nights, he was always there watching.

Over this same time, Dan and Sarah got to know Lester a little better. They didn’t talk much as Lester mostly kept to himself but the true Lester began to show. The mess of his bedroom slowly began spilling into the rest of the apartment. He would leave dishes in the sink for days on end, leave the toilet seat up and a multitude of other behaviours that drove Dan and Sarah crazy. Both liked to keep their spaces in the apartment and their home neat - Lester was their antithesis in almost every way.

He now was much less shy about casting appreciative stares in Sarah’s direction. Sometimes purposely leaving his room at the same time Sarah would be exiting the bathroom after a shower, wearing only a towel.

Still, his pretend presence played a large role in the couple's lovemaking.

By the fall, their game had escalated to making love with the door wide open when Lester was at work. On occasion when Dan could convince Sarah, they would fuck out in the open on the couch in the living room.

On one fateful weekend in December, a blizzard made its way through Chicago burying the city in several inches of snow. The city’s plows were drastically behind schedule making Chicago into a white ghost town. Dan, Sarah and Lester were unable to leave their apartment building for anything more than a short freezing walk up the block to the grocery store.

During most of Sarah’s visits to stay with Dan in Chicago, they had the apartment all to themselves, thinking Lester was working. The freedom to reconnect and make love to one another was something the couple was sorely missing.

Dan and Sarah were determined not to let the weather put a damper on one of the few times a month when they could be together as a couple. They decided to spend their night curled up on the couch with a couple of glasses of wine, watching movies on Netflix

For his part Lester stayed in his room, leaving the couple alone. Only venturing out to get food or use the washroom.

After several glasses of wine, the couple began to pay less attention to their movie and more attention to each other. The only source of light in the room was the illumination from the TV, the darkness gave them a false sense of privacy.

Feeling bold from the alcohol Dan and Sarah began to make out on the couch. Instantly the rest of the world melted away and the only thing they cared about was being together. The movie, the weather, and Lester, all were forgotten.

Sarah’s hands quickly found the bulge in Dan’s sweatpant-covered crotch “Uhmmmm this is what I’ve been thinking about all night.”

Dan never felt this hard in his life. He wanted to flip Sarah over and thrust himself into her. He savagely grabbed at her sweatshirt, pulling it over her head and tossing it aside. Her chest was covered by a sexy black lace bra that put her ample cleavage on display.

Dan’s face dove between her breasts, his tongue feasting on her exposed flesh. Sarah writhed and squirmed at his touch, her hands finding the waistband of his sweatpants and reaching in to touch his bare sock.

The feeling of Sarah’s naked hand gripping his shaft continued to push Dan over the edge. “Let’s move this to the bedroom.”

“Okay,” said Sarah but she made no move to get up. Instead, she quickly push Dan onto the couch and tugged his sweatpants down to his ankles. His tongue found the inside of his thigh working its way up until she started drawing little circles on his ballsack.

“Oh fuck” Dan grunted, his hand running through his wife’s hair as he tensed his body at the sensation.

As Sarah’s tongue began to dance its way up Dan’s shaft and swirl around his cockhead, she slowly removed her sweatpants until she was clad only in her bra and panties. Dan followed suit by removing his shirt.

“Are you sure you don’t want to move to the bedroom Sarah?” Dan asked breathlessly.

Sarah looked up at Dan seductively, her hand gripped around his shaft tightly pumping it “If you want to go then let's get up and go.”

They stared at each other but Dan didn’t respond. It was Sarah who spoke next “then shut up and give this to me.” She lowered her head back down onto Dan’s dick while pumping his cock with her hand.

Lester stood in the doorway to the living room transfixed on the scene before him. There was no wall separating him from their wanton displays of passion. He was here in the room with them. He was only wearing his ill-fitting boxers. His hairy awkwardly proportioned body was naked in the same room where the subject of his obsessive lust was almost naked too.

From his angle, he had a perfect view of Sarah’s succulent ass as she blew her husband.

“Stop. Get on your back.” Dan commanded his wife. She looked up, smiled and stood. She seductively bend over at the waist and slid her panties down her legs and kicked them.

Lester inhaled sharply.

As she moved to lie on the couch Dan pulled her down to him and got on top of her.

