TRICK or treat POLL

Split is a great movie.

Russell

Agreed, Constantine is not a Halloween movie, it should have been on a different list.

Russell

Constantine shouldn't be on this list. Friday the 13th is a definite must and Fright Night would be perfect.

Russell

YodatheHobbit - that's the biggest mistake when it comes to the movie, focusing at all on the ending. Everybody was so primed for the Next Big Twist from Shamalayan after the Sixth Sense, but I say forget about the ending, the film itself is just so good, with so many amazing performances... it's just a criminally underrated movie.

Story Archer

I can understand not liking the ending. It's just strange to me that people use the excuse for hating the ending to neglect all the INCREDIBLE acting performances by REALLY GOOD actors. Steller work in my opinion.

YodatheHobbit

@Richard Yeah, I would agree that most are reasonable and I hear you on the creepy "protective" ones; which is ironic since they are the ones most likely to cause harm to someone in real life. Definitely an ick factor there. Of course there is the other end of the spectrum and the ones who take pleasure in scaring, freaking or grossing out reactors. I am with you in the sense that Cass started this channel to expand her horizons, push her boundaries. The creepers don't seem to understand just how far Cass has come since starting... or maybe more accurately they don't want to see because it is all about them. So, I try and balance picking films I like/enjoy with ones I think she (and sometimes Carly) will enjoy, and finally films that not only meet the prior two criteria but also will push the limits a little.

Doug Fisher

Doug, you need to work on your reading comprehension: The Rocky "Horror" Picture Show TRHPS is part of our culture and should be watched by everyone at least once. The Google page for Black Swan gives the genre as "Horror/Drama". Wikipedia calls it a "psychological horror." Definitely a psychological horror in the broad sense of the term "horror".

Clay F

@Clay Actually, "Black Swan" is classified by your beloved sites as a Psychological Drama and Psychological Thriller. I have seen the movie, there are no "horror" aspects to it. You have got me there... there is "horror" in the title of "TRHPS"... and movie theatres might have had a "horror" of a time cleaning up after a showing, what with all the water logged news papers, hot dogs, rice, etc. being thrown around... so semantically...

Doug Fisher

Cabin in the Woods is clever on the first watch, I’ll give it that. But it’s a horror parody, and doesn’t hold up on related viewing. Blair witch is of its time. You had to see it In 99. It was truly a trailblazer and opened the door to a new genre. I know that Cassie won’t handle a film like The conjuring, that’s a step too far. Even I get creeped out by it. I’m happy to see Constantine on the list, I’ve always enjoyed that movie and I’m looking forward to the rumoured sequel. I’ve just read Carrie for the first time, and that’s a film I’m yet to watch so I voted for it also.

Biggman83

Honestly a great chat going on here. Cabin In The Woods is more comical, then scary? Although that cabin did remind of the cabin from The Evil Dead. My friends and I were so blown away by Cable In The Woods. It's original, it's somewhat scary. It's ranked high in fan polls. Truly I voted for it and Friday 13th and Carrie.

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

I hear you, I can't say anymore on the subject. I am not allowed to say anything on this channel without running it by my fiance first.

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

truly bizarre posts. I've stopped trying to guess what Cassie will like and what she won't. She's watched films I was sure she'd hate (The Thing, for example) that she ended up enjoying. The point of her channel, as I understand it, is to experience new things.

Walter

I'm a gen X voting for Constantine

Walter

We need instant runoff voting / rank choice. Folks change votes to Cabin in the Woods!

Marcos

CONSTANTINE is out in front? Oh boy. Is it the millenials voting for that?

Average White Man

I realy hope constantine 2 isn't just a troll

quentin bentein

Thanks , Doug. I think in general people are mostly reasonable here (yourself included) and I enjoy hearing their opinions, even when I disagree with them. Some come in and try to be buttheads, but they usually get shut down pretty quickly. The only ones who really bother me are overprotective ones, overprotective to the point where they become creepy, who seem overly concerned with keeping Cassie away from movies they have deemed unfit for her. Also anyone who seems overly obsessed with either of the sisters (or both). Those people really skeeve me out.

Richard Maurer

@Richard Still, I usually try to add insightful or at least well informed comments and I didn't do that in this case, but thanks for the pass. ;) I have always found your comments insightful and fair. You are one of the good contributors to the community. Cheers!

Doug Fisher

@Doug - In the end, no political ideology is any better than the people running them.

Richard Maurer

Thanks. Helene wobbled east just before hitting the coast, and saved us from the worst of the damage (just 21 hours w/out power and two days w/out internet). But the poor people living in Taylor county got hit with their 3rd hurricane in 13 months - without a single hurricane to hit them in over 170 years.

crazyivan

I’d say it’s more of a horror than Constantine. Besides, so many movies here have been on polls or even won when they had no business doing so. So, it’s just the norm really.

Shehab Dawoud

@Doug - Considering the choices on this poll I can see how you could mistake it for being Carly friendly though.

Richard Maurer

Ha ha. Doug, you are a freak. Why are you so scared of data? Living in your isolated bubble. Freak. Why so paranoid about reputable sources being tainted and skewed? What other conspiracy theories do you buy into? 9/11 was an inside job? The 1969 moon landing was fake? Deep state? Don't tell me you are a flat earth guy.

Clay F

But is "The Devil's Advocate" really a horror movie? I would classify it more in the fantasy thriller genres. Much in the same vein as "Fallen".

Doug Fisher

@Joe If Clay didn't have Metacritic, RT, etc. he wouldn't have an opinion at all. The dude must be seriously lacking in confidence to feel the need to constantly post review site scores, sites that are tainted and skewed.

Doug Fisher

@Richar Maurer I didn't misread it... I didn't even read it. XD I just skimmed the Treat poll and assumed this one was similar... and you know what they say about assuming. So I messed up twice really. Thanks for pointing it out.

Doug Fisher

Fright Night deserves more love, it is comedic enough for Cassie without being just slapstick.

Allen W. McDonnell

Doug, The Black Swan is characterized as a psychological horror. Good point about TRHPS but at least it has “horror” in the movie name.

Clay F

@John A - if every movie that was supposedly going to send her to therapy actually did Cassie would be under 24 hr. psychiatric care

Richard Maurer

@Doug Fisher - You misread Cassie's intro. The Treat poll is Carly friendly, the Trick poll is not.

Richard Maurer

No, I'll say as I please if that's how I feel. If you're too sensitive to handle it then you can go crawl into your safe space

John A

Therapy? Come on. I know you're probably exaggerating your point but you guys really need to stop coddling her. It's just a movie, she can handle it. She just needs people to stop telling her these movies will do that to her.

John A

I don't really understand what needs to be explained. I think it's better and creepier with less info anyway

John A

Lmao you hypocrisy about selfishness is absolutely wild. I don't want her to watch it either but I'm not a hypocrite about it

John A

I fully support that. Everyone needs more Rutger Hauer in their lives and as always, he is phenomenal in that film.

China Andronicus

I just got a tongue lashing so I am sorry about the earlier message. I was wrong. Yes I do make mistakes. However I think you should look out for her. You called them entertaining reactions even though she hated it? So she didn't think it was very entertaining. Why not do things for her? It's just a thought of course. However..... You should vote on whatever you feel is right. It's not for me to judge. Constantine is not even a horror movie it's a superhero movie disguised as a horror movie. It can happen it's easy to fool people. It heck it fooled me.

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

Mike, stay "squeaky", hope is not lost....yet.

Joe

I believe Cassie wants to watch Constantine, and it should make for an entertaining reaction. I don't care if Cassie likes or dislikes the film, she didn't like "Big Trouble in Little China" or "The Fifth Element", but still entertaining reactions.

Joe

@V M "Democracy" is two wolves and a sheep voting on what is for dinner.

Doug Fisher

Come on Clay... "Black Swan" and "TRHPS"?! That is the broadest of broad senses.

Doug Fisher

You have to remember this is not just for Cass but for Carly too... hence the "Scary but not too scary." Carly's tolerance level is not as developed and Cassie's.

