The Babysitter Beta Part 13

I looked between the girls, slightly alarmed at Lana’s suggestion of taking this to the bedroom. My bed wasn’t big enough for all of us, and besides that, we’d make too much noise. The guest room wasn’t big enough for all of us either. 

“Is there something wrong with right here?” I asked. “I don’t think my bed’s big enough for everyone.” 

“Besides the lack of bed?” Lana asked, poking me. “What if we went to a hotel?”

“I can’t leave Abby home alone.” I said, gesturing in the general direction of the stairs. 

“Oh, shit, that’s right.” Lana said, grimacing at her forgetfulness. 

“Penny can stay.” Amanda suggested. 

“I have a better idea.” Anne said, her eyes never leaving mine. “What if we let Julio choose one of us, and they stay the night with him in his room. The rest of us can take the guest room or go home.” 

“What?” Lana asked, confused. “Anne?” Whatever they’d discussed, that wasn’t part of the plan.  

“Afraid of losing?” Anne asked Lana without looking at her. “I want to see who he picks. And Julio, if you pick me or Lana, you get both of us.” 

“That’s not fair.” Amanda said, frowning and crossing her arms. “Of course, he’s going to pick a threesome.”

I swallowed, shaking my head. Choosing between the four women around me would end up in hurt feelings. 

Amanda was still recovering from her divorce. She put on a brave, adventurous face, but beneath the eggshell-thin facade was a woman scared that her best days were behind her. Choosing someone else would shatter her confidence. I might not see a future with her or want to date her, but she didn’t deserve me hurting her either. 

Lana and I were still fairly new in terms of dating, and our relationship wasn’t so secure that I could leave with another woman I intended to fuck without her. I still wasn’t sure how I felt about her and Anne hooking up without me, but I had no room to complain, not with my relationship with Penny and their desire for me to join their relationship. 

Anne was the easiest to let down. I didn’t know her well, but I knew she didn’t care about me or my esteem. I flattered myself that Lana, Penny, and Amanda cared about me and my emotional state. Not equally, but in some measure. On the other hand, Anne had nothing but the potential profit of a video invested in me. She was okay being a hookup, but there was no commitment there, not to me. Her commitment was entirely toward Lana, and Lana wanted me to come along so she didn’t have to choose. Maybe that was harsh, but it was a business decision for Anne and a source of fun. If I rejected her, she’d find another. If I chose Lana, she’d come with us. 

I met Penny’s eyes, and she darted them toward Lana suggestively. I wanted to pick Penny, but she wanted me to pick Lana? It didn’t make sense in my head, and her alarm grew as I shook my head. 

“I don’t want to pick anyone.” I said. 

“You want to spend the night alone when you have four gorgeous women waiting for your choice?” Anne asked. She stretched, showing off her nude, toned legs, firm abs, soft hips, and smallish breasts as she raised her arms above her head and lowered them to her sides. 

“That’s not what I meant.” I said, struggling to keep my mind on what I was saying. “I don’t want any hurt feelings or for anyone to get jealous.” 

“Oh, come on, Julio.” Anne said. “We’re all adults, and it’s just a game. A bit of fun. How about we make it seven minutes in heaven? You pick someone and go to the bedroom for seven minutes with them. I know you last a little longer with every orgasm, but that just adds another roulette element. It’ll be fun!” 

“He doesn’t have to choose just one of us.” Lana said. “Or choose at all if he doesn’t want to. I thought the plan was–” 

“Oh, relax.” Anne said. “We can still take our turns together. I’m sure he won’t say no to that.” 

“Uh…” I hesitated. 

“Should we spin a bottle or something to make this fair?” Amanda asked. “The three of us can sit–” 

“There’s four of us.” Penny corrected her, raising her hand as if to prove she was still there. “I want in.” 

“Penelope, I don’t think this is funny anymore. I know you enjoyed teasing Mister Castillo, but it’s way past time for you to go home.” Amanda said. 

“I wasn’t teasing him.” Penny said. “I really like Julio. He’s hot, I’m hot, and we’re both down to fuck. So let me play your game.” 

“Honey… no.” Amanda said. “You need to go home now. You’ve had your fun with your little college girl-on-girl experimentation. If you and Anne want to cuddle up for the night, I’m fine with that. But do it at our place. Go home.” 

“No.” Penny said. “I want to stay here with Julio. You know I’ve liked him for weeks now. I’m actually a little pissed off at you for fucking him the other night.” 

