The Best Robin (Jason Todd/Kara Zor-El/Stephanie Brown/Cassandra Cane Commission)

Equally important to actually fighting crime for any young superhero is recreation. If the only thing you think about is stopping the Joker’s sick antics or breaking Lex Luthor’s newest robotic menace, you’ll eventually break down. Sometimes, you need a chance to just act your age.

“Ahhh! That sure is good!” Kara said.

She giggled and looked down at the beer can she was holding. She was sitting on the floor across from another blond girl who was just as pretty as her, and an asian girl with short black hair with more exotic, but no less attractive, features. All three of them were wearing loose shirts and sweatpants. The other blond laughed at Kara.

“You can’t even get drunk but you like beer this much?” Stephanie asked.

“I just like the taste!” Kara said, blushing.

It would be embarrassing to admit that sometimes, she liked to drink it and pretend she was drunk, just to feel a little more human. Even though she loved Earth, it still felt very foreign at times. She was always on the lookout for ways to act more like a local and experience new things. One of those things, which had now become a recurring fixture in her life, were “girls nights”.

Kara, known to the world as Supergirl, and Stephanie Brown and Cassandra Cain, card carrying members of the Bat Family, would get together and spend a night like girls their age were supposed to. Sometimes that meant going out for drinks, or it could take the form of a sleepover.

Tonight they were at Stephanie’s house in Gotham. The three of them were sitting on the floor together with Kara and Stephanie holding drinks, meanwhile Cassandra was empty handed. She didn’t like the taste.

“I’m going to be the only one who's drunk at this rate,” Stephanie said. “That’s no good. It’ll be embarrassing.”

“It’ll be fine,” Cassandra said. She had a quiet and mellow voice. “We won’t make fun of you.”

“I know you won’t!” Stephanie said. “Because before it comes to that, I’ll make sure we’re talking about something so embarrassing that we’ll ALL be blushing!”

“You really don’t have to,” Cassandra said.

“Embarrassing like what?” Kara asked, her curiosity piqued.

“Sex,” Stephanie said.

Kara did blush, but Cassandra just moved her head slightly.

“Sex isn’t embarrassing,” Cassandra said. “That’s where babies come from. My parents taught me that men are at their weakest when they orgasm. It’s the perfect time to strike.”

“First, never say that around your boyfriend when you get one,” Stephanie said. “Second, of course it’s embarrassing! But not in a bad way. It’s called gossip, and it’s fun.”

“But… I don’t have much experience with this sort of stuff,” Kara said. “I don’t have any stories.”

“We’ll just use our imagination,” Stephanie said. “Sometimes that’s more fun. Sooo, I’m gonna get us started. Out of all the Robins, who d’you think is the best in bed?”

There was an awkward silence. Kara chugged her beer so she wouldn’t have to answer. Cassandra seemed like she was thinking it over.

“Dick is the most mature,” Cassandra said. “He probably has the most experience, between Barbara and Koriand’r. Logic dictates that he would be the best.”

Stephanie groaned. “That’s such a BORING way to think about it, though. Plus, he’s too much like an older brother. I don’t want to think about him in bed.”

“You started this conversation,” Cassandra said.

“And I’m moving it on! What about Tim?” Stephanie said.

“Tim’s cute,” Kara said. “But he’s a little bit… I don’t know, he feels young. And he’s a little bit scrawny…”

She blushed, immediately feeling bad about what she’d said, but Stephanie nodded.

“I agree!” Stephanie said. “And so, girls, listen to MY suggestion: Jason.”

You could visibly see both girls thinking it over.

“He’s definitely got the muscles,” Kara said, one step away from drooling.

“He’s popular enough to have accumulated sufficient experience,” Cassandra said analytically.

“True, girls, and think about his personality,” Stephanie said eagerly. “He might act tough, but he’s a softie when it comes to people he cares about. Isn’t that perfect? He probably knows how to be rough AND caring in bed.” She lowered her voice. “Honestly, it gets me a little wet just thinking about it.”

“Stephanie!” Kara said.

“Sorry, sorry!” Stephanie laughed. “Although…”

“You look like you have an idea,” Cassandra said. “I hope it’s not one of the crazy ones.”

“I’m just thinking,” Stephanie said, “that the reason we have these girls nights is to help us relax and unwind.”

“Yeah. So?” Kara said.

Stephanie pulled her phone out and flashed it at them. “With a little help, I think we could do both of those things MUCH better.”

