Is That A Beater’s Bat In Your Pocket? - Chapter 3

Summary: Angelina Johnson has waited her entire Hogwarts career to captain the quidditch team. So when she finally gets her chance she’s not gonna let Harry Potter’s short temper with the new Defense professor rob her of her star seeker. So with the help of her two friends, Alicia and Katie, she sets out a plan to ensure Harry’s temper is kept in check by any means necessary. Hogwarts starts at 14.

-

I’ll Let You Touch My Quaffles (Katie)

-

Katie Bell was nervous. Extremely and utterly nervous. Angie and Alicia had cornered her the night before and explained the grand idea for a foursome with Harry. Excuses like “team building” and “stress relief” were thrown into their spiel but Katie knew the truth. Both girls were just extremely horny sluts.

That’s fine! A-okay with her. She never batted an eye when they detailed their past flings and she’d even admit to using a few of their tales as fuel for her own fantasies, but she had never done anything close to what they described.

Sure she’s snogged a few boys and even gave a handjob once but that was it, and now her two best friends corner her and tell her she needs to shag a guy rotten with them AT THE SAME TIME!

So yeah, Katie was nervous. She had agreed of course. No matter what she would always give in to Angelina and Alicia’s wants.

It’s what got them a month’s worth of detention two years ago when the other two talked her into getting drunk and running out on the quidditch pitch topless late one night. Poor Flitwick couldn’t look them in the eye for weeks.

But it wasn’t just the idea of having sex or them all having sex with the same person that made her truly nervous. It was the person they intended to shag.

It was no secret to practically anyone that she’s had a crush on Harry for years. She had tried to ask him to the Yule Ball the year before but chickened out every time. A very forlorn Katie had spent the entire night crying in the bathroom after watching him dance with Parvati Patil. A fact that her two friends reminded her of when trying to convince her.

She knew of their involvement with Harry already. The chaser trio was far too close to one another for petty secrets like that. If it had been anyone else she would have been furious, but with Angelina and Alicia it was different. They were her best friends and she loved them (the fact that they were both exceedingly hot had a bit to do with it as well). She knew the two cared for Harry but that sex with him was more so just for fun than an actual relationship. Yet for her it would be different. If she were to get that close to Harry she would want more, she would want him entirely, not just physically but emotionally.

She shared this with her friends when they pestered her, and their response wasn’t all that surprising to say the least.

*Flashback*

“Then go fuck him.” Alicia stated, eyes boring into her.

“W-what?”

“I don’t mean with us, that’ll come later. I mean go to him right now, confess your feelings and then mount that giant cock of his and make him forget his name.”

Looking to Angelina for help she was shocked to find the quidditch captain just nodding along before she too joined in.

“Alicia’s right, you’ve held a candle for the bloke all these years and it’s time to tell him how you feel.”

Katie bowed her head down, “But what if he doesn’t feel the same?” she whispered quietly.

Angelina’s hand rested gently on her shoulder and the blonde’s teary gaze rose to match hers.

“Then you can move forward knowing that you took your chance and that you won’t live regretting that you never did.”

“Plus when he admits his feelings too you guys can fuck every day! Ooo and maybe even invite me and Angie to your bed every now and then!” Alicia exclaimed excitedly.

Katie let out a watery laugh at the girls bubbly excitement.

“Sure Alicia, I’ll even make sure Harry gets a pair of those fluffy handcuffs I saw you eyeing in Hogsmeade”

The choked sound that came from the excitable chaser caused her to laugh loudly.

*End Flashback*

So now here she was, hanging back while everyone else left the Room of Requirement after another successful DA session. She watched Harry on the other side of the room, answering a few questions from departing students and giving words of encouragement to everyone that left. Hermione stood with him, eyes glued to that strange parchment she saw one of the Golden Trio with every meeting.

Finally Hermione parted with a whispered goodbye, folding up the parchment and handing it to Harry. She eyed Katie curiously before suddenly the witch’s widened and she retreated quickly. Though Katie swore she saw the bookworm mouth ‘Good luck’ to her before departing. Harry too turned to her curiously, his green eyes tracking her movement as she approached him slowly.

“Good work today Katie! You’re doing amazing!” the teen exclaimed when she finally found herself in front of him.

“T-thanks Harry.” the girl stuttered back.

“Of course. Anyway I was just about to head out myself, do you want me to walk you back to the common room?”

She swallowed once, before raising her eyes to meet his. His beautiful green eyes peered into her soul, piercing her very being. Katie felt her breath quicken and her heart start to flutter rapidly. What was wrong with her? She talked to him nearly everyday just fine and now when she tries to admit a silly school girl crush her words fail her? She couldn’t do this. It was too much, too much, too much- No! She wasn’t in the house of the brave for nothing. She could do this!

“Actually Harry t-there was something I n-needed to speak with you about.” She squeaked.

