Harem House Chapter 36 Part 4

Katelyn had some sense of what she was in for when she agreed to join the harem. Saturday’s test run had been eye-opening and horizon-expanding on nearly mind-breaking levels. Then lunch with Arthur had normalized him in her eyes. He’d always been handsome. There was no denying that. Over the years, she’d known him as the hot guy Kelly crushed on. 

Then he’d temporarily distracted her from her pain over Sean, even if she’d gone about it the wrong way. He hadn’t been like Sean, though. Even with Katelyn throwing herself at him, he’d been faithful to Kelly, even when he didn’t have to be, and their relationship allowed him to sleep around. 

Then he’d been her knight in shining armor, riding to Katelyn’s rescue despite the interruption it put into Kelly’s date. He’d carried her, comforted her, and been a rock with no expectations of her whatsoever. He didn’t brag about it or even mention it again. He did it because that was who he was and not because he thought she might reward him for his efforts. 

Guys like that? They didn’t exist. Men always had expectations, or if not expectations, they had hopes. Sean had been kind at first. Looking back on it, though, she saw the unspoken expectations for his ‘good boyfriend behavior’ in his gaze. If Sean could see her now, his head would explode. Not only was she with another guy, but sharing that guy with other girls? He’d throw a tantrum when he discovered her new relationship. 

No doubt he wouldn’t understand the difference between being polyamorous and cheating in a monogamous relationship. Katelyn entered this relationship with Arthur with her eyes wide open. They’d discussed everything, not only between her and him but with the others as well. Their relationship was an open book from the start, and Arthur would never lie or hide the others from her. He’d never break her trust. That was the difference between what Sean had done and what Arthur was doing now as Rani sucked his cock. 

Arthur laid on the queen mattress in the center of the room with his legs spread. Kelly, Katelyn, and Kat knelt on his left. Selene and Mindy knelt on his right. Rani was on all fours between his legs, sucking his cock in her mouth as though it were her favorite candy. 

Katelyn’s face held a nearly constant blush of pink lust tonight. Arthur was hot. His sculpted physique had lines like someone carved him in stone. He had muscles she didn’t even know existed in the human physique. And his dick? It was more than she could handle. 

The girls were all attractive, too, in different ways. She didn’t know what Arthur saw in her, but she supposed being a plus one to Kat or Kelly didn’t hurt. She came with the territory as Kat’s best friend and Kelly’s roommate, but she didn’t mind if that was what it took or how it started. What mattered was what they made of it. 

The blindfold across Arthur’s eyes hid the upper half of his face, but his smile was ever-present. No matter how genuine his protests of exhaustion were, and Katelyn had every reason to believe him, he enjoyed this. His girls, kneeling around him, most of them wearing their Slave Leia bikinis without anything under them and with the bras long since discarded. The toplessness didn’t bother Katelyn. Her breasts were tiny compared to the others. Mindy must have been uncomfortable, though. She kept her arms under her chest as frequently as possible as the night drew on. 

If they added hanging silks around the mattresses or hung sheets in true blanket-fort style, this might look like an actual harem. Sheets and blankets surrounded them on the floor, as did the pillows. The dimmed lights filled the room with a soft glow. Arthur hummed a pleasant tune as Rani drove her face further down his cock. She made it just past the halfway mark and choked. 

She whipped her head off his cock, turned her face into the crook of her elbow, and coughed as she tried to subdue the gagging reflex. 

Arthur’s smile flicked wider for a moment, then returned. He raised his hand from behind his head and lifted his chin. “That was Rani.” He said. “Right?” 

Rani looked annoyed but sighed in resignation. “Yes, my King.” She lifted off the mattresses and gestured for someone to take her place. 

Kelly pointed at Mindy, who smiled and crawled behind the others until she settled between Arthur’s legs. She rested on her elbows and knees, putting her hands on the inside of his thighs, and swallowed his cock to the root with one forceful surge. She froze afterward, keeping her nose against his bush and holding his rigid cock in her throat.

“Show off.” Rani complained, standing behind now and drinking a bottle of water. 

“Mindy.” Arthur said almost immediately. “Am I right?” 

Mindy whipped her head off him and pouted. “How did you know it was me?” 

“You keep trying to beat your record.” Arthur said, almost laughing as he said it. “You need to vary your technique if you want to try and throw me off.” 

“Aw.” Mindy’s pout remained as she stepped away and took a water bottle from Rani. “Fine, I’m out.” She huffed. 

