The College Girl Next Door 5 - Finale

When I asked Eva how she had gotten the girls to come over she answered: “Easy. I just told them since we had been getting so friendly after going to the gym I wanted to get to know them better. So I invited them over for dinner with the two of us.

You should have seen the looks on their faces when I mentioned your name. Like deer caught in headlights. I’m sure they thought they had played it off well, but I could almost physically feel their apprehension. I don’t think they know I know. You wouldn’t mind keeping up the charade a little longer, would you?

Oh, and wear that green shirt. It brings out your eyes.”

My redheaded girlfriend had already changed to a different topic, thinking the conversation was over. And to be honest, there wasn’t that much more to say. In a few minutes the college girls next door would be standing on my doorstep to have a nice meal. Eva had let slip little hints and giggles that she had planned something more than just food, drink and conversation, but try as I might, she wouldn’t divulge her secrets. While I still was curious, part of it was also fine by me. Whatever surprise she had planned, I was sure that it would be something I would enjoy very much. We were both getting dressed after a shower session that had included a lot of groping and stroking, but no cumming, Eva had been clear about that. I couldn’t help but steal some glances at Eva. As I glanced I just saw her beatiful pert C-cups get hidden by a lacy black bra. And when I say hidden I was generous in the usage of the word. The lace covered her breasts, while hiding almost nothing. Leaving just a few tantalising details to the imagination. She turned around and I was greeted by the matching G-string. The black fabric did nothing to cover her shapely ass and still it accented it well. The lacy front covered a bit more than the bra did, showing small glimpses of pale flesh. Eva had found what she was looking for and I saw her pull on a tight black dress. Her shoulders were covered, but a plunging neckline made sure to show off her cleavage. I knew the dress well. Whenever we went out, and Eva dressed in this dress she expected to get fucked as soon as we came home. The hem of the tight-fitting garment fell halfway to her thighs. To complete the look of the alluring femme fatale she sat down and put on her silk stockings. The transparent black fabric covering her long legs, ending just a little above the hemline of her dress. “You approve?”

“I very much approve!” I answered.

“Now get dressed, I’m gonna do my make-up. The girls will be here any minute.”

Compared to what Eva was doing, dressing was easy as a man. I just put on a pair of boxer briefs with a fancy print, put on socks, pulled on my jeans and threw on the green shirt that Eva had indicated. Easy, but for some reason still appealing to my girlfriend as I saw her give me her signature look of approval through her reflection in the bathroom mirror. I made my way down the stairs while she was still doing who-knows-what with brushes, pliers, tools and swashes. Most of the food was finished and was kept warm in the oven until it was time for dinner. I just had to cook the steaks, but I would do that when the girls were here. Normally I would’ve been busy with all the food, but Eva had stressed that I was to be an integral part of the conversation, instead of hiding in the kitchen with a glass of wine or beer. To kill the time I once again checked on the steaks that were getting up to temperature on the counter. Checked if the drinks were cooled, if we had enough silverware, etcetera etcetera. I was feeling nervous, but I had no reason to be nervous. Eva and I had more than cleared the air, and I knew Emily and Hailey. Then why was I acting like a guy going on his first date? Because this is a date an insidious voice in my head said. I had no idea what Eva had planned, but she had hinted enough that she had a plan. I was just another pawn in this devilish woman’s machinations. Not that I minded.

The bell rang just when I started checking everything for a third time. I pressed my shirt, checked my hair in the hallway mirror and opened the door. “Heya Neighbour!” Emily said.

I couldn’t help but tease her: “Heya film star.” My remark had hit the mark. I could see a blush creep up from the normally quite unflappable brunette. Her cheeks went red as she stepped over the threshold.

“Hey Sam.”

“Hi Hailey.” For some reason whenever Hailey and I met the first moments always were a little awkward. Like we both didn’t know what to say or how to act.

Luckily Emily was there to break our awkwardness. Recovered from her embarrassment she looked around the hallway. “So, which way do we go? This way? Or right upstairs?” Now it was my time to blush. Even though I would have loved to take them both upstairs, Eva had a plan. I swallowed my remark and pointed to the living room.

“Can I just say you both look beautiful?” They did. It looked like they had coordinated. Both were wearing pleated skirts. Hailey a black one, Emily somewhere between yellow and beige. On top of that Emily wore a tight black sleeveless turtleneck shirt. The black fabric conforming to all the right curves in her body. I don’t think I ever told her, but a good, tight, black turtleneck was one of my many weaknesses. Hailey wore a white blouse, the part between the top of her breasts and her shoulders tantalisingly sheer.

“You like this?” Emily twirled around, making sure that her skirt flew up a bit to give me a good look at her beautiful thighs.

“Thanks,” Hailey said with a shy smile.

“Would you like something to drink? I have red and white wine, some blonde beers, soda, we might even be able to make neon-green sweet and sour cocktails.” I said, referring to the disgusting drink we had tried to drink in the hot tub. I saw both girls grimace at the mention of the drink.

“I’ll take the wine if you don’t mind.” Hailey answered.

“Me too.”

“Me three,” I heard from behind me. I turned around to see my redheaded girlfriend. She had put up her hair in some kind of fancy bun, her make-up highlighting her green eyes. Bright red lipstick finished the look. Coupled with her tight black dress she had all the makings of a femme fatale. Eva welcomed the girls while I busied myself with the wine. I returned with four glasses of wine to see the three girls sit on the sofa. It was like watching cats. They all tried to nonchalantly not pay too much attention to each other while they studied each and every tiny move.

“Since you all already know each other from the gym, I’ll make myself scarce and finish preparing our food.” I said as I turned to take my glass with me to the kitchen. I wouldn’t call myself anything close to resembling a chef, but I did like to cook whenever I could spend time on it. Today the meal was quite easy, peppers stuffed with a mixture of cheese, scallion and tomato, sweet potato fries and steaks. The peppers and fries were already waiting in the oven, the only thing left was the steaks. The steaks had been marinating on the counter. I warmed up two pans, put a good chunk of butter in each and lowered the steaks down as soon as the butter had reached the right temperature. The steaks immediately started sizzling, the heat of the pan searing the outside. After a few minutes I started to turn the steaks.

“Need some help?” I felt a hand on my lower back, the mouth close to my ear caressing the small hairs and making the hair in my neck stand up.

