Truth, Dare and Desire E1 | They said they would do any dare

Everyone is over the age of 18

-----------------------------------------

I almost said no when my friend Lea asked me to go to a house party with her. 

“Come on! It's the first week of the semester. What else are you going to do?” she said. 

She was right, of course. Plus, she promised it would be a small party with her and two other girlfriends, her boyfriend Red, and a buddy of his. 

“They told me to bring a guy to even out the numbers.” 

Like I would fit in with some college frat boys. I haven't met her boyfriend yet, but I know her well enough to know her “type”. 

“What kind of name is Red anyways?” I asked as we approached the house. “Is he ginger or something?” 

“Yeah, he is. Well, his real name is Joshua, but his best friend’s name is also Josh, so my Josh became Red.” 

It was Red who opened the door for us, and he indeed has thick ginger hair that contrasts strongly with his pale skin and freckles. His short beard is the same color, and I say to myself that he looks almost too youthful to have a beard. It might just be the fact that he’s skinny, but there was also a certain innocence in his eyes. He greets Lea with a kiss before extending out his hand to me. 

Mid-handshake, a much burlier but shorter guy comes up to the door. 

“Lea! Looking smokin’ mama.” He hugs her before extending his arm to me. “In my house, we do hugs.” 

He squeezes me into his meaty chest where I smell the alcohol coming from his neck already. Then, we went into the living room where the other girls were already waiting. 

After a couple rounds of beer pong where I watched Red and Josh do several unnecessary beer bongs, they invited us outside to their backyard and started a little fire in the pit. 

“Damn, this place is nice,” I say to Red. 

“We lucked out with a cool landlord.” Red burps. “It's not expensive either.” 

“TRUTH OR DARE!!!!” Josh roars to the cheers of the girls as he brings a cooler full of drinks out of the house.

Before long, we had already exhausted a bunch of the classic truths or dares. The girls have kissed, and we've gone through who's a virgin and who's not. On the last dare that Lea gave, Red and Josh took off all their clothes and streaked around the backyard, racing each other in their drunken stupor. 

Josh trots back with his hands on his hips and I might have actually gasped. The girls around him definitely exchanged looks with huffed giggles as they looked too. He hangs extremely low for being soft and it flopped around freely as he sat back down with his legs spread wide. Red comes jogging back a couple seconds later, covering his crotch with both hands. Through his cupped hands, I could see his fire-red pubes.  He turns around as he puts his underwear back on, giving us a view of his hairy crack in the crackling fire. 

“Your turn.” Josh grins at Lea. “Take your top off.” 

“Whoa whoa whoa.” Red laughs as he sits back down in his boxers, his fair skin glistening with sweat. “Leave my lady alone.” 

“Fine, then she has to lick our toilet.” 

“Anddddd girls, I think it's time to go.” Lea rolls her eyes and gets up with the other two girls. I get up too to follow them but Josh tosses me another can of beer.  “Stay dude, you haven't done anything but Truths all night.” 

That is true. But I'm not about to fucking lick a toilet either. 

“Alright, since you're a pussy, I'll give you a question. How many dicks you've sucked?” 

“Oh god, I don't know.” I shrug, cracking open the beer. “10 maybe?” The two men whistle and it makes me feel a little more relaxed. A little more welcomed, I guess.

“What's the biggest dick you've seen?” Red asks me curiously. 

“I think my turn is over.” I laugh as I look at Red. “Truth or dare?” 

“Dare. Give me your best shot.” 

I'm not going to lie and say I haven't been glancing at Josh's hung cock, whose tip is pretty much at the point of touching the seat of the chair. 

“Touch his dick,” I say nonchalantly. 

“Easy,” Red says as he reaches over and grabs Josh's soft cock, swinging the floppy monster around before letting go. 

“Jesus! Buy me a drink first!” Josh chuckles. Red grabs another can from the cooler and tosses it to him. 

Seeing them so uncomfortable with each other is hot, and I'm compelled to ask for more. 

“If that's too easy, frot with him instead then,” I suggest calmly despite my heart in my throat. 

“What's frot?” Josh burps after chugging his beer. 

“Dick to dick.” I simulate it with the index finger on both hands. 

“Gay.” Josh chuckles as he looks over at Red. Red and him share a look before both shrugging. “If we do it, then you have to do a dare next.” 

“Okay,” I say after some rapid inner conflict. What’s the worst they can ask for anyways? 

Josh stands up and faces Red, who takes off his underwear and gets up real close. Red may just be an average size when soft, but compared to Josh, it looks minuscule. 

“God dammit man, you're embarrassing me,” Red says jokingly. 

“You know what you've gotten yourself into.” Josh chuckles as he lifts his heavy meat. Red places his soft cock on top, where it balances easily. 

“Happy?” Red turns his head to ask me. The color difference between Josh’s tanned skin and Red’s pale complexion is interesting to look at, especially since they’re connected at the cock right now. 

I shake my head. “Frotting is when you rub them together.” I do the motion with my fingers again.  Josh shrugs and places his thumb on the top of Red’s cock with his fingers on the bottom of his own dick, rubbing them together slowly. 

In the flickering firelight, I watch Red’s cock grow harder on top of Josh’s dick. When Josh moves his hand to change the grip, I see that Josh has stiffened up too, although it hasn't changed as much in size. His cock stands at the 90-degree angle by itself, while Red’s upwards curve separates their two shafts towards the tip.

“This doesn't feel half bad,” Josh says with a little grin. “Like a dick hug.” He clasps his fingers back on Red’s cock, bringing it back down to meet his big dick. 

Red looks a decent size when fully hard but still not long enough to touch Josh’s pubes. Josh's cock, in contrast, is poking into Red’s balls. 

The sight of them frotting in the backyard is turning me on, but I dare not move so as to not interrupt them. So I stay still in my chair, watching them rub their cocks on each other in the warm night.

“Lea would have loved seeing this when we fucked her together,” Red says to Josh, piquing my interest. So this isn't their first time. I can’t believe she never told me this. 

“Oh, she would've been wet as fuck. That's for sure. She was already so wet when I was pounding her,” Josh says back, rubbing their hard cocks together. “She can really take a pounding, can't she?” 

I notice the change in Red’s body language, but I don't think Josh does. His shoulders have more tension in them, and his calves are tight too. Josh is oblivious, moving his hand on both dicks while reminiscing. 

“She must have loved being filled up on both ends. She's one of the chicks that's all proper on the outside but just wants to be treated like a slut in the bedroom, you know?” 

“Oh shit!” Red exhales loudly looking down at his cock. A spurt of cum escapes his cock head and shoots into Josh's thick dark brown pubes with his first shot, and the second shot lands on the length of his thick shaft.

“Hey!” Josh lets go of both cocks, taking a step backwards. “What the fuck man!” 

“Sorry! Oh fuck, I can't hold it back,” Red says before grabbing his cock and jerking it, releasing more strings of cum that land on the grass between them. His head is tilted to the sky while he unloads, pushing his hips forward while he empties himself. 

“Ah…” Red shakes his head while fluttering his lips with an exhale. “Nothing like a nature cum.” 

“You fucker,” Josh says, standing there with a boner and cum on him. 

“Sorry man, I owe you one.” Red’s cock drips some cum onto the grass. 

“Yeah, like right fucking now. I dare you to clean this up.”