Kelly pointed at Kat next, and Kat crawled forward between Arthur’s legs. Unlike the others, she kept her lips wrapped around the head of his cock, sucking so hard she dented her cheeks with the effort. Behind her lips, her tongue flicked at the underside of his cock head in a motion Katelyn could only assume tickled. However, instead of laughing, Arthur groaned and arched his back. 

“Selene.” Arthur said. 

“Nope.” Rani said. “Ha, ha.” 

Kat stopped what she was doing and moved aside. 

“Wait, I don’t get a second guess?” Arthur asked. The girls shrugged and looked at each other.

“Well, Mindy and I took ourselves out. So, I guess if you guess wrong, that person gets to stay in, right? Last girl standing gets to fuck you?” Rani asked, looking between the girls. They shrugged and nodded their approval. 

“We really should have planned this better. We suck.” Mindy said, frowning. 

“Well, they do.” Rani said, gesturing to those still on the mattresses. The girls stifled their laughter as Arthur sighed. “Wanna makeout while they keep going?” 

Mindy giggled and pulled Rani into a kiss by the panel of her skirt. 

Kelly pointed to Katelyn next, and she did her best. Unlike the others, her left arm was in a sling, so she had to prop herself up with one arm, which she placed at Arthur’s waist. Except last weekend, her experience doing this was with a shorter, narrower cock, so she stretched her jaw before she lowered her face toward Arthur’s crotch. 

She licked first, treating Arthur’s cock like an ice cream cone as she tilted her head, widened her tongue, and licked from base to tip in one long stroke. She kept doing that, licking his balls after the first stroke, then pushing up and bringing her face the length of his manhood. 

“Interesting technique.” Rani said as if commentating while she and Mindy took a breath. 

“I like how she includes the balls.” Mindy said, cuddling into Rani as they watched. Mindy’s hand drifted slowly between Rani’s legs, under the panel of her skirt from the side. 

Katelyn glanced over her shoulder at them, and Rani waved her on. 

“Don’t worry about us. We’re just going to provide commentary like ESPN or something.” Rani said, grabbing an imaginary microphone. “Welcome, ladies! To the first weekly dick-sucking competition! Here we have our mystery contestant, who seems to be focusing on an external technique, licking, more than sucking.” 

Selene giggled at the ‘announcer voice’ Rani used, making her sound like a cheesy sports commentator. 

“She must be getting tired.” Mindy said. “She’s slowing down. One-armed push-ups are tough.” 

“Katelyn.” Arthur said. 

“Aw, come on!” Katelyn protested. “She gave it away.” 

“No, I didn’t!” Mindy argued.

“You kinda did.” Arthur agreed with Katelyn. “I thought it might be her, but as soon as you said one-armed, it was confirmation.” 

“Oh, and there’s a foul on the play!” Rani said. “Excessive commentary on one of the expelled players. Let’s see what the Master of the harem says about her punishment.” 

“I hate this game.” Mindy pouted, crossing her arms. 

Rani laughed, and Katelyn joined her. “It’s okay.” Katelyn assured her. “I’m not really mad.” 

“She should be punished though…” Arthur said. “What do you think, Katelyn?” 

“Me?” Katelyn asked, not sure how to answer. Her earlier punishment had been corner time, so… “Corner time?” 

“Perfect.” Rani agreed. “The penalty for excessive commentary, you don’t get to watch the next contestant!” She pointed to the corner, and Mindy’s pout puckered into something sour. Rani helped Katelyn to her feet. 

Katelyn gave Mindy her best apology face. “Would you prefer something else?” 

“It’s a punishment! She doesn’t get to choose.” Rani protested. “Get in the corner now, Whore. I may not be Mistress, but I’m still the queen of Master’s concubines. Don’t make me look bad.” 

Mindy rolled her eyes but obeyed. She stepped over the mattress and stood in the corner with her hands behind her, protecting her butt in case Rani tried something. 

Rani nodded at Katelyn. “Okay, you join me in the commentary. We’ll give Mindy a blow-by-blow report of the next blowjob.” 

“Very funny.” Mindy said, though her tone didn’t suggest it was. 

Kelly went next, sucking Arthur’s cock the same way Katelyn had before, at least to start. After a few seconds, she took more of him into her mouth before pushing him into her throat and swallowing against his length several times. 