“No I’m alr..”, the hand pinched my butt. “Ow, fuck!”. The steak splashed back into the pan, sending droplets of grease my way and burning my hand.

“Oh no, what did I do?” The voice had turned out to be my brunette neighbour.

“Not your fault. Your pinch startled me and the butter hit my hands.”

“You need to cool the wound before it turns into a real burn. Here, I’ll turn the steaks while you cool your hands.” Emily grabbed the tongs from my hand and bumped me aside with a sway of her hips.

I put my hands under the running water in the sink. First rinsing off the grease, then cooling a spot on the back of my hand that had caught a large glob of the stuff.

“How much longer do the steaks need on this side?”

“A minute or two. Then put them in the aluminium foil that’s waiting on the counter to let them rest a bit.”

While I was cooling my hands I saw Emily busy herself with finishing the steaks. Normally I would have wanted to do that myself, if anybody was gonna fuck up the steaks, it was me. It looked like Emily knew what she was doing though. Deftly she took the meat from the pan and wrapped it in the foil.

“What are you doing here any way? I thought Eva was keeping the two of you out of my kitchen,” the last part I said with half a grin, indicating that I meant it as a wry joke.

“I asked where the toilet was, and she pointed me this way. And then I saw you and wanted to at least have a little fun.”

“Aha, and getting me to burn my hands is what you think of as fun.”

“Not really, let me make it up to you.” Finished with the steaks she dropped below the counter, hidden from the view if Eva or Hailey were to look our way. It didn’t take long before I felt her hands on the front of my pants, caressing my crotch. As for me, my body reacted immediately. I had been pent up the whole day. Eva had done her best to get me as horny as possible, without actually getting me off. She had started the day with a blowjob, stopping just before I had finished. She had kept touching me through my pants, found ways to show off her beautiful body to me and had whispered all kinds of naughty thoughts about our neighbours in my ears. While I was taking a shower she had joined me, stroking my dick until it was painfully hard and then leaving me to the water of the shower.

“I can feel you’ve missed me. You did miss me, didn’t you, Sam?” She looked up at me with her big beautiful blue eyes, fluttering her eyelashes innocently.

“Of course I missed you. How could I not?”

Her hand unbuttoned my pants, lowered the zipper until only my boxer was hiding my dick. She pulled down the fabric. Caressed me with her soft hands. Then she engulfed my dick in her wet mouth. I already felt like I was ready to burst. The pent up horniness of the day, the idea that Emily was giving me a sneaky blowjob while my girlfriend could walk in any moment. “Go slow,” I warned her, “I missed you so much, I’m already ready to cum.” In response Emily’s hand closed around my dick. She started to jerk me while her tongue worked it’s magic on my head. It seemed like slow wasn’t in the cards for today. I had to stifle a moan. Emily had many talents, and giving blowjobs surely was one of them. The sneakiness of the blowjob must have given me enhanced senses, over the sound of running water I heard the sound of Eva’s heels.

I pulled Emily up, “Someone’s coming.” Quickly the brunette made her way to the door at the back of the kitchen. The one actually leading to a small hall and the toilet. Just as quickly I did up my pants, just in time to see Eva round the corner. She caught the last of my move. A smirk appeared on her face. She stepped close to me, tilting her head up to kiss me, as her hand found my hard cock. “Started the fun already?” she breathed in my ear, still caressing my sensitive dick over the outside of my pants.

“Emily felt bad for startling me.”

“Sure, that must have been the only reason.” There was no fooling this woman. Just as she was about to say something more, Emily reappeared. I saw a quick flush of embarrassment creep across her face as she saw Eva in the kitchen. Then the bold college girl was back. “So, steaks ready yet?”

I plated the meal and gave Emily a new bottle of wine to refill everybody’s glasses. When I put the plates on the table I saw that she had taken her assignment to heart. She had divided the bottle over the four glasses, giving us a royal drink of wine to go with the meal. As I joined the three girls at the table, I noticed that the conversation died down. Hailey and Emily were exchanging shy glances, pointedly trying not to look at me or Eva too much. As the silence started to become uncomfortable Hailey commented: “Wow, these steaks are really good.”

“Yeah, so are the peppers,” Emily added, “What did you stuff them with?” I had the feeling she emphasised the word stuff, trying to catch my eyes.

Emily was sat next to me, Hailey on the opposite site from me, and Eva next to her.

“What did you put in the peppers?” The blonde asked.

I was just about to reply when Eva interrupted me. “You know Sam, he’s good at stuffing. Just when I think it couldn’t fit, he just keeps going. He always leave me very satisfied.” She wriggled her eyebrows at me. If she was trying to be subtle, she wasn’t. “With food, I mean of course.”

“Of course,” Emily agreed. I stifled a cough. While agreeing, Emily’s hand had dipped below the table and found the front of my jeans again. I took a sip of wine to hide my quickly reddening face.

“But now we still don’t know how Sam stuffs them.” Hailey added. Just when I thought she was the innocent one, she started to fan the flames.

My head turned red as I almost choked on my wine. I did my best to swallow the mouthful of liquid. Still coughing a bit, I managed to utter “Cheese, the ingredients are cheese, scallions and tomatoes.”

“Awww, I think we’ve teased him a little too much.” It seemed that Eva had pity on me. Still, the stupid teasing had broken the ice a little bit, and soon after we actually managed to have a kind of grown up conversation without too many double entendres. That wasn’t to say there weren’t any double meanings in the conversation, but at least now I wasn’t the only target. I even managed to lightly get some naughty remarks in with all three girls. I didn’t have anything to complain about the amount of attention I was getting. While Emily had quickly removed her hand from my pants as I almost suffocated on a mouthful of wine, during the meal her hand found it’s way back on multiple occasions. Massaging my dick until it was stiff, and then leaving it alone again. And when it wasn’t Emily touching me inappropriately (though very welcome), it was Hailey trailing her foot along my leg up to my crotch. I could feel that some time during the meal she had taken off her shoes. And of course Eva also joined in. Her feet finding mine. She tried to find as many opportunities as possible to bend over the table and give Emily and me an eyeful of her beautiful cleavage. All in all this caused me to not be the most active participant in the conversation. But the three girls held their own, I just made sure to smile and nod at the right time.

Eva’s foot had found my crotch. She caught my eye and wiggled her eyebrows in pleasant surprise when she felt that I was already hard before her foot even started massaging my dick. For a few moments she stroked along my shaft with her feet. “Honey, can you grab some more wine? All our glasses are almost empty.” She said with a mischievous grin. So that was the plan. Embarrass Sam.