Lana and Anne’s eyebrows rose, and both shifted slightly away. For a moment, even I was worried with the look on Amanda’s face that a genuine catfight might break out in my living room. 

“Oh, the babysitter’s got a thing for you, Julio.” Anne interrupted, giving me a knowing look as she stirred the chaos. “What do you think? You’re what… nineteen, you said?” Anne asked Penny, who nodded. “It’s all legal, and you’re young and hot. I’m attracted to you. I think Julio’s attracted to you, too.” 

I tried not to look guilty, but I must have failed. Amanda’s face hardened into something hateful, and she huffed as she stood and stamped her foot. She glared at Penny. “You have a crush. It’s not something either of you can act on. If nothing else, he’s your employer, but he’s too old for you.” She looked at me. “Right? I mean, look, Julio. We’re all adults here, but do you want to fuck Penny? If you were going to have a fuck buddy, wouldn’t you rather it was someone closer to your level of experience?” 

“I–I uh–” I stuttered, but my body betrayed me. We were all naked, and my erection was a dead giveaway to the truth. It started rearing its head as soon as Amanda asked me about Penny. 

“It’s not like that.” I said, raising my hands to defend myself. “Look, Amanda, as fun as tonight was, and our night together, neither night was something I intended to happen, or even provoked. I didn’t put a stop to it, but… you’ve said it yourself, right? You want to sample as much dick as possible. You’re not looking to settle down.” 

“What does that have to do with Penny?” Amanda asked. 

“That’s not–” I sighed. “This whole situation is messed up.” 

“Have you two already fucked?” Amanda asked, her voice higher than normal. 

“Yes.” I answered honestly. 

Amanda glared at me. “You fucked her and me?” Her face twisted into something disgusted. “You disgusting piece of–” 

“HEY!” Penny shouted, jumping up to stop Amanda from insulting me. “He didn’t do anything wrong! He didn’t even look at me that way until I came onto him.” 

“When was this?” Amanda asked. “When did you two start fucking?” She pointed back and forth between us. “Was it before or after we fucked?” 

“Before you and I did anything together.” I answered as I tried to track the dates in my head. It wasn’t that long ago. “Penny and I started our… arrangement a few weeks ago. Just before I started dating Lana.” 

Lana looked surprised at that. 

“So you’ve been carrying on together for weeks while she’s over here babysitting?” Amanda asked, her voice shrill. “And then you seduced me?” 

Anne and Lana shared a look. 

“I didn’t seduce you. You came onto me. And, like I said, I hadn’t planned that, and we–” I kept trying to talk, and people kept cutting me off. 

“We aren’t exclusive.” Penny said. “We weren’t even dating. It started as purely physical.” 

“Started?” Anne asked. “Has it become something more?” 

The girls weren’t even paying attention to me anymore. They were looking at Penny. She blushed crimson under their gaze and looked at me for help. 

“Yes.” I said, getting my words out in their momentary surprise. “It wasn’t my idea, but Penny pursued me, and… well, she’s a very attractive young woman. But we also have a lot in common and–” 

“What could you possibly have in common?” Amanda asked. 

“We’re both over the dating scene, for one.” Penny said, then immediately turned to Lana. “Not you, I mean, like, Tinder. Random hookups. He really likes you.” 

“Thanks?” Lana’s confusion showed on her face and in her voice. 

“And we both love Abby, and I’m not afraid of settling down and being a mom or taking care of her.” Penny said. 

“Settle down?” Amanda asked, her voice shrill. “You can’t take care of someone else’s baby full-time once college starts again in the fall!” 

“Well, maybe I can transfer to the local community college and–” 

“No. Absolutely not. You’re not transferring or endangering your degree because some old man wants to fuck you.” Amanda snapped. 

“He’s younger than you!” Penny shot back. “He’s not old enough to be my father. He's just older!” 

Eh, that was kind of true. There was a twenty-year age difference between us. I could be her father if Charlie and I hadn’t used protection in college. That idea made me shudder. I was still a decade younger than her father. That counted for something. 

“He’s just using you for sex!” Amanda said. “You’re young, and guys like that in a girl, so they can take advantage of her!” 

“You know that’s not what this is. Julio would never do that, and besides, I’m the pursuer here, not him! Julio has been a perfect gentleman every step of the way.” Penny argued. “And yeah, we used each other for sex at first, but it’s more than that! I really care about him! He cares about me!” 

