BTC 2.0: Chapter 13

-- CHAPTER 13: Into the Blue --

****

“What just happened?” I asked Sam in bewilderment, watching Eva run away from my arms in tears without any hint as to why she’d started crying in the first place.

Sam had followed us to the shoreline and didn’t immediately answer, so I started after Eva for a few steps before Sam caught my arm and tugged me back.

“Let me talk to her,” she suggested. “It’s usually easier to talk to another girl about this emotional stuff than to talk to the guy she clearly doesn’t know how she should feel about.”

I sighed and nodded my acquiescence, watching my Head Girlfriend jog after the distraught damsel. But Sam was no more successful than I might’ve been, as I saw the two girls have only a very brief conversation with Eva’s hand palm-out, evidently asking Sam to please leave her alone. And then Eva continued walking down to the far end of the beach in solitude while Sam returned to me.

Sam and I chatted briefly in speculation as to what could’ve possibly set Eva off. But neither of us had a really good understanding of what made that girl tick. In the end we simply had to throw up our hands and hope we’d get another opportunity later. It pained me to see a girl I had come to care about in emotional turmoil, and I felt driven to do whatever I could to help her out. And Sam considered Eva part of The BTC 2.0 - nevermind those initiation rites of passage Belle semi-joked about that Eva had sworn off - and she felt a sort of Mama Bear responsibility for the wellbeing of every girl in her personal circle of friends.

Belle and Lily were the first ones to return, but just to ask us to come over and check out their “Masterpiece Sandcastle”.

“Hey, where’d Eva go?” Belle asked, glancing around.

“Went for a walk by herself,” Sam answered, pointing down the beach.

“She does that a lot. Goes off by herself,” Lily remarked. “You know I’ve got a deal with her dad to report back whether or not she’s being anti-social. I’ll end up telling him she went for a walk today, but otherwise she’s been pretty chill with the whole group, right?”

I nodded my agreement. “So let’s check out this ‘Masterpiece’, huh?”

“You’re gonna love it,” Belle enthused.

I had to admit: for a couple of girls digging in the wet sand without a single shovel or bucket, they’d made a pretty cool sandcastle. It wasn’t about to win any awards or anything, but there was a central keep, an outer wall with a fair number of crenellations, and a shallow moat around the perimeter with a piece of driftwood for a bridge. Sam and I were both suitably impressed, and after noticing the four of us clustered together, Naimh and Skylar both came over and subsequently ooh’d and ahh’d over the girls’ creation as well.

Eventually, the six of us returned to our beach spot and collected my frisbee. We took turns passing it around to each other in a wide circle that morphed and collapsed over the next ten minutes as one of us or another had to chase down errant tosses.

I wound up standing right next to Lily and started reaching over her to catch every toss thrown our way, teasing the little shorty in much the same way I’d long teased Belle ever since getting my growth spurt. Belle certainly remembered, because she was having a total hoot watching Lily squeal and scramble, never quite able to beat me to a catch. But then in a sudden moment of inspiration, Lily actually dragged my swim trunks down to my ankles, leaving me not only hobbled but also with my junk hanging out. And she giggled with glee as she raced over to the flying disc and neatly caught it before thrusting both arms up in victory.

Meanwhile, I yanked my swim trunks back up and blushed while glancing around the beach, hoping nobody had seen that. But of course with five scantily-clad, buxom beauties bouncing around as they raced across the sand trying to catch frisbee tosses, you can bet there were a bunch of eyeballs pointed in our direction, and I caught a couple of guys fifty yards away pointing at me and laughing.

And then I saw a pair of women in their thirties. One of them was holding her hands apart in the universal gesture for, ‘I caught a fish this biiig’ before miming a jacking-off motion, and the other woman shook her head while gawking at me in disbelief.

On the other side of me, Naimh seemed to be laughing at a bewildered Skylar, who had apparently missed my de-pantsing and found herself in a circle of giggling girls. Neevie clued her in, and Lily extended her arm to flash a triumphant V-sign when the English lass’s head whipped towards us, before gently tossing Skylar the frisbee.

I didn’t notice Eva rejoining our circle until the next time I caught the frisbee and then glanced around looking for whom I wanted to throw it to next. She’d walked into the gap between Sam and Naimh, neither of whom noticed her since their immediate attention was on me with the frisbee. But I called out her name, “Eva!” in a loud voice and deliberately sent the disc on a straight line for her.

Unfortunately, the disc started tipping on its side about twenty feet away from her and faded to the left in a shallow curve. I blame the wind. It went straight to Naimh instead, crashing into the sand a few feet in front of her. The redhead scampered forward and picked it up. But rather than toss the frisbee immediately, my Irish girlfriend skipped across the miniature dunes to Eva, handed her the frisbee, and then after a moment, she suddenly wrapped up the other girl in a hug.

I couldn’t hear what Naimh was saying to Eva, but the hapa girl just sort of froze in place with her hands out to the sides, not immediately hugging Naimh back. I knew exactly what that felt like and chuckled to myself. But eventually Eva patted Naimh’s shoulder lightly with her free hand, extricated herself from the redhead’s hug, and then took a step to the side to toss the frisbee in the vague direction of Belle.

Beyond that, nobody asked Eva where she’d gone off to or why. We simply accepted her back into the circle as if nothing had ever happened and moved on. The seven of us remained a single large group for the remainder of the afternoon, laughing and playing and generally having a good time. After frisbee, we all got back into the water (including me this time). But after we’d all exhausted ourselves, we returned to our beach spot, dried off, and just relaxed for the rest of the day.