“Ehm…,” I started. I’m such a good conversationalist. So good at coming up with excuses.

“Ooh, yeah, I’d like some more,” Emily chimed in. Hailey nodded in agreement.

“You’ll do that for us? Won’t you?” Eva added, while her foot kept caressing my cock that was straining to escape through my pants. Well, no sense in protecting my modesty. The girls had copped a feel this night. And they all knew how my dick looked, tasted and felt. I stood up from the table, not trying to hide my hard-on.

“Don’t look too hard,” Hailey chimed. Really, it’s always the silent ones…

I came back with another bottle of red wine, filled all our glasses, and made sure to top off Eva’s a little more than the rest. My little act of revenge. We finished the meal, and since I had cooked the meal, Eva cleared away the plates. Emily, Hailey and me were left at the table. As soon as Eva had left the room Emily leaned over to me and softly said: “Give me your hand.” Happily I obliged. As the took my left hand, I once again felt Hailey’s foot try to find it’s way to my dick. She was just as bad as Emily, maybe even worse.

“Wanna know a secret?” Emily whispered as she slid my hand under her skirt, “I forgot my panties.” She slid my had up her leg to her wet pussy. “Feel how wet just fantasising about your cock already made me.”

I must have show something on my face as I touched Emily’s wet slit, because Hailey gave me a conspiratorial look of recognition. Almost immediately her foot was back on my crotch. I slipped a finger between Emily’s lips. Her cute face twitched as my fingers caressed her sensitive spot. I decided that for all the teasing Emily had done, I’d pay her back. Making sure to put just my middle finger between her lips, I started to caress her wet pussy with the lightest touch. The college girl started to squirm in her seat. Willing me to touch her. This only encouraged me to keep teasing her even more. My index finger and my ring finger stroked the sensitive flesh next to her lips. Touching her without caressing her pussy. Hailey must have known what we were doing. Emily’s face had started to flush red. Her lips pressed together to stifle any wayward moans. I pressed my middle finger a little deeper between her lips. As my finger moved up towards her clit I moved out from between her lips bit by bit. Until my finger was freed from between her lips just when I was about to caress the brunette’s clit. Once again I put my finger between her lips and started to stroke upward. Once again I stopped touching her before I reached her clit. She thrusted her hips towards my fingers in a move of frustration. For the third time my middle finger found it’s way between Emily’s lips.

“So, who’s up for some dessert?” Startled I pushed my finger all the way into Emily’s pussy. The brunette stifled a moan as Hailey quickly removed her foot from my pants. Eva stood at the door to the dining room, holding a plate with ice cream and chocolate pudding. A tiny smirk on her face showed me she knew exactly what we had been up to while she was in the kitchen. As subtly as I could I removed my finger from Emily’s pussy. I was under no illusion that Eva nor Hailey didn’t know what I was doing, but both didn’t remark anything. We were still in the naughty-hidey phase. I have no idea what the dessert tasted like, I know I had a bit of both, as the conversation continued around me. We finished dessert, sadly without too much extra teasing. For the first time in quite a while my dick had a little time to shrink down to it’s usual size. I cleared the table, and when I came back, I saw that the girls had moved to the living room. Another bottle of wine stood opened on the table. Hailey and Emily had both taken a side of the couch, while Eva was sitting in the only chair. For a second I contemplated getting a chair from the dining room, but then I thought, ‘Fuck it, it’s my living room too,’ and scooched in between the two college girls onto the couch. We were all very prim and proper, making sure that no body parts were touching.

As I sat down Eva turned to the couch. “So, you’ve been fucking my boyfriend,” she said with a stern voice. Even I thought I was in trouble.

You could hear a needle drop in the silence that followed. A red blush started to creep over both girls’ faces. Emily opened her mouth, once, twice, but no sound came out. Hailey just hid her face in her hands.

Eva continued a little more subdued. “I’m not mad. I’m just disappointed that nobody told me. Or at least filmed it.” At that last sentence she pointedly looked at Emily. The girls were still silent under this stern treatment.

“So I think there is only one way you can make this up to me. I want to watch you as you fuck Sam.”

I could almost feel the whiplash in emotions that the girls must have felt. They were expecting some kind of fight, anger or confrontation. But instead this woman wanted them to do what they wanted to do all along. Emily was the first to find her voice, “Wait, What?”

“I want to watch,” my beautiful redheaded girlfriend said, “I want to see your nude bodies get hammered by Sam’s dick.”

“What, here?” Hailey had found her voice too.

“Let’s start here. Who knows where we’ll end up.” Eva answered. As for me, I was satisfied in staying silent. A little sliver of doubt crept into me. Wasn’t Eva being too forceful? She might scare the college girls away.

“Well, what are you waiting for?” For a little moment the three of us on the couch were confused. I guess we were all waiting for one of the others to make a move. Or at least, a more explicit move than just a little teasing hidden below a table. The silence stretched. Normally this was when I would have made a move, but the way Eva stared at us dampened my courage. As for the girls, they were sitting the most prim and proper that they had been the whole evening. Hands in their laps, sitting up straight, eyes to the front.

“I guess I’ll have to get you started.” Eva stood up from her comfortable chair. Stepped over towards us and bowed to me. She took my head in her hands and planted her lips on mine. Her right hand travelled down to my pants. Deftly she undid my button and lowered my zipper. Squeezing my soft cock. She hummed disappointed. I would have liked to say that she found me already with a raging hard-on, but the surreal situation had me a little distracted. It would take a little while for blood to reach my dick again. It seemed like Eva was planning exactly the kind of demonstration that would bring the blood back.

Eva moved over to Hailey. Stroked the blonde’s hair. Put her hand under her chin to lift it up. Sweetly she placed a small kiss on her lips. I saw Hailey’s humble breast heave as she sharply inhaled. She opened her lips slightly for my girlfriend. Eva returned, this time kissing Hailey full of enthusiasm. Their lips locked. Hailey’s hands behind Eva’s head, pulling the redhead towards her. From my position I could only watch as the girls were absorbed into each other. Eva’s hands travelled Hailey’s body. She found the buttons on the blonde’s white blouse. Deftly she opened the blouse, her hand pausing each time to caress the skin revealed when button after button made way to her hands. She broke the kiss to admire her handiwork. Unsatisfied with the amount of exposed skin she took both sides of the blouse in her hands and opened it up further. Hailey was surprised by the move, and in her surprise she pushed her chest out further. Doing so revealed her lacy white bra to us. The nearly translucent garment cupped the blonde’s tits nicely, making sure their perkiness showed even more prominently. It didn’t do that much in hiding her nipples. I could clearly see her areola, her stiff nipples poked through the fabric.