Katleyn’s eyes widened. “Wow. She’s going at this like a pro.” Katelyn said, admiring the view as she and Rani stood behind Kelly, who covered Arthur’s naked crotch with her face. Somehow, the back of her red-haired head made a pretty covering for Arthur’s cock. 

“Yes, she’s definitely using an advanced technique, swallowing him to the hilt. That’s farther than I can usually manage, for sure.” Rani agreed. 

“Well, we’ve seen you choke when the going gets tough.” Katelyn said, which caused Rani to snort. 

“You know.” Rani said in her more normal voice. “If this was a real sport, I’d watch the fuck out of it.” 

“Language!” Katelyn said, still teasing. “We’re on the air!” 

Rani laughed with her, but both fell silent as Arthur announced his next best guess. 

“Kat?” Arthur asked. 

“Oh, another wrong guess means we still have three contestants in this round.” Rani said, returning to her announcer’s voice as she skipped away from Katelyn momentarily. She returned with two kitchen chairs, one for her and one for Katelyn. She sat and crossed her legs as Kelly and Selene finished switching places. 

Katelyn sat beside her, watching intently as Selene tried an alternate technique. She bobbed her head on Arthur’s cock, stroking him with her face and dipping lower inch by inch with every stroke until she had him firmly in her throat. Selene timed her breathing well, and by the time she reached the bottom of his cock her strokes might as well have been coming from a pistoned machine. The muscles in her back stretched as she arched her back at the bottom of the stroke, and she moaned. The red stripes from her flogging must have flushed her with the ghost of pain she enjoyed. 

“That’s Selene.” Arthur said, his breath ragged from the onslaught of pleasure. 

Selene popped off his cock with a smile and wiped her lips with the back of her hand. “Yes, Master.” She said, sliding away from her spot between his legs. “But… is there a reason you’re not using our harem names?” 

“Oh, uh… because I’m not really being very dominant right now.” Arthur said, shrugging as he propped himself onto his elbows. He didn’t move to remove his blindfold but looked up at a forty-five-degree angle as if looking directly at Selene, even though he was only turned toward her general direction and his eyeline flew clear over her head. 

“That makes sense to me.” Rani said, shrugging. 

“I guess.” Selene said, sounding defeated. Her preference for the official harem names and calling Arthur Master was clear to everyone. Selene preferred the reminder of her role and took it more seriously than Katelyn did. However, Katelyn realized they each had their own tastes for it. 

Kelly was less comfortable in command, but she learned quickly. Even so, her preference was obviously to help Arthur and play the role of his submissive housewife. Katelyn wondered if that was her real-life end goal or just part of the game they played. Would she give up being a teacher and marry Arthur for real? What would the others have to say about such a plan? 

Rani was the most confident woman Katelyn had ever met and probably the most brazenly sexual being, regardless of gender. Even Sean, who could be a complete pig at times, wasn’t as horny as she was. She reveled in being the queen of the concubines and played up her own submission for the fun of it. 

Mindy was young, naive from what Katelyn had seen, and down for anything anyone suggested. Her enthusiasm for the perverse was downright contagious, which was dangerous. Rani might be the most confident and the most sexual, but Mindy was frequently the most aroused and eager of the posse. Even facing the corner, Katelyn could tell Mindy wanted more. 

She turned around now that Selene had been eliminated, and Arthur returned to his stretched-out position on the mattress. He folded his hands behind his head as a pillow while Kat crawled between his legs again. 

Her technique was the same one Selene used, and Katelyn watched, impressed. She knew Kat well. Possibly even better than she knew Kelly. The girl had always had a romantic and sexual streak, but here, with all eyes surrounding and watching her pleasure Arthur? She gave each blow job her best effort, and damn if she wasn’t good at it. Katelyn wondered how she’d learned and how frequently she practiced. She could have made the school team despite her height if she had put that much effort into volleyball. 

“Kelly?” Arthur guessed. 

Rani made a buzzer noise, cupping her hands over her mouth to amplify her volume. “Wrong!” She chimed in. 

Kat shuffled to change places with Kelly, but Kelly shook her head, and they stepped off the mattresses together. After a brief whispered conversation, Kelly dropped to the mattress and repeated her performance from earlier. 

“Okay, that’s…” Arthur hesitated, and Katelyn could see him trying to puzzle it out. They might have faked him out, having the same person go twice with a different technique, but at this point, his odds were fifty-fifty either way. Katelyn wasn’t sure if he would change his guess or keep it the same. “That’s Kelly.” Arthur decided. 

