My Best Mistake - Part 2

It was a setup. It had to be a setup. Chase was straight. Not only was he straight, but he was very straight. Like, the straightest person I'd ever met. He had a girlfriend for fuck sake. Max did too. It couldn't not be a setup. They were going to get me there and humiliate me, or beat the shit out of me, or maybe even blackmail me.

I continued to stare at the snap. They were both smiling, they knew I'd have to go because what if I didn't? Would they get angry? Would they tell everyone? Would they tell everyone, anyway? I felt dizzy.

I messaged back. I needed to work out what the fuck was going on.

Umm... I'm pretty sure you've both got girlfriends. But like I said, I'd really appreciate if this could stay between us, the three of us at least. Thanks Chase.

He opened it instantly again and once more, a burst of anxiety washed over me. How could I have been so fucking stupid?! It was the lube, I'd obviously added it to my story when I tried to delete it. What a dumb fucking thing to do.

Chase Daniels sent you a snap.

I gulped as I nervously hovered my finger over it. The image that appeared on my screen was one that I had never, in my wildest dreams, expected to see from Chase Daniels.

My jaw slacked, my eyes widened and my heart vibrated violently inside my chest.

There, on the screen in front of me, were two huge, veiny cocks. They were both as hard as nails, one had a thick foreskin which covered half of the large, pink head. The other was circumcised, his head was paler, but no smaller. A thick clump of hair hugged the base of the cut guy, the other was smooth, as though he had waxed rather than shaved.

My cock sprung to life, hardening quicker than it ever had before.

I could see their hands, each holding the base of their own cock as they sat next to each other on a black sofa. I could see the table in the background, cans of beer littered it, and I knew that the photo was not a fake.

I read the accompanying message, though my eyes wanted nothing more than to remain on the two huge, beautiful penises.

They don't need to know. Do they? Now come on, we're horny AND we've got beer!

I badly wanted to screenshot the picture, but fair was fair, and they seemingly hadn't saved my stupid mistake. I replied quickly, less unsure now.

Are you really serious? I mean, I've never done anything with a guy before. I'm a bit nervous haha.

Admittedly, I just wanted another photo response, but Chase began typing and part of me was disappointed by the fact.

Yeah, we're sure. Now hurry up bro! We'll teach you.

I read the message multiple times. My cock was ferociously erect at the idea of being between either, or both of their legs! Did I have the balls? The more I thought about it, the more I realised that there really was no excuse not to go. Sure, it could still be a setup, but what if it wasn't?

I knew where Chase lived, we'd been friends for a period of time when we were children, and his house was less than a five minute cycle.

"Stop being a pussy, Jay" I told myself, trying to stay calm "just do it!".

Okay. On my way."

I sent it before I had time to fully realise what I'd just agreed to. Was it a huge fantasy of mine to suck a jocks dick? Yes. Was it an even bigger fantasy to suck two jock's dicks? Absolutely, but I couldn't shake the nagging feeling that I was being set up.

I'd just have to wait and find out. I grabbed my clothes, dressing as quickly as I could and ran into the kitchen, grabbing a bottle of my brother's vodka and swigging from it. The taste was foul, but I hoped it would do something from my nerves.

I cycled fast, and then slow. I wasn't sure if I wanted to get there quickly or if I wanted to spend more time wondering whether or not to actually go ahead with this crazy plan.

Eventually I stood outside his house. He was the only person I knew of his age that actually had their own place. It had been his parents of course, but they had moved to Prague last year and so the house that I was looking at was used mainly for parties. This evening however, as a fine October rain began to pour down, all seemed quiet.

I was beyond nervous. I could actually hear my heart beating in my chest and as I walked toward the door, I could feel my entire body tremble.

"Just relax" I told myself as I reached it.

I knocked twice and a minute later, Max stood before me.

"Oh, hey!" He nodded, stepping aside.

The awkwardness that I felt was unlike anything I'd ever felt before. I didn't know Max well, but I knew him enough to feel brutally embarrassed that he had watched me fuck my own ass less than an hour ago.

I returned a sheepish nod and stepped inside out of the rain.

The house was somewhat tidy, but had the strong scent of 'man' lingering in it. It did nothing to help my budding erection.

