Untitled D&D Group story, Ch 30-37

Edit: Fixed grammar/spelling and uploaded files.

Sponsored by Andrew and Trav (1 of 2)

Chapter 30

“So, Rhia told me how it went,” Mel said. We were sitting at my kitchen island, coffee in hand.

“Oh, yeah?” I asked noncommittally. I was still torn as to how much I thought I should talk to Mel about the game with the girls.

"She pulled the same stunt I did," Mel smirked, taking a sip of her coffee.

I snorted and nodded. "Handy, having a hot tub. You guys had to pretend to be at a public bathhouse, just hanging around on couches naked for the first time."

Mel barked a laugh and shook her head. "I can still remember the look on your guys' faces when me, Veronica and Rachel took our tops off."

"You say that like any of us had ever thought we'd see three gorgeous women doing that at the same time," I said.

"Good point," Melissa said. "How were they? Nervous?"

"The same nerves we had, doing that play," I said. "They decided to skinny dip while still in the house, so they knew it was coming. Unlike you, getting everyone tipsy and then springing it on them at the last minute."

Mel rolled her eyes. "I didn't have the courage or the backing of anyone else beforehand," she said. "Rhiannon has a bit of a leg up in that regard. Jesus, the balls on my daughter to even be doing this. It's still hard to wrap my head around."

I chuckled, taking another sip of my drink. "Rhia isn't the only one of them pushing the limits," I admitted.

"Really?" Mel asked, an eyebrow raising as she drew out the word curiously. "What happened, a little grab ass under the water jets?"

I cleared my throat, feeling my cheeks flush, and Mel laughed at my expression. "Shane, I don't think I've ever seen you this embarrassed, even that first time we fucked."

That first time, the first time in the Game at all that two people had gone full penis-in-vagina and not oral or some dry (and not so dry) humping, had been between us. Veronica and Jack had been the first to do oral and had quickly jumped to fucking right next to us on the couch of the old student housing place me and the guys had rented back in college, but Mel and I had been the first.

"Yeah, well, having your best friend suddenly climb on your cock is a bit surprising," I said. "Particularly considering I was roleplaying as an Ogre at the time."

"An attractive, half-ogre," Mel cackled.

I rolled my eyes, grinning at the memory. Twenty years of fucking between then and now and I could still remember the adrenaline rush.

"So who did what?" Mel asked. "It had to be Elyse, right? She's a spitfire - I like her for Rhia as a friend most of the time."

"Mel," I sighed.

"Come on," she said.

I sighed again. "I thought you said Rhia told you everything?"

"Well, obviously the little twit is keeping things back," she said. "Probably giggling about paying my back for not telling her the real stories of the Game for so long."

"Let me ask you this - if she starts asking me about how certain events happened in our past campaigns, or even what happened last week between Meliana and Stellan, what would you want me to tell her?"

"You and I both know it's different, Shane," Mel said. "I'm her Mom."

"And she's your daughter," I nodded. "Who is already well aware that, during the Game, we sometimes have sex. It's not my place to give her more details, and it would be betraying her trust in me if I did the same."

Mel narrowed her eyes and got that 'scheming' look in her eye.

"Mel," I groaned.

"No, no, it's fine," she said. "I'll just need to apply more pressure where it's needed. Maybe overloading my horndog of a daughter with details is the way to go."

"Better you get it from her than me," I said.

"Just tell me this; did you fuck anyone yet?"

"No," I said. "But... they are moving faster than we did."

Mel raised her eyebrow again but didn't ask any more questions.

Chapter 31

"What's up?" I answered my phone.

"Hey," Rhia said on the other end of the line. "Are you busy?"

"Not dramatically," I said, minimizing the graphic I'd been working on for the local AAA hockey team. They wanted a refresh of their graphics for the jumbotron screen before their next season and had thankfully come to me earlier than the week before the opening game this year. "What can I do for my favourite- Well, shit, I guess it's not fair if I say 'favourite college coed' anymore, is it?"

"How about 'favourite brunette coed?'" Rhia said, and I could hear the grin on her lips. "That way Elyse can be your Blonde and Tori can be your... Well, black doesn't work. Raven? Noir? Why isn't there a term like brunette and blonde for black hair?"

"Don't ask me, darlin'," I said. "I just speak the words, I don't make 'em up." I could feel her rolling her eyes at me over the phone - she'd done a lot of growing up, but she hadn't lost that teenage tendency yet. Then again, neither had her Mother.

"Well, as your favourite brunette college coed, I just wanted to call and say that from now on you have my permission to tell my Mom about what happens in our game," Rhia said.