Doug Fisher

I hope so.

Richard Maurer

Yeah, near last place. I read that the excellent performance by McAvoy made the movie.

Clay F

John Constantine is an antihero from the DC comic Universe.

Jimmy Stewart

I never watched the Scream reaction (because I hate Scream) but the Idea of anyone being scared by that movie befuddles me. One of the least scary big name "horror" films I've ever seen,

Richard Maurer

👆. Blade really, really, really should be watched this October.

Larry Darrell

I'm sad Split isn't winning. James McAvoy was phenomenal and deserved an oscar for his performance.

Yaisu

Way better.

Richard Maurer

"you can't possibly believe that there is anything about Midsommar that Cassie would enjoy" Why would we worry if she's going to enjoy a horror film? If we did that would rule out most of the good ones. "She'd probably need therapy for a month" yeah, riiiiight.

Richard Maurer

I pretty much consider The Fly a forgone conclusion, and maybe It:2 also. But that shouldn't mean the other polls get to be filled with weak and/or bad choices. And while I agree people recommend inappropriate films for polls all the time., in the case of horror polls it's way more prevalent and in some some cases a deliberate attempt to subvert the poll.

Richard Maurer

Constantine should have never been on this list. Simply put it's a superhero movie. That's my problem with it. There was Constantine The superhero of DC comics who this which is what this is about. However there was Constantine The great the Roman Emperor of the 4th century. That's a story not worth talking about.

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

I alway felt Rec did the found footage thing better than The Blair Witch Project.

Bruce Reid

The eye (2002) would be another one that's super unnerving, again another poor Hollywood remake that couldn't replicate it.

Bruce Reid

Welcome

David Freese

This is why I push for Ringu over The Ring. Unfortunately, I've only seen one reactor do Ringu first, that was VKunia. I think it's mostly Americans who are unwilling or unable to read subtitles, along with some xenophobia, that cause remakes to be pushed all the time.

Richard Maurer

"Why are all the horror movies doing so badly?" Because they aren't good (specifically Blair Witch and Friday)? Then a fairly popular "main stream" movie was included, the end was predictable. Plus, I voted for Carrie, so that one is right out. @Joe - "Squeaky wheel gets the grease!" I've been squeaking for a while, still no grease. @Richard - It pt. 2 is still possible, the Fly is all but confirmed, and fingers are crossed for Saw. We'll have to see before judging the "season". "every horror hater is constantly recommending every vaguely horror adjacent film they can think" That goes for every genre. How many "how is *that* movie winning" comments are there? And it is usually some movie with 500 other reactions.

Mike Lemon

I would have rather seen Blade on either of the polls, but mostly in the Treat poll. It's better than Underworld, by far, and there's a reason for her to watch it.

Richard Maurer

I can tell you why it I don't like it. The twist at the end is actually a unfortunately too common one in horror movies - and a certain Saturday morning cartoon. And I've always hated that twist.

Richard Maurer

Yeah not the greatest list. It is the best one on there in my opinion.

RJ MacReady

The Hitcher (1986) needs to be on this list.

RJ MacReady

It's easily the best of the bunch, but considering how weak that bunch is that's not saying much.

Richard Maurer

I made multiple comments about getting some real horror this year and after last year with movies like The Thing and It: Chapter 1 i had a good feeling about this year. But it seems like my comments were ignored and we're slipping right back to where we were at the beginning. And it certainly doesn't help that every horror hater is constantly recommending every vaguely horror adjacent film they can think of to take space away from real horror movies. And unfortunately it seems that tactic is working.

Richard Maurer

TY!

Carol Rocha

Its coming already on schedule

David Freese

Was filmed here in Colorado Springs! Th place that was supposed to be his place is actually a Baptist church!🤪

David Freese

I can never get enough of band of brothers reactions so I'm right there with you

John A

If we want her to watch something Scary try Friday the 13th or Carrie before Blair Witch

David Freese

Plus I do care about Cassie and what she thinks but trying to protect her from certain things isn't liking her its treating her like a child imo

David Freese

So I guess you never watched a film that got suggested to you and you ended up hating it. This is about her trying different genres and different types of movies. Its not about watching everything that she might enjoy for one reason or another. Even at the beginning there were several movies I bet people said the same as you and she at least appreciated. Almost ever war movie for example.

David Freese

Not to mention at that point people would sit there trying to figure out the twists and just ruin the experience for themselves

John A

I can't wait for her to sleep through the snooze fest that is Constantine 🙄

John A

Same here and I am someone that responds alot but I think Cassie can handle alot more than some try to protect her from but 🤷‍♂️

David Freese

We don't often agree about stuff but yes I agree why isn't more horror being voted on instead of horror lite. Cassie can handle alot more than alot of patreons think she can can and does drive away some people. I'm really on Cassies side but I wish we'd get away from some things.

David Freese

Shes seen both away from the channel

David Freese

PANIC ROOM IS GREAT!

Carol Rocha

THANK YOU!! But, I think it’s necessary to see 1 & 2 before watching Day One. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Carol Rocha

You can’t do A Quiet Place Day One without first doing A Quiet Place 1 & 2. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Carol Rocha

I am not huge fan of Cabin. I am not a horor-movie kind of guy. I see Cassie being incredibly confused by Constantine, but we'll see.

Clay F

Good one. The remake was pretty solid as well.

Chris Thom

Here you go I found something just for you I love it. https://youtu.be/5ywgdylcM_o?si=N9Mse35Qa9dODEs8

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

I remember hating it when it first came out but I really liked it when I watched it again as an adult. I think the reason so many people didn't like it was because it was marketed as something very different than what it actually was. I don't wanna give anything away but I think simply a different trailer would have made a big difference in people's opinion of the movie.

My_Cousin_Mose

I love the Blair Witch Project but have never seen that. I'll have to check it out.

My_Cousin_Mose

I swear that was gonna be my original reply😂 but you never know if someone is a casual and wouldn’t get it.

Shehab Dawoud

These people I think just don't get it. It's about her. Do you really think she will like this movie? Or is it just about you. Gf and I have no idea what this movie is even doing on this poll in the first place. Name calling has no place here but video clips do I have a special place. Constantine was a emperor in Rome In the 4th century. First Roman emperor to convert to Christianity. https://youtu.be/3Gh6w_-QCcE?si=BFVeP86SoA71_af5

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

funny how...? funny like a clown, I amuse you?

ArsTropica

I like Constantine and voted for it. October is the only chance we get for her to watch it. She may do 1st & 2nd on these polls, but probably won't have the time this October. Another poll is coming next week also. For me, she could watch Underworld any month, I want to see a reaction to it for sure, but any month would work.

Joe

A small percentage of Patreons are very active in comments and suggestions. Squeaky wheel gets the grease! And Teacher's pet syndrome.

Joe

It was released on A&E as part of the movie's promotion and depicted as 100% real... I'm pretty sure it was released on the DVD as well, and it was so well done. They probably should have made it the first half of the movie and then cut the 'found footage' aspect of it down by a bit to balance it out. If anyone hasn't seen it, I can't recommend it highly enough. It covers hundreds of years of local history/mythology in the region and takes the movie from a creepy novelty to a genuine experience.

Story Archer

I’d have Constantine over Cabin in the Woods any day. The final chapter only works once, and is given away far too soon

Biggman83

Yeah I’ve been a Patreon member since the Covid lockdown’s. Over the last year I’ve noticed an agenda being driven by certain members, and it’s completely changed the experience for me. October is make or break for my continued support.

Biggman83

I think some people are trying way too hard to get in her good books and become one of her favorites. So I guess trying to shelter and warn her about certain movies is what they think is the best way to achieve that. Besides sending gifts and whatnot, ofc.

Shehab Dawoud

Why are all the horror movies doing so badly? Cabin in the woods doesnt deserve to win. The whole point of this channel/Patreon was to push cassie’s boundaries on films, and for her to experience different genres. Horror is horror not Mickey’s not so scary!

