[Commission] Boys Sleepover With a Fleshlight - Part 4

Everyone is 18. This is fiction.

Cody added “Don’t tell anyone else, I think this is a good number of dicks to pussy ratio” he said, gesturing to my crotch. I wasn’t sure if he was referring to how I held the toy between my legs for them, or if he was saying that I was the pussy. Either way, he was right, honestly.

As soon the time came, around 10pm when his Mom went to bed, I started craving the feeling of Cody behind me slamming into the toy and playing with my ass, but I couldn’t really admit it to him. So I offered that he might want to show us for real how he was going to fuck Carrie if he had the chance. I put the fleshlight back between me legs from behind and presented my ass to him like a bitch in heat. When I assumed the position, I felt a glob of cum fall out of the toy and run down my legs. Fucker used it again today and didn’t even clean it. But, we were too far gone to care about that now. I watched him pull out his hard cock immediately, while Freddy and Johnny took off their clothes and got ready for the action. Cody leapt up from his beanbag chair and onto his knees, then he scooted over to me, his boner bouncing around. It looked bigger now than it used to be. I think this weekend had turned us into men. 

When Cody approached me, his cock tapped against my ass, right on the hole, making me flinch, but I immediately leaned back into it. I could feel the heat from his body as his cock went up between my cheeks. He quickly pulled it back, disappointing me that his cock wasn’t touching me anymore, and he inserted it in one thrust into the fleshlight between my legs, held my hip sand started ramming into the toy, residually bouncing my body and my cock and balls around. Feeling the pressure of his body slamming up against me again, I finally had the horny courage to ask for what I really wanted. I looked back at him and made eye contact, while he held my hips and thrusted.

“Why don’t you show me how you really wanted to fuck her?” I asked. He narrowed his eyes at me quizzically, unsure if I was really asking what I was asking.

“I know you always liked girls doing anal,” I said, referring to his porn preferences of which we were all aware, and his eyes widened like a guy who just won the lottery, and stuck his thumb in my ass again.

His thrusting stopped in the toy, I’m guessing because he was about to cum from the excitement. He started just playing with my hole, repeatedly inserting his thumb. Then he spit on it again, “Carrie likes a good thumb in her ass, doesn’t she?” he asked.

“Yes, Daddy” I responded.

Cody inserted his other thumb, and held it there until I relaxed. I could see where this was going, and I was too horny to say no. I didn’t even care how gay this seemed, if it meant we were getting off better than before.

He started to gently apply pressure with his thumbs, pulling me open. I gasped, and dropped my chest down to the floor, so I was just sticking my ass up, holding the toy in my legs, while Cody’s cock was still inside it. I leaned my ass back into him to let him know he could continue with his thumb work on my hole. When he pried it open enough to see inside, he spit again, just watching it drip into me, apparently pleased with my submissiveness.

He pulled his cock out of the toy, and said “This is how I really would’ve fucked her,” and placed the tip of his cock at the entrance to my ass.

“Oh my God” I gasped. But, I didn’t pull away. Whatever was happening right now was meant to be. Maybe I’ll get a chance to do the same when it’s my turn.

Then he began to insert his cock, which was much bigger than the thumb job I got before. He stretched me out slowly, putting just the head in, then taking it out. I turned my head to look at the other two. They were sitting cross legged, fully naked, mouth agape, and both stroking their big erections. We were in this together.

As if they sensed the unity I was feeling in the moment, Johnny and Freddy approached me from either side and began to rub my body, physically supporting me in this moment. Their hands explored my shoulders, sides, chest, nipples, abs, and even my cock and balls.

Cody put his hands on my hips again, and slowly pushed into me for real, giving me another inch of his cock every few seconds, until he pressed his pubes against my ass cheeks. Through the discomfort of accepting a large cock in my ass, I opened my legs and dropped the toy, which had been forgotten at this point, and leaned back into Cody, letting him know this was good.

I gasped again when he pulled my body back to maximize his penetration. It felt like he opened up yet another hole deep inside me. As Cody sat there having fully penetrated his longtime friend and goon buddy, and the other two rubbing me with increasing curiosity, as well as caressing their cocks, I believe we were all adjusting to a new level of friendship.

Freddy, the guy with the biggest cock among us, in both thickness and length, started accidentally (or so I thought) poking me with his dick while me massaged my back. Cody continued lightly thrusting in me. Apparently he could last longer than the rest of us since he came twice this afternoon already.

Johnny, the smallest one of us, picked up the fleshlight, which I had forgotten about, and said “Does Carrie want to get taken care of too?”

My cock never stopped being rock hard since Cody started literally fucking my ass, and I looked down at myself to see a string of precum stretching from my cock to the floor. 

“I would cum immediately” I said to Johnny.

“That’s fine” Cody interjected, “I can’t hold out much longer either.”

“Do it” I said to Johnny.

As Cody picked up his pace, he started really hammering my ass, and all the sensations and internal tingles, even Cody’s body slapping against my ass felt amazing. I thought I might cum just from that. Then Johnny grabbed the base of my cock and pushed the toy onto me, all the way to the base in one thrust, I immediately started jizzing my soul out of my body into the toy. I came so much that it squirted out the other end of the toy. 

Cody seemed like his brain stopped functioning as he thrusted. “Ung, ohhm, I you’re ass in pulsing on my cock, girl” he said, before freezing inside me. I felt every pulse of his cock as he bred my ass. I was still pulsing in the toy, and Johnny started moving it slowly up and down my shaft, knowing that I was still mid orgasm. Cody collapsed on top of me, pushing me to the floor, and I lost the toy to Johnny’s hand. He was still inside me, and thrust gently a few more times in prone bone position. Feeling his weight on top of me cemented my position in this new hobby of ours. I loved this. I was meant to be right here, under another boy. It wasn’t the toy that would become our whore for tonight. 

It was me.