“You don’t care about him. You hardly know him!” Amanda said. 

“I know him better than you do!” Penny rebutted, which was probably true. 

Amanda and Charlie had known each other, but it wasn’t as if Charlie had divulged all of my secrets to Amanda. I knew I hadn’t. Even if she had, the reverse wasn’t true. I knew Penny and Lana the best out of anyone here. 

“And we’re learning more about each other every day.” I said, interjecting. “We don’t have everything figured out yet, obviously, but I promise you, Amanda, my feelings for Penny are more than sexual. Just like Lana’s feelings for Anne and…” I glanced their way, but they were both watching me, waiting for me to finish. “I mean… right? It’s all a mess; we’re figuring things out as we go. That’s life.” 

“Yeah.” Amanda said, crossing her arms. She couldn’t keep her gaze on me, looking away in disgust. “Right.” She shook her head and refused to look at me as she moved away. “I’m going home.” 

“Amanda.” I said. “Please. We can discuss this like rational adults.” 

“Rational adults? What rational adult would stick around after you just confessed your feelings for someone else? There’s no future between you and me, and I can’t even stand to look at you right now. I swear to God. All men are just disgusting, filthy animals! You’ll fuck anything!” 

“Penny is not–” I started, but Amanda slapped me across the face. 

I took a deep breath. I deserved it. I knew that. I honestly expected Penny to react that way when I told her I’d fucked Amanda, but she’d been a very different person. They were in different places. Was it hypocritical of Amanda to say I’d fuck anything when she was the one who wanted to sample as many dicks as possible? Yes. 

Would pointing that help anyone? No. 

A second slap came my way, but Penny stopped it. She held Amanda’s wrist and stood between us.

“This was my choice.” Penny said. “He told me what happened between you two, and I still chose him. I love him, and yeah, I get off on him fucking Lana and Anne, but I didn’t want to hear about his stuff with you. Like I said, we’re not exclusive, so I can’t stop you two from fucking, but I can stop you from abusing him.” 

Amanda’s face turned crimson with what I suspected was a lot of conflicted emotions. She wrenched her wrist from Penny’s grasp and stalked toward the back door. “We’ll talk about this later.” She said, glaring at Penny. “And you?” She glared at me. “I don’t ever want to see you again. You disgusting, pathetic–” 

“And we’re done.” Penny said, rushing forward and pushing Amanda out of the room. I heard the back door close, and Penny padded into the room a moment later. I took a deep breath and fell back on the sofa. 

“Damn.” Anne said, sitting on the recliner’s arm. “That was intense.” 

“Are you okay?” Lana asked Penny, who was hugging herself as she stood awkwardly at the edge of the furniture. 

“No, she’s… she’s pretty upset.” Penny sniffled. “I think I might need to find someplace to live.” 

“You can live with us.” Lana said. “If you need to. The rent’s pretty cheap.” 

“Thanks.” Penny said, sniffling as she wiped her nose. 

“Do you need a hug?” Anne asked, and Penny nodded. Anne and Lana swooped in, leaving me on the sofa. 

Normally, the sight of three naked, attractive women embracing would make me hard as a rock, but there was no life below the belt. Penny was crying. She needed me, so I rose from the sofa and joined the embrace. The girls made room for me as Penny hugged me. She rested her cheek on my chest, and I rested my head on hers. 

Anne and Lana stood with us, hugging us silently for several minutes. 

“I’m so sorry about her.” Penny said, breaking the silence. 

Lana laughed. “Don’t be. I think she was the odd one out, and now she is out.” She glanced at me. “Is there room in your bed for all of us now?” 

I laughed. “You still want to stay over? You don’t think I’m some kind of pig for dating Penny?” 

Lana shook her head. “I know you. You are no pig.” 

“And if I thought you were a creep for being attracted to Penny, I’d be a hypocrite.” Anne said. “Maybe warn me next time, though. That was one salty surprise.” She winked at Penny, who blushed and then turned to me. “I’m sorry if I caused you any trouble. I was just trying to have fun.” 

“No, it probably would have happened without you, eventually.” I said, taking the blame off her shoulders. 

“So you two are officially a thing?” Anne asked, gesturing as she stepped away. 