The sun started coming down after 6pm, with the weather cooling off. Everyone put their shirts and shorts back on, with the two Hawaiian girls (who were used to warmer weather) donning jackets as well. We ate some snacks, finished the rest of the beers, and chatted about whatever came to mind. Belle spent part of that time sitting in my lap atop the beach mat while I wrapped my arms around her, occasionally engaging in my favorite pastime by copping feels of her big boobies.

At one point, I had just finished copping a feel when Belle grabbed my hand and held it on her tit, continuing her conversation while squeezing my palm a little tighter around the globe. Lily noticed and started giggling, and then all of a sudden, Belle was sliding out of my lap while not-so-subtly pointing at me for Lily to go take her place.

The Hawaiian hottie blushed but I opened my arms and invited her willingly. The cute coed contentedly parked her cutie patootie in my lap and then physically wrapped my arms around her, with my right hand molded around her left breast. But my hand was outside of her jacket, and a moment later she redirected my hand beneath the hems of both her jacket and her shirt, tucking my palm within the cup of her bikini so that she could feel my fingers directly against her bare skin.

“I wish I didn’t have to wait a whole ’nother week to have our date,” Lily whispered coyly, pressing the side of her cheek into the side of mine.

“Well you don’t have to wait a whole ’nother week if you don’t want to,” Belle murmured from right next to us, her eyebrows waggling.

I shot my impish “little sister” a warning look, and she blushed and stared down at her lap for a moment.

“The whole point of making a date for more than a week away was to not only give me time to set up a really nice date,” I reminded them both, “but also to make sure Lily had plenty of space to really think things through. No pressure: remember, B?”

“I know, I know.”

“And thank you for not pressuring me,” Lily said, molding my hand around her breast. “It’s knowing you’re such a thoughtful, considerate guy that makes me feel comfortable doing this. The horny part of me wants to do it right away, but the nervous part of me is glad it’s not happening just yet.”

Belle giggled. “Not yet. But ‘no pressure’ or not, if you find yourself ultra-horny tonight after we take our bikinis off and wanna find out what it feels like to have Matty’s massive--”

“B, seriously,” I cut her off, rolling my eyes and shaking my head while pulling my hand out from underneath Lily’s jacket. Clearly, nothing had been learned whatsoever in the aftermath of Belle’s attempted… R-word… And I silently cursed myself for giving into lust with Belle crooning for me to “punish” her instead of sticking to my guns. I knew I’d basically enabled her continued behavior instead of teaching her an actual lesson, but I swore to myself it wouldn’t happen again.

Fortunately, Belle piped down and let me snuggle with Lily in peace. I wrapped both arms around Lily’s midsection and nuzzled her neck and cheek with my nose. The three of us went silent for a minute while the others kept nattering on about something else. But eventually, Lily turned her face to mine again and murmured, “You know, my mom always told me: Our people exist to go out into the blue.”

I mused on that, my eyebrows knitted in concentration, although the meaning didn’t immediately hit me.

Lily smiled at my expression and explained, “It was her way of challenging me to get over my fears. Now I’m sure she never meant it as encouragement to lose my virginity, but I find myself thinking about her words right now. ‘Into the blue’ is a pretty common phrase for ‘into the unknown’. But more specifically, it’s about venturing out into the open ocean. My ancestors set out from Polynesia on wa’a kaulua: outrigger canoes. They didn’t have compasses or astrolabes. They were wayfinders who had no idea the Hawaiian Islands would be there when they arrived, but they ventured out anyway.”

“I remember reading about that a while back. The whole idea of navigating without instruments was pretty cool. And it must’ve been terrifying for people who didn’t personally know how to do it. They’d have to put a lot of trust into their guides.”

Lily’s smile broadened. “The way I feel comfortable putting my trust in you and Belle.”

On our left side, Belle giggled and hugged both of us.

“With you two… I think I’m finally ready to make my journey into the blue,” Lily continued. “It won’t happen tonight, temptation or not. The idea of having a romantic date with a happy ending for both of us is too appealing for me to give in now.”

“Sounds pretty nice to me, too,” I agreed, nuzzling her neck with my nose again. There was something so squishably huggable about her that made me squeeze her a little tighter. Despite my resolution to not get involved in any further romantic complications, I really couldn’t help myself. Lily was warm, sweet, and innocent. I’d “caught feelings” for her already, whether I liked it or not. I had no idea yet whether or not those feelings would blossom into the same kind of love I felt for Belle, Sam, or Naimh. But I found myself yearning for the time, space, and opportunity to find out.

Lily giggled, grabbed my hand, and then slipped it beneath her jacket again. I once again found myself fondling her bare boobs. And a moment later, Lily turned her face to mine so we could share a sweet kiss.

My ku’uipo and I made out for a few minutes - tenderly but not passionately. It felt… comfortable. Relaxed. No pressure. And when we finally pulled apart, I reached out to caress the white plumeria she’d started wearing every day in her hair. Lily cast a demure glance downwards before shyly shifting her eyes back to mine with a world of warm wonder…

And yes, a lot of love.

There was no mistaking the reason for her plumeria being on the left side anymore.

****

The next time I glanced up, I caught Skylar smirking at me. When she felt my gaze, her eyes rather pointedly focused down on my hand beneath Lily’s jacket. I blushed, having momentarily forgotten she wasn’t part of our inner circle and had never seen me being this hands-on with the girls before. But I just shrugged and went with it, enjoying the feel of Lily’s heavy breast in my hand, and continued listening to the girls talk.

