Truth, Dare and Desire E12.5 | He told me to fuck him to make us even

Everyone is over the age of 18

-----------------------------------

From Red’s POV:

My ass is hella sore from getting fucked. Josh is fucking huge and I can hardly believe he got it all inside me to begin with. My morning wood is killing me right now because when it throbs, my hole aches too. 

Knock knock. 

“Hey Red buddy, you up? I made some bacon.”

The smell of bacon is why I woke up in the first place. I roll over in my bed to sit up and ruffle my hair with both hands. He’ll see my boner in my pajama pants but I guess that's the least of my worries now. 

I found it hard to make eye contact with him at breakfast. Strangely enough, he's whistling as he serves some greasy bacon onto a plate and hands it to me like nothing happened last night. 

“Well? Did you have a good time with Lea last night? She had it bad for you.” Josh makes humping motions against the table with his leg propped on his chair.

“Yeah.” My teeth crunch into the salty bacon. “She let me fuck her in the ass again.” 

“Nice!” Josh says and then drinks directly from the orange juice carton. “Are you okay by the way?” 

“What do you mean?” My face feels like it's burning. I know what he means.

“Your asshole,” he says, “I wasn't too rough, was I?” 

“I'm fine,” I say quietly into my plate. 

“Okay…? It's just sometimes I know I can be a bit rough at the end.” 

“I'm fine!” I say, louder this time. My fork clatters on the plate as I accidentally put it down too forcefully. 

“Okay….?” Josh says with bewilderment in his eyes. “Sorry.”

I felt guilty for my outburst but since I didn't know how to address it without talking more about the topic, which I really didn't want to, we ate in silence. 

“Can I show you something?” Josh asks after wiping his mouth. 

Good, he’s not mad.

“Alright,” I replied and followed him to his bedroom. He's awfully tidy for a guy’s guy, with the only sign of his party animal side being the empty bottles that line the top of his closet. 

Josh goes to his closet and digs around on his knees while I wait.  Soon after, he pulls out a little transparent wand. 

“What's that?” I ask while sitting on his bed. “Wait, are these sheets clean?” 

“Yes, you fucker,” he laughs and waves the wand in the air. It almost looks like it's glass, but it must be plastic from the way it bends as he waves it. “This is my dildo.” 

“Your…” I cock my head at him.

“My dildo. For when I want to fuck myself. Or when a chick wants to fuck me.” Josh says casually. 

“O..k…” My palms are getting sweaty. “You're telling me this because…?”

“Because real men like to get fucked! It feels fucking good!” Josh says as he sits beside me on the bed. Up close, the dildo is definitely a type of hard plastic. I've never seen one like that before. It wasn’t shaped obviously like a cock, and it wasn’t some comical size. 

“O…k…” 

“So stop freaking out that you liked it!” Josh pats me on the back. “Wasn't it fun last night?” 

“Yeah, but getting fucked is not the same thing as getting a dildo put in you,” I replied, no longer to hide my feelings from my best friend. I watched Josh roll the idea in his head as he fiddled with the clear dildo between his fingers.

“Ok. Fair enough. Then fuck me.”

“I'm not going to fuck you,” I say incredulously. “That's not going to solve the problem.” 

“Why not? You feel weird that I fucked you. So if you fuck me, then we've both done it.” Josh takes off his shirt. 

My morning boner was back. This could be my chance to get even with him. Afterward, we would never have to talk about it again. 

Josh slides his pajama pants off and once again, he’s not wearing underwear. 

“Are you always free-balling it?” I ask him. 

He shrugs in return and points to my tent in my plaid pajama pants. “Looks like you are too. Hurry up. I want to get some real food after.” 

I slide off my pants and grip my hard cock. I'm always extremely hard in the morning and the excitement of knowing I'm about to fuck my best friend is keeping me rigid. 

“Oh shit, Lea.” I suddenly remember as Josh pours some lube on my shaft. 

“Dude, she’ll love this. She would have us film it.” 

We both laugh knowing that it’s true. I rub the lube onto my dick and Josh positions himself over me. His ass is huge and I lean backwards onto the bed with my elbows as he lowers himself down.

“Hold it in place.”

His hole is so warm! 

“Here we go…” Josh grunts as he lowers himself onto me. My head penetrates his ring and my mouth opens wide as he continues to take me into his warm and fleshy opening. I let go of the base of my shaft when his ass gets too close and he sits completely on my crotch. 

“Oh FUCK! That is different…” he groans. “Don't move yet.”

“Okay,” I grunt back. My dick is raging hard in him. My balls beg me to fuck him and dump my morning load into him. 

“Let me get used to it,” Josh says and lifts himself off. I lean back fully as he rides me in an inexperienced and careful fashion. It was too slow to get off to, but it still felt good to be in such a tight space. “Sorry man. You know I hate leg day.” 