Their tongues quickly found each other and Sarah reached between their bodies to grab Dan’s cock and line it up with her opening. Dan eagerly pushed his hips forward and his cock found its target as it slid into Sarah’s wet vagina.

“Oh fuck baby. You feel soo good.” Dan said into her neck.

“Fuck me, Dan.”

And they did. Dan and Sarah began fucking like teenagers. Quick rapid thrusts, nails digging into Dan’s back. They both knew how crazy it was to have sex out here in the open but it just added to their fire.

Lester was paralyzed. Without the anonymity of his wall peephole, he didn’t know what to do. His hand found its way to his boxer-clad cock and he awkwardly began playing with it through the material.

“Oh shit Sarah…... I think I see Lester watching us.” Dan teased Sarah. She looked up at him with a knowing grin and continued to play their game.

“Let him watch. mmmmmmhhhhhh.” Now that the game was on Sarah began to buck back against Dan’s thrusts with urgency. She could feel her first orgasm of the night rapidly building.

Fear struck Lester when he heard what Dan said. He stepped back further into the dark hallway. There’s no way he could see me….could he? They’re still playing that game.

“Uhhh yeah. Sarah, are you sure you want to keep going? He is actually in the room now watching us, touching himself.” Dan pretended to look around at the empty to add to the game.

“No keep going. Don’t stop. Dan Don’t Stop!” Dan knew just how to play her. Sarah gripped his shoulders hard, pulling him to her. The muscles in Sarah’s vagina gripped onto Dan’s cock, not wanting to let it go until she got her orgasm.

“Fuck Dan Don’t Stop. Don’t Stop. Ah. Ah. Ahhhh” Sarah’s body stiffened. All the muscles in her body tightened. She came and experienced one of the most intense orgasms of her young life.

Dan knew he was in trouble. The escalation of their game into this new scenario and the way Sarah’s body milked her cock was too much for him. He could feel his cock getting ready to swell. He didn’t want to cum yet, he wanted to experience Sarah all night long.

He slowed his thrusts to a crawl and much to Sarah’s dismay slide his cock out of her. He sat up pulling her to her feet. Sarah stood in front of Dan, now only wearing her bra. Lester’s eyes feasted upon her body, so close with no barriers in between.

Still sitting naked, Dan turned Sarah around so she was facing the bright television and pulled her hips down to onto his cock.

Sarah grinned. She loved fucking Dan in the revere cowgirl position. Dan sunk into the couch, gripping her hips and she ground herself up and down, front and back on his cock. He closed his eyes and ran his hands up her back, then around her sides to grip her beautiful bouncy bra-covered breasts.

Both Dan and Sarah were too caught up in their lovemaking to notice that the bright TV had illuminated another figure in the room. Lester had left the confines of the dark hallway and his boxer behind and stepped into the room.

His naked hairy body was on full display as he stroked his rock-hard cock. He took another step closer to the fornicating couple. With each step his breathing increase. His body was possessed. All rational thought of being caught or beaten up was drowned out by the lustful need to touch Sarah.

He had gotten so close. He was standing directly next to the coupling - between the couch and the ottoman. Sarah and Dan both had their eyes shut completely. Dan was focusing on his breathing, trying to control his eventual eruption.

Sarah’s eyes were closed as she focused on the feeling of Dan’s cock inside her as she built towards another orgasm.

Still sensually stroking his cock, Lester sat down on the Ottoman directly in front of Sarah, out of view of Dan. Oh my god, I can reach out and touch her.

Dan picked up his pace, thrusting up from the couch into Sarah. His hands started working on the clasp of her bra. These movements momentarily distracted Sarah and she opened her eyes.

At first, Sarah’s brain didn’t register or recognize the strange moving shape directly in front of her. The room was dark and she thought the hairy creature was part of the movie on TV. To her horror, she blinked and realized that Dan’s gross roommate Lester was naked sitting down inches away from her, lustfully staring at her.

Familiar movement caught her eye. She lowered her gaze and saw that Lester was jerking off with his hairy cock pointing right at her like a loaded gun. I didn’t expect Lester to be packing that much heat.