Biggman83

Horror movies (“horror” in a broad sense) to consider for future polls: *BLACK SWAN (2010). A psychological horror. IMDb = 8.0 --Natalie Portman, Mila Kunis *LET THE RIGHT ONE IN (2008) [Horror/Romance] [Swedish romantic horror] --"Sinister but gorgeous and compelling." --"Exquisitely crafted." *DONNIE DARKO (2001). A young Jake Gyllenhaal. Set in 1988. --A wild, mesmerizing, jarring movie. IMDb = 8.0 *REQUIEM FOR A DREAM (2000). [Horror/Drama]. IMDb = 8.3 --Jennifer Connelly, Jared Leto. *THE GIRL WITH THE DRAGON TATOO (2011). Daniel Craig, Rooney Mara *TAKE SHELTER (2011). [Horror/Action] Michael Shannon, Jessica Chastain *THE ROCKY HORROR PICTURE SHOW (1975) *TRAIN TO BUSAN (2016) [Action/Horror] [Korean] *ROSEMARY'S BABY (1968) (if not on Cassie's no-way list)

Clay F

The Hitcher with the late Rutger Hauer (R.I.P) That's a good movie. havent seen it in a while. scary, but not too scary.

rakesh

Any lack of context that Cassie would experience with Cabin due to her not being a horror-movie expert would be nothing compared to the massive confusion she will experience with Constantine. As I have commented, the incoherent Constantine is truly mumbo jumbo.

Clay F

Mumbo Jumbo, you say?! How dare you, sir! Hopefully, she'll watch both since they are virtually neck and neck. And it will somewhat lessen the blow that has Underworld in the lead in the other poll.

rakesh

I’m a funny guy.

Shehab Dawoud

I've said it before and I'll say it again: democracy simply doesn't work.

V M

There are more polls to come for October. It’s possible it will be on one of those.

Dan M

Same. Of all the movies on this poll it’s my favorite. It’s a nice blend of scares and good practical effects with some comedy sprinkled in.

Dan M

It won't matter. Remember when she watched "Scream"? There were many people who said she would love it because of all the references she would get from past movies. Turns out, she didn't care about the references, or hardly noticed them, because the movie was terrifying for her.

Mark Vaderr

IF I really wanted Cassie to increase the intensity of her film choices; my next recommendation would be for her to start Carly on her own trek through Band Of Brothers. Cassie could answer all of Carly’s questions and it would increase her own awareness of her growing courage and give her the foundation to go even deeper into the Adrenaline and Dopamine soaked section of the internet’s virtual Blockbuster.

Uncle Phoenix

Probably just her being funny.

Cole Jennett

Like when PS stands for Post-Script, what does PMS stand for? Post-Mid-Script?

mikethemotormouth

I don't think Cassie will get enough of the references in Cabin in the Woods

Jacob Wagner

😂

Cole Jennett

And could not possibly be more confused at PMS

mikethemotormouth

Never knew Constantine had such a cult following until these reaction channels. Always thought it was on the mediocre side. Does have some good performances though.

Chris Thom

Was that doc on the DVD? Or did that come with the sequel?

Chris Thom

Its funny she says how much she likes the high school revisiting movies so this would be perfect

Andrew Heller

ok... that was genuinely funny

ArsTropica

I’m sure she doesn’t have it all figured out just yet. Did you read the post scripts?

Cole Jennett

And wouldn't the best way to have avoided this is being upfront about what's coming?

mikethemotormouth

Because for some reason most people hated it. I'm with you though

John A

Disappointed Fright Night is doing poorly.

RJ MacReady

I wish people would save their complaints about what’s “not” on the polls until after they know she isn’t watching their preferred film outright. Plus she’s mentioned more polls to come next week. Just chill out until you know for sure.

Cole Jennett

Yeah I expected the Treat poll to be full of fluff, but the Trick poll isn't much better.

Richard Maurer

Stop the count!

Shehab Dawoud

Anyone using "milady" in a sentence has no right to call out anyone else.

Richard Maurer

I do agree she should start with the 1st one, but after I’d like to watch Freddy v Jason and maybe the remake.

Dean Holt

I chose to believe she meant Scary but too Scary. Although this poll doesn't really reflect that.

Richard Maurer

Agreed. For one, Constantine and Underworld should have been in the same poll, if they had to be in any poll… or left out completely in my opinion. Both polls a little disappointing from my point of view. Maybe next week will be better.

Larry Darrell

first, to be clear, I'm not planning on taking my vote away from Fright Night, there's no reason to anyway. But in a situation like this where two films are far ahead I usually vote for the lesser of two evils. And my choice would be easy (Cabin) except that the idea of Cassis sitting there trying to get jokes she has no frame of reference for really bothers me. In the end I think I'll not vote for either one. This poll will have a disappointing ending for me no matter which one wins.

Richard Maurer

We get it man, you don't like Constantine (haha).

Joe

Joe, my guess is the realistic choices are really her: (1) reacting to Cabin without watching the movies you suggest or (2) reacting to Constantine. I prefer (1)

Clay F

Carrie (1976) is part of our culture. Blair Witch was also novel and significant when released. I prefer Cabin, Blair Witch, and Carrie over Contantine.

Clay F

Wow, Cabin is closing in on Constantine. Currently, Cabin losing by only 4 votes. I am crossing my fingers that Cabin overtakes Constantine which is mumbo jumbo. Any lack of context that Cassie experiences with Cabin due to her not being a horror-movie expert would be nothing compared to the massive confusion she would experience with Constantine. Looks like the two choices are her reacting to: (1) Constantine; or (2) Cabin without watching older horror movies people are suggesting she watch before reacting to Cabin. I prefer (2).

Clay F

Blair Witch should only be watched with the complimentary documentary that was made - it's a far superior product to the actual movie and explains so much of what's going on.

Story Archer

Blair Witch should only be watched with the complimentary documentary that was made - it's a far superior product to the actual movie and explains so much of what's going on.

Story Archer

you can't possibly believe that there is anything about Midsommar that Cassie would enjoy. She'd probably need therapy for a month.

Story Archer

I really feel like the only film on this list that Cassie might actually LIKE is Split... and it isn't doing too well.

Story Archer

The Village!!! How is The Village not on here? I've been pushing it for the past two years!!! Star-studded cast, incredible music - it's a love story pretending to be a scary movie, you've got to give this film a chance!

Story Archer

Helpful to me. I tend to agree with the consensus among critics. Here, for example, Constantine is mumbo jumbo and that is reflected in the critic consensus. I always decide for myself. I consider a lot of information, as well as my actual viewing of the movie if I have watched it, and in the end, I decide for myself. I posted Metacritic and RT scores for those who find that information generally helpful as one consideration.

Clay F

I would be shocked and amazed if Cassie ever got Carly to agree to watch Constantine (haha).

Joe

Good film, very entertaining. Would never finish high on a poll though.

Joe

Constantine and Cabin in the Woods are clearly going to win. Very doubtful that’s going to change. All you can do is support the films that should properly be there. I know I included Cabin in the Woods in my suggestion list, that I separated by decades. Wasn’t thinking about it overtaking better earlier films. I agree it would be better for Cassie to see more different kinds of horror films before, but at the rate she watches horror films… I guess that is the better one to watch. Perhaps a knowledge of different kinds of horror films might be enough, even though she hasn’t seen them. Although, thinking now, she might not have that knowledge. She will probably not understand what is actually happening in Cabin in the Woods, and probably watch it as a normal horror film. Lots of explaining in the comments afterwards is going to be required.

Larry Darrell

Blair Witch would never get my vote.

Joe

Constantine and Underworld got my votes, two of my favorite films.

Joe

Thanks so much for the Highlander spoiler, not everyone here has the watch-along tier.

Joe

Coddling? Excuse me. Some of us actually like feeling protective of them. Each to his own humanity, please.

John

John A, don't insult your fellow paying customers, okay? Be respectful of others opinions.

Joe

Who needs any of that, just watch something and decide for yourself.