“Ding ding ding!” Rani said, jumping to her feet. “That means Brat’s our winner!” She grabbed Kat’s wrist and raised it like a champion as she and Mindy mimicked the faint cheers of a crowd. 

Selene laughed, kneeling beside the mattress. 

“What do I win?” Kat asked, looking around. 

Rani shrugged. “You get to sleep next to Master tonight.”

“Oh, I like that.” Kat said, nodding. “Yeah. I’ll take that prize.” 

Arthur picked himself off the mattress once Kelly slid away. He stood, his cock still erect, and whipped off the blindfold. Blinking, even in the dim light of the apartment, he looked around at the girls and nodded. 

“Okay girls.” Arthur said. “Line up at the edge of the mattresses.” 

Katelyn watched as the others fell into line and then realized she was supposed to do it, too. She hopped to her feet and scrambled, moving for the end. Arthur took her hand and walked her to the far end so she could stand on Kelly’s right. 

Arthur stood and faced them. Mindy, Rani, Selene, Kat, Kelly, and Katelyn stood left to right between him and the mattresses. He hooked his finger through Kat’s collar ring and pulled her away from the lineup. They couldn’t step far with the chairs. Arthur spun the chair so the back faced the mattresses. He gestured, and Kat knelt on it, her hands on the back, her knees on the seat, her legs spread to either side. She arched her back, sticking her ass toward him, and Arthur slid his hand between her legs. He rubbed her, and she closed her eyes rather than stare directly at Selene and Kelly. 

Arthur gestured, and Selene and Kelly closed the gap. Kat left without a word. The others shuffled to keep beside them. Arthur stepped away and entered his bedroom. He returned in under a minute with a bundle of vibrators. He walked down the line and handed one to each girl. 

“Lie back on the mattresses.” Arthur instructed, and the girls obeyed. He hopped to the other side of the mattresses and walked the line again. This time, he fastened wrist cuffs together or put them on if the girls had taken them off and then fastened them. He tied Katelyn’s right wrist to Kelly’s left, Kelly’s right wrist to Selene’s left, Selene’s right wrist to Rani’s left, and Rani’s right wrist to Mindy’s left. With their arms stretched out above them, each woman formed a Y until Arthur kicked their feet apart and repeated the process, turning each of them into an X. Face up on the mattresses, they couldn’t see much, but Katelyn didn’t have to see anything. 

“You remember your safe words?” Arthur asked. 

“Yes, Sir!” The girls answered in chorus, and Arthur walked the line again. This time, he fastened the vibrators in place, using their bottoms as necessary. Kelly’s remained on the outside of her shorts but under the bikini bottoms. He slid the panel skirts aside to show the connection of each wanded vibe against them with their thick round heads nestled against their lower lips and clits. 

The vibrations shook through Katelyn as Arthur turned the wand on to what she assumed was its highest setting. She was wrong. She bucked her hips, humping the air as the vibrations increased with a twist at the bottom of the wand. 

“Oh, fuuuuuck.” Katelyn gasped. 

“Language.” Kelly whispered beside her as Arthur turned hers on, too. 

“Sorry, Mistress.” Katelyn moaned. 

Katelyn didn’t have to see Arthur turn the others on. She heard the chorus of buzzing grow louder one by one as he walked the line. One by one, the others joined the chorus of pleasurable gasps, moans, and straining limbs as the vibrations pushed past their initial shock and drove them toward the edge. Katelyn squeezed her thighs together, hoping to brace against the onslaught, but it only drove the vibrations deeper, making her shiver and clench, driving her ponytail into the pillow behind her. 

Katelyn, Kelly, Selene, Rani, and Mindy stretched out on the mattresses, breathing hard under the vibrators that pleasured them while Arthur walked away, taking his place behind Kat. He placed his hand on her shoulder and rubbed her back. She nodded at him, and he notched himself against her. 

She moaned as he drove into her, and her grip on the chair turned her knuckles white. 

“Sir…” Kat moaned. 

“Yes, Brat?” Arthur asked. 

“Gags.” Kat said quickly. “We need gags, or the neighbors will complain.” 

“What a good idea.” Arthur said, pulling out of Kat and stroking the small of her back. “Go fetch some. I’ll help you put them on the others.” 

