My Teammates Made Me Realize I’m Hung — Chapter 2

Everyone is 18 and consenting.

Chapter 2: Ass

His cheeks parted when he climbed up, and I saw his pink hole. I stared for a second, just pondering it. He caught me looking.

“What?” he asked.

I smirked. “Do you have any… lotion?”

He looked at me funny, then realized what I was asking. "Are you serious?"

"Yeah dude," I said, wiggling my member as it started to inflate again.

We talked about what happened that night. I asked how he ended up in the room. He said someone texted him, just saying, "You gotta see this guy's dick. Biggest thing I've ever seen. At first I thought they were messing with me. Then they said who it was! Once I realized it was you, I had to see for myself," he said with a grin. "And honestly? The vibe in there was kind of insane. It felt... fun. So I just went along with it."

I asked, "Had you ever done anything like that before? With a guy?"

He hesitated just for a second, then said, "Kinda. My brother, weirdly."

That stunned me. My hand froze, mid-stroke.

He shrugged, not embarrassed. "We were close. And I dunno, it started when we compared dicks one day and he was wayyyy bigger than me. He loved that, and started always walking around hard when it was just us in the house, showing off, teasing me. Eventually we jerked off together and I got curious. We fooled around. Nothing serious, mostly just jerking him off. Oral a couple times. He wanted to try my ass, but I pussied out from going that far."

I didn’t know what to say. I had a boner and a brain full of confusion. "That’s wild," I said, still rubbing myself. "I couldn’t imagine doing that with my brother. Do you wish you went further?"

"Honestly, kind of, yeah," he said, laughing. "But weirdly... it was kind of perfect the way it was."

Then he looked at me. My cock was throbbing. He stared at it like he was trying to memorize it.

"You know, I was nervous earlier. About doing it. But now... looking at it again, I think I want to try. If you’re careful."

I felt a drop of pre-cum escape my cock at those words.

He lay back on his bed and pulled his legs up, showing his ass like a girl in missionary. "Come here, do it," he said.

I basically jumped off my bed. I got the lotion, slicked us both up, and knelt on his bed between his legs, slowly pressing forward, watching his face, making sure he was okay. I had a momentary shock to my system when I looked down and saw his cock getting hard while I was putting it in, but once I slipped in, I thrust forward instinctively, and everything felt right. I watched him tense up, and I slowed down until he was ready for another inch. I pulled back a bit before pressing forward to new depths. I had never done a guy, but it wasn't my first time putting my big piece of meat inside someone, and I knew they needed time to adjust.

I looked down at his soft skin and his pink nipples. His smooth chest was glistening a bit. I looked at his pink lips as his mouth was parted. There was really nothing wrong with male bodies, as much as I had resisted the thoughts my entire life. There was enough attention from girls that I never really thought about it, but if a guy can fetishize the size of my cock, then I can certainly let him experience it. It felt hot dominating another guy.

"We should take pics," he suddenly said, barely breathing, his eyes wide with the sensation of being stretched while I was halfway inside him. "Send them to the guys."

I laughed, but I did it. I lined up the shot with one hand while using the other to help him lift his thigh higher, framing his exposed body and my cock disappearing inside him. The photos were close up, just my oversized shaft stretching Lukas' poor hole. It was honestly hot to document it. I snapped two, maybe three, one of them zoomed out, catching his parted lips and furrowed brow. It was clear in the photo that he was right on the edge of pain and pleasure, really concentrating on the task at hand. I sent them to group chat with everyone who had been there tonight, heart pounding, wondering how the guys would react to this new level of chaos.

Replies came in instantly. Gasps, bro jokes, one guy sent a voice note just yelling my name.

But I dropped the phone. Lukas needed my focus. And I gave it to him.

Until, ninety seconds later, when there was a knock at the door.

It swung open almost immediately—Jake, Greg, and Will barged in like they’d just scored a touchdown. They had all gotten the photos and clearly sprinted over. Everyone was there within ten minutes of me sending those pics to the chat. Jake, the wisecracker of the group, was already laughing. Greg, curious and sensual, looked almost reverent as he closed the door behind them. Will, older and confident, leaned against the wall with his arms crossed, soaking it all in with a proud smirk.. “No fucking way,” Jake said, seeing Lukas with his legs up and me halfway inside him.

They cheered. I froze for a second, but Lukas just laughed and waved them in, sweat glistening on his chest. “What’s up, boys?” he said, voice breathless and proud.

Greg stepped closer, grinning. “Don’t mind us. Keep going.”