Joe

No I'm not patting myself on the back. I'm just saying that even if its done elsewhere on YouTube the 3 i do follow has not done this movie.

David Freese

And as others have said Cabin in the Woods should really be seen only after the Evil Dead, Friday the 13th and a few others

Evil Darth Carl

Friday the 13th is the movie that really set the tone for all the “gore porn” and slasher genre movies. It should be seen for that reason alone. You won’t like it because of its nature but it would make for an interesting reaction. NOT Carly safe lol

Evil Darth Carl

Cabin is so sophomoric 😅 I mean it's bad 😊 in a mediocre sort-of way. I mean lukewarm. Add smiley face 🙂

Mannygogou

Somehow cabin in the woods flew under my radar, gonna have to watch that after seeing all these comments so hopefully it pulls ahead of Constantine

John A

People just need to stop coddling her. They're just movies, she can handle it

John A

Stop coddling her, she can handle it

John A

Most american horror remakes are dreadful. Something usually gets lost in translation, like a good script or they rely too heavily on jump scares rather than build genuine suspense and tension.

Bruce Reid

Really hoping that The Blair Witch Project or Cabin in the Woods win out. Would not be upset with Carrie winning either. Constantine? Really?

Mark Vaderr

It is a good movie. It's probably not as widely seen.

Mark Vaderr

The better movies don't always win in these polls.

Mark Vaderr

And Nosferatu

Mark Vaderr

I voted for it. Just remember that movie is jaded. You either love it or hate it. That's why it's only getting a decent amount of love.

Mark Vaderr

Yes, and I will be voting for it.

Mark Vaderr

People here said the same things when Cassie saw "Scream" for the first time. She didn't care about the references because the movie terrified her.

Mark Vaderr

Agreed. Friday the 13th has a couple good scares and some impressive special effects, but is considerably weak compared to Halloween or Nightmare on Elm Street.

Mark Vaderr

The fact that it's based on true events is what makes the movie so fascinating to me. I'm not a believer in possession, but still a scary film without any gore

Patrick Crippen

And I did vote for Fright Night, but it clearly has no chance.

Richard Maurer

Well, I meant something that actually has a chance of winning ;-). Also a lot good horror films have been made after 2000, but the majority of them are not from the big studios.

Richard Maurer

The Legend of Hell House (1973)

Larry Darrell

Better grouping in the polls could help, such as Decades. Constantine and Underworld should have been in the same poll, if they HAD to be a part of any poll. Hell, even according to these Trick or Treat poll classifications, Constantine should’ve been with Underworld in the other poll.

Larry Darrell

Meh the Friday the 13th movies aren't nearly so essential to Cabin's plot as much as Evil Dead, Hills Have Eyes, Cube, etc. Besides, I've zero interest in a Friday the 13th reaction after Scream

mikethemotormouth

Anything before the year 2000, I say.

Larry Darrell

Not entirely wrong hehe

mikethemotormouth

Why in the world is Constantine winning? And Cassie, you need to watch Friday the 13th, a few of them, before watching Cabin in the Woods.

Joe Monroe

It’s definitely got some humor in it, which will give Cassie a breather here and there. But I think the scares take it above the Scary But Not Too Scary threshold.

Dan M

Friday 13th and Carrie are the two influential horror movies of all time. I don't want to here anything about rip offs. There was a least 50 movies that ripped off Friday 13th. Halloween just ripped off Black Christmas. Friday 13th spawned 11 sequels and they are currently making a series for Peacock. Carrie (1976) they are now doing in theater Piper Laurie was nominated for An Academy Award for her role in it. Constantine was not original, not scary and largely forgotten about. Oh I know why because it's loosely based on the DC/Vertigo comic book Hellblazer graphic novels. It's a dweeby horror movie. No wonder it wasn't even remotely considered my friends just texted me saying it was a superhero horror movie. They called it a horror movie for nerds. Now it all makes sense. If you are going to a comic book horror movie Why not do Venom instead? That's a million times better. Besides the Holy Lance is in The Imperial Treasury in Vienna.

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

The two leaders are both a problem. Constantine is not really a horror movie, also not very good. Cabin is a great movie, but Cassie won't get a lot of the humor, having not seen many horror films. What to vote for?

Richard Maurer

Stay safe and good luck.

Richard Maurer

The other two are good picks though.

Richard Maurer

I could argue that Ready Player One wasn't worth seeing even if she had seen the necessary movies.

Richard Maurer

Ok if Hereditary is a no go, could Midsommar be considered? It’s not so much horror as just weird. With a little horror sprinkled in.

Miguel Tapia

Great film. One of the best movie monologues ever...and by Al Pacino to boot.

Chris Thom

Saw it once when it came out, don't remember a thing about it. And I have a really good memory, so.......

Richard Maurer

I’m not a big horror fan but Hereditary has great acting and great camera work. It’s a not just a good horror movie but a good movie overall. But lol yeah. It’s pretty scurry

Miguel Tapia

Didn't she get spoiled for Ft13th by watching Scream?

Brent Petty

I neither love or hate this movie it's just mid-level to me. Not worth voting for at all though.

Richard Maurer

IIRC, Exorcist is banned because she dislikes the "possessed child" genre in general.

Brent Petty

Sadly, The Exorcist is on her list of Movies Cassie Will Never Watch.

Brent Petty

@John - Thanks for saying this. the only thing I'd mention is - after letting us all know how much he hates horror he still voted in the poll? I hate rom-coms, so when Feb. rolls around I just don't vote. Why would someone vote in a poll they care nothing about?

Richard Maurer

I can agree with you on that one.👍

Toe Cutter

🤨

mikethemotormouth

I've got a hurricane bearing down on me, ain't no wrong time.

crazyivan

I'm even less of a fan The Shining than you. Wasn't impressed (or scared) when I saw it when it first came out, not impressed now. Whenever "name" directors try to make horror movies they end up making good movies, but not good horror movies. The best example of this is Francis Coppola's Dracula, which was more a romance than anything else. Doctor Sleep is a much better horror movie than The Shining.

Richard Maurer

@David- are you patting yourself on the back for not watching other reactors? You be you I guess.

Richard Maurer

+1 for Train to Busan. That film always does well on YT, but continues to get ignored here.

Richard Maurer

The best movie in the poll. Which, unfortunately, means it won't win.

Richard Maurer

The performances were actually really well done. Especially considering that none of them were seasoned actors. That works in the movie's favor imo.

Chris Thom

Critics have their own agendas like politicians, I listen to the people.

John

Yeah, it's an older haunted house movie with Roddy McDowell, good creepy ending, forget if it's 70s or early 80s.

John

Agree. The remake was really effective. But for Cassie individually the original might be a better introduction. The 2009 is on steroids and amphetamines.

Chris Thom

Always thought of Cabin as more of a dark comedy. I think she'd be alright.

Chris Thom

Black Sabbath, excellent, hadn't thought of it in a long time

John

Is that an older movie? Don't think I've heard of that one.

Chris Thom

Yeah Constantine feels like one she might watch at any point in the year. The time is now for Blair Witch.

Chris Thom

We were just talking about Blair Witch in another thread and now here it is! Also, wouldn't hate a reaction to Something Wicked This Way Comes.

FilmFanFred

Or like seeing Ready Player One w/out having seen some essential 80s movies

mikethemotormouth

It's like The Mummy last year, an action movie with horror overtones.

Richard Maurer

Agree with both posters.

Richard Maurer

Heck before I went to the coal mines, I used to be scared of scary movies, snakes, and red headed women. Now I just think that they are just funny and cute. Cassie will get there. I just hope she enjoys the show.

Uncle Phoenix

"It's got a death curse!"

Gro Do

Watching a movie with Carrie might actually be scary. Carly, not so much.

Richard Maurer

Highlander at least had some romance and Connery. Constantine's source materiel seems cool but this movie.... ew.

Gro Do

Good movie, wrong time

mikethemotormouth

Watching The Mist would take 2 years off her life. Not just the horror but the tragedy will hit her HARD.