Kat swallowed but nodded and practically raced to the bedroom. The different kinds of gags weren’t all the best for muffling the noise, but she did her best to pick the ones that did. Katelyn received a small pink ball gag that she appreciated. Kat put it on, buckling it behind her head as she bent over from behind. Arthur started at the other end and kept a large red ball gag for Kat’s mouth. 

Katelyn and Kat made eye contact as she stood between Katelyn’s feet, standing on the mattress as Arthur fastened her ball gag. 

“Come on.” Arthur said, pulling her away and leading her to the chair. Kat climbed onto it again. She took a deep breath, swelling her chest with air. Arthur pushed her knees apart and rubbed her from behind in slow, gentle strokes. He stroked into her as the others suffered through their pleasure below. 

Katelyn didn’t mind the vibrator. The lewdness might have been strange, open, and exposed to Arthur and Kat with the others, but it was nothing compared to things she’d done Saturday. Last weekend felt like such a crazy and wild night, but that was life in the harem. Inhibitions had to be dropped at the door. Modesty? No one seemed to remember it once the collar buckled around their neck. Her body pulsed against the vibrator every time she locked eyes with Arthur, and she couldn’t help the small smile tugging at her lips to see the lust in his eyes. 

Katelyn wouldn’t have minded being in Kat’s place, but Kat earned her reward. It struck Katelyn as odd that she thought of Arthur’s dick that way, a reward, but honestly, nothing about this situation was normal. When presented with this perverse society, she had two choices as she saw it. Run away, or run toward it. No matter how experienced she thought she was, they always seemed to find some new mountain to climb. She was Don Quixote, tilting at windmills with little hope of victory but hope nonetheless. 

She enjoyed herself regardless of whether she’d ever find victory over the feeling of perverse weirdness. The buzz between her legs drove her arousal into her as she opened for it. She bit down on the gag behind her teeth and found the pressure helped to give her some sense of expression and relief from the intensity. 

That was probably the strangest aspect of it. Before Arthur, sex with Sean had been okay and even pleasurable at times, but even at the height of pleasure, the intensity had been low. She’d thought it had been high, but she knew better now. If this was a ten, sex with Sean was a three. If this wasn’t a ten… she didn’t want to think about it. That meant there would be more intense pleasure waiting for her in the future, and she wasn’t sure she could handle that. 

The others took each hurdle at face value and enjoyed them. Katelyn turned her head to see Kelly’s face already turned toward her. Her forehead glistened with sweat, and her red hair was mussed and loose behind her head. Her braid had come undone, and her hands clenched into fists above their heads. Katelyn twisted her hand, finding Kelly’s and grasping it. Kelly squeezed her hand, and Katelyn squeezed Kelly’s in return. 

Kelly moaned and shuddered. Katelyn realized it wasn’t a shudder against her orgasm but through it. Kelly was cumming, and however intense the pleasure was for Katleyn, it seemed multiplied for Kelly. Maybe Arthur had made her vibe harder since it was outside her shorts? Or perhaps she was simply feeling everything more than Katelyn was. 

Beyond her, Selene bucked as though she were fucking Arthur on the mattress above her. She moaned into her gag without restraint, and unless Katelyn was mistaken, she could make out the slick moisture of Selene’s arousal coating her thighs and exposed pussy. 

Above them, Kat watched them, her eyes hooded and half-open as Arthur switched from fingers to his dick, which he drove into her from behind. She braced herself against the chair, her chest flattening against its back with every thrust. She pushed back against Arthur, who had to hold the chair to keep her from rocking it as they fucked. 

Mindy’s high-pitched whine turned into a muffled scream as she came, letting the pleasure through her and kept going. Katelyn’s pleasure-fogged mind turned toward her safeword, not because she wanted to say it, but because she realized she had a gag in her mouth. A three-grunt signal. Right. She had to grunt three times if her mouth was full, and he’d let her out of this. 

She didn’t want out of this. She wanted more. She’d cum earlier tonight already, but damn if she wasn’t close to doing it again, and again, and again. Honestly, she wanted to see how many high-vibration orgasms she could endure before she passed out. Kelly was probably a champ, but Katelyn? Her waifish figure and lack of physical endurance meant she was probably going to be the first one to give up. Still, she didn’t want to be first. She refused to be the weakest. 

Katelyn lost track of who was cumming when, and honestly, she wasn’t even sure the girls knew either. Some were bigger than others, sure, but others simply rippled through her in flutters that felt nice, like small breaking waves between larger ones that sent her tumbling in a sea of pleasure and arousal. 