“Steph, you don’t mean—” Kara said.

Stephanie scrolled on her phone and put it to her ear.

“Hey!” she said. “Nice of you to pick up. Say, are you free right now… Jason?”

LINE BREAK

Jason Todd had just finished patrolling when his phone rang. Stephanie called, inviting him to her apartment, and the strangest thing was that he could hear Kara in the background squealing. Cassandra was there too; he heard her voice at one point. It kind of felt like he was being lured into a trap.

But as the big, scary Red Hood it wouldn’t be appropriate for him to run away just because of that. Even if these girls could be scarier than his rogues gallery when they were in the wrong mood.

Jason stood in the hallway outside of Steph’s apartment in plain clothes. He reached out and gave the door a knock.

“Steph?” he said. “It’s me. You said you needed something?”

“Come in!” Stephanie said. She sounded… out of breath?

Jason opened the door. It wasn’t locked. Which was crazy considering what he found on the other side.

The owner of the apartment was on her back, Cassandra Cain on top of her. The sweatpants they had been wearing were sitting on the floor with their old shirts on top of them. Both were wearing skimpy panties and had gotten rid of their bras. Kara Zor-El was next to them completely naked. Stephanie had been sucking on Cassandra’s boobs while Cassandra straddled her and leaned over Stephanie’s head to eat Kara out. Stephanie stuck her head to the side of Cassandra’s toned and scarred body. “Hey Jason!”
“What the fuck?” Jason said.

“Well, we invited you because we wanted to see if you were as good in bed as we thought you’d be!” Steph said. “We kind of got bored waiting, though. And we were hornier than expected. So we started things without you.”

“Come here already!” Kara said.

Her face was flushed, and her inhibitions had been eroded by the lesbian orgy she was engrossed in. Kara disappeared from the floor, reappearing in front of Jason faster than he could see. She grabbed his clothes and ripped them straight off of his body, including his underwear.

“Look how big it is!” Kara bent forward to look at and touch Jason’s dick. “It’s at least six inches! That’s above average, right?”

Jason cleared his throat.

“What’s wrong?” Kara asked. “Am I wrong? Is that small?”

“No,” Jason said, “but you should probably wait a minute. It’s not hard yet.”

“It’s not…” Kara’s eyes widened.

Blood was still rushing into Jason’s member. It went from six inches half erect all the way up to nine. Kara could only stare at it.

“And human women… take that inside of them?” she asked.

“Sometimes it takes a lot of lubrication,” Jason said. “Speaking of…”

He hadn’t counted on walking into something like this, but he wasn’t going to run away now. How could he call himself a man if he did that? So he steeled himself and grabbed a Kryptonian by the pussy.

“Goodness!” Kara said. “Oh, oh wow.”

She bit her lip. Jason’s fingers located her clit, which he was happy to find was in the same place it would've been on a human. As he teased Kara’s sensitive point, she gasped and moaned, sounding like a regular human girl. Her strength temporarily failed her, and she leaned back against the wall, letting Jason keep fingering her.

On the floor, Stephanie and Cassandra watched them while touching each other. They both got rid of their panties and turned so that they were scissoring each other, watching Kara get fingered.

“Something’s happening,” Kara said. “I’m… cumming!”

Jason pulled his fingers out, scared that she’d clench down and crush them, but her orgasm was the same as a human’s despite her alien body. Emboldened, and seeing she was more than wet enough, Jason grabbed her hips and slid her up the wall, putting his dick against her entrance.

“Are you alright with not being on top?” he asked.

Kara couldn’t take her eyes off his dick pressing against her, waiting for permission to enter. “That’s fine! I’m happy with this. You can start whenever you like.”

When Jason’s dick entered her, Kara made duck lips, stretching them forward and howling. She was super durable, but she was as tight on the inside as any ordinary woman. Jason thrusted into her as she moaned and moaned.

He could hear Steph and Cassandra grinding on each other and moaning themselves. Jason was a little bit shocked by how this was going. Well, he was SUPER shocked that this whole thing had been a superheroine booty call, but it was Kara’s taste he was moderately shocked by. He’d seen her punch through tanks without flinching, yet his dick was making her writhe.

“Kiss me Jason!” Kara said.

Jason did. He put his palms on the wall and stuck his tongue in the mouth of Metropolis’s princess. If Superman found out about this, was Jason dead?