Gro Do

Sooner or later she will HAVE to see it. It is mandatory for a list of most influential horror movies

Gro Do

Oooo yes! The Devils Advocate is perfect.

Gro Do

If someone had to sum up 70s and 80s horror into one movie thats Cabin in the Woods

Gro Do

Part the problem is what gets chosen for the polls, but you could rightly say that is the fault of the patrons too. I see so many recommendations in the comments sections that leave me confused, "you really like that movie?" .

Richard Maurer

Cabin In The Woods!!! Thor in a horror movie, what's not to like?

crazyivan

Man people lie to you about how scary some of these movies are. You absolutely 100% could handle Hereditary, The Exorcist, etc

John A

Same

Richard Maurer

Yeah with a poll full of movies that aren't scary in the slightest

John A

God I would love to see her watch Candyman

John A

Absolutely nothing about Constantine constitutes a place on an October scary poll

John A

Not a great movie by any means but still good, scary, and would make for a great reaction from her. But since the exorcist is on her "never" list, I'm sure that is too

John A

I remember thinking the book was way better

John A

The mental gymnastics you people resort to to justify being such an outcast is hilarious. And the fact that you think we're all gonna be so impressed with how different you are from everyone else... Will you ever wake up? Probably not, little snowflakes need to live in their fantasy worlds

John A

"stop reminding me that I'm one of 16 people on the planet that liked Constantine! Stop reminding me that my taste in movies is trash! Let me have this one little validation, it's all I have in life!"

John A

You might like it the most, but it's hardly the best choice for this channel in particular

John A

Have you ever reacted to The Exorcist from 1973? Perhaps Bride of Frankenstein from 1935? Perhaps Black Sabbath from circa 1967 with Boris Karloff? Just a few thoughts.

Peter Andrews

Adding my voice to the group pointing out that Cabin in the Woods gets better the more horror movies you have seen. It's like watching Deadpool without watching any X-men movies to compare to some recent watches.

Kniggit

Seriously don’t watch Constantine, you will hate it.

Aaron Ritchie

Yeah, we know who the "killer" was in that move ... I am referring to the .... scene ... in the canoe. Not trying to give away spoilers

Bill Maurer

And all the Hammer ones.

Richard Maurer

I'm aware that she'll probably watch It:2. I was commenting that none of the films here are in the same league. The movie I voted for, Fright Night, is probably the scariest movie here, which isn't saying much.

Richard Maurer

Considering how rarely Cassie reacts to B&W classics, is it really that shocking?

Richard Maurer

Better than Friday the 13th, but not by much.

Richard Maurer

If you know… you know.

Larry Darrell

Worst movie on this list, imo. Not scary, not interesting, or clever, and, to make things worse it features real-life animal abuse. No thanks.

Richard Maurer

Click the title, not the box

Larry Darrell

Ditto

Larry Darrell

You must be a very miserable person with a sad, empty life that you feel the need to make multiple posts just because you don't like a movie. it also says something about your character, that you have a complete lack of respect for not only the channel owner but the other patrons. Cassie created the poll, Cassie put the movie on it and the majority of patrons are in favour of it. But like I said I am very much enjoying your little meltdown of bitching and calling everyone else nasty names, because again you don't like a movie on a poll.....hahahahahaha

JimJames

@Mike LL One reason you may feel that you didn’t miss anything is because you didn’t. It’s a slow, boring, poorly executed and poorly acted movie. And it’s not scary. At all. The only thing it has going for it is people’s mistaken belief that it was the first “found footage” film. It wasn’t. “Cannibal Holocaust” came out twenty years earlier. For that matter, there were several Sasquatch movies that came out in the 70s that were faux documentaries (first cousin to found footage films). And “Ghostwatch” came out seven years earlier. “Blair Witch” wasn’t original, it wasn’t unique and it definitely wasn’t good.

Just Plain Bob

Cassie needs to be well versed in horror tropes before she watches that one. She's getting there, but still has a ways to go.

Richard Maurer

Thank you John A for your 'distinction' acknowledgement... I appreciate that. But still... I'll miss you all (and Cassie) during this month's long 'base exercise' you are...... "enjoying"?

Terry Yelmene

Fantastic movie that absolutely deserves a reaction. I just hope that Cassie reacts to it before the Godawful remake “Quarantine.”

Just Plain Bob

Carrie 4 Cassie!

Ricardo Rodriguez

Constantine isn't THAT bad but you're right, The Devil's Advocate is a way better movie in all regards.

David Collins

That scene just triggers my extreme distaste of children. Then they start running and screaming making me angry and confused because I can't see a damn thing.

mikethemotormouth

Yep, Constantine is mumbo jumbo.

Clay F

How can there be a Trick or Treat poll WITHOUT including the best Halloween-themed movie ever: Trick ‘r Treat (2007)!?!? I know it’s less known because it didn’t get a theatrical release, but everyone who has watched it agrees it’s a Halloween classic because it’s all about Halloween traditions. There couldn’t be a more perfect Halloween movie. It’s worth making an exception for so PLEASE Cassie watch it this year, and invite Carly too because it’s scary-but-not-too-scary.

Rod Reavern

Personally I dislike polls because of what is suggested & of course the results but I understand it's somewhat necessary to have them in order keep Patreons involved and their majority voices heard.

Shawn Kildal

Well Chris i usually don't hop from one reactor to the next so I haven't seen it reacted too. But hey you be you.

David Freese

Agreed it doesn't belong on the list. Still one of my favorites with Keanu and still need to see it on the channel.

mikethemotormouth

Fright Night is great fun

Grinznmore

Good lord Constantine is bad. I love me some Keanu, but it doesn't even belong on this list in the first place and if you're gonna watch another Keanu movie it should be Hardball before anything else, but The Devil's Advocate is far more appropriate for this poll and a far better movie than Constantine

John A

Some of us just really hate Jim Halpert and can't take him seriously in any role

John A

For the first time in your life your tastes are validated! By a handful of nerds in a small sample size of people that love a movie universally hated by everyone else. I'm glad you get to feel special for a least one little moment in your life

John A

The fact that we got a chance to have her watch an actual scary movie like Blair Witch but got Constantine instead is the ultimate SMH moment.

shaneth138

Rec (2007) is a great scary movie, not a lot of people seem to talk about

Bruce Reid

Don't get me wrong, I enjoy the movie. It's the book I prefer. The movie comes in second place, next to "The Thing" and I'm talking about the 80s version, not that crap from 2011.🤨

Toe Cutter

Carrie is so very scary, but it's also very sweet in that you can't help but like her.

Paul Stelter

Metacritic 50%, RT 46% = CONSTANTINE (2005) Metacritic 72%, RT 92% = CABIN IN THE WOODS (2011) Metacritic 86%, RT 93% = CARRIE (1976) Metacritic 80%, RT 86% = BLAIR WITCH PROJECT (1999)

Clay F

The only thing better than seeing that Constantine is winning is reading all the comments from grown men whining and crying about it.

JimJames

I am incongruent with the voting patron plurality on the channel, as indicated by the resutls of these two trick/treat polls.

Clay F

Halloween 2! I mean... come on!! (maybe it's on her list already)

Philip Alan

I need to watch it again then. I remember watching it right after I read the book which I thoroughly enjoyed and not liking it at all, maybe I should give it another try

John A

You either love or hate Blair Witch. I love it. Despite what the people that hate it think about it, it would still make for a good reaction channel movie

John A

Come on.. the scene where you hear the kids in the woods at night is terrifying! In general, fear of the unknown and unseen is a great and scary concept.

Shehab Dawoud

I would like to see you and Carrrie watch the movie - The Ring

Steve Grad

These wimps aren't watching any of those movies. Most fragile women on the planet

John A

Oh yeah I can't wait for Cassie to not understand what's happening or why 🤪

mikethemotormouth

Stephen King is probably the one single solitary person on the planet with the same opinion as you

John A

@John A Careful about the name calling in here.

