NokiMo
Fakeminsk TG Fiction: Constant in All Other Things
Fakeminsk TG Fiction: Constant in All Other Things

patreon


Ramblings: On Keeping Motivated

I've been meaning to write about this for a while but held off because I'm worried it'll come off as a little whingey, like I’m having a moan. And I’m not, or at least I don’t think I am, though it’ll probably come off that way at times. But today feels like a good day to write about keeping motivated, because it’s been a great day for writing, a full 2000 words, and it really feels like the current chapter of Constant is humming along nicely. So I hope you’ll indulge me in a little bit of a ramble as I try and work through my thoughts on keeping motivated.

(It turned out longer than expected, but maybe you’ll still enjoy the read.)

So, writing’s a fairly lonely experience. What I’ve read on the craft of writing tends to emphasise this. After all, to produce anything of length, the writer’s got to lock themselves away and, well… write. Stephen King recommends not showing anyone what you’ve written until you’ve completed the first draft; I suspect other writers are a little less militant than that.

Writing TG fiction isolates it even further. Once upon a time, I harboured dreams of professional writing. (Those dreams aren’t dead, but with a milestone birthday approaching, those dreams are growing increasingly impatient.) Took some writing classes, wrote some fanfiction way back in the day. Every now and then it comes up in discussions with family and friends, though with an increasingly teasing tone: you writing anything? And I’d love to be able to answer: yes! A novel’s worth of writing, more even! But of course, I’m writing under a pseudonym in a genre that might not go down especially well with family and friends, and so it remains secret. They might wonder, with some justification, why I keep writing about men being transformed against their will into beautiful young women.

So sharing work with people I know in “real life” isn’t really possible, and that can be slightly discouraging at times. On the other hand, my current approach of sharing sneak peeks and the like via Patreon, seems to work. It’s a necessary adaptation to how the system works: why should anyone sign up to support the writing if there’s no evidence of writing happening? Previously, I’d only share once a chapter was completed, and though that worked well it also led to me eventually abandoning writing altogether for about a decade.

This also happened a little over a year ago, in between chapter 5 and the interlude. It’s hard to pin down exactly why, though a combination of pandemic, work and real-world pressures all played their part. And even though many of those real-world pressures (especially the work ones) remain, I don’t feel anywhere close to abandoning my writing this time around.

Quite the opposite, in fact. My writing is one of the parts of the day I look forward to the most. It’s been a welcome distraction through some recent rough patches.

And yet, it’s hard to not get discouraged at times. For example: I had a blast writing Silk and Shadows. I’d wanted to try my hand at writing Fantasy for ages, and that was the perfect excuse. What came out of that first month of writing in 2024 is, I think, pretty good. And yet by the few metrics available for judging the success of a piece of work, it appears to have been a bit of a failure. In terms of read count, part two on FM has only recently limped past the 1000 mark. To put that in perspective, the two stories on either side of it released that day, Lawyer2Maid and The Visit, have enjoyed 8000+ and nearly 5000 views, respectively.

(The read count is worse on Big Closet, and better on Tgstorytime, though there you can’t distinguish between individual chapters.)

Based on those numbers alone, it’s hard not to feel a little discouraged, you know? There’s a similar story with Constant. The final part of the Interlude sits at around 1500; the story immediately before it, Emily’s Summer Job has around 8800.

And I know it’s not just about read count. Reviews also matter, and I have to admit I’ve been very lucky there. Constant especially has drawn out a wonderful quantity of reviews over the years. It’s a pity more readers don’t appreciate how—encouraging?—a comment can be; it’s often the main currency for a writer.

So that balance of read count and reviews begs a number of questions: is my writing any good? Am I writing what people want to read? What is it that keeps some readers away? What am I doing—or not doing—that draws or repels readers?

The other currency for a writer is, of course, actual currency: money. I didn’t start writing Constant with any intention of profiting off of it, but then when I started writing it 17(!) years ago or so, monetisation options were pretty limited. (One of the pay-for sites did offer me money for the story back in the day, but I declined.)