He’d think about that later, once he wasn’t balls deep in such an addictive pussy! Besides, dying? He’d been there and done that. If the price for fucking Kara was another trip to the Lazarus Pit, that was one he’d gladly play.

Jason started going pretty fast. Kara seemed to be supernaturally sensitive to sexual pleasure, because even though it was probably like he was moving in slow motion to her she was having the time of her life. She wrapped her legs around his hips.

“Wait, Kara!” Jason said, breaking their kiss off hastily. “If you do that—”

Too late. Fortunately she didn’t crush his hips to dust, but there was no way he was going to be able to pull out. Jason seeded Kara’s womb with a warm load of fresh spunk.
Kara orgasmed as he semen rushed into her. She giggled and let go of him, sliding down to the floor the moment Jason pulled out. She touched her own pussy, feeling Jason’s marks seeping out of her.

Jason got stuck staring, thinking about what he’d just done, until he was grabbed from behind. Stephanie and Cassandra pulled him into the ground.

“Our turn,” they said in unison.

Despite their different personalities, at times like this they were totally in sync. 

The two of them got down, putting their legs over Jason’s crotch from opposite sides. Leaning their lower bodies forward, they put their pussies on his dick from opposite sides.

“Let’s go, big boy!” Stephanie said. “Let’s see if you can handle some nice bat family teamwork!”

Cassandra didn’t say anything, but they both began rubbing their slits along Jason. It was easy to do because both of them were wet from pleasuring each other, and Jason’s dick was equally soaked after being yanked out of Kara. 

Stephanie and Cassandra were enjoying themselves as much as Jason was. Stephanie said: “Fuck! Damn! Sooo thick!” Cassandra didn’t say words, but Jason heard her moaning softly.

The two of them flexed their six packs and well defined legs to sandwich his dick. Their pussy lips were actually stretching open somewhat to engulf him. Jason groaned, holding his hands in fists and beginning to pant. Just five minutes after creampie-ing Kara, he was ready to cum again.

“Who gets this load?” Stephanie asked.

“Rock paper scissors?” Cassandra said, her voice as inexpressive as usual.

They followed through. Stephanie threw paper. Cassandra used scissors. Steph threw her head back and groaned out of frustration, scrambling away, while Cassandra smirked and straddled Jason.

She dropped her pussy onto his dick from above, landing heavily. Cassandra grabbed his hands, squeezing her fingers between his. She only had to lift and drop her ass three times before Jason’s load arrived.

Cassandra’s face shivered and twitched as she felt herself get filled up. She smiled warmly at Jason, and bent down to french kiss him as she felt bits of his cum leak out of her while more raced into her womb.

“You better have enough left for me,” Stephanie said, crossing her arms.

“Enough… left?” Jason said.

Cassandra slid off of him, and as soon as she did, the girls saw something shocking. His dick hadn’t wavered for a single second.

“How is that possible!?” Stephanie said.

“It’s been like this ever since I came out of the Lazarus pit,” Jason said. “I think it has to do with the life energy in that place, but I don’t understand. I just know that I don’t get tired quickly.”

“Then how many times can you cum then?” Stephanie asked. All three of the girls were staring at his member like they’d found the holy grail.

“I don’t know,” Jason said.

“You don’t know!?” They all asked, including Kara. Cassandra even raised her voice like the other two.

“I’ve never had it happen,” Jason said. “Maybe we can find out tonight.”

After a moment of silence, Stephanie squealed and jumped on him. Jason flipped her over, putting himself on top and fucking her from above.

“Don’t stop!” Stephanie commanded. “And I mean that for the whole night!”

“Gladly,” Jason said, slamming his hips against her ass and feeling it jiggle.

He fucked her like that until he’d dumped three loads inside her, giving her extra because she had to wait. After that it was all a blur. Jason moved between the girls for hours, until the moon eventually set and the sun rose again in its place.

He fucked them standing up, laying down, with them on top then with him on top. Sometimes he used their asses, but most of the loads went straight into their pussies. Not only did the Lazarus Pit give him an unending sex drive, his sperm was especially potent. By the time the night was up and Jason’s body finally gave out, leaving him laying on the floor with the three girls cuddled against him, they all knew that the girls had been knocked up.

It shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone, after that, that such nights weren’t left as a one time thing. Stephanie, Kara, and Cassandra knew they had to lock down this stud, even if it took all of them to do it.

Such was the start of their four way relationship, and eventually, family.