Belle and Lily got into the kind of semi-telepathic conversation they sometimes got where they were both talking so fast it seemed impossible they could actually catch every single word the other said. Eva, Sam, and Skylar got into a conversation about something else, but Naimh was pretty quiet. She fiddled with her fingers a little bit while staring wistfully out at the sunset. But every now and again I also caught her staring rather wistfully at me.

There were a few minutes left before the sun itself set when I tapped Lily’s leg and then pecked her cheek. “Hey, Lil. Would you mind sitting next to Belle for a bit?” I asked gently.

“Oh, sure, no problem,” Lily said, sliding out of my lap and continuing on her hyperspeed conversation with Belle as if they’d never been interrupted.

In the meantime, I glanced over at Naimh and gave my Irish girlfriend a warm, inviting smile. Snuggling together while watching the sunset had always been “our thing”, and the way her emerald-green eyes lit up with delight when she realized what was going on more than offset the sun’s dimming illumination.

My freckled redhead happily slid out of her beach chair to come sit in front of me on the beach mat. Within seconds, she grabbed both of my hands and slipped them beneath the hem of her shirt so that I could cup the bare skin of both boobies. At that point, the girls opened up our conversational circle so that everyone could turn and face westward across the Pacific blue. Sam was on my right, leaning against my side and setting her head down on my shoulder while reaching up to tenderly caress Naimh’s arm with her fingertips. Belle and Lily sat together on my left, holding each other’s hands in their laps. And Skylar and Eva remained in their beach chairs.

The conversation died down as we all watched the sky paint the clouds overhead in an array of rich colors. Dark purples formed overhead, with magenta, pink, and orange further away across the horizon. Naimh turned her face towards mine over her right shoulder, and I leaned forward to capture her lips with mine. I pinched her nipples and rolled them between my fingertips while our lips gently massaged each other. And when we parted, I found Sam staring at me with shimmering eyes only inches away, and I leaned in to gently kiss her as well.

A few seconds after that, I pulled back and Sam smiled invitingly at Naimh. My two gorgeous girlfriends came together for a sweet kiss of their own, almost playfully making out with each other until I tugged a bit on Naimh’s nipples as a way of getting her attention. I didn’t want her to miss the actual sunset.

Naimh giggled as she broke her liplock with Sam and gave the blonde a quick peck on the nose before turning to face forward. I spooned myself around the redhead while Sam once again set her head down on my shoulder. And together, all seven of us stared off at the horizon watching the bottom of the big yellow disc start to sink down into the sea.

A hush fell across the entire beach as everyone present went silent as well. The only sounds were those of the breeze across the bay and the unceasing surf crashing to shore. I hugged one girlfriend in front of me while another girlfriend hugged me from the side, the three of us cuddled together in a warm embrace more emotionally intimate than physical. I even let go of Naimh’s tits to wrap my arms around both girls’ waists, if you can believe it.

And that emotional intimacy I felt extended beyond the two girls in direct physical contact with me. I glanced to my left and smiled at the sight of Belle and Lily leaning together with an arm wrapped behind each other’s back and their free hands clasped together. To my right I could see Skylar and Eva seated silently on their beach chairs, both absorbed in the beauty of nature.

It was an amazing sunset.

This was an amazing group of girls.

And I considered myself the luckiest man in the world.

****

The original plan was to get dinner together in Mill Valley or Corte Madera on the way back, but the girls were all tired and just wanted to go home. It was an hour-long drive back to campus, and after the winding mountain roads of the Marin Headlands gave way to the droning monotony of Highways 101 and 580, the girls started nodding off in the van.

I didn’t need Sam to help me navigate anymore, so she slipped off her sandals, put her feet up on the dashboard, and reclined her seat back while closing her eyes and turning her head away from me. Oncoming headlights filled the cabin every now and again, enough to show me through the rearview mirror that Lily had fallen asleep on Belle’s shoulder. Eva braced herself against the opposite corner. And Naimh’s head started doing that slow, inexorable droop right up to the point of unconsciousness before jerking upright momentarily and then starting the process all over again.

Only Skylar remained fully awake for the entire journey, perhaps not quite relaxed enough amongst strangers to completely let her guard down. But she merely looked thoughtful and remained silent all the way back to her apartment.

I parallel parked my minivan in front of the apartment building’s driveway and then hopped out to go fetch her duffel bag from the trunk.

Meanwhile, Skylar opened the sliding door and then stepped down to the sidewalk. The statuesque blonde gave me a warm smile as I handed over the bag and she slung the strap over her head to her opposite shoulder. She opened her arms out to me, inviting a hug, which I gladly gave her.

“Thanks for coming,” I told her sincerely as I took a step back.

“Thank you for inviting me,” she replied earnestly in her alluring English accent. “I can’t remember the last time I went to the beach, and today was everything I could’ve asked for and more.”

“Glad you enjoyed yourself.”

“I did more than enjoy myself. Today was the best day I’ve had in years. Thank you.”

“Well I think Neevie deserves more credit for that than I do.” I glanced into the van where the redhead was conked out with her head against the side window.

“Perhaps,” Skylar conceded. “Yet you’re the one who made this all happen. You’re the very center of this… this Big Tits Club.”

I blushed and shook my head. “So weird to hear you say the full name out loud.”

“The girls are proud of being The BTC. Neevie said I fit right in.” Skylar glanced down at her chest but stopped short of grabbing her boobs on the sidewalk. I also glanced down at her chest before catching myself and forcing my gaze back up to her face, just in time to see Skylar smirk at me.

