Pledge Games – Chapter 2: Afterparty

Everyone is 18.

Chapter 2: Afterparty

The door clicked shut behind us, muffling the thrum of the party. James stood there, his smirk morphing into something mischievous, predatory even. My heart kicked up a notch, and not just because of the adrenaline still buzzing in my veins from earlier. The room was small, cluttered with boxes of old beer cans and forgotten textbooks, but it felt vast suddenly, like the air between us had expanded, charged with something unspoken.

“You didn’t cum earlier,” James repeated, his tone low, almost teasing. He leaned against the wall, arms crossed, his biceps flexing beneath the thin fabric of his shirt. The guy was built like a fucking statue—broad shoulders tapering down to a narrow waist, his abs faintly visible even under the dim light. His legs, long and muscular, were planted firmly, and I couldn’t help but notice how his jeans clung to him in all the right places. Jesus. I’d seen him naked hours ago, but somehow, clothed, he was even more intimidating. Like a wolf in sheep’s clothing, except the sheep was a perfectly tailored pair of Levi’s.

I shrugged, trying to play it cool. “Guess it wasn't time.”

He tilted his head, his eyes narrowing, and a chuckle escaped his lips. “Not feeling it? You were hard as a rock. I felt it when you were ‘cleaning’ me up.” His voice dropped on the last part, and I felt my cheeks burn. Damn it. I thought I’d been subtle.

“Okay, fine,” I admitted, crossing my arms defensively. “Maybe I was. But it’s not like I was the only one. You weren’t exactly… uninterested.”

He laughed. “Touché.”

He pushed off the wall and took a step closer. I could smell the faint scent of his cologne mixed with sweat, something earthy and masculine, and my brain short-circuited for a second.

“So,” he said, his voice quieter now, “what are we gonna do about it?”

My heart was pounding so hard I was sure he could hear it. I swallowed, trying to keep my cool. “What do you mean?”

James took another step, closing the distance between us. He was close enough now that I could see the faint stubble on his jaw, the way his Adam’s apple bobbed as he swallowed. “You know what I mean,” he said, his eyes locking onto mine.

I didn’t respond. My brain was a fucking mess, torn between instinct and reason. This was James. James, the guy who joked around in the locker room, who high-fived me after volleyball games, who called his mom every Sunday like clockwork. But it was also James who had lain there, half-naked, whipped cream and cum dripping down his body, letting me lick him clean like some kind of… well, I didn’t know what.

“Relax,” he said, his lips curling into that damn smirk again. “It’s just us. No one’s watching.”

“That’s not the point,” I muttered, my voice barely above a whisper.

James tilted his head, his expression softening slightly. “Then what is?”

I opened my mouth to respond, but no words came out. What was the point? That I was straight? That this was some kind of line I shouldn’t cross? But then, wasn’t I the one who’d sucked him off in front of the entire frat? Who’d pressed my boner into his side like some kind of desperate animal?

James reached out, his fingers brushing against my arm, and I froze. His touch was warm, electric, sending a jolt of sensation through my body.

“Relax,” he said, his voice low, almost a growl.

“You're just kind of shocking me,” I said back, but there was no bite to my words.

James laughed, a soft, breathy sound that made my chest tighten. “Well, look where it’s gotten me.”

Before I could respond, he leaned in, his lips brushing against the shell of my ear. “You want this,” he murmured, his breath hot against my skin. “I know you do.”

I shuddered, closing my eyes as a wave of heat washed over me. He was right. But admitting it, even at this point… that was a different story.

James’s hand slid down my arm, his fingers wrapping around my wrist, and he pulled me closer. His body was solid, warm, and I could feel the faint thrum of his heartbeat through his chest. “It’s okay,” he said, his voice gentle now, almost soothing. “You don’t have to say anything.”

I opened my eyes, meeting his gaze, and something inside me broke. The tightness in my chest, the nagging voice in the back of my head—it all melted away, replaced by a need so fierce it stole my breath.