Dan continued thrusting into Sarah hitting her in the perfect place. She gasped and her eyes locked with Lesters. She saw that his eyes were filled with lust. Did Dan know Lester was in the room? Was he serious before when he said Lester was close by? Is he okay with this?

Sarah quickly glanced back over her shoulder and saw that Dan was thrusting into her with his eyes closed. He doesn’t know. Or he is loving it.

Before Sarah could decide, Dan’s hand managed to unclasp her bra and pull down the shoulder straps. Her bra fell down her arms completely exposing her now naked body to the hungry eyes of this troll of a man.

Sarah tried to cover her breasts and naively looked up to see if Lester had noticed her nakedness. His eyes were greedily memorizing her bouncing of her breasts as she was fucked. He looked up and her and smiled.

Dan’s cock continued to hit the perfect place deep within. She was feeling a mix of disgust and pleasure all at once. She couldn’t close her eyes. She wanted to stop and run out of the room but her orgasm was right on the edge. She thrust back into Dan while watching Lester jerk off with his grubby hands. The eye contact between them made her feel uncomfortable - a level of unwarranted intimacy.

“Oooooooooh Gooodd” Sarah Climaxed. It was too much for her. She rode the wave of this orgasm right into another. The taboo situation excited her and cause another firey orgasm to wash over her.

Dan loved making Sarah come. He wanted to push her over the edge into another orgasm and drive his dick deeper. As she was coming down he gripped her hip with one hand while strongly thrusting into her. His other hand pressed down onto her back forcing her forward.

It happened too quickly for Sarah to realize. Dan pushed her down and she wasn’t ready for it. Instinctively she reached out to catch herself and her hands found themselves planted squarely on Lester’s thighs. What’s Dan doing?

Sarah was now face to face with the ugly hairy cockhead of Lester’s member. She watched as pre-cum oozed out of his dick. She tried straightening herself up but Dan was putting too much pressure on her back.

Lester’s left hand was violently jerking his dick off like a missile. At any moment it would erupt and shoot all over the pretty wife. Without thinking his right hand reach out and grasped the back of her neck. I’m touching her. His fingers ran through the hair at the base of her neck...

“Oh, gawd Dan!” Sarah came again. Lester’s hands moved to paw and feel her breasts. She had never experienced anything like this before. The lewdness of the situation was setting off fireworks in her vagina. Lester placed both hands on the back of her head and pulled her down to his cock. She turned her head to the side, her head now firmly planted in Lester’s crotch with his cock directly in front of her face. His hips instinctively began thrusting upwards.

Dan opened his eyes to triumphantly view the pleasure he had delivered to his beautiful faithful wife. He was shocked to see Sarah bent over with her face in the crotch of his disgusting roommate. His fat fingers filled with strands of her beautiful blonde hair, one of his favorite features. Is she blowing him?

Dan didn’t know how to process the situation. Sarah continued to push back onto his cock like a woman possessed. “Ummmmmmmphhhhh”

Lester noticed Dan watching but not yet reacting. He decided to try and push his luck. He grabbed Sarah’s hand and wrapped it around his cock. He began masturbating using her hand. Up and down he squeezed causing her warm hand to tighten around his shaft.

“God that's hot” Dan absentmindedly said.

“Dan?? What are we doing?” Sarah questioned. “Ohhh god Dan!”

Despite her reluctance and the bizarreness of the situation, Sarah couldn’t deny that she was soaking wet. She had never been this turned on in such a manner in her life. She was being fucked by the man she loved and her face was buried in the crotch of this weird stranger. Her hand was freely jerking this guy off. When did Lester take his hand off of mine?

Lester was leaning back on the Ottomon watching the pretty wife jerk him off. He took his hand off and she kept instinctively pumping his dick. The blonde strands of her hair contrasted beautifully with his curly brown leg hair.

“Dan? Oh, Dan. Dan. Dan? Oh, Dan.” Sarah’s head was clouded the stimulation of Dan’s dick was causing her not to think clearly. She knew all of this was wrong but it felt so right. She couldn’t help herself, all that was occupying her mind was the pending orgasm and she knew it was going to be a big one.

“ Fuck Sarah, I’m going to cum.”

“Dan don’t stop!” She pleaded as she continued to jerk Lester. “Oh, Dan don’t stop.”