“Yeah.” Penny said. “But he wasn’t cheating on you or me.” She assured Lana. “You two weren’t exclusive, and we just had to keep our arrangement on the down low since… well… you know.”

Lana nodded. “I get it. Besides, Anne and I did the same thing, except that it started with Julio.” 

Anne shrugged. “We’re all adults. It’s fine. It works out that we’re all kinda freaks, too.” 

“I thought I was pretty normal.” I admitted, shrugging. 

The girls giggled at my expense until Anne clued me in on the joke. “You realize we’ve met your family, right?” 

I laughed with them. 

“So, bedroom?” Anne asked. “Or are Lana and I heading home?” 

I nodded. “Penny can show you where it is.” I said. “That was a lot of yelling. I’ll check on Abby and join you three in a minute.” 

“Are you sure?” Lana asked. 

“I’m sure. It’s easier for me to throw on some clothes than you.” I said and did just that. It took time since I had to go outside to fetch them. Once I was dressed, I followed the girls upstairs, and while they continued to my bedroom, I checked on Abby. She was still asleep, but I took time to catch my breath and process. 

When I was confident I wasn’t overthinking, I left her room and traveled to mine, pausing before I opened the door. Giggles floated through it. Penny’s laughter was music to me, and Lana’s was so distinct I’d recognize it anywhere. I almost felt like I should knock, but it was my room. I cracked open the door, and the laughter subdued itself as I stepped in. 

“Is she asleep?” Penny asked. 

“Yeah. She’s a pretty heavy sleeper.” I explained to Lana and Anne. “Especially after playing with Penny all day and her cousins.” 

Lana and Anne nodded, their smiles broadening as I closed the door. 

Penny stood beside the bed on the left, closest to me. Anne sat on the covers on the far side, her leg dangling off the side and the other tucked under her. Lana lay between them, her cute backside to the ceiling with her face cupped in her hands as they supported her chin. She kicked her feet in the air by my pillows, crossing her ankles behind her. 

“So…” Anne said, smiling. “What are you into, Penny? Anything kinky?” 

“Not really.” Penny shook her head. “Except maybe my thing for watching and older guys.” 

“Good thing I get off on being watched.” Anne said, chuckling. “How about you Lana?” 

Lana smiled and pushed herself up. She swung her legs under her so she could sit to mirror Anne. Her right leg dangled off the left side of my bed, and she folded her left under her, holding her calf with both hands. “I enjoy a lot of things.” She said. “As does Julio, apparently.” 

“Let’s get these clothes off you.” Penny said, stepping forward. She undressed me one piece at a time to the hushed hoots and hollers of Anne and Lana, who laughed at their bawdy jokes. 

“We talked while you were checking in on Abby, you know.” Lana said. “I think we’ve come to an arrangement you’ll enjoy.” 

“Oh?” I asked as Penny unbuckled my belt. My pants fell, but she left my boxers on.

“Penny wants to share you.” Lana said. “So, essentially, the deal remains the same. You and Penny date, you and I date, Anne and I date, Anne has her professional partners, and you and Anne hook up if you want to, or sometimes all three, or all four of us can have fun together.” Lana winked at me. 

“And you can hook up with whatever Tinder matches you get, or if we bring you someone to hook up with.” Penny added as she unfastened my button-up shirt from behind. 

“What do you think?” Anne asked. “Sounds perfect, doesn’t it?” 

I took a deep breath. On the surface, it sounded fantastic. If my life could be a porno, I’d want it to be that one. Two girlfriends, three sexual partners, and plenty of hot, steamy sex to go around. The idea was pornographic, and yet, they presented it to me like a reality I could choose to experience. 

Yet the real world pressed into my visions of the future. I had responsibilities, family, friends, and a daughter to set an example for as I raised her. How would this affect my daughter in the long term? How would my coworkers react? How would my family?

Then, there was the consideration of what they weren’t offering. Lana’s invitation to join her and Anne’s relationship was what she’d presented. What if I wanted a more traditional relationship? If I wanted Lana to date only me and me to date only her in a conventional, monogamous relationship? It didn’t sound like that was an option. I could either date Lana with the understanding of her dating Anne, as she suggested or not date Lana. Fair enough. She didn’t have to date me. So, did I want something complicated and non-traditional? 