“I think you do fit right in,” I tried to say graciously, “and it has nothing to do with your boobs.”

She shrugged and gave me a shy smile.

“There’s no pressure to continue hanging out with us,” I told her sincerely. “You’ve got a busy schedule, I know, and probably other obligations I don’t know about. But you are welcome to join us again if you’d like to.”

She shrugged again. “I appreciate the offer.”

“So…” I began while arching both eyebrows, “should I let you know the next time The BTC makes another beach trip?”

Skylar’s smile broadened. “That’d be lovely, thank you.”

I raised both eyebrows. “Should I let you know the next time The BTC makes any kind of trip? Or a barbecue at the house? Or even just wants to hang out?”

This time, Skylar bit her lip and glanced away to the side. Her eyes narrowed and she pursed her lips for a moment before returning her attention to me. “You’re serious, aren’t you? This isn’t just a polite ‘We should meet up for lunch sometime’ but never follow through kind of invitation. You really mean to invite me to spend more time with you and your friends.”

“I really mean to invite you to spend more time with us, yes.” I smirked and gestured back into the van. “Neevie would castrate me if I didn’t, and then none of us would be happy.”

Skylar snorted and gave me a wry grin. I thought for sure she was about to say that she’d be happy to come hang out with us, but instead she took a deep breath and gave me a serious look that was decidedly less optimistic.

So I quickly added, “No pressure, of course. It’s no problem if you’re not up for it.”

Skylar regarded me seriously and took a deep breath before exhaling and stating evenly, “Let’s start with: ‘I’ll see you at class on Monday’, hmm?”

I nodded slowly, understanding that she wasn’t ready to make any kind of commitments yet. It made logical sense, since we still barely knew each other. So I simply smiled and said, “I’ll see you at class on Monday.”

“Cheers.” Skylar stepped forward to give me another hug. I patted her back chastely and then released her a second later. She backed up and then turned to head into her apartment building. And I tugged on the minivan’s sliding door to close it.

But just before the door closed, a voice from inside the van yelped, “Sky! Sky!”

The door itself closed and latched shut, but a moment later it jerked open again. Naimh leaped out onto the sidewalk, calling again, “Sky! Sky!”

Skylar turned around and smiled as the semi-groggy, semi-delirious redhead rushed up to her and then wrapped her up in a fierce hug.

“Were y’gawn leave wit’out sayin’ goodbye?!?” Naimh complained plaintively.

Skylar laughed and patted her new friend’s back. “I was going to let you rest, Sleeping Beauty!”

“No way! Wake me up next time! Promise!”

“Alright, alright. I promise!”

Naimh wrapped up the blonde in another fierce hug, nearly lifting Skylar up into the air, duffel bag and all. As it was, she merely brought the blonde up onto her tiptoes and then set her back down. “We’ll meet up later, alright? Promise?”

Skylar laughed again. “I promise.”

“Great.” Only then did Naimh finally release the other girl and take a step back.

By then, the sounds of Naimh squealing and the sudden way in which the sliding door had been jerked open stirred the other girls inside from their slumber. Sam had rolled down her passenger window, and Belle, Lily, and Eva all looked out the open slider at the rest of us on the sidewalk.

“Goodnight, ladies,” Skylar called while waving her hand.

The “ladies” chorused their respective goodnights and goodbyes in return. And then Skylar finally went into her apartment building while I reached out to take Naimh’s hand and gently draw her back towards the minivan.

“C’mon, love,” I told her kindly. “Let’s get Sleeping Beauty back to her castle.”

****

Our next stop was Mrs. Morris’s house. Eva stepped out with comparatively little fanfare to Skylar’s dramatic exit, and when she took her duffel bag from me I didn’t attempt to hug her. Instead I gave her a sincere look, willing her to understand with my eyes that I was ready to listen should she ever want to tell me what was going on.

Eva studied my face for a moment, taking deep breaths. But eventually she pursed her lips, shook her head, and turned away to walk into the house.

Lily remained in the van, to nobody’s surprise.

Three doors down, I pulled the minivan into the tandem driveway of what was less The BTC’s castle and more our humble abode, parking behind Sam’s Escalade. I sent the girls in first, telling them to go shower and clean up while I unloaded the minivan. But then Sam countermanded me by barking out different orders.

“Lily: take in everybody’s bags and set them in the living room. Belle: beach chairs, picnic mat, and the toys. Neevie: bring in the ice chest and then the canopy. Matty can get the barbie, and I’ll hunt around the cupholders and the cabin and grab whatever’s left.” Sam then clapped her hands together while proclaiming, “Chop-chop!”

“Yes, Mummy,” Naimh drawled with a laugh as she was the first one out from the sliding door and then circled around to the trunk, raising the lift gate while I was still getting out from the driver’s seat.

With the girls’ help, we had the van unloaded in no time. Not everything got put away exactly, but the van was empty. I still did one more pass from stem to stern and grabbed Sam’s sunglasses from the glove box. By the time I returned, Belle had already taken Lily to the upstairs bathroom, where I could hear their giggles echoing down the stairs. Meanwhile, Sam and Naimh posed prettily in the doorway of the downstairs bathroom, having shed their clothes but kept their bikinis on.

I had very fond memories of Naimh’s cobalt blue bikini dating back to high school. It wasn’t the skimpiest of bikinis nor the fanciest. But everything from the way the color really accentuated the color of her copper-red hair to the particular way it shaped her breasts to the perfect amount of bare ass it displayed without being overly gratuitous - the whole thing just worked. And then she untied the halter-top, allowing the cups to fall down and expose her freckled Double-Ds, and it all just worked so much better.