Sarah could feel Dan’s thrusting become more erratic. He was about to come, it was sending her over the edge.

“I’m gonna cum too” Lester breathed hoarsely.

Sarah looked up at the stranger in front of her. His stare of lust touched something instead of her. She felt the orgasm start to explore. Before she realized what was happening Lester lifted her head and shifted the weight onto one hip and lined his dick up to Sarah’s mouth. He thrust forward and in her state of orgasmic bliss, she opened her mouth and allowed Lester’s foul tool in.

Sarah’s orgasm exploded and sent lightning bolts throughout her entire body. Her toes curled and her legs went stiff. She was on the verge of losing consciousness but was brought back to reality by the twitching cock in her mouth. Lester let out a primal roar as he emptied his seed into the young mother’s mouth. Sarah didn’t know a man could produce so much cum, she felt as if her entire mouth was full of the sticky substance. With Dan still thrusting into her from behind she had no choice. She swallowed all of Lester’s load and then pushed off of him and tried to catch her breath.

Lester slinked away off the Ottomon as the coupled finished  Dan now mad with lust over watching his wife just take his roommates’ load pushed forward into Sarah, forcing her across the Ottomon. Dan was now kneeling on the floor behind Sarah jackhammering away.

“FUCK Sarah I’m going to cum.”

Sarah was still rocking the cascade of orgasms and was about to unleash another satisfying one.

“No wait I’m almost…..” but it was too late. Dan quickly slipped out of Sarah and came across her back.

Lester watched as Dan collapsed to the side. Sarah, exhausted was content to just lay on the Ottomon. All of the intense orgasms she experienced tonight had done a number on her. She had never experienced a more powerful night of sex than tonight. Neither knew what to say to the other so both stayed silent.

Dan reached out for some Kleenex and wiped his cum off of his wife's back. God, she is beautiful. I can’t believe that just happened.

Dan moved across the room to throw the soiled kleenex into the waste paper basket. When he turned around he saw his creepy roommate getting into position behind his wife’s unknowing body. He didn’t see Lester’s dick before but he now saw that it was the opposite of everything Lester was.

While Lester was short and pudgy, his dick was large and firm. He was rock-hard already.

Dan had seconds to stop what was about to happen but he didn’t move. It may have been the alcohol or the shock of what was happening. Or perhaps it was the curiosity of the uncharted territory. While he half attempted to answer this question in his head Lester made his move.

Lester quickly used one hand to line up his cock with Sarah’s unprotected vagina, he placed the other on her hip and gently ease himself into her.

“Oh fuck Dan. Mmmmppphhf yeah baby.” Sarah said. Still exhausted she felt unfulfilled for not achieving that last orgasm. “Fuck me.”

“You got it babe” Lester snarled into her ear. His thrusts came fast and furious slamming Sarah into the Ottomon.

Sarah shot up with alarm and looked around. Her husband was standing across the room, unmoving with a shocked look on his face. Lester his disgusting roommate was inside her. She felt his fat hand gripping her waist tightly, not daring to let this experience go. What the hell am I doing!?”

Sarah’s body was craving that last orgasm. It took her a second to fully process that her hips were pushing back in perfect timing to meet Lester’s thrusts. Part of her wanted to scream and run into the bedroom but that voice was quickly drowned out by her body’s desperate need to cum.

Dan didn’t know what to do. He certainly didn’t expect to end tonight watching his stranger of a roommate fuck the mother of his children. How the hell did this happen? His mind fogged by the alcohol, couldn’t process what was happening.

He sat down in a chair and watched the forbidden coupling of his wife and this hairy beast. She was actively fucking him back. She likes it.

“Mmm Sarah I’ve been wanting to fuck you since you walked in here.” Lester saw Dan sitting down. He’s going to let me fuck her.

Lester was savaging thrusting himself into Sarah, she couldn’t catch her breath. She couldn’t take a second to process any of this. All she knew is that it felt good. Good and different. Lester’s cock felt different than Dan’s. It touched and fill different parts of her vagina that hadn’t been stimulated before.

“Sarah, do you want me to stop? Do you want me to stop fucking you?”