"Straight through there" Max told me, pointing to a room on the right side of the house.

"Bud okay?" He asked, and I nodded absentmindedly. I wasn't there for the beer.

Max was hot, there was simply no denying it. Like Chase, he spent most of his week either working out or playing football. Aside from that, he was almost always the life and soul of every party, and women seemed to flock to him.

Chase too was overly popular with the ladies, though for the most part he remained faithful to his long time girlfriend, or so I thought.

I walked into the living room. A football match was blaring on the television, the coffee table, just like the photo had shown, was filled with beer cans, some empty, some full, and then my eyes fell on the beautiful specimen that was Chase.

He was quite tall, and bulky as well. The young man was mostly muscle, but not in an unattractive or over the top kind of way. He oozed confidence, and always had. Today seemed no different.

"Jay!" He beamed "long time no see, bro".

I nodded as my face blushed.

"Well, I guess I did see you actually" he laughed, but thankfully moved on rather quickly as Max returned and handed me a beer.

"Watch!" Chase snapped and I almost jumped.

Max grabbed my arm, and I knew in that second that I was right. They were gonna' beat my ass. I winced, waiting for a punch, and then realised that I had simply been moved out of the way of the television.

Max and Chase watched intently, Chase was now hovering above the chair, his eyes wide and then the two of them roared in celebration as their team scored. My heart hammered and I felt rather stupid.

"YOU'RE OUR LUCKY CHARM!" Max howled, grabbing me into a strong bearhug and lifting me off my feet.

I groaned, but it felt quite nice to be manhandled by the handsome athlete.

When they'd finally stopped celebrating, Chase grabbed the beer from my hand, opened it and handed it back to me.

"Stop being nervous" he grinned "we're not murderers!"

I smiled back, feeling a little bit more comfortable now.

"Well technically, you are" Max shrugged "remember that goldfish you had?"

"I didn't murder it you idiot" Chase growled "I didn't know they don't eat normal food".

The two of them sat back down, still watching the tele and I stood there awkwardly, sipping from the can in my trembling hand.

"Well sit down" Max said, and he moved up the sofa so the space between him and Chase became free.

I shuffled between them, feeling their thick biceps against my much thinner ones and we all watched the football match.

"You don't act gay" Chase considered, glancing down at me.

"I'm not gay" I scoffed back and he glared at me curiously.

"So why were you shoving that thing up your ass?"

My face reddened.

"Long story" I groaned and he shrugged.

"Well, here" he added, and I watched in awe as the stunning young man lifted his butt and pulled down his shorts.

He wore nothing underneath and his huge cock flopped out as soon as the waistband passed his crotch. My mouth fell open, but Max hadn't even noticed.

"Wanna jerk it?" Chase asked, a wry smile on his handsome face.

I continued to stare at it. It looked even bigger and better than it did in the photo. I nodded eagerly.

I slowly reached toward the first cock other than my own, that I had ever touched. I wasn't sure what to expect. Would it feel the same as mine? Albeit, much larger. Would it be soft, hard, a mix of both? My fingertips reached it, it was indeed a mixture of both hard and soft, and warm too. Very warm.

"It doesn't bite" Max laughed over my shoulder, waking me from my stunned gaze.

I nodded, closing my hand around his shaft, but barely able to close it fully.

Chase continued to watch the match, seemingly unbothered that I, another man, was holding his cock.

"Jerk it" Max whispered.

I slid my hand up his long, thick shaft. There wasn't a hair in sight and it made my own cock stand to attention. His foreskin slid over his cock head, covering it as I ran my hand all the way up and then slowly back down as the skin revealed it again.

I was mesmerised. I reached the base of it, feeling his full balls against the bottom of my hand before sliding it back up once again.

It was at least eight inches long, and I could have easily used both my hands for the job, but I was glad that I didn't, because a moment later I felt my right hand being guided to Max's groin.

He too had exposed himself, and his long, veiny rod was already erect but I had little time to savour the sight as he closed my hand around it.

I felt like I was skiing. In each hand, a thick, perfect cock sat. I wanked them in unison, unable to do anything to pleasure my own aching meat. Though now that I thought about it, I was feeling pleasure.