Satisfied with her effect, Eva moved over to Emily. Emily had seen how my girlfriend had treated Hailey and me, and was waiting in anticipation. As soon as Eva closed in on her, Emily answered the kiss with enough passion of her own. Her hands found Eva’s shoulders and she pulled my girlfriend towards her. Eva made a happy, surprised, noise before her lips found Emily’s plump lips waiting for her. Eva fell into the kiss, almost surrendering the initiative to Emily. Then she found herself again. While kissing the brunette her hands roamed the college girl’s body. Her hands caressing the bare arms, roaming over the black turtleneck, until they found their target. Gauging from the moans coming from Emily, Eva had found her target. Pinching the brunette’s nipples through the black fabric. Emily panted as Eva broke the kiss.

“So, you think you’ve been sufficiently warmed up?” Eva padded back to her spot on the chair. Made herself comfortable, poured another glass of wine. For all intents and purposes she looked like she was settling in to watch a great movie.

I knew I was warmed up enough by Eva’s display, but something in me still kept waiting for the girls to the side of me to make the first move. What can I say? Old habits die hard. Every time before this it had been one of the two to start seducing me. This freedom to do what I wanted paralysed me. I looked over at Eva, sitting in her chair, legs crossed, holding a glass of wine. A supportive smile on her face. I guess this was really happening, I would be fucking these college girls in front of my girlfriend. It seemed like Emily was the first to break free from the awkwardness of the situation. She turned her head towards mine, her lips found mine. I could taste Eva on her lips, my girlfriend’s smell lingered on the brunette. This kiss was the kiss to break my indecision. As I was about to turn towards Emily I felt hands on my chest. A voice close to my ear stirred the little hairs next to my ears.

“If I lose my blouse, it’s only fair you lose yours too.” I glanced out of the corner of my eye. Hailey had taken off the white blouse and was now sat in her white bra next to me.

Her hands continued over my chest, unbuttoning me slowly from the top down. Emily felt my distraction and with a soft but firm move turned my head back to her. This time the kiss wasn’t a soft kiss. All of her horniness was collected in this kiss. Emily kissed with abandon, pulling me towards her. As my back was lifted from the sofa, Hailey took her opportunity to remove my blouse. Her hands reached the hem of my shirt and started pulling it up. I had to break my kiss with Emily to allow Hailey to pull the shirt over my head. Dressed in just my pants and boxers, Emily pulled me over her. Hailey quickly moved out of the way, standing up from the couch to move over to Emily. I took the opportunity to caress Emily over her tight black turtleneck. My hands following her sides, up to her ribs, towards the middle. I was pleasantly surprised when I felt no bra under the garment. It seemed like panties weren’t the only thing Emily had left at home. I used my fingers to tweak her nipples, rewarding me with a squeak of pleasure coming from Emily.

“You’re the only one still dressed. Shall we try to change that?” Hailey stage-whispered in Emily’s ear, loud enough that Eva could make out all the words. Emily moaned in agreement. Hailey found the hem of the sleeveless turtleneck and pulled the black garment up. Revealing the soft tanned skin of the brunette college girl. As her breasts were revealed I was once again taken in by their perfect form. The small pink areola and stiff nipples, accentuated by the white tan-lines. I couldn’t help myself and took one of her nipples in my mouth. Emily moaned.

“If I may make a suggestion…” Eva’s voice sounded from her corner of the living room.

“Always.” I answered.

“Emily, go sit in the middle of the couch. Sam and Hailey each to a side of you. And Sam and Hailey, give those pretty breasts the attention they deserve.”

We didn’t need to be told twice. I pulled Emily back up to a sitting position and planted her in the middle of the couch, her back against the backrest. As I was about to settle in to her left, I looked over at Hailey.

“You’re wearing too much, let me help you.” I stepped behind her. Snapping loose the white bra to reveal the blonde’s tits. Appreciatively I reached around her, cupping her soft breasts in my hands. She softly moaned. I reached over to kiss her neck. Her soft B-cups in my hands. I felt that she appreciated the attention, slowly I could feel her nipples getting harder. I let my massaging hands wander, took her left nipple between my fingers. As I pinched she pushed her ass into me. Even though her skirt and my boxer separated us I could feel the softness of her cheeks press on my rapidly hardening cock. I pulled her into me. She turned her head to kiss me. For a little while we grinded into each other until I heard Emily clear her throat.

“It seems like someone is getting impatient,” I murmured.

“Good, let her,” Hailey said as she pushed herself harder into me. Grinding on my cock with her ass. For about a minute the blonde was grinding up to me, while we kissed and I massaged her breasts. Finally I reluctantly let go of her soft flesh. I knew this was only the warm-up, but part of me wanted to just bend Hailey over the couch then and there.

We both dropped to our knees in front of the couch. Each on a side of Emily. Almost like we had rehearsed it we both started kissing her, starting at her knees, our hands caressing the supple skin of her thighs as we kissed her further up. My hands we caressing both the inside and outside of her leg, my mouth making a trail of kisses up to the hem of her skirt. Out of the corner of my eye I looked at Hailey. Flashed her a quick grin in between kisses. As we both reached the hem of her skirt once again we operated in sync. We passed over the cloth to the hem on the other side. Hands sliding up her stomach, kisses following the outline of her abs. Slowly we moved up. I could feel Emily pant under the synchronised attention. Bit by bit we closed in on her breasts. It seemed both Hailey and I had decided to ignore the soft flesh with our hands, instead being satisfied to stroke her tummy, her sides. Our kisses crept upward. I shot another look at Hailey. We stopped kissing as we reached the under side of her boobs. Pausing a little. Then both moved to the brunette’s hard nipples. I heard Emily moan. It seemed like Hailey wasn’t content in just kissing and had sucked a nipple into her mouth. Happy to follow the blonde’s lead, I copied the move, sucked Emily’s nipple. My teeth closing around her erogenous zone earned another moan. Loud enough that Eva must’ve heard it.