No matter how many times I’d seen Naimh’s tits before, I would never stop being entranced by the sight.

Then Sam snickered and reached behind her back, tugging down one string of the bow fastening her bikini top as well. And I could swear I heard an aria of angels singing from heaven as her magnificent melons came into view.

Clad in blue and red, the two topless teen dreams posed prettily for my viewing pleasure. Sam jutted a hip out to the side and planted her left hand on it. She fully removed her red bikini top and then twirled it through the air around a single finger while waggling her eyebrows and giving me saucy looks. Naimh left the back strap of her bikini top connected so that the cups merely dangled down below her breasts. She turned herself sideways to me in profile, leaned back against the doorjamb, and raised one foot against it while reaching back with both arms to thrust her naked chest forwards and upwards. A coy bite of her lips really sealed the deal.

Nobody had touched me, but I had an enormous erection threatening to bust a hole in my swim trunks. I quickly set Sam’s sunglasses down onto the small table in the foyer where we kept our keys and then sauntered down the short hallway.

My gorgeous girlfriends grinned at me in greeting but then turned and walked into the bathroom, Naimh first and then Sam. But rather than fully enter the bathroom, Sam stopped in the doorway facing away from me, bent forward at the waist with her legs together, and slowly dragged her fire-engine red bikini bottoms down to her ankles. Her big bubble butt thrust upwards and out of the way, revealing to me her puffy pink pussy lips already glistening with moist arousal. And I had to pause and bite my fist while grunting, “Holy fuck!”

The platinum blonde giggled and glanced back at me upside-down from her spot just to the left of her knees. She waggled her booty at me before standing upright again and then sauntering further into the bathroom. And I heard the sound of the shower starting up.

Naimh, meanwhile, leaned back against the sink and reached up to cup both of her humongous hooters in her hands. She mashed them together and then dropped her chin while lifting up her left breast, extending a long tongue out to lick the nipple. But a moment later Sam returned into view, squatting to take Naimh’s big boob into her hands. She took over swirling her tongue around the redhead’s crinkled nub while gazing upwards into her fellow BTC mate’s brilliant eyes. And then Sam stood up, leaning forward to mash her melons up against Naimh’s and grind their tits together for a few seconds before tilting her head and then capturing the redhead’s lips with her own while they both moaned.

“If you two keep that up I’m liable to pop before I even get into the bathroom,” I muttered.

That made Sam and Naimh both crack up, and my girlfriends both glanced out the doorway to grin at me. Sam crooked a finger ‘come hither’, so I went thither and entered the bathroom.

Sam turned and squatted again, this time taking hold of my swim trunks and dragging them down to my ankles with her. My stiff schlong sprung out right in front of the sexy blonde’s face, and she quickly stuck out her tongue to tease my balls before taking a long, languid lick along the underside before wrapping her lips around my crown.

Meanwhile, Naimh slipped out of her bikini bottoms, and after I also stepped out of my swim trunks, all three of us were naked. Naimh tested the shower water and apparently found it warm enough, so she pulled open the curtain and stepped inside.

Sam continued blowing me from her squat position, bobbing her head back and forth along my length while holding the backs of my thighs. I stared down at the stunning sight, smiling as she repeatedly made my rigid rod vanish and then reappear. But then I turned my attention to the soaking-wet stunner standing in the shower’s spray, her eyes closed and her face tilted upward as she ran both hands through her copper tresses to rinse them, the position causing rivulets of water to run down the redhead’s upthrust breasts.

After a minute, I reached down to rub Sam’s cheek and indicated with a nod that we should go join Naimh. She pulled off my prick with a pouty frown but smiled immediately after. I took her by the hand to help her up and then we stepped into the cramped confines of the combination shower/tub. The three of us still knew how to arrange ourselves, though, as we’d already done this same thing many, many times by now. And we actually focused on cleaning ourselves and scrubbing out every last grain of sand from the depths of our unfortunate crevices rather than have more sex. There would be plenty of time for that after we got out and rejoined the others.

At least, that’s what I thought we were going to do. But then while Sam was rinsing herself off beneath the showerhead, at the other end of the tub Naimh turned to brace herself against the back wall and thrust her amazing ass at me with her feet spread apart in invitation. I simply couldn’t resist bending my knees and lining up my mushroom head with her moist muff. And as soon as she felt my knob notch into place, Naimh crooned in complete contentment as she pushed herself backwards and captured my cock.

Sam heard that particular note of Naimh’s satisfaction and she turned around to find us already fucking. My Head Girlfriend laughed and rubbed my ass before scolding, “Do NOT make him pop. Save it for when we’re all together.”

“Yes, Mummy,” Naimh sighed while slow-stroking herself forward and back, her tight cunt really clamping down around my cock.

Sam shut off the shower and then stepped out, grabbing her towel off the double rack. She dried herself off while I held Naimh’s hips and increased the pace of my pumping. But once she was done, Sam leaned over next to us, reached around with her right hand, and started rapidly rubbing the redhead’s clit.

“Sam! Sam! Sam! UUUUNNNNGGGGHHHH!” Naimh cried as she abruptly climaxed, the sudden sensations unexpectedly overwhelming her. The redhead’s suddenly spasming snatch nearly sucked out my semen as well, but I gritted my teeth and clenched down on my Kegels, successfully keeping my cum at bay while Naimh continued to scream in orgasm, “UUUNGH! UUUNGH! UUUNGH!”