The room smelled strange, she realized as she breathed through her nose, but the fleeting realization left her at the next orgasm, and she wondered how big the wet spot on the mattress was. Even Kelly’s grip on her hand had loosened, and Kelly had to be the toughest of them. 

Katelyn didn’t know for sure how long they lay there, enduring their pleasure and the orgasms the vibrations drove out of them. For her, the pleasure came in waves, with the low feeling as though something was punching her in the pussy until she rode it to the height of pleasure again. The wand between her legs drove each release from her without mercy or afterthought. It was a machine, and she’d surrendered herself to it at Arthur’s command. 

Arthur, who stood above her fucking her best friend from behind. He had one hand on her chair and the other on the back of Kat’s head, pointing her face toward the girls spread out below them. Kat grunted and moaned. The ball gag muffled her noises as Arthur became her machine. He drove each release from her with as much mercy as the wand between Katelyn’s legs. His own release? Arthur didn’t seem capable of it, but that didn’t soften him or his cock. 

He was relentless, and Katelyn wondered if he was going to keep going until one of them gave the signal. Who would be first? Who would be the first one to signal or beg him to give them a break? How much pleasure could they endure? 

As it turned out, Kelly surrendered first. 

She whipped her head side to side and gave the three-beat signal with muffled screams through her gag. Arthur was between her legs faster than Katelyn thought possible. He immediately turned off her vibrator and uncuffed her wrists and ankles with confusing precision. 

The haze of lust still lingered over Katelyn as she came again, seeing Arthur come to her roommate’s rescue. God, he was so good at this. He comforted her, holding her as she curled up. He looked at Katelyn and Selene, silently checking in on them. 

“Shh.” He comforted Kelly as he unbound her gag, and she apologized. “It’s okay. You’re a good girl. Good wifey.” He squeezed her, letting her rock in his arms. “It was intense. You did very well.” He kissed her head. “I’m very proud of you.” 

Katelyn thought he might pull her away, but no. He laid Kelly against the mattress and pulled the pillow beneath her head. He undid her top, pulling it away gently. He unfastened her other cuffs and pulled off the bikini bottoms, leaving her in the matching shots she’d worn beneath the panel skirt and gold plate bikini. 

He kissed her, kneeling between her and Selene, then kissed her forehead as if tucking her into bed. He unclipped her choker and assured her she’d find it on the coffee table in the morning. “Good girl. Lay back. Enjoy your rest. You’ve earned it.” 

Was that what Katelyn had to look forward to? Well shit. What was she pushing so hard to endure for? Kelly had been the first to give up, and she was the most fit of them. Her physical endurance should have been the longest, but she wasn’t feeling one hundred percent. Besides that, they’d all played earlier, and it was late. There was no shame in admitting it was too much and putting an end to the unrelenting intense pleasure vibrating through her entire body from its source between her legs. 

Mindy relented next, crying out in three high-pitched whines that immediately brought Arthur to her side. He repeated the process, turning off her vibrator and unfastening her wrists and ankles. “Such a good little whore.” Arthur assured her. “Good girl.” Arthur rubbed her back and wrists. “Did you enjoy yourself?” 

“Yes, Boss.” Mindy whispered, her energy spent and gone. Arthur cared for her, brushing her hair from her face, pulling the pillow behind her, and kissing her forehead. 

Rani gave in next, surprising even Katelyn. With the girls dropping off and relenting from their pleasure, Katelyn found herself distracted from her own core-quivering releases. She was tired. She wanted to sleep, but if it was only down to her and Selene, she wanted to hold on. She wanted to surprise everyone and be the last to give in. Selene was the slut of the group. She was the sexual savant, and Katelyn was the newbie. The underdog. Could she defeat the champion in a test of endurance? 

Katelyn wouldn’t have thought so when they started. She’d have betted against herself. But now? She was surprisingly close to winning this thing, even if it wasn’t a stated competition. She wasn’t the most competitive woman in the world, but the spirit of sportsmanship was in her heart somewhere. She squeezed her thighs again, closing her eyes at the flush of pleasure that shot through her. 

Arthur, waiting for her and Selene to give in next, hesitated to return to Kat, but after neither showed any sign of giving in, he did. Kat had kept herself ready for him by rubbing herself between her legs, and she moaned as he plowed into her again. He held her by her hips and rocked her back on her knees, fucking himself with her body as though she were a toy. 