The pair of them simply watched the tele as I stroked. I felt a bead of pre-cum spill from Chase's slit, drool down his shaft and become soaked in my hand.

"You're tenting bro" Chase grinned, and without an ounce of warning, he squeezed my erection through my bottoms.

My face blushed. I certainly wasn't small, but in comparison to both of these guys, I was nothing impressive. Chase seemed unbothered as he held my covered tool like a shifter, and it appeared that I wasn't the only one to think that.

"Hey Max" he laughed and with his free hand, pretended to hold a steering wheel.

Chase began making engine noises, steering the invisible wheel and using my hard cock as a gear stick. The two of them burst into laughter, and I still couldn't get over the fact that I was holding both of their cocks.

I continued, both of their rods now slick with their own fluids as Max pulled his t-shirt over his head to reveal his impeccable body.

My cock pulsed harder in Chase's hand and he seemed to notice, deciding that he too would disrobe.

As I sat between the two naked jocks, a cock in each hand and my own boner being toyed with, I realised that despite my earlier reservations, this had been my best mistake by a long shot.

Max gasped against my touch, his cock felt like it was vibrating and I wondered if he was going to nut already. He was watching my hand slide up and down his shaft with concentration.

"Wanna suck it?" Chase asked, and he too seemed on the verge of blowing his load.

The question surprised me. I knew what he had suggested in his message, but the idea that these guys, or at least Chase, was willing to let me actually suck his dick was overwhelming.

"I... Uh... I dunno" I replied "I've never sucked one before".

Chase shrugged and grabbed his cock at the base, swinging it back and forth. It looked invitingly pleasing as more pre-seed dribbled down it.

Max leaned over me, taking my bottoms down quickly and pulling off my trainers. I just sat there, hornier than I had ever been before, but rather embarrassed that I was about to be undressed in front of them.

"Wait, Max" Chase said, as his buddy began to reach for my boxers. Max stopped and looked up.

"Are you okay?" Chase asked me seriously "you can leave them on if you want, it's no big deal".

I felt a punch of admiration for the young man. I'd always looked at him as a bit of a brute. The type of person who didn't really care about what other people wanted, and yet he'd noticed the reluctance in my face and stopped the whole thing.

"I'm good" I smiled, and he returned it, nodding to Max who yanked my underwear down with one sweep.

My boner sprang back and smacked against my stomach and a second later, my t-shirt was being pulled over my head and I sat there, as naked as the others.

Chase flicked his cock at me again, and I held it.

He reached over, gently taking the back of my head and guiding it toward his crotch. My heart raced and I inhaled deeply, feeling his manly musk pouring into my nostrils. It drove me wild and I could tell that my cock was leaking as I opened my mouth.

I wasn't sure what to expect, but as his soft, wet head slid across my tongue, a burst of pleasure rippled through my cock. I turned my body around to get a better angle and was know laying on my stomach, Chase's cock sliding further into my mouth and my feet still firmly on the ground. It was uncomfortable to say the least, but I didn't dare stop.

I gagged hard as Chase's salty tool hit the back of my throat. I expected them to laugh, or at least comment, but instead I felt his strong hand run through my hair, as though he was encouraging me to continue. How had I been so wrong about Chase Daniels?

I began to suck hungrily, tasting his juice as it poured down my throat, and then I felt my legs being swept up and laid across Max's lap. This was comfortable.

Chase moaned lowly from above, his hand continuing to guide my head as I swallowed his thick cock. I was nowhere near the base, It was hard to even imagine reaching that point without choking to death, but I was having a nice time trying.

Max's hand ran up the inside of my leg, and it felt wonderful. My aching cock was pressed awkwardly under me, but I could feel it swell further as he lightly dragged his fingers up my thigh.

I gagged again, harder this time, but Chase's grip was a little firmer and I continued deeper. More gagging, deeper again. It felt wonderful, and yet my throat was being violated uncomfortably.

Max reached the cheek of my ass, rubbing it gently. His other hand took the other cheek and I felt them being spread apart.

My eyes widened. The idea of having my asshole seen by anybody was bad enough, but Max?! And then I realised, both men had already seen it.