Shehab Dawoud

No one cares that you dislike something so many people enjoy. No one. You're sooooooooooooooooooo different we're all SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO impressed

John A

Such a guilty pleasure for me. I don't know why that movie just does it for me

John A

"regular people" is a bit of a stretch when talking about people that loved Constantine

John A

As far as movie reactions go Blair Witch tops this poll EASILY. Instead she's gonna watch that absolutely forgettable trash Constantine

John A

Because the large majority of patreon followers are weirdo dorks so naturally their taste in movies is cringe at best

John A

i actually prefer the 2011 remake of fright night to the original

diego kontarovsky

Agree with the people suggesting 'The Devil's Advocate'. That is the ONLY Keanu horror movie we should be getting.

Shehab Dawoud

Speak the truth, brother. Don't let them silence you!

Shehab Dawoud

???

Mike Lemon

Please add the Devil’s advocate if you haven’t seen it

Miguel Tapia

I want to recommend Drag Me to Hell & The Mist too, but I just can't bring myself to that to Cassie

Shawn Kildal

Constantine sucks come on guys. She’s going to hate it more than she hated Highlander. Why do the worst movies on the list always win these polls? Underworld is winning the other one too smh. I gotta unsubscribe. I have watched like 2-3 things Cassie has watched in the last 4 months.

shaneth138

Kind of a joke on my part, kinda not. As hilarious as Cassie's reaction to that would be, it'd mess her up, especially since she's got a son who's almost a teenager.

William Bryan

I didn't think anyone else had heard of Strangeland. I'm the only one who has recommended it on the app, so if you can you may want to give it a vote on there.

Mike Lemon

Clay! I'm 66 and have seen plenty of horror movies even though I don't care for most... 'however' as someone who loves the 'art' of great movies... for me... 'The Shining' is the very best of the genre. BTW, Cassie's react for 'The Shining' is 'classic' too.

Terry Yelmene

@Chris - Strangeland is the Dee Snider (Twisted Sister) one.

Mike Lemon

Yeah, and how badly do we want to see an unsuspecting Carly react to this one??

Kent Theaker

Obviously, this is where I was a Below Average Dave, Shehab 🤣

Above Average Dave

Uh, about that . . .

Mike LL

Hey, I've never watched Blair Witch, never wanted to, and I don't feel I've missed anything!

Mike LL

I sent you Constantine so long ago so this had better win.

Timothy Burrows

I think most would enjoy it. It's got some of that good Rear Window/Disturbia neighbor intrigue that works really well.

Chris Thom

Agree. Perfect for this channel.

Chris Thom

A classic. Always have some extra nostalgia for that one because it came out really close to the day I was born.

Chris Thom

It's been done to death on other channels. That might be why.

Chris Thom

Not sure if I remember that one. Was that from the same people who did The Collector series?

Chris Thom

A lot of good ones. But I think Blair Witch would make for a great reaction on this particular channel.

Chris Thom

You're right. 227 movie critics gave it an average score of %46, conveniently left out that 250000+ regular people have it's avage score at %72.

JimJames

Wish the Legend of Hell House had hit one of the polls

John

FRIDAY THE 13th because it's kinda cheesy but fun at the same time, FRIGHT NIGHT a true 80's vampire classic, and CONSTANTINE because hey Keanu Reeves, what more do you need lol🤣 Those are my votes for this poll 😁👍

Wesley White

She’s seen way bloodier ones

Lance Li

Questions to ask? #1 How Original was it? None It was like The Exorcist meets Demons meet Night Of The Demons meets The Devil's Advocate. #2 How Scary was it? The Keanu Reeves movie Knock Knock (2015) was much scarier # 3. How did it influence pop culture? After the second one it was largely forgotten while Friday 13th (1980) Carrie (1976) it's influence still goes on today #4. Box Office Results, it's saving grace $75 million in US and Canada $230 million world wide #5. Fans score, This will go in the win column with Popcorn Meter 72% IMDB score of 7.0 Cabin In The Woods (2011) made our list so did Friday 13th (1980) and Carrie (1976) was the highest ranked I think at #15

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

Carrie is too bloody I think for Carly, the newer remake sucks milady, don't waste you re time on it. of the others I think you'd have it easier with Constantine than Cabin in the Woods.

John

Carrie was so iconic. You're kinda obligated to see that one just for the memes

Kuskesh Haramzadeh

You didn’t get it.

Shehab Dawoud

Jackson Harper

It won’t win, but “Something Wicked” is just the kind of creepy that would work for Cassie without her cowering under the blanket the whole time! 😊

Rick Moreno

Fright Night has some very good gore. Also some people won't pick up on the underlying comedic tone of the film

Thin White Duke

Yes the more horror films you've seen the more movie references and tropes you will recognise

Thin White Duke

We should have watched it last Friday 13th. It should be the law

Thin White Duke

I sometimes get that. For me it works by clicking areas right next to the box you want to vote for.

My_Cousin_Mose

Yeah it did poorly on Jen Murray's poll too. We'll get to it eventually, Cassie would love it

Thin White Duke

She won't get Cabin in the Woods, the fewer horror films the viewer has seen the less effective it is

Thin White Duke

Cabin in the Woods is fun too!

Don

Fright Night 1985, then Carrie

V M

Constantine is 47% fresh on RT. 🤦🏽‍♂️

Marcos

Good point about CABIN IN THE WOODS but a positive is better choice than CONSTANINE.

Clay F

Fright Night is a lot of fun.

David Blount

Constantine gets worse after the first 30 minutes.

Clay F

I can't click a choice for some reason, but I pick"Carrie"

Don

Looks like it doesn't stand a chance in the poll.

Clay F

Looks like Fright Night (1985) doesn't stand a chance in the poll. I wouldn't mind seeing Cassie react to Fright Night (1985).

Clay F

Fright Night 1985!!!!!!

V M

True - Paranormal Activity is quite good in the found footage space.

Mark Duedall

I wanna see Cassie watch Strangeland. 🤣🤣

William Bryan

Ok maybe it is just me. I found it absolutely terrifying.

Mark Duedall

I think we would've had grounds for a class action suit 🤣

Above Average Dave

I am 61 and not a horror movie kind of guy, but I think The Shining is a work of art. I saw Friday the 13th (1980) in the theater when released but don't really remember it. I was able to get in even though age 16.

Clay F

Cabin heavily references the Evil Dead lore so there's that but also features nods to The Ring/Ringu, Hellraiser, The Hills Have Eyes, Cube...need I go on?

mikethemotormouth

I really liked Life as well. It's somewhat derivative, like Alien meets the Blob, but it was done really well and is quite effective and creepy.

Stranger2Reality

Maybe the Bottom 100

Clay F

Cassie, you have toughened up right? Never mind...I forgot about "War of the Worlds"(haha).

Joe

Yeah it's not doing well in this poll, but I absolutely love Fright Night. Hopefully Cassie sees it someday.

Stranger2Reality

Such a boring movie. All I got out of it was a slight case of motion sickness.

Just Plain Bob

I saw it at home way later and was so upset I wasted my time. Does that count?

mikethemotormouth

Richard, she almost for sure has It:2 already scheduled. Constantine will be plenty scary for her and a fun watch, for me anyway.

Joe

Am I the only one who saw BLAIR WITCH in the theater and wanted my money back? Plus a separate award of funds for having wasted that much time out of my life?

Above Average Dave

Constantine will be plenty scary for Cassie (haha), and she already mentioned in one of the premiere chats it was "highly likely" this October.

Joe

It's a very good watch IMO, sadly it will never get high on any polls.

Joe

I think that one she has already selected.

Joe

I am not a fan of Blair Witch Project but it is the original -- something to watch b/c of the historical aspect of it being novel and somewhat impactful when released.

Clay F

I have similar sentiment. I voted A Quiet Place. I don't like Constantine b/c mumbo jumbo. I voted Cabin in hope that Cabin will overtake Constantine.