I moved up to kiss Emily while Hailey kept her ministrations to Emily’s left breast. Her lips greedily closed on mine. She moaned in my mouth as Hailey kept pleasuring her breasts. My hands roamed the brunette’s body. Over her ribs to the underside of her breast, down to the band of her skirt. The tips of my fingers caressing her flesh with the softest of touches, just barely teasing her. I felt her react, goosebumps appeared along the trail I made over her belly. My fingers continued their way, down over her skirt back to her leg. Still just tracing the most minute touches. As I reached the inside of her thighs she parted her legs, inviting my hands under the hem of her skirt. I traced my fingers up her leg until I could feel the warmth of Emily’s pussy. Then, just as I was about to touch her, I removed my hand and used it to turn Hailey’s face towards mine. I kissed the blonde. Then asked her: “Do you want to stay up here? Or do you want to lick her pussy?”

“I want her pussy. I want to make her squirm,” the blonde said, a wicked smile on her face.

“She’s all yours.” I lifted up Emily’s skirt, revealing her shaved pussy.

“What about me? Don’t I have a choice?” Our subject asked.

“Nope,” I answered, as my fingers found her nipples and my mouth found hers. She moaned in my mouth. I kept pinching her a little longer. Then made it up to her by kissing each of her nipples. Softly caressing them with my lips and licking them.

Hailey made her way down Emily’s body. Softly caressing her as she sat down between her brunette roommate’s legs. Emily parted her legs to give the blonde more room. I could see how Hailey’s hands stroked their way up Emily’s thighs. The brunette made little sounds of pleasure as Hailey closed in on her pussy. I heard the sound of kisses. By Emily’s squirming I inferred that Hailey had started teasing. I made my way back to Emily’s mouth to kiss her, while I kept kneading her beautiful petite tits. Emily moaned, Hailey must have started to find her sensitive spots. Stroking her pussy with her fingers, kissing Emily’s thighs. Emily’s skirt had flopped back to cover Hailey’s head. I couldn’t see what the blonde was doing, but by the way Emily was moving, I could make out that the brunette sure liked whatever business Hailey was up to. Emily broke our kiss.

“Fuck. Stop teasing. Finger me.” She pushed her crotch up to where Hailey was hidden beneath the skirt. From her frustrated sigh I could hear that Hailey was still teasing her brunette roommate. Time for me to add to the sensations.

Once again I made my way down the brunette’s body. Kissing her lips, her chin, the soft flesh just beneath her jaw, down to the hollow above her sternum. I continued between her breasts, kissing the soft skin. Further down and to the right, making sure to kiss the soft skin of her breast, but deliberately missing the pink areola and her hard nipples. I circled her breast, continued down to her belly button and then up to the left breast, making sure to tease her left nipple in the same way. I felt Emily inhale in anticipation. Just before I changed my attention to the brunette’s hard nipples I felt Hailey’s hand on my calf. Four fingers gripped my leg, then three, she was counting down, and I could imagine what the blonde was planning. I hovered with my head above Emily’s right nipple, while my hand was just about to cup her left breast. I waited, softly exhaling over the sensitive skin. Two fingers, one, none. I bit down on her right nipple, as I pinched the left one. Emily let out a deep moan. Bucked up her entire body to the pleasure Hailey and I were giving her. Whatever Hailey did, I was sure we timed it just right. Once more I bit on her nipple, before softly covering it in kisses. I moved over to her left nipple to also give it some much needed love. Emily for her part was breathing heavily. Letting out soft mewling moans to our ministrations.

I stole a glance at the chair where Eva had been sitting. The last time I had paid my girlfriend any attention she had been sitting with her legs crossed, a glass of wine in her hand and a soft smirk on her face. A lot had changed. The wine glass was gone. A red blush of excitement had crept up her face. She had put one of her long shapely legs over an arm rest. One hand was caressing her breast over her dress. The other one had crept beneath her dress. I could imagine what it was doing there. She was biting her lip as she was taking in the spectacle the two college girls and I were making. She caught my eye, gestured at Hailey, who was perched between Emily’s legs. Her head hidden by the brunette’s skirt. Her panty-clad ass up in the air. It was time to pay some attention to the blonde college girl. I let Emily’s nipple out of my mouth. Kissed her on her lips, then softly stood up from my position on the couch. For a few moments I saw a look of regret on the brunette’s face, but as she saw me move behind Hailey, the look was quickly replaced by one of anticipation.

As I took position behind the blonde I used my hands to caress her sides. I moved my hands around her body to cup her breasts, softly massaging them while I planted kisses between Hailey’s shoulder blades. I trailed downward, my hands following over the front of her body while her head was still hidden underneath Emily’s skirt. From the sounds the brunette was making I wasn’t distracting Hailey too much. My hands continued their path over Hailey’s tight body. Caressing her until I encountered her panties. With a quick tug on the bands on both sides of her hips I lowered the white fabric. Immediately Hailey moved her legs so I could take the last of her clothes off. I let my hands wander over her cute little butt. Caressing her buttocks, the tips of my fingers grazing over her lips. I heard the blonde moan with her head beneath Emily’s skirt. I was doing something right. I started stroking the inside of her thighs, sliding my hands up and down the supple flesh. The tips of my fingers softly touching her flesh, before sliding down again. When I felt that I’d teased her enough, I let my hands wander further up. My fingers touched the soft, moist, skin of her pussy. She pushed her hips towards my hands, inviting me to expand my touches. Slowly my index finger disappeared between her wet lips. It seemed that my touches, together with the work we did on Emily had excited her. Softly I slid my finger up and down between her lips. Caressing the outside of her lips with my thumb and middle finger. All the way up to her opening, all the way down to her clit. She bucked her hips a little, the first time my fingers touched her sensitive clit.