Katelyn gushed at the thought, her vibrator’s noise changing slightly at the rush of her arousal. She moaned, her eyes fluttering as her limbs twitched and spasmed through another body-wrenching orgasm. She panted, trying to catch her breath but rolling into a second orgasm without pause. Her eyes shot wide in surprise as that orgasm fluttered into a smaller third one, and then an earth-shattering fourth surged up behind it and sent her soul to heaven. She felt as though she left her body, and bliss tore through every corner of her world. She screamed through the gag, but it sounded as if the noise was coming from someone else. 

Her eyes fluttered closed, and the next thing she knew, her head was in Arthur’s lap, with him and Kat looking down at her from above. She smiled weakly at them, barely able to move her mouth enough to form words. The gag was gone. The vibrations were gone. Her entire body was exhausted, and her eyes were no exception. She couldn’t focus, as though she were drunk, but she’d tasted no alcohol tonight. 

“Good girl.” Arthur said. “But next time, use your signal. Okay? Don’t let it get that far again.” 

Katelyn understood he was talking to her, but she didn’t know what he was saying. She focused on his first two words and smiled. "Good girl," she understood. She was a good girl—his good girl—and that was all she cared about. 

“Thanks.” She said. “Thank you, Sir.” 

And that was the last thing she said before sleep and exhaustion took her. 

~~~

“Is she okay?” Kat asked, concerned. 

Arthur nodded. Katelyn was okay, but she was down for the count. She’d fallen asleep from her orgasm, or at least, he thought she might have. As it was, she was healthy but exhausted. He didn’t blame her. He was tired, too. Falling asleep in subspace wasn’t the strangest reaction to the experience, but the wake-up and recovery tomorrow would require extra care and attention. 

He’d need to watch her. She was new to this, but they all were, especially Katelyn. For some reason, the primal monkey part of his brain didn’t want the things he wanted with the others when it came to her. With Kelly and the others, his monkey brain said: sex. With Katelyn? Monkey brain said: protect. He’d check in before he went to sleep, just to make sure she was okay, but the snore that came out of her told them she was fine, if a little congested. 

“What about you, Slut?” Arthur asked after he laid Katelyn down and adjusted her pillow. “How are you holding up?” 

“I– gu–” Selene tried to speak through her gag and found she couldn’t, but both hands turned into thumb’s up, and Arthur decided to take matters into his own hands. He turned, moving into a 69 position with Selene, and knelt behind her head. He pulled the ball gag from her mouth, and she groped for his cock with her tongue until she found it. He bent over her again, sliding into her throat until he brought his lips to her pussy. He removed the vibrator between her legs and let his vibrator take over. 

He hadn’t cleaned himself off between fucking Kat’s pussy, even after she’d cum with him lodged inside her. Selene arched her back and moaned her pleasure, vibrating her throat against Arthur’s cock. He grunted but shook his head. He pulled his hips back, but Selene grabbed his thighs, trying to keep him inside her mouth. He smacked her pussy, and she released him. He spun, twisting around on one hand and landing between Selene’s legs. She spread wide for him, and he pulled her closer to him as he stood on his knees and lifted her by her ass. He pushed into her and grabbed her by her hips. 

Selene reached overhead behind her, grabbing the mattress's edge to brace herself against the movement. Arthur moved her with his hands on her ass and hips, squeezing her and fucking himself with her like she were a fleshlight. 

She shivered, quivering as she came, and Arthur slowed to a stop, grunting as he fired the absolute last of his release into her. His breathing shifted, turning heavy as she clamped down around him from every side, vibrating against him as her orgasm tore through her. 

“Fuck.” Arthur gasped, causing a few eyes to open slightly and look at him through their exhaustion. 

“I’ll take that as a compliment, Master.” Selene said, smiling an exhausted smile as he lowered her body against the mattress. 

“You should, Slut.” Arthur said, hugging her. “You’re a good girl.” 

“Thank you, Master.” Selene said. “I love you.” 

“I love you too.” Arthur said, wiping her hair away from her face. “Lie back.” 

“Yes, Master.” Selene said and relaxed against the mattress. Arthur pulled a pillow under her head and individually removed her ankle and wrist cuffs. He left the brown leather choker on her throat because she grabbed his wrist when he reached for it. She could sleep in it. He didn’t necessarily advise it, but he didn’t have the energy to fight her. 