James must have seen it in my eyes because his smirk returned, sharp and confident. “That’s what I thought.”

He moved quickly, his hands grabbing my hips and spinning me around. I stumbled forward, catching myself on the edge of a table, and before I could react, James was behind me, his body pressing against mine.

“W-what are you—” I started, but he cut me off with a low chuckle.

“Relax,” he said again, his voice right in my ear. “Let me take care of you.”

His hands slid down my sides, leaving a trail of fire in their wake, and I felt my breath hitch. He was so close, so warm, and I could feel the hard press of his cock against my ass through his jeans. Fuck.

“You’re so tense,” he murmured, his lips brushing against the nape of my neck. “Breathe.”

I did, taking a shuddering breath that did little to calm the storm raging inside me. James’s hands moved to the waistband of my jeans, and I felt my heart skip a beat.

“Wait,” I said, my voice hoarse.

James paused, his hands stilling. “You want me to stop?”

I hesitated, my mind racing. Did I? Fuck no. But saying it… that felt like crossing a line I wasn’t ready to acknowledge. James must have sensed my hesitation because he let out a low chuckle, his lips brushing against my ear again.

“I’ll take that as a no,” he said, his voice dripping with amusement.

Before I could argue, he dropped to his knees behind me, his hands sliding around to unbuckle my belt with practiced ease. My breath hitched as he tugged my jeans down, the cool air hitting my skin making me shiver. James didn’t waste any time. His hands gripped my hips, steadying me as he leaned in, his breath warm against my ass.

And then, without warning, his mouth was on me.

James’s tongue was relentless, exploring every inch of me with a precision that left me trembling. His mouth was hot, wet, and impossibly skilled, tracing circles and pressing deep, sending endless tingles up my spine and through my upper body. I gripped the edge of the table tighter, my legs threatening to give out as he worked me open, his tongue never stopping, never hesitating. It was overwhelming in the best way, my breath coming in ragged gasps as my body surrendered to the pleasure.

At some point, I couldn’t take it anymore. I turned around, my cock hard and dripping, a string of pre-cum glistening as it trailed down to the floor. James didn’t miss a beat. His eyes locked onto mine, dark and hungry, as he leaned forward and licked it clean, his tongue catching every drop. The sight alone was enough to make me groan, but then he leaned closer, his breath warm as he took me into his mouth again, his lips wrapping around me with the same intensity as before.

“Fuck, James,” I muttered, my hand tangling in his hair as he sucked me deep, his throat opening for me like he couldn’t get enough. The power dynamic shifted again, my hips rolling forward instinctively, pushing into his mouth with a rhythm that was as desperate as it was controlled. James let me, his hands gripping my thighs for support, his throat working around me as I took what I wanted.

The room was a haze of heat and hormones, the air thick with the sounds of wet, hungry noises and my own ragged breathing. Every inch of my body was alive, electric, and I couldn’t help but feel like this was where I was meant to be—lost in the moment, lost in him.

I gasped, my hands gripping the edge of the table as James’s tongue traced a line up my length, sending a jolt of electricity straight to my core. He didn’t tease, didn’t play coy—he took me in, deep and slow, his lips wrapping around me like he’d been waiting for this moment all night.

“Fuck,” I muttered, my hips twitching forward again instinctively.

James hummed in response, the vibration making my knees buckle. His hands tightened on my hips, holding me in place as he took me deeper, his throat relaxing around me.

I didn’t realize I was moving at first, my hips thrusting forward in small, shallow movements, but James didn’t stop me. Instead, he groaned around me, the sound sending a surge of raw power through me.

Suddenly, something shifted. The nervousness, the tension—it all melted away, replaced by something primal, something dominant. My hands left the table, one tangling in James’s hair, the other gripping his shoulder.

“That’s it,” I growled, my voice low and rough. “Take it.”