I wanted to do… I don’t know what I wanted to do. There was so much. I wanted to bury my dick into her wet pussy. I wanted to taste her, I wanted to make her cum on my fingers. I looked back at Eva, for, I don’t know what. Inspiration? Encouragement? My beautiful redheaded girlfriend looked at me. I saw her panties lying on the floor, her fingers caressing her pussy. I saw a finger tease between her lips. She smiled at me. Blew me a kiss. Then made a ‘get on with it’-face. I guess I was up to my own creativity. With my hand I stroked Haileys soft pussy, dipping my middle finger between her lips. Dipping a little deeper each time until I entered her hole. Slowly I started fingerfucking her. I covered her butt in kisses while my middle finger slid in and out of her pussy. I entered a second finger. And for a little while Hailey stopped licking Emily. Emily opened her eyes and looked at me. A look of jealous support on her face. She mouthed some words at me. I didn’t catch them. Then the brunette looked past me, locking eyes with Eva. It seemed that Hailey was finally getting used to my fingers, because Emily let out a deep moan while Hailey started paying attention to the brunette’s pussy again. From my current perspective I could see how Hailey was fingering her roommate, while her lips were locked to the lithe brunette’s clit. How she hadn’t cum yet was a mystery to me. But seeing the red blush creep over her cheeks and breasts, her orgasm couldn’t be far off.

For me, I started paying attention to the blonde again. My eyes looking at the view of Emily spread in front of her, her legs parted, her crotch hidden by her skirt, but for the rest everything open for observation. The lithe form of the kneeling blonde before her. Her blonde hair hanging down, her pert bum standing up. My fingers between her long soft legs, filling up her wet and willing pussy. My dick strained in my boxer at the exhibition of sexiness in front of me. I moved my other hand down to Hailey’s pussy. My thumb on her clit, softly touching the little knob. Immediately I felt Hailey buck against my fingers. I kept pushing my two fingers in and out of her. Faster and faster. My thumb softly circling, pressing, going up and down. I saw how the blonde got lost in the throes of pleasure. Emily all but forgotten while my fingers worked their magic. Emily for her part was still focusing her look behind me, at my girlfriend who no doubt was fingering herself. A small smile curled on the brunette’s face, and suddenly I felt a breath on my ear.

“When are you going to fuck her? Look at how wet she is, she is waiting for your cock,” Eva whispered in my ear. I felt her hands on the band of my boxer. She pulled it down, leaving Eva in her tight black dress as the only one left with any clothes on. My dick popped free from it’s confinement. Eva’s hand encircled my dick, pumped it a few times.

Then I felt her breath in my ear once again: “Don’t cum, your first cum is mine.”

Eva had plans. And I was all to happy to fulfil them for her. I sat up between Hailey’s legs. Parted them a little to make space for myself. Then I took my cock in my hand and aimed it at her wet slit. The top of my dick felt the warmth of her pussy before I even touched her. Softly I entered between her lips. Teased her a little by sliding my dick up and down, once. Then I couldn’t take it any more. Slowly but inexorably I felt her tight pussy envelop me. I heard Hailey moan from below Emily’s skirt. Then Emily caught my attention.

“Fill her up Sam. Fuck her good. I want to feel you fuck her while she’s licking my pussy.”

What other choice did I have but to comply? Slowly I moved my dick out from Hailey’s tight pussy, then I pushed in again, a little faster this time, a little more forceful. As I filled Hailey up with my dick I pushed her forward, her face into Emily’s pussy. From the happy moans I saw that Hailey was once again doing her duty of pleasuring her roommate. I started fucking Hailey faster and faster, her moans quickly mixed with Emily’s moans. I felt her warm pussy grip my dick, her moist wetness inviting me in, again and again. I looked over at the form of Hailey, moving with my rhythm, and Emily, getting pleasure in the same rhythm with which I was fucking Hailey. Emily had her eyes closed in pleasure, her hands working her nipples while Hailey was licking and fingering her. Her moans started to increase in speed and volume, and before I knew, she came with Hailey’s tongue on her clit and the blonde’s fingers in her pussy. The orgasm made her tremble on the couch. Losing all control of her body while the pleasure flowed through her. The only thing I could do was to fuck Hailey even harder with this display in front of me. Only one problem, the whole day of build up together with the fucking erotic view that was now in front of me didn’t help, and soon I felt myself approaching my orgasm. But I had implicitly promised Eva not to cum.

Emily started to come down. She flipped her skirt up, for the first time in a while I could actually see Hailey’s head. Her blonde hair was plastered to her face, dishevelled by Emily’s thrashing. Her three fingers plopped from Emily’s pussy, as the brunette stood up from the couch.

“Too much, too much pleasure,” she panted, as she slid down to the floor. Sitting next to Hailey and taking the blonde’s face in her hands before she planted a kiss on her mouth, “So fucking good though. C’mon Sam! Make her cum, I want to thank her for the orgasm she gave me.”

It’s not like I needed any encouragement, but still, this enthusiastic brunette got me going. I gripped Hailey’s hips and started pounding. Moving her whole body on every thrust. After a while I saw Emily break the kiss and crawl on her back below her blonde roommate. I felt her hands on my legs, then I felt her tongue on my balls. Every time I pulled out from Hailey I felt her warm wet tongue on my balls. Whenever I pushed back in, Emily moved her attention to Hailey’s clit. It didn’t take long before Hailey started moaning loudly. Her arms gave out, and her head landed in Emily’s crotch. I felt her tight pussy squeeze around me. I was sure the blonde was about to cum. Which was good too, because I couldn’t hold it in much longer. The combination of her tight pussy, the view of Emily lying below her and licking her clit and my balls, and the idea that Eva was watching us all made my orgasm all but inevitable.

Still, I powered on. Trying to distract myself while I fucked this pretty blonde to orgasm. What maintenance did I need to do to my bike? What did I need to get for grocery shopping. It didn’t help. Hailey’s tight wet pussy squeezed around me. The air was filled with smell of sex. Haileys moans sounded through the room, and softly I could hear the sound of Eva’s fingers working their way inside her behind me. My orgasm was as good as inevitable. I felt my balls constrict. I squeezed my legs, doing my best to stop the orgasm.

“I’m going to…” I tried to warn Hailey.

“Fuck, fuck fuck fuck!” Exactly at that moment Hailey started spasming. I felt her pussy constrict around my dick. It was a miracle that I didn’t cum inside her right there. She moved forward. Freeing my dick. I saw how Emily tried to follow Hailey’s slit, but she moved out of the way.

With a naughty look on her face Emily licked me from my balls up to the tip of my dick. My dick jumped around at the attention. A small droplet of precum forming on my head. Quickly I slid back. If Emily would continue licking me, I would cum.

“Fuck, that was close.” I sighed.

“You saved yourself for me.” Eva purred in my ear.

“I said I would, so I did,” I answered. As far as witticisms go, it wasn’t really up there. But right now, most of my thinking was being done by my dick, my brain was just taking a backseat.