Clay F

Constantine is just not a good movie and I truly believe Cassie will hate it When my friends and I along with several horror websites we're putting together the Top 100 horror movies of all time that one was immediately thrown out. It probably wouldn't even make the Top 200.

Zachary K. (Verified Swiftie)

Oh NO! Now comes that part of the year when I have to forget about watching reaction videos for 31 days. I really, really dislike this wild obsession with horror (it's horrible). Then again, I've never seen 'Blair Witch' even though I recall being intrigued by all the scuttlebutt it caused when it came out... so... I voted.

Terry Yelmene

I can understand that and everyone has their own opinion. For example, The Shining, from 1980, almost everyone I know like that movie. It's okay, I'll give it a B, but it's not an A+ to me, sorry.🤷 I'm in my 60s and I've seen all of those 80s horror movies in the theater, including The Shining. The original Friday the 13th blew me away back then and I saw all of the 80s Friday the 13th movies when they first came out. So I do have a fondness for them. You are entitled to your opinion, just like me, screw what others think.

Toe Cutter

If Constantine wins I recommend viewing with Carley. It's not too gory and it is Keanu Reeves. I think you both will like it. Cabin in the woods is great, but it's pretty gory. While I think Carley would really like the characters, I feel she may mis a lot of the film from covering her eyes or looking away.

DM DC

Cabin in the Woods…oh boy. This might be a “Ben, get in here now!” reaction. So excited to see Fright Night on this poll! And so disappointed that’s its doing so poorly. I’m begging you…make it a Popcorn Pick of the Month. Such a fun movie, great practical effects, and some nice scares without being too scary. I think even Carly would enjoy this movie. 🤞🤞🤞🤞

Dan M

I voted for Friday the 13th. Hopefully one day they’ll have Childs Play, Candyman or Texas Chainsaw Massacre on the poll.

Carlos Molina

I agree, Paranormal Activity is much better - serious creepy factor. I just thought everyone had seen Blair Witch Project. I personally preferred the sequel non-ff Blair Witch better.

John Callahan

Some good movies on here, but voted for Constantine. I know I’m probably in the minority but I actually think the Friday the 13th remake from 2009 is so much better that the original as it just doesn’t hold up very well now. But if you are going to dip your toe into it eventually you obviously have to start with that one.

Dean Holt

I’d really like to see a poll of Canadian horror films for Scary But Not Too Scary. Films could include (but not limited to): *Ginger Snaps *My Bloody Valentine (original) *The Changeling (1980) *Black Christmas *Pontypool *Cube *Terror Train (starring Jamie Lee Curtis) *Videodrome

Just Plain Bob

Lots of things I want to see on the channel but nothing even close to scary. So where's It Chapter Two??

mikethemotormouth

“Blair Witch” made me vaguely sick to my stomach from the shaky cam and that’s it. Such a boring, overrated film. Not even a little bit scary. It’s been touted as the first “found footage” film but it didn’t even accomplish that much. “Cannibal Holocaust” preceded it by 20 years.

Just Plain Bob

Agreed. Most are not that scary or scary at all. I like Constantine but would not rate as scary. The ones that are just not that good. Blair Witch usally just gives me motion sickness and Cabin in the Woods just not good.

T.L.A

Lucky, sadly i was too young to see it at the cinema, but i watched it everytime it came on TV.

Jasbro

I can't believe how few votes A Quiet Place is getting. Love both movies but I like or love most of the films here so let's see what wins. P.s. one of the few I don't like is Constantin because his story is done better in other media.

David Freese

Yeah, most of us haven't read the comics. Yet, I like seeing comments on the underlying comics of movies.

Clay F

Hopefully Train to Busan and Panic Room are under consideration. Those Carly could handle. I don't even consider PR a horror. Just a great suspense thriller.

Brent Petty

Actually I've never watched it either never got the appeal of lost footage movies.

David Freese

Eh. None of those are really that good.

Jacob Balaam

You misspelled V/H/S, the one good example of the genre I've seen yet

mikethemotormouth

It's okay. Paranormal Activity is a better example of the found footage genre.

Brent Petty

Currently in a distant last place. Is the book better than the movie? I read Ray Bradbury stuff when I was a kid.

Clay F

+1 for both Carrie and Cabin.

Clay F

Currently in a distant last place.

Clay F

You really haven't seen Blair Witch Project? You (and Carly) may be the last two holdouts in the entire world.

John Callahan

Something Wicked is a good creepy movie.

Jeffrey Joll

Many good ones here, though not Carly-friendly. Voting Carrie because the entire cast is excellent but clearly Sissy Spacek and Piper Laurie turn in career-high performances. I also though this movie was much better than the novel, something you can't say about many Steven King adaptations. Cabin in the Woods is wierdly fun. Still hoping for Near Dark. Or have you already reacted to that one? Bill Paxton (though not much like his Twister role) is awesome, as is the entire cast.

John Callahan

Some good movies! Can you find "The Prowler" 1981? It's a good, underrated slasher from director Joseph Zito and make up icon Tom Savini.

Toe Cutter

Oh, Something Wicked This Way Comes! Great story by Ray Bradbury. I used to watch it on the Disney Channel back in the day. Perfect choice for “scary but not too scary.”

Silver Machine

Amen. Need reactions to ALL the Universal classic monster movie.

Just Plain Bob

I'm all about Constantine and Cabin In The Woods. Also, Cassie loves Keanu, so it works out

Walter

Dracula 1931

Brian Wood

Yep. And it’s lived off that jump scare for almost fifty years. It’s actually a well made, well acted movie. When I say “overrated”, I’m talking about as a horror movie. It’s simply not scary and I don’t think it was meant to be. It’s more of a coming of age film, though very dark. Kinda like “Stand By Me”, which makes sense because they’re both based on Stephen King stories (although very different at the same time).

Just Plain Bob

I will skip the reaction to Constantine (2005). Constantine (2005) has the beauty Rachel Weisz and cool aspects, but is confusing/incoherent. I voted Cabin in the Woods (2011). I voted Carrie (1976) b/c part of our culture. I voted Blair Witch Project (1999) even though I didn't really like Blair when released -- yet, was novel at the time.

Clay F

Agree. It’s another of those that’s best enjoyed if you’ve seen some of the films it references, the most obvious being “Evil Dead.”

Just Plain Bob

Oh damn, Constantine!!! It's been a while since we watched a live action DC film on the channel. Pretty sure the last live action DC reaction was The Batman, Mask of the Phantasm being the last DC project in general. Though I have to say that Constantine: City of Demons, the animated movie, is a much better film, with a stronger depiction of the character. But if you go into the 2005 live-action movie with zero knowledge of Constantine, you’ll still enjoy it. It’s just very different from the comics in how Constantine looks, acts, and sounds. But it's a unique take on the character just like I said a very differant one to the comics.

LittleGalaxyBoy

Great, great movie. Really doesn’t get the credit it deserves. Plus it’s a family film!

Just Plain Bob

One of the most overrated movies ever. Wasted 80 + minutes of my life on that

Bill Maurer

FANTASTIC film that doesn’t get nearly enough love.

Just Plain Bob

Original Friday the 13th and Cassie's first (and probably only encounter) with none other than Jason Vorhees

Bill Maurer

Let’s go Constantine !

Greg Florez

Is "PMS" a joke? Because that's pretty funny. PS- I voted for Fright Night PMS-I also voted for Carrie ;)

clutchkman

It has one big jumpscare tho

Eli van Aggelen

It also happens to be the best movie in the poll.

Just Plain Bob

Constantine here and Underworld over there. Hmm. It’s still early though.

Larry Darrell

“Carrie” is vastly overrated. It wasn’t scary forty years ago when I first watched it and it isn’t scary now. I don’t even think it belongs in the horror genre. It’s more of a coming of age/melodrama.

Just Plain Bob

Indeed.

Mike LL

If CONSTANTINE wins this (and I'd be fine with that), I'd like to see it paired up with THE PROPHECY so that Cassie can see (arguably) the two best depictions of Lucifer in cinema.

