Jay's Stories

Truth, Dare, and Desire | Josh and Red's first threesome

Added 2024-07-12 14:00:10 +0000 UTC

Everyone is over the age of 18

---------------------------------------

From Red’s POV:

“It’ll be fun!”

“It doesn't mean I don't love you, Red.”

“We don’t have to if it bothers you.”

Her words echo in my brain while I stare into her eyes. I'm hurt. And angry. And annoyed.

And confused.

How else am I supposed to feel that my girlfriend wants to get fucked by my best friend?

I knew something like this was coming though. I saw the look she had when we went skinny dipping together and she saw the massive tool Josh has hanging between his legs. Then she kept hinting at it, until those hints became questions, and then those questions became these long discussions. She really wants it.

“Is it cause he's hung like a horse?” I ask quietly.

The silence that follows from her answers my question.

“It doesn't mean you're small,” she responds finally. “It could be fun for everyone.”

That's when we hear the front door swinging open and the noise of Josh kicking off his shoes. We hear him whistling to himself and rummaging through the kitchen cupboards before my bedroom door opens.

“Oh shit. Tender moment.” He looks at us sitting on the bed holding hands. “My bad. Thought you were alone jerking off like usual.” He throws a can of beer at me.

It's hot out, so he took off his shirt as soon as he got home. He looks like the way I wish I did, with that masculine burly look to his upper body completed with a layer of chest hair. I can’t seem to lose this skinny ginger look no matter how hard I try.

I look back at Lea, who is clearly checking my friend out. I sigh mentally, and motion to Josh to talk outside.

“You guys fighting? Sorry I barged in.” Josh looks at me seriously as I close the door. I shake my head.

“She wants us to … together,” I motion to the bedroom with a nod of my head.

“What together?” He drinks from his beer and I stare at him until he understands. “Oh shit? She wants me? Wait, what do you mean together?”

She didn't exactly say together but there's no way in hell I'm leaving her alone with him. I've heard through the walls how the girls moan his name (my name too) for hours.

“Just a kink that she has.” I swallow my pride. “Do you want to or not?”

“I mean, I'd fuck her,” he says while drinking from her beer again. “If you're cool with it.”

I open the door again and we both walk in. I see my girlfriend’s eye light up with pure excitement when I nod at her, and she begins to brush her hair back.

I sit on the bed next to her and she grabs my crotch, rubbing me while kissing my neck passionately. It turns me on to see her this excited, even if she's not looking to get fucked by me. It's been a bit since she's been so sexually charged.

“Alright, let's get this party started.” Josh finishes his beer and places it down on my nightstand table. He pulls down his shorts, revealing that he was going commando. “It's hot out,” he says when I raise an eyebrow at him.

His elephant trunk of a cock swings as he pulls his shorts off his ankles. My girlfriend crawls on the bed until she's face to face with his dick and holds it with her two hands. In her petite hands, he really is huge.

She kisses the shaft delicately, rubbing her lips against his skin while he slowly gets harder.

“Damn Lea.” He watches his dick get worshiped by her. The first entry into her mouth makes him open his mouth wide and tilt his head back. I go up next to her, brushing her hair back as she throats my best friend. Her mouth looks so full with such a thick cock inside.

I could never have that effect with her.

Fucking bitch.

I push her head into Josh and watch her gag on it.

That's what you want, isn't it?

I do it again.

And again.

And again!

It's incredibly satisfying to watch her choke on the dick that she's been begging for. She asked for more than she can handle and now she's going to suffer the consequences.

Dumb

Bitch!

I get up from my position and go behind her. Tearing off her skirt quickly, I take off my pants and jam my hard dick inside her.

“Oh!” I moan at the very wet feeling. She's so turned on by his monster cock that she didn't need any warm-up to take me fully. I fuck delicately into her, getting used to the warm and wet feeling.

“That's not how you're going to fuck a chick that wants other guys’ dicks, are you?” Josh says to me while holding her hair back. “Take off your shirt, man. Fuck her like you mean it.”

I take off my polo shirt, self-conscious that I'm so much skinnier than he is. Side by side, he is a lot more manly than I am. The broad shoulder with the chest hair, with the fur concentrating into the thick furry trail that leads to his big dick and low-hanging ball sack.

The dick that my girlfriend is slobbering all over.

The dick that my girlfriend probably fantasizes about when I fuck her. That's why she puts her fingers in too when I'm inside her. She wants her hole fucking filled up, and I can’t do it for her.

The anger flashes in my body and I begin to fuck her as hard as I can. I slam into her cheeks, creating a loud thwacking sound against her.

thwack!

I slap her ass as it jiggles. Unimpressed by the mark I left, I smack again harder, until I leave a red welt on her skin.

This

thwack!

Ungrateful

thwack!

Bitch!!

thwack!

I dig inside her with the best boner I've had in a long time. I know all those moans she's making right now are from me, from how fucking her like she needs.

“Nice, dude.” Josh nods at me in approval as his dick gets polished. “Mind if I get a turn?”

I’m getting too close to cumming anyways so I give her a final deep fuck, listening to her whine, before I pull out. I shuffle aside as Josh gets on the bed. The bed creaks under his weight.

His cock is so thick that I'm not sure how he's going to even fit in there.

“Awww fuck that's fucking tight…” Josh moans as he enters her. My girl is going insane, burying her head into the sheets. “That's what you wanted, isn't it Lea?”

She moans affirmatively into the sheets and the jealousy permeates my body again. I can't make her feel like that just by putting it in. I can't stretch her out like this and make her lose control with such little movement.

“It's okay man, you'll get the final fuck,” Josh reassures me as he starts thrusting. Lea starts moaning loudly as Josh picks up his speed, creating the loud moans and claps that I'm used to hearing next door.

thwack!

“Josh! Josh! You're so big! You're so big!!! Oh my god!!”

Even with her head in the sheets, her moans are loud and annoying. I hate that she's getting so much pleasure from getting fucked by him.

I hate that it's turning me on.

My dick is as hard as ever.

“If you want her.. to shut up… just…uh…” Josh pants while looking at me. His forehead is beading with sweat as he continues his hard and fast fuck. “Just cover her head.”

I pull the blanket by the edges off the bed and cover her head with it, immediately muffling her loud moans.

“That's better.” He smiles while he repositions a leg to fuck her deeper. “Oh god! Fuck! Dude, she can really take it!”

I watch her ass jiggle as he thrusts himself forcefully into her.

“Can I cum in her?” His jaw is tight in concentration.

thwack!

“Dude? Fuck!”

“Go ahead,” I croak out and he unleashes a loud roar as his head tilts back. He grabs onto her hips with both hands as he thrusts deep, holding his position for a couple seconds before a big sigh.

“All yours,” he winced slightly as he pulled his wet cock out. I watch the whole length slide out hugged tightly by her flesh.

I shuffle back on my knees and penetrate her, feeling that it's noticeably looser than before.

And all the warm juices in there that's coating my dick.

His cum.

I look down as I pull out a bit, and his white liquid dribbles out. The pleasurable sensation surges to my cock and I look up in panic.

“Let it go, man.” His hand is on my shoulder. “Seed this slut.”

I heed his advice and start fucking as hard as I can.

thwack!

“OHH!” I bust only two pumps in, adding to his mess inside.

“Seed her, dude,” he says while squeezing my shoulder. “Nice.”

I pull my cock out, and more cum comes out of her and onto the bed.

His?