“That deserves a reward. Stay there.” Eva had stood up from her position on her chair and walked around me. She was a dream in a tight black dress.

“Girls?” She knelt in front of me. Her face framed by her red hair staring up at me. Emily and Hailey saw what my girlfriend was about to do and both knelt next to Eva. I now had three eager faces staring up at me. Eva seized the initiative. Her tongue found the underside of my dick and licked all the way up to the tip. Placing a little kiss with her red lips on the top. Emily quickly followed, covering the left side of my cock in small kisses and licks. Hailey decided to copy her brunette roommate and kissed and licked the right side of my dick. Eva engulfed the head of my cock in her mouth, her tongue finding the sensitive spot on my frenulum. She looked up at me with her big green eyes. With a plop she let my dick escape from her mouth.

“Are you ready to cum all over our faces?” She asked. She didn’t need to ask, I was almost incoherent with lust. The view of these three beautiful women pleasuring my cock would be something that would be written on the inside of my eyelids for the rest of my life.

“Cum for us Sam,” Emily added.

“Yeah, cum!” Hailey cheered.

Intent on making me blow, all three of them locked their lips around my dick again. I felt the cum rising from my toes. My dick twitched, I felt lightheaded. Eva saw that I was about to cum, placed her tongue once again on my frenulum, closed her lips around my dick as the first spurt of cum spit out. Quickly she moved back, took my cock in her hands. She aimed the next spurt at Emily, one at Hailey and then she opened her mouth for my cum. I don’t think I’d ever came that much before. The day of teasing had surely built a reservoir. Eva kept aiming my cock at the two college girls and herself. Then, when I was finally done cumming, she took Emily’s head in her hands. Placed her mouth full of my cum on Emily’s and french kissed her. Soon after she did the same to Hailey.

“I’ve always wanted to do that,” she said with a little embarrassed shrug.

I sat down, not trusting my legs to keep me up. Slumped back against the chair. I saw how the girls kept kissing each other. Hands caressing naked bodies. Then Eva took both girls by the hands and led them out of the living room, up to the stairs. As she reached the door she turned around to me. “Don’t dawdle too long. We’re far from done.” She winked and led the college girls out of the room.

Suddenly the room was silent. I heard steps of the the girls going up the stairs and then I was left with my rapidly beating heart. A few weeks ago I wouldn’t have expected that my life would’ve taken such a turn. Not that I complained but I needed to just get my breath back. Gather some strength and then I’d be ready for these three vixens again. I found Eva’s glass, still some wine left. I leveraged myself into the chair, took a long sip of the red liquid. Just a little rest. Regaining some energy. The girls were quiet, not much sound penetrated from upstairs. Or were they too quiet? Nah. I could relax here for a little bit.

My eyes flew open. Fuck! I’d dozed off. How long had I been sitting here? Naked in a chair, my cock out, an empty wineglass in my hands. I shook my head to clear the cobwebs. Stood up, made my way up the stairs. As I climbed up the steps, the sounds of pleasure started to return. The closer I got to the bedroom, the more pronounced the moans became. My soft cock started stirring in anticipation. It sounded like the girls hadn’t been missing my attentions.

The moans and giggles hadn’t prepared me for what I was about to witness. I crossed the last few steps and opened the door to the bedroom. What I saw stopped me in my tracks. The petite blonde Hailey was lying on her back on the bed, her legs hanging down. Emily sat next to her, her brown hair draped down, hiding the blonde’s tits as she was caressing her friends nipples. And my girlfriend, the beautiful redhead who had been lamenting the fact that she didn’t have any naughty adventures anymore, was standing between Haileys legs. Rhythmically she was pushing in and out of the college girl. As she pulled out I saw a strapless strap-on, one part anchored in Eva’s vagina, buzzing against her clit and mons. The other side parted Haileys lips, before Eva pushed back in. For a while the only thing I could do was lean against the door frame. Just enjoying the view of these three women pleasuring each other. My dick rapidly started to grow from the view, and I subconsciously started to stroke it. The girls hadn’t noticed me yet, lost as they were in pleasure. Emily had moved to Haileys other nipple. The blonde moaning on the rhythm of the fake cock penetrating her. Eva was moaning too, but after a while I started to recognise words in her moans.

“You like that? Getting fucked with my strapon? That’ll teach you to seduce my boyfriend without my permission.

I want you to cum. I will keep fucking you until you cum as hard for me as you did for him. And then I’ll keep fucking you until you make me cum.”

I didn’t know my girlfriend had this kind of dirty talk in her. Something in the situation had released her, allowed her to seek her pleasure in this girl that was squirming beneath her. Part of me hoped this was only the beginning of a lot more adventures. I woke up from my musing, to see Emily catch my eye. She licked her lips, then curled her finger to invite me. Well, done with the passive part of the show, time for more action. My dick was standing at attention. I entered the room. My first stop was Eva. As my girlfriend was pounding the college girl next door I stepped behind her. Pushed her hair aside and kissed her in her favourite spot behind her ear. My hands wandered her body, finding her perky tits and her hard nipples. For a while I stood there, kissing her, fondling her breasts. Each time she pulled out from Hailey, she made sure to push her buttocks into my dick.

“Hmmm, this is nice”, she cooed, “but I’m kind of in the middle of something, and you’re distracting me. Go fuck Emily, she’s been a good girl.”

Eva didn’t need to tell me twice. A little pinch and a little kiss goodbye and I made my way over to the eagerly waiting brunette. The one whose naughty actions had kicked off these sexy adventures.

“I’ve been waiting for your cock the whole day,” she said as she reached out a hand and closed it around my member. Softly she pulled me towards the bed.

“Go on, lay down. You’ve had a busy day. Let me take care of you.” The brunette pushed me onto the bed. I fell next to Hailey, our heads at nearly the same height as I felt Emily’s knees dent the bed next to me. Her hand once again on my dick as she aimed it towards her entrance. No hesitation, no apprehension. In one fell move she impaled her wet pussy with my hard dick.

“Fuck. Why do you always feel so good?” The brunette moaned as she got used to my length in her pussy. Slowly she started moving. First she was grinding her pussy back and forth. I could feel her muscles tighten and release as the pleasure started building. Soon after she started lifting herself up a little bit. And a bit more, and more, until my cock almost left her pussy before she sat back down again. For a while all I could hear around me were the sounds of pleasure. Emily moaning and riding my cock. The strapon buzzing in between Hailey and my girlfriend. Haileys increasingly vocal moans.