"Oh," I said. It was a Monday and I'd seen Mel twice for coffee since the last session, and that second time she hadn't brought it up at all. "Are you... sure about that?"

"Yeah," she said.

"I assume you traded... something, to give that away," I said.

"She... might be... telling me things," Rhia said. "Old stories."

I groaned, and she snickered a little.

"Don't believe everything you hear," I said.

"Oh, I think she's telling mostly the truth," Rhia said. "Though she'll only tell me stuff about you, her and Dad. Nothing about anyone else."

"Which brings up an important note - you can give permission all you want for stuff that involves you, and your Mom knows pretty much everything about me already except for this game so I have no true shame - but that's not permission to talk about Elyse and Tori. The fact that your Mom and Dad know about them isn't super fair to begin with, let alone divulging details."

"Fuck," Rhia sighed. "OK, yeah, that's true. Let me think about that, OK? Maybe I should get permission from Mom to tell them."

"Whatever happens, you'll need to tell them everything," I warned her. "Including that you'd been hoping for this from the start."

There was a long pause on the other end of the phone. "Fuck," she finally said.

"Welcome to the real world, Rhia," I said. "Where secrets can hurt the ones we love."

"I'll figure it out," she promised.

Chapter 32

The girls came in like a whirlwind again. It was becoming their routine.

Elyse was first through the door, knapsack on her back and Tupperware in hand. She set the container down quickly on the table I kept my keys, not stopping her movement, and came right to me. The summer months were starting to get even hotter so it wasn't surprising that she was wearing a loose crop top and a pair of cute little daisy dukes. She swept her sunglasses up to the top of her head and raised her arms to pull me down into a kiss as she said, "Hey, Shaney."

The kiss hello was hot and heavy, her tongue pressing between my lips almost immediately. My hands went to her bare waist immediately, my thumbs landing on the soft feel of her ribs and tempted to travel up under her shirt. I managed to resist that urge and just kissed her back - she ended it by using the same trick that I'd used on her last week, tugging on my bottom lip with her teeth as she pulled away.

"Hello, gorgeous," I said a little breathlessly.

It was a simple compliment, really, but it made her grin broadly and I was reminded that while I'd gotten used to (and wonderfully enamoured by) her quirky, slightly tomboy prettiness she was often surrounded by girls like Rhia and Tori in the theatre program.

She bit her lip cutely, looking into my eyes with her grey orbs, and then gave me an extra little peck on the lips before slipping away to grab the container she'd set down and heading to the kitchen. Rhia was already following her into the house, burdened the same way with a backpack and container, though she was wearing a summer dress.

"Hi, Shane," she said as she strode up, leaning in and kissing me hello with slightly less immediate, upfront lust but just as much passion. Her free hand found one of mine and led it up to the side of her breast, encouraging me to grab a feel, but Tori's footsteps on the front porch behind her seemed to spook her a little and my palm only grazed her before she was letting go and pulling away, blushing. That one little touch revealed she was braless under the dress - a bold move for a woman so endowed as her.

"Hello, Rhia," I said with a smile, catching her hand again and pulling her into a full-bodied hug. This pressed her braless tits to my chest and she laughed, knowing what I was doing and hugged me back.

"Get that shit in the fridge," Tori urged Rhia, giving her a smack on the butt. "It's already been out for too long."

"Sorry, sorry," Rhia said, stepping out of my arms and heading for the kitchen after Elyse and making way for the Indian girl.

"Hi, Tori," I said with a warm grin.

"Oh, please," she said. "Don't just 'hi' me." She crooked a finger, summoning me close to kiss her. As I did she hooked two fingers in the front of my shorts, tugging me closer still, and kissed me with a simmering heat. I groaned a little into the kiss, and she slid her hand from my waistband up my shirt, across my stomach. "I can still hardly believe all that happened last week," she murmured against my lips.

I pulled back gently. "Any regrets?" I asked her quietly.

She shook her head. "No, it just felt like a dream. A really, really good one." The stunning girl then broke into the kind of smile that would make casting directors swoon. "Best session of D&D I've ever played, and I'm hoping this week is even better."

"I always strive to provide," I said, and then pulled an Elyse and leaned in for an extra peck. "What did you bake this week?"

"Muffins," she said as we parted. "Chocolate chip and banana, because raisins are a lie and bran is of the devil."

I laughed and pulled her into a hug. "You are my kind of girl."

She dropped off the container of muffins and headed back to the others to get dressed up in her character costume, and I headed back into the game room where I'd been prepping before they arrived.