Harry nodded. Sensing that this would be a somewhat serious conversation the wizard asked the room to conjure two plush chairs. Gesturing for her to sit, Katie did so, wiping her sweating hands on the black material of her uniform skirt.

‘Gryffindors charge ahead, Gryffindors charge ahead’ the girl chanted in her mind.

Taking a breath the girl made to speak only for Harry to speak up first.

“Look Katie, if this is about what I’ve been doing with Angelina and Alicia I get it. I just want you to know I would never hurt them.”

Katie nodded sharply at his statement, her mind whirling not knowing how to respond properly. His statement irritated her in a way. Here she was ready to admit her feelings for him and he wants to make sure she knows he wouldn’t hurt her friend’s feelings? What just because he was shagging them every now and then? She had worked herself up, sick with nervousness at the thought of telling him she liked him, and this- this idiot has the audacity to think it’s about his stupid broom cupboard fucks?

“…plus me and Angelina already talked and we decided that while we care for each other, a relationship just isn’t-“

“WILL YOU JUST BLOODY SHUT UP ALREADY?!?” the blonde finally exploded. She hadn’t realized how quite worked up she had been getting but it had finally proven too much. The boy snapped his mouth shut instantly at her shout, wisely not uttering another peep.

“You are just so fucking thick Harry Potter! Simply the biggest, stupidest twit I’ve ever known! I have spent hours working up just the smallest shred of courage to tell you I have a bloody crush on you and what do you do? Prattle on about you and my friends shagging! Who bloody gives a damn that you’re shagging them?! When a girl asks to speak with you, have some common sense once in a while, and just shut the fuck up and listen!”

The girl finished her rant with a glare towards the gaping teen. Her chest heaved from her shouting and her hair, which had been secured by a ponytail, now fanned out like honey blonde waves around her head.

“…you have a crush on me?” the messy haired wizard finally spoke up with quietly.

The girl just scoffed, her blood pumping far too hotly to care about her accidental admittance.

“Obviously you bloody idiot. Practically the whole school knows I do!”

Nodding once the boy who lived stood slowly. The girl sighed internally. Here it was, the rejection she knew was coming. What did she care now? She said her piece now the boy would simply walk out the door without a word. Probably share a few awkward glances and small talk throughout the rest of their Hogwarts ten-

The blonde haired witches thoughts were cut off at the feeling of a soft pair of lips upon hers. With a start, the third chaser realized he was kissing her. Harry bleeding Potter was actually kissing her!

Moaning into his mouth she fully gave herself to the kiss. Matching the movement of his lips with hers. She felt his tongue swipe softly across her bottom lip seeking entrance, something she happily gave. As he deepened the kiss with her the girl in turn gripped the front off his robes tightly pulling him in flush with her body. Only when the need for air became too dire did they part.

Panting slightly between her now flushed lips the girl rose her gaze to meet her crush’s. His eyes were alight with awe, his own lips reddened and formed into a brilliant smile. The words he spoke next warmed her heart.

“I like you too Katie.”

With a joyful laugh she flung herself forward, knocking the boy back into the conjured plush chair. She followed right behind him, landing on his lap causing a bit of air to be knocked from his lungs. She didn’t give him a chance to recuperate though. Her lips descended upon his again with more urgency. An undercurrent of need fueled her, making her kisses wilder and more heated. She began to push back against his tongue with hers, nip at his bottom lip, and suck lightly at the skin of his jawline. With every step forward she took in exploring him, he did the same.

When she bit his lip, he gripped her firm bum with a squeeze. When she sucked gently upon his jaw, he trailed his hands slowly up under her shirt. It was only when he reached the bottom swell of her breasts did they halt.

“We don’t have to do this. I don’t expect anything from you and would never force you to do something you don’t want to do.”

Katie nodded. “No, I want this. I just- this would be my first time, with anyone. So just go slow okay?”

Harry gave her a reassuring smile and leaned forward to kiss her once more. His hands snaked up the final few inches and came to rest gently around her bra-clad breasts. The girl shuddered at the contact, having never felt anyone else touch her chest before. It excited her to know that it wouldn’t be the last place to be touched for the first time tonight.

Harry massaged her chest for a while as they kissed. Seemingly content to enjoy feeling her up for the rest of his days, yet Katie wasn’t. The blonde had nearly four years of pent up sexual frustrations to let out and Harry Potter’s chivalry was not about to get in the way of that.

The girl pecked his lips once more before pushing herself a way. The teens hands were still trapped in her tight school shirt yet she made no move to remove them. Instead she started to slowly unbutton the garment. Hands taking their time to undo each individual button. With each one, more and more of the girls porcelain skin was revealed until finally, after what felt like forever to the boy, the shirt came loose leaving her only in a lacy purple bra.

