The next character from Damsels Anonymous is Caitlyn. Somewhat naive and trusting, Caitlyn was a bikini model who befriended Gina. After her boyfriend sunk most of her money into his failing gym business and then left her, Caitlyn had nowhere to go. After moving in with Gina, she became caught up in the other woman’s plan to kidnap Felicia Fetters as revenge for a botched kidnapping.
Caitlyn followed Gina to Marston’s Pointe and assisted with the kidnapping of Janet and Felicia and was deputized when Gina declared herself Sheriff, though Caitlyn never really took her duties seriously. Soon though, Caitlyn found herself a prisoner alongside Gina, Eva, Felicia, and Janet after Shelly Arnold took control of the Sheriff’s Department.
Arrangements were made to sell the women to the trafficker Red, and despite a three way shoot out happening at the sale, Caitlyn, Janet, and Eva were successfully brought aboard Red’s boat where they were prisoners for a few months before being sold to Shana Bram, former fitness model and mother of social media princess Autumn Beam.
Eventually Caitlyn and Janet escaped, while Eva chose to stay with Shana. Both women made their way back to Marston’s Pointe to rescue Felicia Fetters from the clutches of the dominatrix The Queen, but Janet was caught. Alone and outmatched, Caitlyn returned to Shana and Eva and offered herself to them in exchange for their help in rescuing the other girls. Shana refused this offer but said she would help in return for Caitlyn’s assistance in finding her daughter, who had been kidnapped by Ace’s man Brad and sold to Red. Eva meanwhile, only requested to rejoin the police force after saving the others.
The three women staged a dramatic rescue of Felicia, Gina, and Janet at the wedding of Felicia and The Queen. In the confusion, Shana decided to keep one of The Queen’s prisoners, Jessica Lannon, for herself, and in the confusion Caitlyn was the only one who noticed.
In the beginning of Volume 5 Caitlyn still serves as a Deputy under Gina, though she mostly works behind a desk.