Anal With My Friend From School (Both of Us Are Straight) - Part 3

Everyone is 18. This is fiction.

I caught my breath, and wiped my cum off my face. “My god, Ethan. I can’t believe how good that was.” He finally pulled his fingers from my ass as he leaned back showing his hole. “We’re just getting started, and it’s my turn to nut… See if your dick fits in here.”

My mouth dropped open. “What…the fuck”. But, noticeably, my dick had not gotten soft one bit.

This kinky event started when I came across my friend’s butt plugs. Two minutes later he was teaching me that even straight guys can get off with their ass, and he literally fingered me to orgasm. Now he was lying back like a girl in a porno with his legs in the air, and wanted me to fuck him??

"You want me to put my fat cock in there?" I said, my voice thick with disbelief, “It’s bigger than your toys, bro, it’ll stretch you out.”

“Exactly,” he said, “I’ve outgrown those, and now I know you have a thick monster.” He said this while stroking his cock, and I saw his hole wink at me a couple times. His eyes glazed over slightly and I saw some precum start to drip into his belly button. His tight abs and bulging pecs flexed a bit, and I could see some sweat bead on his chest.

I guess since he just did me the most amazing favor a friend had ever done for me, and given me my first anal orgasm, it was only fair that I could work his hole out with my rod. He would do the same for me if I asked, which honestly, I might.

So, I did what any good friend would do and waddled over to him on his bed, totally naked and on my knees, hard and thick cock jutting out from my pelvis. Then I sunk down until my balls rested on his soft comforter, and my rock hard fuck-stick rested on his balls. He lifted up further, so his hole seemed to naturally pull my cock right to its entrance. He had weirdly accurate control over his ass. He had muscles I’d never seen before, and actually wiggled his hips, and moved his ass cheeks, then puckered his hole back and forth. With his movements he literally started to sort of suck my cock into his ass, without us even moving closer together. I guess he was very used to taking objects up his ass, because he got the head of my cock inside all by himself. He groaned at the penetration and gripped his cock tight. I watched a whole string of precum escape his cock and fall to his abs. 

I reached out and grabbed his legs by the thighs. I’d never fucked a girl before, so I had no rhythm, but I knew the general movements required. He opened his eyes and looked down as I began to push forward extremely gently.

“Faster” he urged, “I had a butt plug in basically all day, I’m lubed and ready bro.” He notified me matter-of-factly as he closed his eyes again and slowly rubbed his cock.

As shocked as I was a few minutes ago when I found his butt plugs, I actually kind of understood him now. He had discovered something amazing, basically having a second orgasm. I was so glad he shared this with me. What a cool fucking guy. 

So, I did what he asked and pushed in all the way, until my balls squished up against his body. He surprised me by literally squealing when I pushed all the way in. I could feel every crevice of his insides, and I felt like I was going to cum again immediately. I was hoping he wouldn’t mind that I was about to creampie his boy hole. He relaxed again, and slowly rubbed his cock in the bliss of the moment. I was giving him exactly what he wanted, and he was letting me rub my cock inside his hole. I only needed one thing to make this perfect. I reached over to the butt plugs, picked the biggest one, and shoved it in my hole. Without opening his eyes, he said “I just felt your cock get even harder, did you put a plug in?”

“You know it.” I confirmed to him.

I started to rock my body back and forth, staying as deep inside him as I could, just pushing against the soft parts of his crotch area and pushing my erection as deep as I could. Then I pulled out almost all the way, and shoved it back in, which made him moan.

“Bro.” he said, and I waited for him to continue, but then he didn’t. I understood, this was a moment. A perfect moment. Sex doesn’t get better than this, even with a girl.

“I’m gonna slam your ass bro” I warned him. Hearing no resistance, I started to pound him with my full length. He let go of his cock and grabbed my hips. I started going faster. His cock started leaking more and more precum, like he was pissing on himself. It went from clear to slightly cloudy, to almost white. I felt like I was fucking the cum out of him. He started pulling me into him, making me slam harder into his ass. Our skin was slapping so hard it was turning red, and would’ve hurt if it weren’t for the heat of the moment. 

I was so new to this anal stuff, that with the plug in my ass and my cock becoming a blur in my friend’s hole, I actually felt like I was cumming for a full ten minutes. I wasn’t sure if I was actually cumming or if this just felt so good that it started out already as good as a normal orgasm. Being so lost in the moment, I know this sounds crazy but I feel like I came two to three times, not even sure. My cock never got soft, and my hole never stopped quivering, until I was literally out of breath, and my abs were sore from hundreds of powerful thrusts at a rate of five per second. Just when I was about to stop, to prevent literally passing out, Ethan suddenly opened his eyes and looked at me directly in the eyes, opened his mouth as if to talk, but froze, and his eyes glossed over. I kept pumping, and then felt his hole contract rapidly and repeatedly on my cock. I watched as his cock spasmed and shot globs of cum in various directions, the first one landing right in my mouth and across my nose, almost hitting my eye, and making my body freeze. His continued to wildly spew onto his own chest and face. Some hit the wall, a bunch landed or dripped onto the bed. I stayed inside him until his hole finally stopped pulsing. 

He didn’t even wipe any of it off. He just laid back on the bed breathing hard. “Bro, best nut ever,” he heaved between breaths. “You can keep going until you cum if you want.” 

I started to laugh and cough a bit between breaths, “Dude I came at least twice already”.

We laughed together, both at the surprise amount of cumming and at the situation in general. I slowly pulled out, and he moaned a bit and rubbed the last bit of cum out of his flesh tube onto his stomach. I did the same to my cock and found a surprising amount leaking out. I leaned back and threw my legs up to show him the plug, and he slowly pulled it out of my ass. It felt so good I felt like jerking off again. “Bro it feels even better when you pull it out” I told him.

“I know, right?” He agreed. He threw it into the box with the rest of the toys. “Those are gonna need a wash… the box too.” He said, chuckling again. Our cocks didn’t even really get soft, they just stayed firm. This was the best experience I’ve ever had in my life, and I feel like he felt the same. I wasn’t sure where we would go from here, but I knew it was going to be amazing.