And that’s when Lily poked her head in through the doorway before looking back over her shoulder to say, “They’re fucking already.”

Belle immediately poked her head in as well, whining, “Hey! No fair starting without us!”

****

While foursomes between me and my three girlfriends were quite commonplace, Lily’s participation in the large group activities was not.

It had been three weeks now since that fateful party up in the hills after which Lily came upstairs with me, Belle, and Sam, the petite Hawaiian hottie had taken her first exploratory licks of another girl’s succulent snatch, and the almost bashful virgin first tried to fit my lala-hu into her little mouth. Since then there had been many more opportunities to continue “practicing” her blowjob skills and also let me taste her treasures as well. But the majority of those had either been one-on-one moments during the day or just with Belle present, although on occasion Naimh or Sam would be with us as well.

Friday nights would’ve perhaps been her best opportunity to be with the entire group at once, but as I mentioned, Friday nights were Lily’s nights to talk with her family back on Kaua’i. This past Sunday night had been the first time Lily joined all of us at once, and she’d been a little nervous about it then. But from the way she joyfully bounced around the living room in her birthday suit like a true veteran tonight, totally at ease, I figured her presence would soon become a regular occurrence.

“Hey, Matty?” Lily asked rather coquettishly while spinning around to face me in front of the couch, completely at ease in her nudity. She came to a stop with both hands on her hips, a brilliant white smile across her face.

“Uh yeah, Lily?” I asked when she didn’t immediately continue.

“Would you please cum on my face tonight?” she asked with wide-eyed innocence that stood in stark contrast to the debaucherous words that had just come out of her mouth. “You haven’t done that yet.”

I blinked a couple of times and then glanced at Belle, who was laughing as she skipped across the room over to join her shorty friend to hug her before returning my attention to the Hawaiian hottie. “Uhhh… yeah. I’m sure that can be arranged.”

Lily gave me a pixie giggle and turned to shake her tushie at me. I admired her dynamite derriere that definitely had a bit more junk in the trunk than Belle’s pert booty. And she reached back with both hands to grab her cheeks and separate them for me invitingly, even if we both knew I wouldn’t be penetrating them anytime soon.

“Dayyumm…” Sam drawled as she came to stand alongside me, having taken a bit longer to exit the bathroom while towel-drying her hair. She put a finger to her lips and took on an expression as if she were pondering fine art. “That is a lovely arse.”

“You’ll get no argument from me,” I replied with a smile.

Lily suddenly snapped upright, letting go of her buttcheeks and spinning around to face us. Her eyes were the size of dinner plates and her mouth opening and closing like a beached goldfish. “Yeah I know I said I was ready to venture ‘into the blue’ and all that but I really don’t think I’m ready yet to try fitting your entire la’au nunui into my asshole,” she stammered nervously.

My eyes got big as well and I quickly held my hands up. “No… no…”

“I mean Belle said that once she managed to fit you in there it felt absolutely incredible, but she also said the first few times you tried it really, REALLY--”

“I’m NOT asking you to have anal sex with me anytime soon,” I interrupted her quickly, striding forward to wrap up Lily in a warm hug and stroke her shoulders reassuringly. “Or ever, really.”

“Doesn’t have to be anal,” Sam remarked with glittering eyes, “but that arse was made for bending over.”

“Seriously, though, we were just admiring your… ‘arse’,” I stated apologetically. “Not suggesting we go all the way to fifth base right off the bat.”

“I still remember watching you just pound Holly into the mattress,” Lily said in a quiet voice, her eyes still quite big as she stared up at me.

“And I told you it’s not always like that.”

“But sometimes it is like that,” Naimh chimed in, coming out of the bathroom all flushed and happy with post-orgasmic bliss. “And when it is, it’s amazing!”

“But doesn’t it hurt?”

“I feel stretched, for sure,” Naimh admitted. “But it’s a wonderful kind of stretched. He feels so deep in me, like we’re so closely connected together and couldn’t possibly be any closer. Deep down in me sacred core.”

Lily blinked. “Wait, your sacred core that you keep talking about is in your ass?!?”

Naimh laughed. “You’d bettah b’lieve it.”

“But nobody’s rushing you into trying it,” Belle stated reasonably. “Let’s worry about, uh… fourth base?… before we think about fifth.”

Sam snickered, “The only mainland American girl here messes up the baseball metaphor?”

I rubbed Lily’s upper arms and gave her a serious look. “When Belle is telling you to relax and take your time instead of squealing, ‘Try it! You’ll love it!’? That’s when you know--”

“--know that I should relax and take my time,” Lily finished for me, nodding quite rapidly. She’d been gripping my elbows pretty tightly but started to ease off.

I nodded as well. “I’m pretty sure those Polynesian ancestors of yours made sure they were damn well stocked-up and prepared before setting sail into the blue.”

“I still have my pink butt plug set,” Belle stated reasonably.

“A what plug set?” Lily tensed up and tightly gripped my elbows again.

“You know, let’s just not talk about anal sex anymore tonight, huh?” I suggested.

“Well what DO you suggest?” Naimh asked before turning her attention to Sam. And I quickly realized that both Belle and Lily had also turned their attention to our de facto leader.

“Well, Lily’s still not ready to cash in her V-card just yet, right?” Sam mused aloud. “But there’s a LOT of stuff she can still do leading up to that. If there’s anyone who knows about pushing all of the boundaries just short of having sex, it’s The BTC.”