All three of the girls returned together, dressed up. Rhia hadn't changed anything about her costume - she was waiting to get a new piece of armour to do any more work, likely starting with a breastplate - but Tori had designed a new top that had a similar look of being a binding across her chest, but there was a zipper under on arm instead of it needing to literally be untied for her to take it off.

"Like it?" Elyse asked as she swept in last, her silk robe swirling as she gave a little spin. The embroidery work now circled the entire lower half and crawled up the sides and back like creeping tendrils. Combined with the exotic jewellery she used to accent the costume - the finger-claws, the nose-to-ear chain and the other dangling bits and bobs, she looked like she could have stepped out of a video game.

"Holy shit," I said. "That's - wow, Elyse. How long did that take?"

"I've got time," she chuckled. "Maybe twenty hours, since last week, to finish it off? I work on it while we're watching shows and stuff." Then she winked and pulled the top part aside, flashing her little tits as she stuck out her tongue - except her one nipple that was pierced now had a thin chain running from it, across her chest in a little dainty arc, to the other nipple where it was attached with a nipple clamp.

I almost choked and had to clear my throat. Tori snickered, likely having already known the plan, and Rhia gasped and then laughed at my reaction.

"Alright, Little Miss Shadow-Temptress," I said. "Put those deadly weapons away and take a seat. We need to follow up on our talk from last week."

She covered up, grinning impishly with her dimples showing, and all three of the ladies dug into their backpacks to bring out their game stuff, and extra papers.

The first thing we did was trade printouts of our STD tests. Blessedly, everyone was clean.

"Before we talk about the other stuff, there's a follow-on for this," I said, tapping the stack of papers once we'd all had a chance to confirm. "I told you ladies last week, but I do have other partners, and they take this as seriously as I do. I'm not expecting there to be any... 'growth' of the partner web on my end, but I know you girls are in college, and I'm not expecting you to limit yourselves from other 'companionship-'"

"Yeah, the boys I might have been interested in either had to leave for the summer or turned out to be flakes," Rhia interrupted me. "I'm not looking to hook up with some guy I just met at work or something."

"Me neither," Tori agreed. "I'm picky. Hell, I might as well be demisexual - I don't even like kissing guys that I don't feel like I have an emotional connection with."

That spun off a series of thoughts I didn't have the time to examine at the moment. She was kissing me, and this was only the fourth time we were meeting. How, or why, or when did...?

"That's not gonna be easy. He's a hunter," Elyse smirked a little, gesturing down at her crotch.

"You call it a dude?" Rhia said, and then all three of them started laughing as I grinned and shook my head.

"It's from-" Elyse started.

"Pitch Perfect, I know," I chuckled. "Good movie."

"Marry me," Tori said. "A guy who likes Pitch Perfect unironically? You're a fucking catch, Shane."

"Might be a little early for marriage, Tori," I winked at her.

"I'm not actually looking for anything outside of this room," Elyse clarified her position. "Or, well, this house."

I nodded, but again made a mental note for later.

"Alright. Well, if that changes for any of you, then we need to be clear on boundaries - and that means honesty. If you hook up with someone not in this group you don't need to tell us who it is, but you do need to tell us it happened, and you'll need to do another test before we do anything sexual again - the game doesn't have to stop, just participation in anything... naughty."

Rhia snorted at the word, and Tori grinned a little and covered her mouth with one hand. Elyse just laughed. "Naughty? Really?"

"I was fishing for a good word to say it," I waved them off. "Anyone have questions or concerns about that?"

None of them did, and they all agreed to the plan. Then we presented our Consent lists to each other.

Chapter 33 - Shane’s Consent List for the Girls

I'd typed my list out, making edits for each of the girls to be a little more specifically addressed to each of them, but they all followed the same format and had the same content.

Dear Tori,

I'm still a little amazed that we're going through this process, so I apologize if this might be a little long-winded. You, Rhia and Elyse are three very wonderful young women that I already felt blessed to get to play a game I love with - now I'm finding that the blessings are multiplying like crazy! I value you as a friend already, so please know that I will never hold any hesitation, reluctance or refusal against you. Your wit, charm and intelligence have added to my life, and I would much rather hold onto that than sacrifice it for a moment of carnal pleasure.

When it comes to sexual consent, I will not hide that I am fairly experienced. I am open to trying most things once if I haven't happened to try it before, and am open to roleplaying most potential scenarios - if there are any specific fantasies you think would be hot to try in a safe group like ours, please let me know! My goal is entirely to give you and the others the fun that you are looking for.