Patreon changes things, I think. I honestly don’t think I’d still be writing Constant without it. It’s not the money. It’s a wonderful bonus, but this is quite a small Patreon, and the income from it is correspondingly small as well. However, it does bring a—pressure? Or sense of responsibility?—with it. Knowing people are willing to pay for it bring me back to the keyboard. It why, when I disappeared for those months a year ago, I tried to make reparations as best I could.

Of course, the other bonus from the Patreon is the ability to share the work in progress. I think it makes a big difference as well, and it’s another motivation to keep writing. The comments and responses really are encouraging—and often, helpful.

Do I wish my Patreon was bigger? Of course, how could I not? I recently had a little poke around for the first time, curious what other writers were offering. I was stunned by some of the success stories out there, like Foxface, with 700 paying members – that’s probably a near-liveable income – or Melissa N – pulling down over £4000/month, definitely a liveable income. Absolutely stunning! I’m very happy for them (and jealous, obviously) and again it begs the question: what are they offering that’s proved so successful? Consistency? A certain kind of fiction?

Which also begs another question: would I do this full-time, if I could? I honestly don’t know. Write professionally? In a second. To wake up and actually look forward to the day’s work? I can barely imagine how wonderful that must feel. But to do it writing in a genre I might not be able to share with friends and family? I don’t even know how that would work.

Nevertheless, it’d be nice to grow the Patreon a little more, draw in a few more readers. Someday, I suppose, I should really put some effort and time into the design and the contributor levels. I set those up quickly, back when I first started, without really knowing what I was doing. They probably deserve another look.

Anyway, I started this rambling exploration as I’d been thinking about keeping motivated recently, especially in the face of some discouraging moments, such as the smaller readership for Silk and Shadows. Fortunately, as I said at the start, I’m writing this at a time when I feel more motivated than ever. I think there’s a couple of reasons for the high spirits.

The first reason is also the dullest: routine. I’ve managed to establish a pretty good and solid routine, and on the days when I stick with it, motivated or not, I find the words come much easier. They’re not always the greatest words, but it’s something, even on days when I’m eyeing the word count and counting down to 500. (Which hasn’t happened much recently, these past few weeks I’ve been hitting 1000+/day pretty easily.)

Two, I enjoy writing. This is very cheesy to say, but I still find myself marvelling at times at the magic of imaginative writing. The way ideas form, coalesce in some unconscious soup and emerge onto the page is—magical, wonderful. Yes, that magic is frustrating and hard and exhausting at times, and the words used to manifest the characters and events I’m thinking often painfully elusive. But just as often, it just seems to happen and the next thing I know I’ve got two characters flirting playfully with each other against the backdrop of a moonlit sky and it’s hard not to feel good about that.

And finally—well, I think the stuff I’m writing is pretty good.

I mean, I also think it’s terrible, often, and yeah, I wonder what I’m doing writing this stuff about a thirty-five year old man forced to live a young girl’s life, and whether it’s just a massive waste of my time, and other peoples’ time.

But then I’ll also think about the characters, and underlying motivations, and the intricacies of background and plot, or indulge in a spot of world-building, and see how it comes alive on the page and think—I’m writing something pretty good, here. I look forward to the plot twists I’ve planned for, and to the plot twists and characters I never anticipated in my planning. There’s a joy in writing a character and finding them acting in ways you never anticipated. And even when my talent doesn’t quite match up with my aspirations, the attempt often feels rewarding and worth the effort. I thinkI’ve gotten better at writing over the past two years—and decade!—though I suppose that’s not really for me to decide.

Ultimately, I think I offer something—if not unique, at least uncommon—a slightly more literary erotica with TG flavouring. And whilst that might not be terribly popular, I think it’s still worth writing. And hopefully, you and others will find it worth reading.

Comments

As for the genre itself - maybe I'll save that for a different rambling entry. Lots of thoughts about that, many of them confused or conflicting.