My throat was stretched wide now, Chase's cock pushing deeper into it and causing me to gag more violently than ever. I willed myself not to throw up, trying to concentrate on anything else. I felt a shock of pleasure buzz through me as Max ran his finger down my sensitive hole. I moaned onto Chase's cock.

"I think he likes that" Chase laughed to Max who repeated the motion, and I moaned again.

"There's plenty more where that came from, bro" Max assured me, and I felt my cheeks being spread wider and something warm and wet run up my quivering hole.

I wasn't sure exactly what it was, and despite the overwhelming arousal that it caused, I was now focused on the fact that every inch of Chase's thick prick was embedded into my throat.

"Good job" he whispered, rubbing my head again, as the warm wet object slid up my asshole again.

"And by the way" he continued, his hand now rubbing down the area between my shoulder blades. "You're getting your first rimjob".

My eyes shot open again and for a second, I considered pulling Chase's cock from my throat and jumping from the chair, but then Max's tongue slipped inside me and I nearly came. I moaned out deeply, feeling my hole clench around his wet tongue and feeling a spark of electricity shoot through my stiff cock.

My body shuddered contently and I returned my attention to the cock in my mouth. I moved my head up and down, my neck straining with each suck. Chase purred as my tongue lapped at the underside of his pole and my lips squeezed against his sensitive organ.

I never realised how messy a blowjob would be. It certainly didn't resemble the neat, clean blowjobs that I'd seen in porn videos. His cock was drenched in saliva and it pooled around the base. Strings of pre-cum linked my lips to his meat and my eyes were red and teary from choking, and yet despite it all, it was the most amazing thing in the world.

Max continued to eat my ass out, his tongue felt magical as it enveloped my tight hole, punching inside every so often and filling me with a feeling unlike anything I had experienced before. My cock spasmed beneath me.

It was like the young men could read my mind. I felt a hand around my shaft, squeezing it and toying with it while I sucked. I couldn't tell who was playing with my dick, but whoever it was, was good. I moaned again, and Chase chuckled.

"Horny little guy, aint ya?" he whispered, and I realised that it was his hand around my junk.

I knew that I was leaking copious amounts of pre-cum into his hand, and despite the fact that he was doing the same down my throat, I felt slightly embarrassed. He however, didn't bat an eyelid.

I sucked and sucked, Max lapped at my sensitive, puckering hole and Chase stroked and fingered my pulsing cock. It felt like I had died and gone to heaven.

"Send him over here" I heard Max say as he pulled his tongue from my ass.

I felt Chase guide my head back up his long cock and I breathed deeply, sucking air into my lungs as my throat finally became free. Without any movement from me, my naked body was manhandled between the two strong young jocks and a moment later I was repositioned, with Max's thick, drooling pole pressed against my cheek.

"You've got such a fucking hot ass" I heard Chase say and once again felt him grasp my cock

"Kneel" he ordered, and the discipline in his voice made me almost orgasm in that instant.

I pulled my knees under my naked body, exposing my hole to him whilst Max pushed his meat into my eager mouth. I was being used, and it felt fucking wonderful.

Max's cock tasted sharper and saltier than Chase's had, almost as if he had been working out prior to sticking it down my throat, and if so, I was glad he had. I sucked it deeper into my mouth, gagging once again and felt my aching rod being pulled backwards between my spread legs.

It didn't hurt. If anything, it felt mind numbingly amazing and then a new sensation whisked through me and I genuinely felt as though I would pass out from an overdose of pleasure.

I knew what it was, but my brain couldn't comprehend that Chase fucking Daniels was sucking my cock. It was my first blowjob, and in that instant I knew why people loved them so much. It felt like bursts of sexual energy were coursing through my cock and balls, and I didn't want it to ever end.

Max was moaning as I took more of his meat. He was slightly thinner than his buddy, though equally as long, but it made it easier to slide it deeper into my throat. I began to bob my head, my nose nestled in his mound of pubic hair as his hand pushed up and down.

Chase pulled my cock from his mouth and ran his tongue from tip to base. I shivered in ecstasy as his tongue continued up my balls, over my sensitive taint and lightly across my already saliva soaked ring. I moaned eagerly.