Then there was Penny. If I were to pick any of the women before me to date solo, it would be Penny. My feelings for her outweighed my growing feelings for Lana. I couldn’t ignore that. Penny was the one, even if I knew that was impossible. I couldn’t date Penny. Not the way I’d want to. She wasn’t offering a steady, traditional romantic relationship. She was offering a casual, friends-with-benefits arrangement, and she wanted me to sleep with other women. 

And what would happen when summer ended? I wanted Penny to stay after the end of summer, somehow, but that was another impossibility. In some ways, Amanda was right. Penny couldn’t give up her education to become a stay-at-home mother. Even if she wanted to, I would be irresponsible to allow it, much less encourage it. Dating Penny meant criticism, even hatred, from everyone who knew us. Dating Lana didn’t have that stigma unless others found out it was a poly relationship. 

“Did we break him?” Anne asked, concern in her voice as I stood there, naked once more, and watched as Penny stepped away from behind me. My shirt, pants, and boxers were in a small pile at my feet, and I stepped out of them and toward the bed. 

“It sounds like a porno.” I said. “And not a terribly well-written one.” 

Penny chuckled. “Just because it’s sexual?” 

“Because it’s… unrealistic.” I said, hesitating to ruin what my body wanted but letting my mind take control. 

“You want to date Penny.” Lana said, searching my face for the truth. 

“Do you want to date me?” I asked Lana. I looked at her, holding her gaze in mine. “Just me, I mean. Not me and Anne. If I were to say I wanted to date you exclusively, would you want that?” 

Lana frowned and looked at Anne, who returned her gaze with a curious one of her own. 

“No.” Lana answered, shaking her head. “I have opened a new chapter in my life. I do not want to pretend it never happened; I want to keep reading and see what happens next.” 

Anne smiled softly and reached for her hand, squeezing it. 

“Is her sleeping with me really something that bothers you?” Anne asked. “Especially when we’re inviting you to join us?” 

“No.” I said, shaking my head. “It doesn’t bother me. I’m just not sure how realistic this relationship you’re offering is. Can we make it work? Can I juggle two girlfriends and work and Abby?” 

“Can you stop being a coward long enough to try?” Anne asked. 

“Anne.” Lana said, squeezing her hand harshly in rebuke. 

“No, she’s right.” I said, sitting on the edge of my bed. “I’m scared of what people will think, say, or do if they find out. I’m worried about the example it’ll set for Abby and if she’ll be confused about who I’m dating or what’s going on between us.” 

“She’s a little young to understand.” Lana admitted. “But non-traditional families raise children together all the time. If we become one, we’ll be there to help you explain to her that she has three moms and one heck of a good dad.” 

“More like two moms and a really irresponsible aunt.” Anne corrected Lana with a smile. “Everyone needs a fun aunt.” 

“What about you?” I asked Penny. “If I asked you to be in a real relationship, to be my only girlfriend and not just a friend with benefits or a casual relationship, would you do it?” 

Penny didn’t frown or smile. She thought about it, stroking her chin and crossing her legs as she fidgeted through the mental considerations. She hadn’t suggested it was an option, but I wanted to know. Lana and Anne looked at her, too, curious to know her thoughts. 

“If you want to be boyfriend and girlfriend together, I…” Penny hesitated, and I braced myself for rejection. It was the responsible choice, and we both knew it. “I’d love that.” Penny said, hugging me. She kissed me, soft and gentle. “I love you, Julio, and I would love to be your girlfriend.” 

I sensed a but.

“But that doesn’t mean I don’t want you to date Lana and hook up with Anne.” Penny continued. “I’m fine with commitment. I don’t need or want your exclusivity. You know what I want in a sexual relationship. I crave and need it, and I want you to provide it. If you’re willing. In return, I’ll do my best to be the best girlfriend I can be.” 

I kissed her, and she kissed me back. Lana stroked my shoulder. 

“You’re okay to tell the world we’re dating?” I asked her, just to make sure we were on the same page. 

“Well, if you’re going to date both of us… maybe Lana should be the official girlfriend. At least until I graduate.” Penny said, kissing my cheek to show her approval. 

“So what does this mean?” Lana asked. 

I took a deep breath. “It means I accept your proposition.” I said, smiling slightly at the semi-professional term. “Penny and I will date. You and I will date. We’ll be the ‘official’ couple as far as family and friends are concerned. We’ll see where it takes us as time draws on. You and Anne will date and see where that goes, and Anne and I will hook up on occasion if we want to.” 

“Perfect.” Anne said, smiling. “That works out perfectly.” 

