Two MJs Are Better Than One (Spiderman)

Summary: Stephen Strange’s failed spell didn’t seem to cause any trouble to his surprise. No new villains, no alternate Spiderman, and no world-changing events. Peter Parker, however, found a stacked redheaded calling herself MJ, who insisted that they belonged together. His girlfriend, Michelle, also called MJ, was not pleased.

A/N: Poll Winner from January. Finally getting caught up... sorta. Still a bunch left to post.

Peter didn’t know how this happened.

Well, that’s a lie. He knew exactly how this happened, but it still made no sense.

Doctor Strange’s spell did what Peter wanted and made everyone in the world forget who Spiderman was, other than the exceptions he kept adding in the middle of the spell. The only issue was that the constant changes in Peter’s requests in the middle of the spell screwed something up. It wasn’t obvious initially, but the situation in his bedroom clearly was a problem.

There were two MJs in his room. Two very different MJs. One was his awesome girlfriend that was out of his league, and the other…

Well, the other MJ was out of his league too, but in a very different way. While Michelle was a kickass girl that Peter definitely loved, Mary Jane was stacked.

It was almost unfair how much her body looked like a wet dream. Mary Jane had an hourglass body that almost seemed too good to be true. If Peter didn’t have his powers, he would have even thought that some plastic was involved, but he had seen the subtle bounce of Mary’s assets whenever she took a step. Peter knew what plastic looked like, and Mary Jane wasn’t plastic.

It wasn’t a surprise when Mary Jane said that she was an actress in her universe. What did surprise Peter was that she wasn’t dating her world’s Spiderman, especially with how much she raved about him.

“Wait, Mary Jane,” Peter flinched at the glare he got and corrected himself, “I mean, MJ. You were going to get married to someone else?”

The stunning redhead had made herself at home on his bed. She hugged a pillow, making Peter look away from her breasts getting perked up, and said, “My Peter was too focused on his hero business. He didn’t care about me at all and refused to even consider cutting back a little.”

Peter hid a frown and shared a glance with Michelle. He felt it was a little rude for Mary Jane to ask that of her Peter.

The redhead saw that and smiled wryly, “I know what you’re thinking. I was fine with him being a hero, but near the end, my Peter had started to spend all of his time saving people with barely enough time to eat and sleep. I tried my best to accept it, but there’s only so much neglect I could take before snapping.”

Peter winced, even he didn’t go that far. It sounded like the other Peter went around solving petty crimes in addition to the city-threatening villains. Well, Peter did that too, but only if he saw it on his scheduled patrols. After all, the cops still existed for things like that.

“Look,” Michelle spoke up, “I’m sorry that your Peter is messed up, but we still need to get you back to your universe. Peter… My Peter says that Dr. Strange can get you there.”

Mary Jane frowned, “I already said I don’t want to go back. I have nothing there for me! All I have to look forward to is being a trophy wife.”

Michelle crossed her arms and said, “Well, what do you have here? Isn’t it even worse than your universe?”

“Well,” Mary Jane perked up with a smile, “I have this, Peter! I could be his awesome new girlfriend!”

“What?!” Michelle yelled as she jumped up.

Peter was staring wide-eyed at Mary Jane until he felt the angry glare of his girlfriend shooting a hole in his head. He realized his mistake and stuttered out, “Y-Yeah! What she said!”

MJ punched Peter in the arm for his unconvincing act before turning back to Mary Jane. “Look, lady, I don’t know what your deal is, but Peter is MY boyfriend. If you want to be Peter’s girlfriend, go back to your own universe and date him there.”

Mary Jane was unaffected by Michelle raging and only cared about the drool that was about to drip out of Peter’s mouth. It wasn’t often she was worried about a man being attracted to her, but Michelle was almost the opposite of what Mary Jane looked like. That wasn’t to say that Michelle wasn’t gorgeous, because she was, but Michelle looked more like what a traditional model was supposed to look like. A woman with a slender frame with long legs and sharp features. Mary Jane had the sharp features covered, but slender she was not. Her body was more of an hourglass shape with large breasts and wide hips.

Luckily, it looked like this universe’s Peter liked both body types. That was perfect for Mary Jane.

She looked at Peter, who was struggling to keep his thoughts out of the gutter, and said, “Would you mind giving us the room, Peter?”

Mary Jane smiled at the glaring Michelle while Peter hesitantly left the room. As soon as the door closed behind him, Michelle growled out, “You’re crazy if you think you can talk me into this.”

“I think I’ll manage,” Mary Jane said calmly, “You know what made me really happy when I found you two? That there was an MJ that Spiderman fell in love with. Even in another universe, MJ was the girl. I always wondered if one of the other girls interested in Peter… my Peter, belonged with him more than me.”

“You weren’t with your Peter, though,” Michelle pointed out, “Doesn’t that break your logic?”