He massaged her, rubbing her, soothing her, offering her water, and tucking her in as he had the others. He kissed her forehead before he pulled the blanket over her.

Confusion momentarily overtook her exhaustion. “But, my slave bed.” She said, pointing to the foot of the other mattress. 

“Shh.” Arthur said. “Sleep here. Sleep where I tell you, Slut.” 

“Yes, Master.” Selene said, not protesting further. “I hear, and I obey.” 

“Good girl.” Arthur said. He sighed and looked at Kat, the only other person who seemed awake. She sat backward in the chair behind him, exhausted but awake. “If only it were always that easy.” He said to Kat, who laughed in motion only without making any noise. 

Arthur laid the collars and chokers out on the coffee table and straightened up slightly because he couldn’t help it. He checked the door locks and turned the lights to their lowest setting. Then he patted Kat’s back, rousing her slightly. 

“Wait.” Kat said, surveying the mattresses and the girls under their blankets across the three mattresses side by side. “Where do we sleep? I’m supposed to sleep next to you, remember? That was my prize.” 

Arthur took the last blanket and offered Kat his hand. She took it, standing from her chair with uncertainty plain on her face. He led her to the sofa and laid down. He spread his legs and patted his stomach. Kat got the hint. She didn’t seem confident, but she lowered herself with her legs between his, her arms hugging him, and his pec acting as her pillow while the sofa arm acted as his. 

Arthur kissed her forehead. “Good girl.” He said. “You were a very good girl tonight, Kat.” 

Kat smiled softly and kissed his pec. “Thank you, Sir.” She snuggled in as Arthur threw the blanket over them, enclosing their naked bodies together. 

Silence swept over the apartment, interrupted only by the gentle sleeping noises of the women on the mattresses. 

At least until Kat spoke again. “Master?” 

“Yes, Brat?” Arthur asked, both of them whispering as quietly as possible. 

“I know it’s not the right time, but… thank you for sharing earlier about Lynn.” Kat said. “With me, I mean. Even if it was with the group too, I mean… I know you wouldn’t have done it if you weren’t comfortable sharing it with any of us.” 

Arthur wasn’t sure how to respond to that. So he kissed Kat’s forehead and closed his eyes again. 

“And Master?” Kat whispered. 

“Yes, Brat?” Arthur asked. 

“I’m sorry she did that to you.” Kat said. 

Arthur wasn’t sure what to say to that. It wasn’t an emotional statement driven from her in tears or during an intense emotional moment. No. It was in her sleepy whispers as she drifted off to sleep. Something she wanted to express and let him know she was there for him and supported him. 

For some reason, that tender confession struck his heart harder than any tearful declaration of hatred toward Lynn. He felt the tears press against the corner of his eyes and slide past, trailing down his cheeks. He kissed her forehead again, not trusting his voice to express his gratitude. 

“Master?” Kat asked, her whisper breaking the silence once more. 

“Yeah?” Arthur asked, barely able to hold himself together as Kat squeezed him in a gentle hug even as she laid on top of him. 

“I–” Kat hesitated. Clearly, there was something else she wanted to say, but she stopped herself when she reached up to touch his hair and felt the hot tear against his cheek. She crawled forward slightly, bringing her head to his shoulder instead of his pec, curling against Arthur as he wrapped his arms around her. “I’m here for you. Whenever you need me.”  

She spoke the truth. Warmth seeped over Arthur under their blanket, and comfort came with it, washing him in lilting waves to the shores of dreamland. Whatever the future held, Arthur wouldn’t have to face it alone. Despite his reluctance, he was beginning to agree with Rani. Perhaps sharing what he’d told them with his mother was the best course of action. And maybe he didn’t have to do it solo. If his harem was there to support him, he’d be strong enough to do anything.

Arthur didn’t answer Kat with words. He held her, and in the safety of the dark, he cried as they held each other. They stayed like that as they fell asleep, and sleep brought him the peace only a true break from reality could. He might have had nightmares, but no, not with Kat there. Her defiant attitude could have frightened away any bad dream that came for him. Instead, he dreamed of her, walking hand in hand with him through a library laid out like a forest, its cylindrical bookcases standing in for the tree trunks. He had no idea what it meant, but it was a pleasant dream as she took him by the hand and showed him her favorite books. He didn’t remember them when he woke, but book by book, she showed him her favorites until he rejoined the waking world the next morning.