“It sounds good to me.” Lana said, smiling as well. 

“Deal.” Penny smiled, wiping a tear from her smiling face. “Now, can we seal it with a kiss?” 

I kissed Penny, turning my head to the right as she made out with me for several long, passionate seconds. My body woke, stirring to life as her tongue explored my mouth. Then she withdrew and turned my face by my chin to the other direction where Lana waited.

Lana kissed me, her hands on my shoulders as she shifted and straddled my lap. Her naked body was a delight to hold as I put my arms around her, and she rubbed herself against my growing erection while we made out. 

Lana came up for air and turned my face again. I looked left, and Anne kissed me, sitting beside me on the bed but facing me. We made out, and after half a minute, she turned my face toward Lana again, who turned it toward Penny. Penny and I made out while Anne and Lana kissed, with Lana still sitting astride my lap. 

I caught my breath between kisses but didn’t have long as we rotated kissing partners. Penny, Lana, and Anne took turns making out with me on the bed. Penny and Anne made out while Lana and I kissed. Anne and Lana made out while Penny and I kissed. Lana and Penny made out while Anne and I kissed. The rotation worked well, and soon, my body ached for more. 

The women had the same reaction, and as I pressed against her stomach, Lana started stroking me. Penny moved aside, sitting on the pillows and spreading her legs; she watched and rubbed herself as Lana shifted forward. Lana sank onto my shaft, and I leaned back. Anne lowered me to the mattress and shifted, covering my view as she sat on my face and opened herself for my tongue. 

I ate her while Lana rode me. She and Anne held onto each other, making out and moaning their pleasure into each other’s mouths. Penny watched from beside us, biting her lip as her eyes fixated on my cock disappearing and reappearing beneath Lana as she bounced on my lap from her knees on either side of me. 

I gripped the sheet for all I was worth, enduring the bliss of Lana’s hot pussy soaking through my cock and grabbing it every time she sank onto me and ground her clit against my pelvis. I licked Anne, groping her lower lips with my mouth while my tongue played with her clit. I toyed with her, swirling, pressing, flicking, and curling in alternating motions. I kept the same motion going for several strokes, pushing her closer to release, and then I’d switch my method, bringing her a different kind of pleasure. Each change dropped her further from her goal, but then I’d build her up toward her climax again, only to change my method every time. 

Anne moaned in pleasure and groaned in frustration in equal measure, clamping my head between her thighs and flexing herself against my patient onslaught. 

Penny finger-fucked herself, spreading herself open, groping her breasts with one hand. Her other hand spread her lips and pinned them aside. Her ring and middle finger pumped into her hole. Her thumb, trapped beneath her palm, rubbed her clit with every inserting motion from her fingers, driving her to higher heights of pleasure as she masturbated to our fucking at the other end of the bed. 

I braced my feet against the floor and thrust to meet Lana as she fucked herself with my dick. She groaned in appreciation at my efforts, muffled by Anne’s kiss. I couldn’t see anything, but my world became a series of sounds, smells, tastes, and touch. Lana’s body straddled my lap, her insides milking my cock in patient anticipation of my release. Anne straddled my face, clamping down on me as I ate her pussy. Penny finger-fucked herself, and judging by the sounds she made, she was going fast and hard, matching Lana's and my pace. 

I had no answer if anyone asked me how I’d convinced these three women to share me. Luck? Circumstance? Open-mindedness? That last part was most likely the rarest. The girls had more open minds than I did, which surprised me. Still, it was nice to know where we stood and what we wanted for the future.

The future was still uncertain in many ways, but I couldn’t ask for more than I had. I’d lived too long to think I could see the end of every path before I set out on it. The universe didn’t offer any maps for this kind of thing. I was out of my depth, but I wasn’t drowning so long as I remembered to breathe. 

Alternating between using my tongue and lips allowed me to take several deep breaths between plunges. Anne moaned as I gripped her ass for support, raising my hands behind her and squeezing. Holding her ass, she came, flooding my face with her arousal as she clamped her thighs around my face and trembled above me. She held onto Lana for support and fell aside, closing her legs and letting me breathe deeply. 

I caught my breath, and Lana fell over me, kissing me hard on the mouth as her tongue licked and lapped Anne’s juices from my mouth. She moaned, and her breath caught as I squeezed her breast. I swept my thumbs over her nipples, which hung pointed toward me. They’d become diamond-hard nubs during our lovemaking, and I pressed them upward, letting my thumb trap her stiff nipples against his forefinger. 