His hands still lay atop the covered mounds, yet that didn’t stop the girl from reaching back to deftly unlatch the covering.

His hands fell to her flat toned stomach, and with them so too the bra fell. Harry simply drunk in the sight of her rounded perky breasts. Guiltily, he found himself comparing them to Alicia’s and Angelina’s. Her’s were bigger than Angelina’s but not quite as big as Alicia’s, yet they were perkier than the latter girl’s, with small quarter sized areola capped with pale pink nipples. Her nipples too were different. Whereas Angelina had longer hardened ones that jutted out from her small chest, Katie’s were smaller and much less pronounced like Alicia’s though not as rounded.

They were a perfect middle ground to balance out with the other two girls and he found himself hardening rapidly at the sight of her perfect tits.

Harry couldn’t help himself. Seeing her lovely chest sitting right there in front of him was too tempting. Surging forward the teen wrapped his lips around one of her pale nipples, sucking gently on the small nub while his hand came up to cup her other breast.

The topless witch moaned at the feeling of his mouth on her tits. She threaded a hand loosely through his messy hair, gently pushing his head deeper into her chest. Unconsciously she began to grind herself on his hard cock. The clothed member line up perfectly with her panty clad cunt and she mentally thanked Julie Runcorn for suggesting she wore her uniform skirt today instead of the pants.

It soon became too much for the girl. She needed him and needed him now.

Grabbing his face with her hands she forced his eyes to meet hers.

“Harry, take me to bed. Now.”

Swiftly Harry stood, hands holding her up by her ass as she wrapped her legs tight around him. He walked her forward and she squeaked in surprise when he flung her down only to be met with the soft plush mattress of a queen sized bed that hadn’t been there before. The rumbling chuckle of her green eyed soon-to-be lover earned him a glare though she had no time to chastise him for his small prank as the teen’s head soon dived under her skirt.

For half a moment she was confused before she felt her knickers being pulled aside and a warm wet muscle roam over her womanhood.

With a gasp she drew up her long skirt to find an incredible sight. On his knees before her was Harry Potter with his tongue lavishing her cunt as if it were a delicacy. His mouth worked at a frenzy, licking and slurping at her clit and it took all her will power to stop from bucking her hips into his face.

“O-oh-OH FUCK!” she screamed, a climax rippling up her spine in an instant. Harry pulled back in surprise at the girls cries, string in wonderment as she convulsed on the bed.

“Merlin Katie, I didn’t think you’d cum so easy!”

The girl simply groaned. “D-din’t th’nk would feel so go’d” she stuttered out, aftershocks of her orgasm still shocking her nerves.

Ego rising Harry stood with a smirk. Remembering a spell that Alicia had showed him a few days ago, he pulled out his wand. With two quick flicks and a muttered incantation their clothes flew off their bodies into a folded pile on the floor.

Laying his wand upon the pile he turned to find Katie sitting back up and staring at him, eyes glued to his hardened cock. She absentmindedly rubbed her stomach, likely in disbelief that the large pole would even fit. Harry remembered her earlier request and knew she probably had a few lingering nerves. Deciding to ease her into it, the teen walked towards her before picking her up and laying her farther up onto the bed.

Katie only smiled at him as he lifted her, her heart fluttering quickly with excitement and a small amount of anxiety. Not only was this her first time but she also knew she would have to stack up against Alicia and Angelina as well. The two girls were practically sex incarnate and she would be a liar if she said she wasn’t a tad bit self-conscious compared to them.

Harry seemed to sense her thoughts as soon he was right there beside her, softly rubbing his palm against her cheek before placing a gentle kiss upon her forehead.

“You’re perfect Katie, just the way you are. No one can compare to you because you are the best version of you possible and I would never wish you to change.”

Her heart fluttered at his words and she pulled him in with her arms quickly before placing her lips upon his. This kiss wasn’t like the others. It wasn’t hesitant or passionate. It was comforting and warm, like the very boy she was sharing it with. With a few words and his comforting presence Harry had managed to dash away her insecurities and make her feel as if she was the only girl in the world.

This is what she wanted. Not just his body, but his heart as well and now she truly felt like she had it, and he had hers.

She pulled back from their shared embrace, but not before he dipped down and placed a quick kiss upon her nose causing her to giggle. She stared into his deep green eyes, like the very forest was contained within them, and tried her best to convey her want through them.

He seemed to get her message as soon the teen positioned himself between her legs, the tip of his length teasing her wet folds.

He searched her eyes, seeking permission to continue. His answer came when she nimbly wrapped her legs around his waist, pulling him forward. His cock slid into her slowly, her juices from her first orgasm slickened the member enough to allow its entrance comfortably.

The feeling was intense.

She felt as if she would split open from the intrusion. Her eyes screwed shut from the stinging pain as her breaths grew labored. After what felt like forever, he was finally hilted inside of her. She held him there with all her might, not wishing him to move as she adjusted.