Naimh frowned like she didn’t understand. “Y’mean dry-humpin’im wit’ar clothes on and shovin’ our tits’n’is face wit’ou’ let’nim suck onna nipples?”

Sam thought about that. “Well, letting Lily grind her clit along his rod, lubing him up with her leaking pussy juices and making out like bandits while he grabs her ass and yanks her back and forth sounds like it’d be kinda awesome.”

“Ooh! Ooh! Me, please! Me, please!” Belle squealed with her hand in the air.

“He can hot dog her buns, really mash those supple buttcheeks around his big dick,” Naimh suggested while reaching out to caress Lily’s ass.

“He can stand behind her with his dick between her thighs,” Sam continued, “fucking that tight crack with her leaking pussy juices lubing him up while she holds up his cockhead so that it rubs against her clit.”

“You seem to really like lubing his dick up with your leaking pussy juices,” Naimh drawled.

Sam grinned. “I do. I really do.”

“But what about her?” Belle insisted.

“Well that’s easy,” Sam replied with a shrug. “Nothing better than Matty going down on her, suckling on her love button and just goin’ to town on it.”

“WITH his dick in her mouth?” Belle pondered before looking over at Lily. “You know, I really don’t think you two have sixty-nined yet, have you?”

Lily blinked, looking rather surprised. “Uh, no. I don’t think we have. And honestly I’m happy to try anything that involves getting that yummy cock into my mouth.”

“Yay for more blowjobs!” Belle cheered with both hands thrust into the air.

“Blindfolded blowjobs are always fun,” Sam proposed.

Belle dropped her hands and screwed her face up before gesturing at Lily and herself. “Two shorties still having difficulty fitting his giant tree down their throats versus the two remaining Blowjob Queens of the BTC? I don’t think so.”

“Nobody said versus. I was thinking Lily would feel less pressure if Matty was blindfolded and the four of us could take turns teaching her our technique.”

“Trading blowjobs sounds like a lot of fun,” Lily said brightly, “but I’d rather he not be blindfolded.”

Sam pouted. “But that’s half the fun!”

Lily shook her head. “But I love the way he stares down at me when I’m doing it. Like I’m a goddess descended from heaven sent specially to bring him pleasure. The look in his eyes makes me feel like I’m the sexiest, most incredible, most desirable woman on Planet Earth.”

Sam smiled and gazed over at me adoringly. “I know exactly what you mean.”

****

So we started off with a four-girl blowjob on the couch for which – thanks to Lily – I had a completely unobstructed view. Sam was on my left, Naimh was on my right, and Belle and Lily squished together in the middle. While Lily had been getting quite a bit of practice orally pleasing my pecker over the past few weeks, I wasn’t much of a coach – content to just sit back and let her experiment on me. When the other girls were present with us, they’d give her some pointers as well. But not since that first three-girl blowjob the night of Lincoln’s party had things turned into a full-blown teaching session, at least not until tonight.

“Not quite so tight,” Sam advised. “You wanna apply enough pressure to be pleasurable but not so much as to squeeze him.”

“Pssht,” Naimh disagreed. “Squeeze as tight as you want. Your hand is simulating a pussy, and what guy ever said a pussy was too tight?”

“This guy did!” Belle exclaimed. “With me!”

“Oh… well… uhhh…” Naimh muttered. “Well we all know you’ve got ‘diameter’ issues, B.”

Belle stuck her tongue out and blew a raspberry at the redhead.

“Can we please stay on track?” Sam asked, a bit exasperated before returning her attention to Lily. “Squeeze if you want but pay attention to his eyes. If they get tight, you’re probably squeezing too tight.”

“Or it means he’s about to cum,” Belle pointed out. “One of the two.”

“The more you watch him, the better you can recognize his ‘I’m gonna cum’ face,” Naimh said brightly. “Almost like… Uh, no not quite. I still think you need to squeeze a little tighter. Or just stop using your hand entirely and bob your head all the way up and down to take as much as you can. I mean--. Well. If you pull off for a sec, I can show you what I--”

“Neevie! Please!” Sam scolded. “This is for Lily.”

“I just wanted to demonstrate,” Naimh muttered plaintively.

“Stop fighting! He’s going soft,” Belle complained.

“Ugh,” Sam groaned. “You talk too much.”

“I’m just saying: I wouldn’t talk so much if me mouth was full.”

“Neevie!”

“What?!?”

“Just…” Sam rolled her eyes in exasperation. “You know what? Let’s move this upstairs so he can lie down while you sit on his face, hmm?”

“Works for me!” Naimh enthused excitedly, immediately hopping up to her feet and reaching a hand down to help me off the couch.

But instead I reached down with my right hand to gently caress Lily’s cheek. I’d been doing that a lot lately with how many blowjobs she’d been giving me, and she grinned around a mouthful of meat before slowly pulling her head back, maintaining suction every inch of the way until she finally popped off the top.

“Like I’m the sexiest, most incredible, most desirable woman on Planet Earth,” Lily murmured dreamily.

I smiled and stood up while taking hold of both of Lily’s hands to bring her to her feet as well. Then I cupped her chin and dipped down to give her a sweet kiss, all while she wrapped both arms around my waist and rubbed her belly against my rock-hard erection trapped between us.

Belle then stood to join us, and we got ready to leave. Sam had already stood up and strode off towards the stairs.