And I did. I started thrusting again, deeper this time, as the guys surrounded the bed like fans watching a wild halftime show. Jake smacked my ass once, then again harder. “You’re a fucking legend,” he said. Lukas moaned in between laughs, clearly riding the line between overstimulated and obsessed.

Then Will reached around and started jerking Lukas off, fast. Lukas gasped, legs shaking, his body clenching around me as he exploded all over himself. The noise he made was somewhere between a whimper and a laugh.

I pulled out slowly, giving him a moment to breathe, and he collapsed backward into the sheets.

Then all the attention turned to me. Four hands stroked me, teasing, edging, squeezing. My head tilted back as I let them work me over. And that’s when I said it.

“Well, whose ass is next?”

Jake and Will looked to Greg. His eyes darted away for a second, then back to me. He blushed. The twitch in the big tent in his shorts gave him away before his mouth could. His fingers gripped the edge of the desk, and he exhaled like he was trying to calm himself down. Then, like he was possessed by something older and bolder than him, he stepped forward, still quiet, and peeled his shirt off.

"Yeah, I will. If you're offering… I want to try it too," he said.

I gestured to my cock, then leaned back on my elbows. I let my cock pulse in the air, letting Greg decide how he wanted to do this. Lukas scooted over on the bed, rubbing himself slowly, as Greg crawled over me, and squatted down toward my dick. He held it in his hands, and lined it up with his ass. He just let it rest against it for a long time, feeling how big it was, and much mass it had. Greg had the most defined body on the team. I'm sure every gay dude on campus would be jealous as fuck that he was on my bed, curious about my cock. The rest of the guys watched curiously as he slowly rubbed his ass onto me. Will took matters into his own hands and squirted lotion directly onto my cock, then started rubbing it in, getting onto Greg's hole at the same time. I was about to enter my second hole for the night, not including all these guys' ravenous mouths having devoured my cock earlier. 

It was like the worship was never going to end. After another couple minutes of Greg hesitating, Will got bold again and grabbed my cock, pressing it into Greg's hole. I felt it pop in. It was so tight, but lubed up with lotion, and after blue balling myself inside Lukas, it felt amazing to get enveloped again by another tight ass. Greg dropped himself down onto me quicker than I expected, thanks to all the warm up I guess, and soon I felt his balls rest on my body while he sat on me with all his weight. I held his hips, and rolled forward, putting him on his back, and keeping myself inside him during the maneuver. His head was next to Lukas' now while I pulled out a little and thrust back in. I started humping him, ready to get my nut. He was clearly new at this, but his hard cock was showing how much it was working on him. Will and Jake took out their dicks while they watched. Jake started spanking my ass, which felt weirdly good, and soon I was jack hammering Greg's hole, surprised he wasn't asking for a break. 

"I'm gonna cum, dude," I said without stopping.

"You can do it inside me," Greg said quickly, like he was scared I was planning on pulling out.

I just pressed on, and lowered my head down to his neck. From this angle it was honestly a lot like fucking a girl. I just held his sweaty body in my arms and humped until I reached my peak. I froze inside him and grunted while I filled him up. I lifted my head, and saw Lukas coating his abs in a layer of cum. Greg grabbed himself and rapidly started pulling his pork.

"Leave it in," he said while his hand became a blur on himself. In a minute he was squirting his own load onto himself, and I felt his hole pulse on my cock. I slowly pulled out and watched a burst of white goo fall out of his gaping, red hole. I missed watching Will and Jake cum. I guess they couldn't hold out, as I saw a puddle of their combined their loads on the floor as they put their dicks away.

"I'll get you guys next time," I said.

"Yeah," said Will, a look of exhaustion forming on his face. "Next time." 

Greg seemed too stunned to speak, like he was on a high. I was hoping everything was going to be ok with these guys in the morning. After all, it was their idea to start worshiping my cock in the first place. 

"See ya guys," I said, as the three of them left together, their calm and satisfaction a clear change from the rowdiness they had had when they came in.

I got up and stretched. When I looked over to Lukas, he was asleep on top of his blanket. There was a ton of cum and sweat spots all over his bed. I shrugged, pulled a blanket over him, then curled up myself under my own blanket. 

—[]—

The next morning, everything felt too quiet. My throat was dry, and my cock was sore in that good way, like it had been through something heroic. The dorm was dim, and Lukas was still asleep across from me, one bare leg dangling off the bed, his ass half-exposed under a twisted blanket. I stared at him sleeping for kind of a long time, some form of morning meditation, wondering what emotions were going to come up today after all the excitement from the night before.