Mary Jane waved it off, “Semantics. That doesn’t change what I meant.”

“Yeah, it does,” Michelle muttered, something Mary Jane conveniently ignored.

“Look, let’s make a deal. We’re both MJ, right?” Once again, Mary Jane ignored the glare she was getting, “It’s like we’re both the same person, just from different universes… or whatever. How about we ask Peter what he wants?”

Michelle eyed the redhead before yelling, “Peter!”

[Break]

“So unfair.”

“What’s unfair is you expecting to get with my boyfriend.”

Mary Jane and Michelle were standing off to the side while Dr. Strange and Peter talked about getting the redhead back to her own reality.

“I still don’t get why you didn’t ask Peter what he wanted.”

Michelle looked at Mary Jane with disbelief, “OH, I don’t know… maybe because I don’t want to tempt Peter with a bimbo?”

“Please,” the redhead rolled her eyes, “Like you’re the first to try and insult me like that. Peter clearly loves you, so I don’t get why you’re so threatened with an alternate version of yourself.”

Michelle wanted to argue that there was no way that they were anyway similar, but Peter interrupted their little spat.

“Uh, girls? There’s a little problem here.”

Peter flinched when two pairs of eyes stared at him. He looked to Dr. Strange for a little help, but the helpful sorcerer just smirked and walked through a portal, leaving Peter alone.

“Perfect,” Peter muttered before clearing his throat, “Dr. Strange says that MJ… er, Mary Jane, is stuck here. Apparently, something about reversing the spell being too dangerous.”

“YES!”

“WHAT?”

Peter nervously chuckled and edged backward as his MJ and the redheaded MJ had two very different reactions.

“Do you mind if I stay with you, Peter? I don’t know anyone in this world.”

“No!” Michelle blurted out instantly, “There’s no way he’ll let you do that.”

“I think that’s something Peter should decide.”

Peter gulped as the two girls stared intently at him. He tentatively said, “Maybe we could get a hotel room for Mary Jane?”

[Break]

Mary Jane didn’t stay in a hotel. Much to Michelle’s displeasure, the redhead would be staying at Peter’s house, directly in the room next to his. Even more surprising was that May seemed to take the new guest in stride and made her feel at home.

Michelle pulled Mary Jane aside to lay down some ground rules.

“Look, bimbo, if you’re going to be leeching off Peter, you’ll listen to what I say. First, the only MJ here is me. This is my universe, so I get dibs. I don’t care if you say you’re an alternate version of me, but MJ is what I go by here.”

Mary Jane raised an eyebrow and tilted her head in curiosity. She was wondering what the much younger woman would try to get the upper hand. This seemed pretty tame in her book.

“Second. Peter is MINE. Don’t try to be a homewrecker, and I might tolerate you.”

Michelle glared at Mary Jane to get that point across before continuing.

“And third, you need to find another place to stay. I won’t have you trying to seduce my boyfriend.”

“Those are pretty tough rules,” Mary Jane said with a smirk, “What if I say that I don’t care what ‘rules’ you have for me?”

Michelle clenched her jaw before opening her mouth to say some pretty harsh things to the stacked redhead, but Mary Jane took that opportunity to shut her up.

“Mmph!”

Michelle protested into the lips covering her own as she froze in shock. Peter was her first boyfriend, and basically first in everything, so she had never kissed someone else before, let alone another girl. Michelle didn’t want to admit it, but she didn’t hate it.

Mary Jane was about to feel the kiss starting to be returned before the sound of Peter choking on air interrupted them.

“Peter!” Michelle gasped out after pushing Mary Jane away as she frantically waved her arms, denying what just happened, “She started it!”

“Umm…” Peter wasn’t sure what his reaction should be. Was he supposed to do the right thing and get angry at the busty redhead laying one on his girlfriend? Or should he go with what his mind and cock were in agreement with?

“I… don’t mind. As long as I get to be part of it.”

Peter obviously went with the latter choice.

“I knew you’d see it my way, Peter.”

Mary Jane’s response was in stark contrast with Michelle’s, who was staring in outrage at Peter’s response.

“Why do you have to be such a boy! If you want to sleep with this bimbo, be my guest! I won’t be—- MMPH!”

Michelle’s rant was interrupted by another kiss from Mary Jane. This time it was with tongue. Peter could feel his pants getting tighter as he watched his girlfriend and the supposed ex-girlfriend from another reality make out. He didn’t think he could be blamed for liking what he saw. Which guy didn’t want to see two hot girls sloppily kiss right in front of him, especially when the kiss was to convince the other to agree to a threesome.

Mary Jane pulled away from Michelle’s face and licked her lips with a shudder. She preferred men, but there was nothing wrong with having fun with a girl now and then. And Michelle was a girl Mary Jane could have a lot of fun with. She glanced at Peter and smirked wickedly.