Dan realized that in all his time at this apartment, this is the most he had ever heard Lester talk at once.

“No” whispered Sarah.

Lester slowed his pace a bit. “What? I couldn’t hear you.”

“No!” screamed Sarah. Lester’s change of pace was slowing her approaching orgasm.” Don’t Stop.”

“Don’t stop what? Huh, Sarah what shouldn’t I stop?”

“Don’t stop fucking me.”

“What do you want me to do?”

“Fuck me! Fuck me, Lester!”

Hearing Sarah say his name was bliss. Lester continued ramming his fowl meat into Sarah. The soft folds of her vagina enveloped his manhood in a warm embrace, unlike anything he had ever experienced. The muscles of her vagina gripped his dick, trying to pull him further into her to milk out all of his cum.

Dan could not believe that he just heard his beautiful wife tell his man to fuck her. His head was swimming, this was all too much to process. He was aware that his dick was beginning to well again. The raunchy show in front of him was captivating. He finally managed to do something.

“Lester don’t cum in her.”

Lester didn't acknowledge what Dan said. He was sweating like a pig. His hands were not content to remain on Sarah’s hips. He began running them all over his body like he had imagined doing for months.

“Lester.” Dan sounded louder “Don’t cum in her.”

Without looking at Dan, Lester replied “You got it.”

Lester grabbed both of Sarah’s heaving breasts into the palms of his hands and gently squeezed. Between his dick and the rough way his hands were now touching her chest, Sarah couldn’t hold back any longer.

She looked down and saw his hairy hands and their fat fingers holding her breasts. His pale skin looked out of place against her soft tanned skin. The inappropriateness. The lewdness. The craziness of someone like her having sex with someone like Lester drove her crazy. He was the last person she would find attractive yet she couldn’t help craving him.

“Oh God, don’t stop. Please don’t stop” Sarah arched her back, her tits pushing into Lester’s hairy hands.

“Say my name, Sarah.”

“Lester.”

“Again”

“Lester.” She was going to come.

“Louder Sarah!”

“Oh fuck Lester!” Sarah’s orgasm hit her like a thunderous wave. Her face contorted into pain and pleasure.

Lester saw this and turned her head to the side, covering her mouth with his. Lester’s tongue dove into Sarah’s mouth exploring every inch of it. Sarah reciprocated. Her tongue danced with Lester’s and ran over his yellow teeth.

Dan sat there and watched as this disgusting man was pounding his wife from behind. Making her scream his name as he played with her breasts and made out with her. This man making his wife cum. This is fucked.

Lester broke the embrace and whispered into Sarah’s ear. “I’m going to cum.”

“Mmmmmppphhhh” the waves of Sarah’s orgasm continued to rock her body. Her vagina gripped Lester’s dick not wanting to let it go. This feels too good.

“I’m going to cum inside of you,” Lester whispered again. Sarah knew she wasn’t on birth control, she knew it was wrong but she held onto Lester even tighter.

“Don’t stop.”

Both of their bodies were moving faster and faster. Dan recognized what was about to happen. “Sarah! Lester!.”

“Oh fuck yeah Sarah.” Lester roared uncharacteristically. “Take it. Take it all.”

Lester emptied himself into the unprotected mother. His cum washed over Sarah’s womb. The power of his ejaculation sent Sarah into her final orgasm of the night. Her hands brace herself on the Ottomon and she thrust herself back onto Lester.

Her vagina milked his cock, desperate to get every last drop of his foul baby-making batter. Sarah felt that every crevice of her most private of areas was bathed in Lester’s cum. Millions of Lester's sperm whose brothers were wasted on a wall while he looked through a peephole were now spreading themselves and exploring Sara’s body.

As the two lovers slowed their pace, they remained connected. Lester held Sarah’s face in his hands and kissed her lips tenderly.

Dan was speechless. He had just watched this gross man impregnate his beautiful wife, clearly against his wishes.

Lester slowly slide himself out of Sarah and sat back on the couch to catch his breath. She slowly laid down on the floor and tried to process what happened. She made eye contact with Dan and both of them shared a confused expression. Not knowing what the future held for them.

Lester smiled the most shit-eating grin he had ever used in his life. “Ha, I wonder if the neighbours heard all of that.”