“It's fine,” I close my eyes as his hole swallows my dick whole again. “Alright, we did it.” I tap his right hip for him to get off. He's heavy and his weight on me like this is a lot of pressure. 

“Oh, you're going to cum in me. Then we’ll be even and you won't be weird as fuck about it.”

“This is fucking weird.” I laughed as the big man started riding me again. “I'm not going to cum like this.” 

“You want to try the dildo?” 

“How?” I grunt as he grinds on me. He seems to be getting more comfortable with my cock inside him. His movements are becoming more fluid and it feels like he's trying to use my shaft to hit a certain part inside him. 

I felt the cold tip of the dildo at my hole. “It’ll help you cum.” 

Cumming would be nice. Otherwise, I’d have to jerk off after.

“Yeah okay,” I grunt back and the cold feeling disappears. A couple seconds later, the feeling returns with an additional slippery sensation. 

“Lift your legs a bit,” Josh grunts and I comply. “Relax.”

I take a deep breath in. 

“OhhHhh!” I moan out as the hard plastic enters me. It stung a bit from my fucking last night. 

“You okay?” Josh moans. “Fuck, I felt you get harder.” His riding gets faster. 

“Yeah… oh shit!” I moan out. I reach up to grab his hips but hesitate, deciding to grab the sheets beside him instead. The feeling of getting pleasured on both ends is so new and so exciting

And so fucking good!

With every thrust of the dildo inside me, Josh comes off my dick. When he sits back down on me, he takes the dildo out. It didn't take him long to get the coordination into a consistent rhythm. 

The feeling snuck up on me while I was absorbed in the moment. I thrust my hips upwards to fuck him, enjoying the dildo penetrating me as I lower back onto the bed. 

“I'm about to cum!” 

“Told you,” Josh pants. He shoves the dildo deep inside me. 

“FUCK!” I cry out. “I'm going to cum!” 

His ass rides me relentlessly and I lurch forward, finally grabbing his thick hips as he rolls on me. 

“Ahh….ahhhh…AHHHH!” I shout as I cum into my best friend’s ass. My body contracts around the dildo, making it hit all kinds of spots inside me. I spasm in response, thrusting into him. 

It's sensitive to be inside him!

It's sensitive inside me! 

I cum!

My hole contracts!

“Oh FUCK!” I collapse onto the bed and writhe as his ass rides the load out of me. “Dude!” 

“Fuck…” Josh pants breathlessly and gets off my cock. “My thighs are fucking burning.” 

“You fucking did it,” I covered my eyes with my hands. The aftershocks of the orgasms were still vibrating through me.

“Can I cum in you? I'll be fast.” 

I open my eyes to see his rigid fat cock in his hand. I look up at his face to see just how badly he needs to cum. 

I did it. I did that with my cock. 

“Yeah.” I swallow. 

“Thanks.” Josh pulls my legs and my back slides on the sheets until my ass is at the edge of the bed. “I'll be quick.” 

He yanks the dildo out of me and replaces it swiftly with his cock. 

“Holy shit!!” My eyes widen at how much thicker it feels than the dildo. 

“Oh fuck!” Josh moans, looking completely out of control. He starts thrusting fast almost immediately. Because of the dildo, my hole felt like it could handle his massive size and his rapid stroke. “Yeah! Yeah!”

I squirmed while he fucked me. Even though my hole felt fine, being post-orgasm made it feel different than last night. 

His hands landed beside me and my legs went on his wide shoulders. 

“Fuck, your hole feels so good, dude.” Sweat beads on Josh’s forehead. “Your dick felt good too.” 

“Yeah?” My dick hardened at his admission. My dick in his hole turned him on this much. 

“Yeah!” His thrusts become faster and harder. “I'm close.” 

Creak!

Creak!

Creak!

The bed creaked loudly as he railed my ass.

“Oh Jesus, I'm going to cum! I'm going to cum in your ass!”

My vision shook with the force he was fucking me and I grunted with each of the thrusts that went deep inside me. His face blurred but I still felt his sweat dripping on my chest. 

“I'm cumming!”

“‘Me too,” I say as I realize it. 

Oh shit!

Oh shit! 

Oh shit!!  

“Yeah cum for me!” Josh loses himself in his pleasure. I spurt on my stomach while I watch him fuck me deep and hard 3 times.

Creak!

Creak!

Creak! 

“AhHhHhHhH!” Josh exhales and blinks hard, staring at the pool of cum on my stomach. “Fuck me, that was something else.” 

“Fuck,” I repeated back at him. 

“Does this mean you have to fuck me again now?” Josh asks with his cock deep inside me.