Things I will not do:

- Water/Scat

- Anything with an actual animal

- Nothing with honey (I will tell the story behind this when appropriate)

- Nothing in or around my asshole

- No dildos/vibrators/other phallic sex toys in my mouth

- No roleplaying a male/male scenario

Things that I promise to do:

- Always make sure you are consenting in the moment to an act

- Checking in, verbally and with eye contact, during any acts

- Focus on your experience over my own

- Follow up after any acts, both informationally and with aftercare

I look forward to continuing to play the game with you, no matter where it takes us.

Your DM,

Shane.

Chapter 34 - Rhia’s Consent List for Shane

Rhia had hand-written her list for me, which made sense considering its length.

Hey,

I'm down to try anything with you and the girls. I trust you implicitly.

Love,

Rhia

PS - OK, I've never done butt stuff, so I'm kinda nervous about that. Give me some warning if that's something you want because, like, I'm down to try it but I want to prepare myself first. XOXO

Chapter 35 - Tori’s Consent Letter for Shane

Tori had typed her list out like I had, and I could tell she'd written a different letter to each of us based on the amount of text on the sheets she handed around, though I didn't get a look at the girl's ones.

Hi,

So, last week was crazy, and even the week before was way out of my usual comfort zone. But I had a BLAST. You are an amazing Dungeon Master, Shane. You could be running one of those live shows people stream online.

The thing is, I'm really slow to decide I like someone usually. It takes me months to decide if I even have a crush or not. But with you, I don't know - maybe it's because of Rhia, but I just trust you. And I find you attractive. And flashing you, and getting naked with you, and OMG doing that thing with my foot?

Most fun I've ever had in a sexual situation. Seriously.

I'm open to sex with you as part of the game. God, that's weird to write down like that. Oral and vaginal. (Ew, that sounds clinical.) And roleplaying sex scenes sounds really fucking fun.

If possible, I would like to be the one to be the aggressor. I trust you, but I'm used to waiting for someone to ask me out, and I want to change that. I want to take control of me, if that makes sense.

Watching you and Elyse last week also made me think of the fact that we could be doing stuff in front of each other. I obviously liked the voyeur stuff, and I'm open to exhibitionism as well. At least in our little group.

And I'm open to experimenting with Rhia and Elyse. I'm telling them that in their letters. Just... give me time to make the moves, OK?

Thank you so much.

- T

Chapter 36 - Elyse’s Consent Letter for Shane

Elyse had handwritten her letter on lined paper, sliding it over to you with a bit of a blush before handing over two more to the others.

Fuck me up, Daddy.

OK, seriously, this is my fourth time starting this and my palms are sweaty and shit, but that's how I decided to start it.

You are super fucking hot, Shane. Like, ideal man in my books. I've always had a thing for older guys but never went for it, and for real I find you so fucking attractive. Not just your physicality either. Your charisma gives me butterflies, and the way you look and listen to me just talking about whatever gets me fucking wet.

I'm not trying to say I love you or anything, OK? But even if we weren't doing this whole consent thing I would be finding a way to stay back some night after the game and seeing if you wanted to fuck.

And seriously, I'm not a slut or anything. I've only been with two guys before (and one girl :P). Both of the guys were blegh, but I put up with it because I wanted to feel pretty and have a boyfriend. You make me feel pretty without even trying.

I want you to take me to pound town. And yes, I know that sounds silly, but... I've never had a guy satisfy that itch for me. I want rough sex. Like R.O.U.G.H. When you grabbed my hair while I was blowing you, how the fuck did you read my mind? I want you to throw me around the bed, or table, or floor. Wherever. Bend me over the kitchen table. Maul me with those big hands. Squeeze me. Just stick to spanking my ass, I'm not looking to get slapped around. Pull my hair though! Choke me! I'll come so fucking hard, I swear. Just masturbating to the idea gets me off so good, having you do it? Mind will be blown.

OK, maybe that's all a bit much, I just think you can handle it I guess. But I'm too far in now and don't want to start over again. Maybe a list will help:

- Oral: Yes. Fuck my mouth like before. Skullfuck me. If I can deepthroat you by the end of the summer I'd fucking cream myself.

- Vaginal: Like I said, fuck me up, Daddy. Pound town. Any position you want. Hell, every position.

- Anal: I'm an anal virgin. Circle back around on this - I'm scared of the fact that I want to say take it. Maybe I'll bring it up after the first couple of times we fuck normally. I know I like playing with it when I'm thinking about you slamming me.

- Roleplaying: Don't fucking look at me when you read this, I'll die a bit - I'm into monster porn. Like, werewolves and demons and godzilla and Sasquatch and stuff. I'm a freak, OK? So fuck me with tentacles, fuck me with monster cock, whatever. And we can do non-con stuff if you're into it - blackmail Renee. Or mind control her. God, if some big monster demands sexual tribute? I'm your girl.