Her eyes locked on mine. A half smile of pleasure on her face, her blonde hair plastered on her forehead. I don’t know what overcame me, but I reached out to remove the hairs from her forehead, tucked them behind her ear. Then with the last of my movement I planted a kiss on the blondes mouth. She answered it like a drowning sailor reaching for air. Our lips locked. Her eyes closed. From deep in her throat a moan rose up. I felt how her hips started bucking. How she lost the ability to focus on the kiss as her orgasm overtook her. I looked down. Her pert breasts heaving in pleasure, a small sheen of sweat making her glisten. Her bald pussy speared by my girlfriends strap-on. Eva didn’t slow down. I could see from the expression on her face that she was close, and whenever she was close to orgasm, nothing could keep her from her pleasure.

I felt some movement near my hips. Emily had speared herself down, and now was attempting to turn around.

“I want to see too,” she said. A small shameful smile on her face, as if she had to apologise. With a few moves she turned around. Facing Eva and Haileys pussy. Hailey finally started to come down from her orgasm.

I heard her mutter: “She just keeps going. Fuck. Sam, if she keeps going I’m going to cum again.”

“I think that’s the idea.” I answered.

“Fuck…” muttered Hailey.

From my position I could see how Emily’s firm buttocks were bouncing up and down. She had reached out her hands, found Eva’s tits. One hand massaging her right breast, the other one pinching the left nipple. I saw how a red blush crept up from Eva’s chest. She was close. Maybe just as close as Hailey. And if I could read Emily well, the brunette was also very near cumming. I let my hands wander. Prop myself up with my left arm, as my right hand reached around the brunette to find her clit. Immediately her moans increased. Her rhythm became erratic. Spearing herself down, then moving up and back down, just trying to get as much of my cock inside her again as quickly as possible. I caught Eva’s eyes. Her deep green eyes bored into mine.

“Cum.” I said.

It started around my cock. I felt Emily clamp down. She pinched my girlfriends nipples. Then I saw Eva’s face change into a face that I longed to see. Her orgasm overtook her. She slammed into the brunette’s pussy a few times before falling down, trapping the buzzing vibrator between them. The sensation was too much for the blonde, and she came too. The power of one small word. Emily clamped around me. The muscles in her pussy milking my dick close to an orgasm.

“Too much, too much!” Hailey squirmed away from under my girlfriend. In her movement dislodging Emily from my dick. Fuck. I was so close. Just a few more seconds and I would have cum too. I saw Eva reach between her legs to remove the strapon, and then she also fell on the bed.

“Wow, simultaneous orgasm!” she giggled. Hailey started to snicker, and soon after Emily also laughed in orgasmic bliss. For a while we lay there. I saw hands wander. Eva caressing Emily’s stomach, Hailey cupping Eva’s breasts. But for whatever reason I was left alone. Not that I minded. This would be a memory I never forgot. Making these three hotties orgasm with just one word.

Hailey was the first one that remembered I existed. Her hands followed my leg up to my cock.

“Wait, Sam is still hard. Didn’t you cum?”

“Not just now.” I answered. “But no problem, I loved seeing the three of you cum at the same time.”

“I bet.” Eva laughed.

“Still…” Hailey added.

“Still what?” Emily asked.

“We should thank our hosts for this evening.”

“Do you have anything in mind?”

“Yes. You lick Eva, and I’ll take care of Sam.”

Hailey immediately acted. Her hand following the curve of my dick, softly caressing it before closing her hand around it. She moved up to sit next to me, and with tiny licks she started to moisten my dick. Emily copied her. Turning Eva onto her back and diving between my girlfriends legs. Hailey started licking me with full licks. Her soft wet tongue following my dick from the base of the shaft all the way to the top. As she reached the top, she closed her mouth around my dick.

“Hmmm, tastes like Emily.” She said as she let my dick out of her mouth.

A small wink as she once again closed her red lips around my dick. This girl was a top tier cocksucker. I felt how my orgasm started to build again. I didn’t need much, the whole atmosphere. Eva’s soft moans and Emily’s brown hair between her legs. Hailey looking up at me with my hard dick in her mouth.

“I think he’s ready!” Hailey exclaimed.

“Eva is warmed up too.”

“Eva. Come sit here.” Hailey manoeuvred my girlfriend to the edge of the bed. She set her down on hands and feet, her ass sticking in the air.

“Now Emily, crawl under her.” I guess Hailey hadn’t quite lost her penchant for arranging people for sex. Not that I minded, because she took my hand and had me stand up from the bed. She took my cock in her hand and positioned me behind Eva. Softly she pulled forward until the head of my cock touched Eva’s lips.

I heard Eva moan, “Come on, give me your cock.”

She didn’t have to ask again. I plunged in her. As I moved between her lips, I felt Emily’s tongue on my shaft. Softly alternating between my shaft and balls, and Eva’s clit. Every time her tongue touched my girlfriends clit I felt Eva contract around me. I wouldn’t be able to last long. I felt Eva caress me, stroke my back, kiss my neck. Then she stepped back on the bed. Her hand found Emily’s pussy. Her other hand went to Eva’s breasts. I felt the hum of Emily’s moan as Haileys hand reached her sensitive spots. Eva moaned out loud.

“Fuck me Sam. Show them I’m yours.” Eva moaned, “Give me that cock and mark me.” I gripped her sides to give myself some extra purchase. Started moving in and out of her. Quicker and quicker, until the movement became a blur. I felt her soft tissue around me. Her the moans. Felt a tongue on my balls. Eva’s moans increased, changed in pitch. This was it. She was mine. The college girls and I were pleasuring her like she had never been pleasured before. Another thrust. Her arms gave out as pleasure overtook her. Her pussy contracted around me, adding to the sensation. I kept up my pace. I was so close. And then, with a last push I buried my cock inside her. The orgasm came from my toes. My legs started to shake. I felt Emilys tongue on my balls, hear Hailey cheer.

“He’s cumming!”

I fell down on the bed next to Eva. Pulled her towards me and took her in my arms. I saw Hailey and Emily stand up. Land between Eva’s thighs and started lapping up the cum dripping from her snatch. Softly I asked Eva “Was this what you expected?”

“This is only the start,” she softly whispered into my ear.