She had never felt so full in her life. She swore if she looked down now she would see his girth poking a bulge into her stomach. Her mind was addled by lightheadedness and it took a few minutes for both it and the pain to ebb away.

Finally, when it all became bearable she nodded, surprised to find a few tears had escaped her eyes. Harry simply wiped them away with the pad of her thumb while whispering sweet nothings into her ear. It was a comfort she needed, especially as he began to rock gently within her depths.

The pain returned, stinging with every small thrust yet there was an undercurrent of something else there. As his thick cock continued to push and pull out of her no longer virgin pussy, jolts of pleasure began to make themselves known. She slowly but surely overcame the stinging sensation and soon the girl felt her body relax as her walls finally accepted the intruding length.

“Faster Harry. Please!” she begged. She knew not why, only that her body craved it. The pain was gone and all she knew was that his cock was delivering her such sweet sensations. She wanted more. She needed more.

Harry answered by rocking his hips faster. While with the others he would normally take them hard and fast, pounding into their cunts relentlessly, he knew Katie needed gentleness. Plus there was something about the slow but steady plunges into her depths that was mind numbing pleasurable. She was tight sure, tighter than any of the other girls, yet it was the way her pussy grasped his cock as he worked. It was almost like tender grasps and their loins made to know each other intently.

He wondered if the girl below him felt the same, though he guessed most likely as her continued mewling and soft gasps to his grinding cock soon gave way to louder and heftier moans. He picked up the pace slightly, feeling his balls clap gently against the girls ass.

Without warning the girl pulled him close with her arms, her legs wrapping around his hips tightly as well. She cried into his ear as her walls began to spasm around him. He groaned at the feeling. Her clamping walls like a velvet vice as she came. So intensely tight yet warm and pleasurable beyond belief.

She mashed her lips against his as her orgasm ebbed away. He responded in kind, his hips beginning to rock back and forth once more. Yet the girl had other ideas.

“I’m ready Harry please. Please fuck me.” She gasped out, voice dripping with lust.

Nodding Harry sat up on to his knees, his cock pulling out slightly till just the tip remained. Grabbing her waist for support the teen swiftly plunged into her.

“FUCK!” she screamed out causing Harry to pause abruptly.

“No! Don’t you dare fucking stop Potter! KEEP! GOING!”

Harry obeyed in an instant, his cock sawing in and out of her intensely tight snatch. The blonde witch fell back boneless, her mouth spewing a continual stream of moans and pleas for him to keep going.

On he went, thrusting madly into the girl. It wasn’t the rough fucking he was used to but it still proved to be intensely satisfying. The chaser under him was a mixture of pleasure and cries and she herself fell into a heaven of pleasure. Words failed her now as her mind refused to work. Harry knew not how many times the girl reached her peak. Her slippery cunt tightened and spasmed around him constantly. His only clue was the growing puddle of her juices wetting the sheets below them. Her spasming walls were inching him closer to his own climax. He could feel it building, the pressure in his balls becoming more and more pronounced. He couldn’t hold it back even if he wanted to, the girls pussy too inviting for that. His thrusts started to become more erratic and harder. The slaps of their flesh impacting drowning out the incoherent witch’s moans. Pushing himself forward he folded her legs up to her chest This new position grinding her tight walls harder upon the sensitive underside of his cock.

With one final thrust the teen erupted into her needy cunt. His cock head unintentionally hitting her G-Spot as it passed bringing the girl to a final peak of her own.

They lay there for what felt like forever as he slowly emptied his seed into her pussy. Her walls content to lazily milk him as her own climax receded.

Finally, Harry pulled off and out of her, his cum beginning to leak out of her numb cunt.

Katie pulled herself into his side, cuddling him as she lovingly stroked his chest. She hummed contentedly as he held her.

“That was perfect.” She whispered. Harry could only groan out softly in agreement.

The teen suddenly raised his head though to meet her eyes. With a serious expression he took her hands. She grew worried for a moment, wondering what he would say.

“I‘ll tell Angelina and Alicia in the morning we’re together now. I’ll make sure they know that sex is no longer an option and that I’m loyal to you.”

Katie stared at him for a moment in confusion before her faced morphed into a smirk and she let out a loud laugh. Harry just looked on bewildered, his confused look only fueling the girls mirth. Finally her laughter dampened down to a chuckle and she patted his cheek affectionately.

“Oh love I don’t know about that, they are so looking forward to the foursome we planned.”

His stunned expression at her declaration only stood to stir up her laughter once more.

-

Authors Note

I’ve been on a kick with this story, it’s just proven to be so fun to write. This is probably my favorite chapter so far! I promise though that the next chapter for Knut For Your Thoughts will be next! I’ll most likely upload the final chapter for this fic afterwards so make sure your notifications are turned on!

Thanks for reading!