Matt Rose

I love all these movies, but "Fright Night" would be an awesome reaction.

Cliff Endicott

I voted for it. As much movie rite of passage as an individual film.

Jason Chirevas

Well said

Clay F

I voted for it. A total classic, I saw it in the cinema when it came out. I was young and found it very creepy 🙂

Tina P

CABIN IN THE WOODS all the way. Lots of good ones in this poll, though. FRIGHT NIGHT is a hoot.

Matt Rose

I never understood the hype around Blair Witch. I saw it in the theatre when it came out and the entire group I went with, including myself, found it boring, tedious and not the least bit scary. I haven't watched it since. Plenty of people seem to enjoy it though, so maybe it's worth giving it a second chance? I wouldn't object to it, but it would certainly be my last pick of the bunch.

Ian Tonge

A lot of good ones here, which makes me wonder what is already planned. I have a suspicion (fear) they won’t be that good or scary, which makes it even worse that a non-scary one like Constantine is winning. But who knows, one of the few times where I’m hoping to be proven wrong!

Shehab Dawoud

Split would be fun to see her react to

Coen Taylor

It’s pretty shocking Cassie hasn’t watched ARSENIC AND OLD LACE yet.

Jason Chirevas

It's not. It rules no matter when you grew up.

Daniel Allen

Constantine isnt all that scary really, but that may be why its the better choice. No need to traumatize the reactor...

Miguel

It’s fairly nuts how good the Constantine show was. Not that anyone noticed.

Jason Chirevas

Good grief..

Shehab Dawoud

Im shocked more people dont want her to watch Blair Witch.

Jasbro

Constantine is leading? Seriously, guys? Serves me right for reappearing…

Jason Chirevas

One of these days, DARK CITY will be on a poll. 🫤

Steven Perez

I'm...split between split and cabin in the woods. Both so good....

Brogan

"The Exorcism of Emily Rose"

Patrick Crippen

Yes that is much more her speed than a lot of these movies!

Joel Cagle

Looking at this list I'm struggling to find anything that qualifies as Scary but too Scary. Nothing in the league of It: Chapter 1 anyway. Don't get me wrong, there are some good choices here, but they're just not that scary.

Richard Maurer

Def agree with cabin in the woods, i feel like that movie is for horror fanatics

Andrew Heller

Alot of these are great choices but really hoping for Cabin in the Woods or Split. Cabin is much more appreciated after you've seen a plethora of horror films as its more of a celebration of horror cliches wrapped in a fairly clever story. Kind of a new age Scream if you will. And Split just for James McAvoy's performance alone. Mind blown.

Blake Evans

I have to think that Cassie would love WITCHES OF EASTWICK. It has a stellar cast with a fair bit of humor and just scary enough in the right places.

T.J. Gengler

Some corkers here. Voted for Constantine and cabin in the woods. Fyi. Constantine TV series is awesome. Only lasted a season but pure gold like swamp thing.

rakesh

Yes Constantine! The all mighty Keanu must be seen 🤣

Joel Cagle

I'm not a big fan of horror and especially slasher movies BUT I agree that " Arsenic and Old Lace" would be perfect for Halloween. Or.. failing that "Quiet Place Day One" .

Anthony Perez

There are some good ones on here, I'm trying to talk myself out of voting for like 6 of them. I loved Fright Night when I was younger, but I'm not sure if it's one of those 80's movies you had to grow up with to enjoy it.

BibbitduBois

I’ll be PUB in October! 🫣😅

Ike

Hoping for Friday The 13th or Fright Night. Cabin In The Woods would be good to. Something scary for Cassie for another poll, Candyman, Final Destination or I Know What You Did Last Summer. For a fun one(not scary for Cassie) Happy Death Day.

Katie Jackson

C'mon people - Fright Night. That movie just kicks so much "A$$" as Cassie would say. A total must-see 80s classic.

Daniel Allen

New post - still rooting for "Carrie"...

Jens Kristensen

All I want is IT chapter 2. Must close out the series!

Bobilicious

Neither is Constantine, which is out to an early lead. I'm voting for Fright Night because it's easily one of the coolest and funnest movies on this list, and one of the best horror genre classics of the 80s. It's also definitely scarier than Constantine in any case.

Daniel Allen

Constantine for me, apparently a second one on the way. and a second choice Split! (James McAvoy / Anya)👌

Grégory Gautier

Not really a horror movie fan. But I enjoyed Constantine though. So that one gets my vote

Robert da Spruce

Fright Night all the way!!!!!

Joel Baumgartner

I voted for Blair Witch, and Cabin in the Woods. Constantine will probably win, but I got about 30 minutes into and felt that was enough😂

Cole Jennett

Unfortunately that film is on Cassies' banned list

Richard Maurer

My top 10 wish list for October: The Crazies, Dawn of the Dead (2004), The Omen (1976), Fright Night, Promethius, Brightburn, Don't Breathe, The Shallows, and Happy Death Day.

Shawn Kildal

Wow. Cassie is going hard this year, facing fears and crushing obstacles.

Uncle Phoenix

https://youtu.be/QRG1dbpoar8?si=BkEp0gWdBgbgIMu9

Wrench_In_The_Works

I think CARRIE is an excellent movie. I"m not sure that Cassie has seen enough genre movies to appreciate all that CABIN IN THE WOODS has to offer. But I would like to suggest again ARSENIC AND OLD LACE (1944) as a Halloween themed comedy and a great Cary Grant movie! (Edit: Of course I didn't read all the text before I commented, and realize that ARSENIC AND OLD LACE would fit nicely in the Treat category and hope it might be in the Treat poll next week!) (Another Edit: Did I say next week? My fave is in the other poll NOW! My heart!!)

Mike LL

haha NEVER!

Cassie

I hope they include Life 2017 with Ryan Reynolds and Jake Gilianhall. Such a fantastic horror movie! Very simple concept with an incredible execution. One very underrated movie that deserves better!

Edwin

I think Carrie (1976) would leave Cassie in tears, rather than in terror!

JONATHAN REDFERN WILLIAMS

Anything but Blair Witch please.

T.J. Gengler

Fright Night isn't all that scary, if I remember correctly.... 🤔

Dirk-Jan (DJ)

Paranormal and Monster squad should be on this

MatthewBrown74m

Popcorn Under Bed!

Cassie

I'd like to suggest The Host (2006) as a great horror movie that should also be quite Carly friendly.

Henry Graham

Voting for Constantine because, Keanu Reeves! And because they finally have a Constantine 2 coming! Script is done and it probably won’t come out until 2026 or something like that but it’s been a long time coming and in an interview several years ago Keanu was asked if there was a role he’d ever played that he would love to do a sequel for and Constantine was who he picked that he wanted to revisit so I can’t wait!

Wrench_In_The_Works

Keanu and "Constantine" are a perfect fit for the channel. Especially since there's word of a sequel coming out.

R F.

Cabin in the Woods is definitely the best made and most original film of this poll

Collin Palmer

🤣 I wish you all a fantastic PIB October! I’ll be under the bed, hiding.

Ike

Blair Witch is probably more suitable for you Cassie. Not gory, but very suspenseful. Friday the 13th is good but it's obviously a Halloween knockoff with more blood & violence. It's still worth a watch for its interesting plot developments...

Raj K. Dixit

I wouldn’t recommend Cabin in the Woods for someone who isn’t very seasoned with horror movies.

Tim Borzi

Any of these could win and I'd be excited to watch!

IngloriousPrime8

I predict a photo finish for Blair Witch

Rosario Cicero

Cabin in the woods might be fun for you but also the Orginal Friday isn’t that scary

Neil Varma

Come on Friday the 13th!!! Cassie has seen Halloween and Nightmare on Elm Street, she's got to get this one in to complete the top 3!!

Todzilla

Put Drag Me to Hell on the list

William Jackson

Fright night is a greaaatt 80s horror movie

Andrew Heller

Quick edit for ya: “Some SCARY but **not** too scary”

Ben Forrester

Put Hereditary on this list

Miguel Tapia