“Looks like your Peter is just as gifted as mine was. Why don’t you just accept this so we could have some fun?”

Michelle slowly opened her eyes to look into Mary Jane’s green eyes before seeing Peter’s pitched tent. She could feel her pussy getting wet as she thought about Mary Jane’s stacked body completely in the nude. Maybe it would be smarter to think more carefully about changing how her relationship with Peter worked, but it was like Mary Jane put a spell on her.

Michelle’s eyes dropped down to Mary Jane’s swollen lips and said, “Fine. We can give this a try, but I’m still the one who gets to be MJ. This is my world, so that’s my right.”

Mary Jane shrugged and accepted. If Michelle wanted something to call it her ‘win,’ Mary Jane would let her have it. After all, it was a big ask to share Peter.

“I have no issues with that… MJ.,” Mary Jane smiled before looking at Peter, “What about you? Are you alright with this?”

Peter knew that the redhead wasn’t asking about something as trivial as who would be called MJ. And Peter also knew that he definitely wanted this.

[Break]

Peter was in heaven. MJ didn’t mind giving him blowjobs, but it was never her favorite thing to do. Mary Jane being here changed that drastically.

With the redhead cheering her on, MJ hollowed her cheeks and sucked on Peter’s cock like she was trying to pull his cum right from his balls. That obviously didn’t happen, but MJ did take his cock deep into her mouth.

“Wow, Peter! I didn’t think MJ loved sucking on your cock this much! She’s more like me than I thought!”

Peter grunted as he lightly pushed down on MJ’s head. That didn’t agree with her. Even though she had been much more enthusiastic about the blowjob than usual, MJ didn’t ever try to take it down her throat, mainly because she had never done it before. But Peter’s push made his cock invade her gullet for a brief moment.

GLACKH

MJ slapped Peter’s hips in protest before pulling herself off his cock and coughing harshly.

“What the hell, Peter! You know you’re too big for that!”

“Shit, I’m sorry! I didn’t mean to do that, MJ.”

MJ rubbed her neck while wincing at the feeling of a phantom cock filling her throat. Mary Jane couldn’t keep quiet anymore and scoffed, “Really? You never gave your man the chance to know what it feels like to have his entire cock disappear in your mouth?”

“Hey, why don’t you try it, bimbo!”

Mary Jane rolled her eyes and paused MJ aside to make room between Peter’s legs. To be completely honest, Mary Jane adored that this world’s Peter was even willing to do this. Her Peter treated her like a queen, and it would have never occurred to him that he could just sit on the bed with a girl serving his cock. Let alone the fact that there could be two girls that would happily suck on his cock.

“Let me show you how it’s done, MJ.”

MJ watched with wide eyes as Mary Jane down Peter’s cock past her lips and into her throat with ease. Peter’s breath hitched as his cock entered a tight, warm hole massaging him on all sides. He must have been in a daze because the next thing he noticed was that Mary Jane was kissing the base of his cock with it down her throat.

“Oh my god!”

Mary Jane looked up at Peter’s praise and winked before smoothly pulling his cock out before slamming her face down. MJ looked on with a gaping mouth as her boyfriend was given a sloppy throatfuck from a bimbo claiming to be an alternate version of herself.

“Fuck, Mary Jane! I’m coming!”

Mary Jane didn’t let up and kept fucking her own face on Peter’s shaft before pulling away right at the last second. She kept her lips around his leaking cock head while rapidly stroking his thick shaft to make him spew all the cum he had.

It worked.

Mary Jane moaned as her mouth was filled with Peter’s thick cum. She expected it to be a lot, but Peter kept cumming until her cheeks were bulging with the amount of cum she held in her mouth. When she pulled away after he was done, Mary Jane was about to open her mouth to show the cum before swallowing it, knowing that would get Peter going again, but then she saw MJ staring at her with amazement.

Mary Jane shifted over to MJ before looking at Peter with a sultry look. He could only stare in shock as his new… girlfriend? Yes, his new girlfriend made out with MJ while swapping his cum between them.

“Oh my god….”

Peter felt like he was a recorder, repeating the same words repeatedly. Still, there was nothing else he could say about what he was seeing. His cock had sprung right back into hardness as he watched MJ swallow a bit of cum passed to her from Mary Jane’s mouth.

“Peter! I’m home!”

Peter panicked as he whisper-yelled, “Aunt May’s back early! Clean up while I distract her!”

The girls watched their boyfriend speed out of the room after cleaning himself up in record time before looking at each other.

“So?” Mary Jane asked with a smile, “This wasn’t a bad idea, was it?”

MJ looked away with a faint blush even though she had just drunk her boyfriend’s cum out of another girl’s mouth.

Mary Jane chuckled and gave MJ a deep kiss before pulling back and licking her lips. “It’ll be nice to have another girl to be my support when Peter is off doing his crazy stunts. And I'm sure you feel the same after he worries you sick.”