TOYSHK (mini comic #540)

With the reveal Monty is an older animatronic, like appears in SOTM, this genuinely had me thinking about Andrew again.. Andrew, is a ghost kid from the books, who keeps haunting William Afton, and is both in the switch wrath and fetch. With everything we know about him, the recent developments, and the ITP game

I definitely think Andrew is the vengeful spirit or also known as “the one you shouldn’t have killed”

I still think Cassidy exists too, I don’t think one existing cancels out the other at all. A couple things that never added up for me, for Cassidy being TOYSHK is the “the one you shouldn’t have killed” line… like why Cassidy out of the 5 kids was she the one William shouldn’t have killed?

I think this line makes more sense with Andrew, if Andrew was not planned to be murdered like the other 5, it makes sense, he LITERALLY wasn’t supposed to be killed.

Cassidy is also characterized, to be angry for sure, but also sweet to cc. In the survival logbook they make an effort to help them remember their name and pass on. In the fnaf movie even, Cassidy is nice to Abby, and was just trying to lure Mike to kill William for him. Cassidy personality as we know it doesn’t line up with the vengeful spirit, who seemingly holds other spirits down just to keep torturing William

This does make sense for Andrew though, seeing Andrew has literally killed other kids before as fetch, etc. It seems more likely he’d do the events of UCN, I even think he’s holding down Cassidy and that’s why we see the golden Freddy suit still active, cause Andrew is holding Cassidy down with him. Why old man consequences shows up as an alligator too, it’s to match Andrew,,

This is all just a theory (a game theory) but I think this makes a lot of sense, I’m not sure why Andrew existing would ever cancel out Cassidy, or vice versa. That was a silly rule to have, I think they both exist, and I think they are both angry, but Andrew is the main one doing these things. Super fun to draw out some horror again!! William’s wide eye shocked look just creeps me out too,, like he didn’t expect Andrew and is fearful of being caught. Anyway!! I hope you enjoy this comic!! 🩵💜