Lana moaned and pressed her palms against my shoulders, holding herself above me. She thrust her hips low, grinding against me as I pushed deep into her, and she shook as she came. Her insides overwhelmed me, seizing my cock for everything she was worth and fluttering against it in seismic waves until she, too, fell to the mattress, facing Anne and leaving my glistening cock alone and standing in the air. 

I’d cum too many times today. My erection remained, but it was an echo of its morning glory. I’d eaten, drank, and rested but didn’t know if I had a big release left. At best, they could expect a small one. To be fair, though, I was impressed I had anything left in the tank. Something told me a weekend with these girls would be wonderful but that I’d return a desiccated husk of my former self. 

Penny crawled forward, climbing over Lana as she lowered her face to my crotch and swallowed my shaft into her throat. She closed her eyes and moaned in bliss as she sucked my cock, which made Anne give a soft giggle. 

“Such a beta.” Anne said. 

I raised my eyebrow, which asked the question for me. 

“Alpha.” Anne pointed to Lana. “Beta.” She pointed to Penny. “Sigma.” She pointed to herself. 

“What does that make me?” I asked, my voice tight as Penny gulped against my cock.

“Lucky.” Anne said, smiling as she and Lana held hands beside me. I put my hand over theirs and rested my other on Penny’s head, which she took as encouragement. She redoubled her efforts, bobbing her head on my cock as if fucking me with her face. I didn’t know if it would produce results, but her mouth, tongue, and throat felt amazing. 

I closed my eyes and enjoyed the sensation as the three of us held hands. The connection was reassuring, and for the first time tonight, I felt that Lana and Anne might want me around for more than sex. I clenched against my oncoming release, but Penny felt my legs tighten and pushed away, lifting her head and taking a deep breath. 

She climbed onto me, sinking onto my dick so it disappeared beneath her. She settled her weight across me, straddling my lap, and rubbed herself with her fingers as she rode me cowgirl style. Her other hand ran through her hair, pushing it back and away from her face, which consequently revealed her breasts to my gaze. I smiled at her, and she blushed and smiled down at me. Then, she fucked me, riding me as hard and as fast as she could to make me cum. 

I tried to hold off, get her there first, or at least arrange it so that we came simultaneously, but I only partially succeeded. 

She fucked me hard and fast, rubbing herself in a fury as she rode me, and when I felt she was close, my resolve weakened just enough. I emptied my final load of the night into her and felt burst after burst leave me. A haze of relief and pleasure swept over me, and every muscle in my body relaxed, even those I hadn’t realized I’d been clenching. My arms slumped, my shoulders drooped, and my eyes couldn’t open for long. 

Penny came shortly after I did, rubbing herself with my cock still lodged inside her. She came, lifting herself off of me as she did so and sliding to the floor. She twisted, squeezing her hand between her legs as she kicked and flexed. 

“You are a very lucky man, Julio.” Lana said, her voice soft and sleepy. “And we are lucky women.” 

“Yeah.” I agreed. “I’ll do my best not to fuck it up.” I reached for Penny and shuffled slightly, moving around. I lifted the covers, and the girls slid inside, shuffling until satisfied. I slept in the center. Penny slept on top of me, my legs spread to let her use me as a partial mattress and pillow. Lana slept on my right, curled against me with her leg over mine, her hand on Penny’s back, holding Anne’s. Anne slept on my left, her face buried in my shoulder. 

“See that you do.” Lana said, giving me a sleepy wink. “I will want to sleep like this many nights in the future with my new official boyfriend.” 

When she looked at me, I matched her smile. When I looked at Penny, she smiled and kissed my chest where her head rested. She had her fingers in my chest hair, stroking and petting me with her fingertips. 

“I’m so happy I could cry.” Penny said. 

I smiled. If Penny was happy, then I was happy. I could only hope the future held even more happiness for us as a couple and a group. 

“Goodnight.” Penny whispered, squeezing me. I squeezed her back. 

“Goodnight.” I whispered, expecting an answer from Lana or Anne. 

Lana was already asleep, so I received a sleepy mumble in return. Anne was, if not already asleep, pretending to be. I closed my eyes, blissfully devoid of any issues. My brain was too tired to process. I could only sleep and dream of what the future held.