It felt like he was making out with my ass. His tongue slid deep inside me, wriggling around as his lips pressed against my ring and he slurped. If he even breathed on my cock, I was going to cum.

Max fed me his pre-cum in even greater amounts than Chase had. I had to swallow multiple times to avoid my mouth filling with the stuff, though I wouldn't have minded that either.

"Ready to find your special spot?" Chase asked, pulling his tongue out of me.

Max slid his soaking tool from my throat and both he and Chase began to adjust my naked body again.

"How do you know about that?" I asked Chase curiously, as I was turned around and laid on my back.

"I'm a sex god" he grinned, his hands lifting my legs and spreading them apart. "Now you just relax".

I was relaxed. In fact, I was more than relaxed. I had never believed that I could be this comfortable in the presence of two people who I knew, whilst my most private areas were fully exposed.

Max reached under my arms and dragged me backwards so that my head now hung back over the arm of the sofa and his long rod hung inches above my face.

"Or" he grinned down "you can continue sucking my dick".

He didn't have to ask twice. From this strange new angle I opened my mouth and he positioned his cock back inside my mouth and began sliding into my throat once again.

From the other side, I felt Chase's finger against my tight ring, his other hand now held the base of my stiff cock. I took a breath as I felt the pressure and a moment later, Chase Daniel's finger was inside me.

He twisted it around, turning it upside down as though he were making a 'come here' gesture with his finger and then I felt it.

For a split second I thought I was gonna piss myself. It was like a bolt of mesmerising electricity was pulsing through my groin, and my cock twitched without warning. I moaned loudly onto Max's rod.

"That was easy" I heard Chase grin as his finger began to rub and toy with my overly sensitive prostate gland.

Every touch made me shake with immense pleasure and I had to battle hard not to blow my load. I knew it would be like the video, I didn't need to touch myself, I just knew that if Chase continued to finger my prostate, I was going to explode.

"Jay you're so fucking cute, bro" Max gasped, rubbing my chest and toying with my nipples.

I had barely remembered that his cock was still impaling me, but I turned my attention back to him, opening my throat further as his balls pressed against my cheeks.

He pulled it out, then thrust his hips forward and fucked my throat hard. Saliva and pre-cum were draining from my mouth and up my face due to the angle, and in my line of vision I could see his hot, hairy taint leading to his dark hole. I wanted nothing more than to return his favour from earlier, but it would have to wait. Chase had a new plan.

"I can't resist, dude" he gasped, and I could hear him jerking his own rod. "Can I fuck you bro?"

The words were like music to my ears, and yet I was nervous. Up until a few hours ago, nothing had ever been inside me, and Chase was the exact opposite of nothing. He was huge, far too huge to be able to fuck me without ripping me in half.

Max pulled all eight inches of his meat from my throat to allow me to speak.

"Big" I gasped, taking a long deep breath "too big".

I looked down at Chase who remained between my legs with his finger inside me. He was smiling.

"That's what lube is for, buddy" he grinned and reached behind the chair to reveal an identical bottle of KY Jelly that my dad had.

"Don't worry" he whispered, stroking my cock now "we'll go easy".

The worry was still hanging over me, but I couldn't deny him this. I wanted it as much as he did. I needed it.

I nodded to him and he looked like a kid at Christmas.

A few seconds later I could feel the lube pouring down between my cheeks and coating my sensitive hole. Chase was applying it in copious amounts, stopping only to coat his own stiff cock in it. When he was done, and we were both dripping with lube, he looked back at me.

I nodded again, bracing for a terrible pain as he lined his cock head against my quivering opening. Max sensed my nerves, rubbing my face gently as his best friend pushed softly and his thick bellend spread my hole wide.

I gasped, but the pain was nothing like I had expected. It wasn't even pain, but I could feel the pressure of his fat, veiny cock as it opened me.

"You good, bro?" Chase asked, looking from his cock to me.

I nodded again.

Max continued to console me, though really, there was nothing to console. It felt magical.

One inch, two inches, three.

The further Chase pushed, the better it felt. I was trembling with the intense feelings that were pulsing through every inch of my body and I wouldn't have changed a thing.