David Sanders

I appreciate the support - and the considered response. You're probably correct that I should try writing something more public, more shareable with friends and family but--and this is the whole reason I started writing Constant in the first place--I'm not convinced I've got what it takes. It's a confidence thing, obviously, but for all the kind words I don't think I'm at a level ready for profession publishing. I -think- I've gotten better over the past year or two, though from within my own head that's a difficult thing to assess. Also, I've never brought a project to completion, and that seems like a pretty big hurdle. Part of finishing Constant is proving to myself that, yes, I can actual finish a novel-length story work. I do like the idea of challenging myself to write actual short pieces in between chapters, though. I failed at that utterly with Silk and Shadows, but maybe I'll aim at a 5 to 10k word short story once I've wrapped up the current chapter of Constant. Time is sadly tight, though - I can only really work on one thing at a time. In any case, I wrote the ramble at a time when I'm feeling quite positive about the whole experience of writing. I don't think I'm anywhere near burning out, or giving up. I'll probably need to take a break soon, mostly to catch up on a backlog of work, but for now my 1000-words of writing a day is a frustrating (because I want to write more) but very enjoyable part of the day. And the fact there's a small group of people along for the ride is wonderful, too.

David Sanders

So I first read this post Thursday morning and decided to think about it some during the day before replying since it deserves a thought out reply, but by Thursday evening I'd crashed early after a long day's work. So it's Friday after work now and I'm ready; I'm hearing you loud and clear in the first part. You are exercising daily to do metaphorical ab crunches on a skill set you have prowess with and it must be murder to not be able to flaunt it in public. I think (though it might be against my own interests as a devouror of your genre work,) that you need to try putting pen to paper for some other more publicly accessible genre. I think it would do you good to have some examples of your writing you can show off to family and friends. We try to express our thanks and admiration as patrons through posts and a little bit of money, but some real world praise for your writing would be awesome too. You don't even need to share it with us here if you feel demarcation might help, (although I would absolutely like to read your non tg stuff.) but I think you should seriously put 'write a non tg short story' on your near term 'To Do' list. On to reading metrics; I'd say that you're in part right that 'thought provoking porn' is a niche market with little market. But as you point out Melissa N makes a damn tidy sum with stuff of similar length as does Emory Ahlberg, but the key difference there is the digital 3d art. I'm mostly a literary pervert in that i fapp to the written word, but the words and pictures porn seems to sell well. I don't know if it's something you could teach yourself one of the 3d poser suites, or perhaps put feelers out for a collaboration. I have to say that as a patreon of both 3d story artists your writing is far superior. You might with some trail and error get up to speed with their poser style comics, but they could never reach your writing level. It might simply be 'not your bag',but it might be worth a bit of looking into. There seems to (or course) be an explosion in A! comics, but their style as of now is too random so each page is an impression of the last page while not being 'it'. Feels like an off kilter dream. but meanwhile the 3D comics seem to get more realistic as the software evolves. But just saying that comparing with a visual patreon 'competitor' with your words to the page approach might be selling yourself way short. Another route to explore is a few random short stories ( actually short this time :P ) little 'one and done's' that might attract a few of the short time span types and subject them to your cut about average narratives. Maybe a few out and out 'spank tales' (if you're comfortable with writing them) that could hook a few more readers that may go on to read to longer magnum opus. I can see reading back how tiring all that extra writing might be I just suggested with no though for the logistics given the need to, you know,..work to live and such. As for the genre itself and whether its a massive waste of time, I'd be hard pressed to give an honest No answer to that question. I don't know why I like tales of men turned to girls or what is says about me as a person but I do know I like it. I also like niche music and niche films. All the main stream stuff that sells a bundle leaves me cold and I know I'm the odd one out, so frankly one more odd ball taste that I simply don't share with immediate family is no biggie. They wouldn't get Ween or Jim Jarmusch either so I don't bring them up. So if you're feeling disheartened, that's so understandable it hurts. But just focus on whether you're still enjoying it personally. If you are, then please carry on. Might come off a bit hedonistic in a 'If it feels good do it' way, but writing stuff you like is the key. Writing for others should be secondary. In the end, you're the best I've read at what you do, and I've read a fuck of a lot of online stuff since I found online at the turn of the century. I'd hate to see you stop or burn out or give up. Do what you gotta do for you, I'm gunna support it. Thanks.