I pushed forward, fucking his throat without hesitation, my movements wild and unrestrained. James didn’t fight me. He just let me use him, his hands still gripping my hips, his throat opening for me like he was made for this.

The room was filled with the sounds of my ragged breathing and the wet, needy sounds of James’s mouth on me. I felt a rush of power, a thrill of control that I’d never felt before. This wasn’t just about pleasure—it was about claiming, about taking what I wanted.

And James… he was letting me.

I looked down and saw his hairless globes of ass sticking out on his narrow frame, tight and smooth, practically begging to be claimed. The hunger surged through me, raw and unrelenting, demanding that I push further, that I take more. I had to have his ass. My fingers tightened in his hair, holding him steady as I thrust deeper into his throat, but my eyes were locked on those perfect curves.

James moaned around me, the sound muffled but unmistakable, and it only fueled the fire burning inside me. I pulled out of his mouth abruptly, my cock slick with his spit, and he gasped for air, his eyes wide and glazed with lust. Without saying a word, I yanked him up by the hips, spinning him around until he was bent over the table, his ass on full display.

“Tell me you want this,” I growled, my voice rough and commanding. My hands roamed over his bare skin, squeezing his cheeks, feeling the way they yielded under my grip.

James didn’t hesitate. “Yes,” he breathed.

That was all I needed. I leaned over him, my chest pressing against his back, and I reached down to spit into my hand, slicking myself up without breaking contact. “You’re my ass whore,” I whispered, my lips brushing against his ear.

James shivered beneath me, his body arching in anticipation. “Yeah,” he echoed, his voice barely audible.

I didn’t wait any longer. With one hand on his hip and the other guiding myself, I pushed in, slow but firm, savoring the way he opened up for me. James gasped, his fingers digging into the edge of the table, but he didn’t pull away. If anything, he pushed back, urging me deeper.

“Fuck,” I muttered, my head dropping forward as I bottomed out, my cock buried inside him. The heat, the tightness—it was everything I’d imagined and more. I stayed there for a moment, letting us both adjust, but the need to move, to claim, was too strong to ignore. My hips rolled back, and then I thrust forward again, harder this time, eliciting a sharp moan from James.

“That’s it,” I murmured, my voice low and rough. “Take it.”

My hips pistoned faster, the rhythm becoming wilder, more desperate. James’s back arched, his ass pressing against me as his moans grew louder, more unrestrained. I could feel it building, that coiled tension in my gut, and I knew I was close. James must have sensed it too because he reached back, his hand gripping my thigh, urging me on.

“Cum in me,” he rasped, his voice broken and raw.

That was all it took. I buried myself deep, my cock pulsing as I spilled inside him, hot and unrelenting. James let out a choked cry, his body shuddering as he came too, his release spilling onto the floor beneath him. The room was thick with the sounds of our heavy breathing, the air electric with the aftermath of what we’d just done.

I pulled out slowly, my body still thrumming with residual heat. James stayed bent over the table, his chest rising and falling rapidly, his skin glistening with sweat. For a moment, neither of us spoke. Then, without a word, we straightened up, fixing our clothes in silence. The tension between us was still there, but it felt different now—less charged, more settled.

We headed back to the party, the thump of the bass growing louder as we reached the main room. As we passed by an open door, I glanced inside and saw a group of guys laughing and comparing lengths in some sort of dick measuring contest. My eyes lingered for a moment, a smirk tugging at my lips. Maybe later, I thought, but for now, I kept walking, James trailing behind me.

Out on the dance floor, the girls were everywhere—grinding, laughing, their energy infectious, reminding me I wasn't gay, at least not fully. For a moment, I hesitated, my mind still buzzing from what had just happened. But then the beat dropped, and I couldn’t help but jump in, my body moving to the rhythm. I bounced my butt around, laughing as the girls cheered me on. This, I thought, this is where I belong.

For now, at least.