Truth, Dare and Desire E4 | Two straight guys call me out in front of a group

Everyone is over the age of 18

If you've missed it, you might want to check out the first story arc here first.

-------------------------------------

It wasn't my first time ever messing around with a “straight” or curious guy, but I still am not sure how to handle the interactions when I see them again. 

I feel like most of the time, they want to keep it on the down-low and swept under the carpet. I had one guy who pretended that I didn't exist at all the next day. It’s pretty laughable as if that erases the fact he held onto my cock while I rode a big load out of him. 

Whatever. 

So when I saw Josh and Red again at the next campus party the next weekend, I was expecting pretty much nothing at all and I wasn't about to confront them about the events of the other night either. It was good old drunken fun, nothing more. 

“Ey!! Felix!!” Josh gives me a bear hug, wearing a Hawaiian patterned tank top. He almost lifts me off my feet with how he's hugging me, but at the moment I'm mostly surprised he remembered my name. 

“Hey, what’s good man?” Red gives me a polite handshake and a firm nod of the head. I could tell he was thinking about the other night from the shiftiness of his eyes and he looked more willing to acknowledge it than Josh does. However, before we got into too much conversation, more people arrived and the drunken debauchery began. 

When the night begins to die down, the remaining 5 of us hang out in the living room. I’m lying on the floor, having found walking too difficult at this time, while listening to Josh lead the conversation. Having drunk the most, he is still the life of the party. Naturally, the conversations turned sexual and he started boasting about his track record with women. 

“For someone who talks such a big game, you’ve been single for a long time,” Red says with his arm around his girlfriend Lea. 

“You're dating a hot chick and you still spend more time with your hand than I do!” Josh takes off his socks and throws them at Red. His toes are upside down from my position on the floor and it makes me giggle to see them stretch. “I get it when I want it.” 

“You're going to run out of women soon in this town. We all talk, you know,” the girl I don't know says. “We know more than you think.” She and Lea giggle to each other. 

“Let them talk.” Josh shrugs his wide shoulders. “I ain't afraid. Give me a damn rating for all I care.” 

Someone with such a big thick dick would have this kind of confidence. Sure, smug guys can be jerks, but that self-assuredness is also so attractive to me. 

“Tell ‘em, Felix.”

I blink at the ceiling. Tell them what? That you face fucked me until I almost passed out from the lack of oxygen? 

That was pretty hot. 

“Tell them. Did I not do a good job?” 

A hushed silence falls in the group. I sit up to look at everyone's faces. The girls look like they've put it together but are in disbelief still. Red is looking down at his pants, avoiding eye contact with anyone with a sly grin on his face.

I look over at Josh, trying to confirm with him silently that he's talking about what I think he's talking about. Although there was nothing else he could be referring to, it just seemed surreal that he would bring this up in a group. 

He nods at me and raises his eyebrows to confirm it. “Tell them!” 

“He's… good,” I stammer out.

“Just good?!” Josh replies quickly. “You cum all over me in seconds and it's just good?” 

My face burns in embarrassment as the group laughs softly at what's been said. I felt the need to defend myself, even though what he said was the truth. 

“It was fine! But I wouldn't give it 5 stars or anything.” 

“You creamed yourself while I was filling your pretty face. You liked choking on my dick.” He grabs his crotch through his board shorts.

“I– no, it's not that…” My body heats up as I feel like I'm being held on trial.

Josh scoffs and sits up straight. “Alright then.” With that, he comes up to me and picks me up by the armpits. Suddenly, I landed on the couch next to Red and Lea. 

“How's this for 5 stars?” Josh grabs my ankles, pushing my legs forward until my right foot almost accidentally hits Red. “Hold them.”

I do as he says, taking over for his hands while admiring his bushy pit hair on either side of me. His grin is as charming as ever and I could tell from his smug expression that he knew I folded as soon as he picked me up. 

“Further back,” Josh instructs while pushing my legs back more. Then he runs his hand down the center of my chest, grazing my cock on the way to my ass. He probes at my hole with two fingers through my pants. 

“Ah…” I moan out slightly despite all the eyes that are watching me. Josh winks at me before taking off his tank top, showing me his thick body in its hairy glory. He presses his hands beside my head on the couch, surrounding me with his wide frame and pushing his crotch against my hole.  He humps me, reminding me of the strength of how his cock rammed the back of my throat. 

Jesus. This man is not playing any games tonight.

“Not 5 stars?” Josh asks as he grabs my crotch too tightly, squishing my trapped boner. 

I didn't know what to say, and I didn't have time either because he pulled my ankles back down, and tore down my pants roughly. 

With my bottom half naked, everyone could see I am incredibly hard. Embarrassingly hard. He pushes my legs back again, and I hold them with my hands behind my knees. My cock, balls, and hole feel exposed to everyone in the room. 

“Is this what you expect from someone who isn't having a 5-star experience?” Josh asks the group while picking up my rock-hard cock. 

“Nope,” Red says softly beside me. I glance over at him and see Lea playing with his crotch through his pants pockets

“Ah!” Josh pulls my aching boner back until it can go no further and it rebounds back onto my abs. 

“Looks like you're pretty turned on to me,” Josh says as he does it again. He leans down and spits on my cock loudly. 

“I said I always do things right, didn't I?” I moan as his hand pumps my cock. He presses his clothed crotch on my exposed hole again. He might be hard, or maybe it just feels that way because he's so hung. Either way, I have no doubt what I’m feeling is his thick meat through his shorts. 

I'm about to cum.

In front of everyone. 

Proving him right.

Proving to everyone that I'm his bitch. 

“Why don't you join in?” Lea says to Red while kissing his neck. I look down and see his hard-on looking uncomfortable confined in his pants. “That'd be hot.”