Julia

And the support is definitely appreciated; thank you! I do wonder what the size of the user base is for sites like FM, BCTS and TGStorytime - how many people actually like this stuff? Are the counts driven by repeat visits, by one-handed customers? It's tempting to think so, and stories like Constant probably don't meet that audience's needs very well: there's a lot of faff between the fapp, as it were. But I think the whole picture is far more nuanced than that. "For a Girl"--with 151 reviews and 121k views-must be one of the most popular stories on FM. It's long and while it definitely has its "R"-rated moments, isn't just about the sex. So there's definitely an audience out there also looking for longer, character-driven stories. I think you're right about the multi-chapter thing, though. Part 6 of Series 2 is hardly an appealing jumping in point for discovering a new story. I think that's where TGStorytime comes into its own - since chapters are nested under a dropdown menu, readers always discover a story on chapter 1 and its easy to keep reading through published material. There, it seems to be crazy-long, multi-part stories that collect the most views and reviews.

David Sanders

I did a little research and I definitely think that the reader numbers are not really representative. In short , short one shots get the most hits. Anything with a part number in the title gets fewer hits. I think the nature of sites like FM is that they are visited by lots of people who want a quick read, rather than by people who are looking for a richer deeper experience, such as that provided by your writings. The reviews are where the real action is! And yours are stunning. I'm really happy to be a member of your patreon and my main motivation was to help inspire you to continue writing - though, access to the sneak peaks is a really cool side perk!

Asklepios

I remember reading, years ago, something to this effect - that writing is odd as a hobby because if people know you're doing it, there's often an automatic assumption that you ought to be trying to make money off of it, go pro; which is very different than being a hobbyist painter, or musician, or warhammer 40k painter. I suppose my bias in this is desire - I'd love to go pro! I started writing Constant way back when with an eye on this, hoping I'd learn and develop as a writer sufficiently to then write something that could be published. Mind, I didn't plan on taking a decade off... In any case, I don't want to give the impression I'm about to stop writing or anything. Maybe I'll get a pleasant surprise if I ever get around to publishing Constant via Amazon's self-publishing or a similar service. In the meantime, I still thoroughly enjoying writing, and keeping this Patreon going.

David Sanders

Setting aside the question of writing professionally at some future date, would it be helpful to reframe your efforts? For example: A. It's a hobby! Some people spend their time brushing up on guitar skills, or that particular stage in the video game, or working jigsaw puzzles. They improve over time, but some days that hobby is simply more of a slog than other days. Still, the reason to keep going is because it interests you, or because you enjoy the regular practice. B. Volume of reviews, and even views, can be capricious. Lots of factors go into determining these things. Maybe those who'd appreciate your work simply weren't watching for new posts at the time, and so they slipped through the cracks. And like you say about the genre being awkward to announce to family, many readers will prefer anonymity and be averse to creating login usernames, etc., that would allow them to leave reviews. I'm also reminded of professional sports, where we have lots of stories about star athletes who found stardom only after joining their umpteenth team and finally finding the right combination of talent plus opportunity.

Dan T

I think it's great that you mentioned Tolkien--he's a wonderful example. A few months ago I had a few credits on Audible to spend, so decided to pick up the Silmarillion I've ready Lord of the Rings many times over (though not recently) but never managed to get through even the first chapter of the Silmarillon. So why not listen on the commute to work? Well, the Audible version has Andy Serkis doing the reading, and he does a fantastic version of Tolkien, and the open in a long letter Tolkien wrote to his editor explaining what it was all about. And it's a looooog letter, and almost hilarious in how very, very seriously Tolkien takes it all! Even when he's being a bit self-depricating, he clearly takes his world of Hobbits and elves, dwarves and dragons seriously; and I think that's great. And probably a very fine example justifying me taking my own work seriously. So... thank you!

David Sanders

That's way I try writing some comments to writers, even if I'm perfectly aware that the comments, not the writers, aren't very bright. Certainly, without any doubt it isn't waste of my time. My best guess: it's not a waste of your time too, the more you write, the better it goes. But you can always imagine Tolkien writing "the Lord of the Rings" trying to explain what is his story about. - You know, about hobbits, dwarves and elves. - What? That must be a massive waste of time! The visit received no reviews at all, Lawyer2Maid, all 4 parts 9 reviews. That means something too. But generally why some stories are read more than others, I wish I only knew. But I know that I remembered Your story for many years and judging from comments I'm definitely not the only one. Sorry, but I doubt that these will be remebered at all. I wish them that, but it probably won't happen.

Carmons58


Related Creators