- Finishing: Don't look at me again, because I've never told anyone this, even Tori - Creampie me. I've got a breeding kink. I promise to God and everything good that I take the pill religiously; I might even want to be child-free my whole life. But the idea of getting knocked up makes me come really, really hard. Oh, and just FYI, I've never let a guy actually do it to me before, so you'd be my first!

- Other kinky stuff: I'd be willing to try anything you want to, but I don't want to ever see you, like, not being the badass MAN I see you as. So please don't be a guy who likes to wear diapers or something - if you are, I'm sorry, but just keep it away from me. But tying me up? Or making me submit? I've never done BDSM before but I've watched, like, a lot of porn.

- Girl/Girl stuff:  Like I said, I've done it before. I already talked to Tori, we're good. I'm explaining to Rhia that I'm open to whatever she is. Order me under the table and I'll tongue them all fucking night - or, well, don't because I want to play the game, but you get it.

Alright, I'm already writing on the back of the paper now so I'm probably rambling. Hopefully someone else writes as much as I do - oh, who am I kidding, there's no way.

Look, Shane, I might not have ever played D&D before, but this is the BEST THING. Ever. I already don't want it to stop at the end of the summer.

So yeah. Fuck me up, Daddy.

Elyse. AKA Renee de l'Ombre. Shadow Slut-ceress.

PS - OK but for real I keep thinking about you in my ass now, so like, probably gonna happen.

Chapter 37

I cleared my throat, trying not to look up from the sheet of paper as I set it down and carefully folded it. I'd known I was probably going to get turned on, reading the consent letters, and had been prepared for most things. I had not been prepared for Elyse's detailed admission.

My face was a little red. I could feel it.

I glanced up at Rhia first - she was the one who had set all this in motion, she should be ready for it.

Rhia was blushing too.

So was Tori.

I finally looked at Elyse and she was blushing extra hard.

"Alright," I said. "Everyone finished?" They mumbled their replies, their nods telling me more than their words. "OK. Ladies, I know that was personal. Vulnerable. I appreciate the time each of you took on what you communicated to me, and I hope mine was clear and helped settle some nerves. Since I'm the person with the most, ah, 'control' in the situation, did anyone have any questions for me about what I gave you?"

"Nope," Rhia said. Tori shook her head. Elyse blushed just a little more, turning a cute pink colour, and swallowed.

"Then I think, before we jump back into the game, I want to do this." I stood up and went around the side of the table to Elyse, offering my hand. She took it and looked up at me like she thought I was going to act on what she'd written immediately, and was both terrified and delighted. Maybe a little more towards terrified. Instead, I pulled her to her feet and wrapped her up in a bear hug, and she quickly hugged me back.

"Thank you for trusting me," I said quietly.

"I can't believe I wrote all that," she mumbled into my chest.

I pulled her back by her shoulders lightly and cupped her face in my hands, wiping her cheeks with my thumbs. "Thank you," I said again. Then I kissed her on the forehead. She crashed into me for another hug, then let me go.

Tori was next and she stood up as I circled around to her, slipping into my arms easily. Her note had maybe been the most surprising, or vulnerable, even if it hadn't been the most graphic. Elyse had told me about her wants, but Tori had admitted to a major vulnerability she had. I held her softly, rather than the crushing hug I'd given her roommate. "Thank you for trusting me, Tori," I said.

"Thank you for being trustworthy," she replied before letting me go and smiling softly.

Rhia was last, and she was still blushing. "I guess maybe I could have written more," she said as I took her into my arms. I cradled her head to my chest, silently saying goodbye to the kid I'd known and hello to the woman before me. Kissing was one thing. Even nudity. Blurry lines compared to the one we were approaching. I shifted, hugging her more fully as I accepted that, and she tightened her grip on me.

"It was all that you needed to say," I said. "Thanks for trusting me, Rhiannon."

"Love you, Shane," she replied.

"Alright," I said as we parted and I headed back to my chair, settling in. I let out a long breath, then tidied up the letters they'd given me and carefully put them into a pocket of my DM binder for the game. Depending on how things went, those letters might be important artefacts for me in the future. "Where did we leave off?"

"We were heading back from the hot springs," Rhia said, using Olivia's voice. "Back into a camp sprawling with bandits, murderers and thieves."

"And being run by a guy who is definitely a werewolf or something," Tori said as Jade.

"And has some god-hating magicians who already don't like us," Elyse tacked on as Renee.

"Well then," I said. "I guess you three heroines have a lot to do."