I felt full. Fuller than full. Chase was still entering, and my hole continued to accommodate him until finally his heavy, full balls pressed against me and I knew that Chase Daniels was deep inside.

"You okay?" He asked again, and even he was out of breath.

"I'm good" I moaned

"You ready?"

I nodded once more.

Chase slid half of his thick cock from my hole before slowly pushing it back in. A burst of pleasure buzzed through my groin.

He did it again, this time faster. I moaned out.

Again, more of his cock sliding out and slamming back in. Again, even faster.

I was sweating now, but I wanted it to continue forever. The young jock dragged almost every inch from my gaping hole and pushed it fully back inside, his balls slapping against me loudly.

I moaned fiercely as once again his pace quickened.

He was fast, and even as an athlete, I was unsure how he had the stamina to fuck me as brutally as he was. There was no pain now, not even a bit, it was just sheer enjoyment in every inch of me.

I hadn't noticed, but Max was now rubbing his leaking rod against my lips and I could taste his salty juice in my mouth. I opened up, tonguing his meat into my mouth and waiting as he began to enter.

I was being fucked from both ends, and it was the hottest thing that had ever happened to me. I gurgled, purred, moaned and groaned as the two men got themselves off with my body.

The sound of Chase's sack bouncing off my ass filled the room. So too did my gagging and moaning, and the two buddies were gasping and groaning themselves.

I could smell the scent of fresh sweat in the air, it belonged to all of us and it made us all even hornier. I reached for my cock, I needed to cum, but Max held my wrists.

"You're gonna enjoy this" he moaned, gently keeping my arms at either side of my head as he thrust deeply in and out of my throat.

My cock was begging for attention. Anything at all, a stroke, a lick, hell even a strong breeze would have done it, but neither man seemed willing. The sexual tension was driving me wild.

"I'm gonna blow" I heard Chase groan, his voice shaky and breathless.

"You ready, bro?" Max asked, and he too sounded like he was on the verge of busting his nut.

I nodded. I wasn't sure what I was supposed to be ready for, but it didn't take long for me to find out.

Chase angled his cock upwards, his thick, wet head now sliding roughly across that special area inside me. I squirmed and moaned so loud that it almost sounded as though I was screaming, but my scream was purely an explosion of the most terrific, most intense, most mind blowing pleasure that I had ever, or probably would ever feel.

He continued, each quick stroke making me weak with arousal, and then he moaned gutturally, his hands squeezed my hips, his balls bounced harder and his cock pushed hard against my prostate. He was shaking now, his balls tightened and in that exact moment, my cock spasmed and twitched without a single touch.

I whimpered and moaned deeply. It was happening. I was cumming without ever touching myself and it was the most powerful and most wonderful orgasm that I had ever had.

My entire body shook. My muscles tensed, my toes curled, my eyes rolled. I could feel Max's legs begin to shake as he poured thick, hot cum down my throat. It all happened so fast, and yet I could feel every sensation.

My own load was spraying from my aching, twitching prick. Covering my stomach and chest. Max was depositing every drop of sperm from his low hanging balls, into my tired but hungry throat, and then I felt Chase as his cock seemed to expand in my asshole.

It was as though somebody had turned on a tap inside me as waves of delicious, thick cum began to flood my rectum. It shot out in vast amounts, splashing around the walls of my insides, dripping down and pooling deep within me.

I could smell the cum in the room, the sweet, lingering, arousing scent of man. I could taste the saltiness on my tongue as Max's load dripped into my stomach. I could feel Chase's heavy fluids as they sloshed around inside me, and I knew that my own ropes of cum were spread out all across my naked, exhausted body.

Max pulled his drooling, limp cock from my throat. Chase slid his out with a wet squelch and we all remained silent, other than our heavy breathing.

Max sat me up and sunk into the chair beside me, Chase did the same and we all sat there, our cocks wet and leaking, sweat dripping down our bodies and me, destroyed in multiple loads of cum.

"I need a beer" Max said, reaching for one on the table.

"Me too" Chase added, doing the same.

"Me three" I announced and we all drank together, drained and satisfied, but none more so than me.