The other four of us followed after, and my jaw dropped at the sight of Sam’s sexy, sultry naked body reclined on her right side in bed, propped up on one elbow with her knees bent just so, like a lingerie model (without the lingerie). I couldn’t help but go straight to my Head Girlfriend, rolling her onto her back and then spearing my tongue through her lips so we could play tonsil hockey together. Her thighs spread apart in invitation. My rock-hard erection nudged its way into position automatically. And a moment later I felt myself sinking several inches into her sweet snatch.

“Pahtty Foww!” Naimh hooted in a mock-Aussie accent, and Sam and I abruptly broke apart our passionate liplock to find the redhead pointing a finger straight at us. “Did you seriously clamjam me downstairs with promises I could sit on his face just so you could get him into you first?”

Sam blushed in embarrassment but quickly recovered. “Technically, you were already first when you got him to fuck you in the shower.”

Naimh blushed. “Um, well, fair enough, but still.”

“Sorry, sorry,” Sam apologized. “I fair dinkum got a little carried away. I blame Matty for being so handsome I couldn’t help myself.”

“Well that I can totally understand,” Naimh replied with a grin.

“I’m the one who got a little carried away,” I stated apologetically. “I blame Sam for being so incredibly sexy that -I- couldn’t help myself.”

Belle parked both fists on her hips. “You saying that the rest of us aren’t so incredibly sexy that you can’t help yourself? Huh? Because you seem to be able to stop yourself from mounting us three just fine.”

My eyes got big. “B, I didn’t--”

“See, that’s exactly the sort of thing that other catty bitches would say to each other,” Belle stated with a self-satisfied smirk, having already turned her attention to Lily. “And that’s the kind of shit we won’t tolerate in The BTC, alright? Sam was so effing irresistible lying naked there just now that -I- would’ve jumped her had Matty not beaten me to her. But we all share… together… without jealousy or greed.”

Lily nodded rapidly with her eyes wide. Sam started laughing. And Naimh groaned before burying her face in her hands.

I blinked. “What just happened?”

“Belle’s proving a point about me complaining about you sliding yourself into Sam,” Naimh stated with a sigh before giving Sam an apologetic look. “My bad. Especially when I’m supposed to be Miss All-For-One-and-One-For-All.”

“My bad. Especially when I still have him in me,” Sam insisted before tapping my chest to get me to pull out. And with some reluctance, I withdrew and sat back on my heels, my throbbing erection jutting forth and upwards at about a forty-five-degree angle.

Naimh sighed with a rueful look at my lengthy love machine and then turned her attention to Lily. “The reality of The BTC is: that boy is our only dick.”

“No,” Sam countered while propping herself up on her elbows. “There is another.”

“Another?” Lily asked in confusion.

Sam smirked as she rolled over and off the bed, quickly dropping down to the floor. A moment later, she popped up again after retrieving a familiar object.

Lily’s eyes got big. “What is THAT?”

Sam’s smile widened. “Lily, meet Matty Junior. You wanna try him?”

Lily’s eyes got even BIGGER. “Um, WHAT? I, uh, thanks? I think? For the offer? But I think I’m gonna stick to losing my virginity to Matty’s real thing.”

“Oh! No-no-no,” Sam stated quickly. “I didn’t mean one of us wearing Matty Junior and then penetrating you. I meant to ask if you wanted to try wearing Matty Junior and then fucking one of us.”

Lily relaxed quite a bit before furrowing her eyebrows in confusion as she muttered, “Oh. Ummm…”

“It’s easy,” Belle encouraged. “Try it! You’ll love it!”

“On who?”

“On me, of course,” Belle pronounced excitedly. “Look at Matty right now. See the way his eyes are glittering as he fantasizes about it? Two short-but-stacked little hotties like us rolling around completely naked except for this strap-on dildo? Watching our pouty lips crash together while our big titties mash together at the same time? Seeing our tongues tangle while we both let out breathy moans of lust, all while your ‘lovely arse’ pumps up and down learning the rhythm of how to thrust your fake dong in and out of my tight pussy?”

Well if I hadn’t been fantasizing about it before, I certainly was now. “Holy shit, B,” I muttered beneath my breath.

Belle giggled and flashed me a pixie wink. “C’mon, Lil. Just try it,” she prodded.

Lily took a deep breath to collect herself, pursed her lips, and then momentarily glanced at me before returning her attention to Belle. “Alright then,” she stated, clearly trying to psych herself up. “Into the blue.”

Our night was just getting started.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Patrons will maintain a 2-week head start on StoriesOnline and Literotica. For anyone who can't wait, VIP Tier has the complete first draft (https://www.patreon.com/posts/93690378)

Remember that all authors thrive on feedback, so let me know how you're enjoying the story! Leave a comment here or come chat with us on Discord! And be sure to connect your Discord account here on the Patreon website to get access to the Patron-Only channels! https://discord.gg/fg3m6MdfN9

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

Prologue & Chapter 1: The BTC: https://www.patreon.com/posts/99290461

Chapter 2: Hoalauna: https://www.patreon.com/posts/99357682

Chapter 3: E10: https://www.patreon.com/posts/99433482

Chapter 4: Leeloo: https://www.patreon.com/posts/99506524

Chapter 5: The Fifth Element: https://www.patreon.com/posts/99618767

Chapter 6: Lily: https://www.patreon.com/posts/100326143

Chapter 7: The Hangover: https://www.patreon.com/posts/100548952

Chapter 8: Quality Time: https://www.patreon.com/posts/100806434

Chapter 9: The Favor: https://www.patreon.com/posts/101140618

Chapter 10: Ku’uipo: https://www.patreon.com/posts/101372817

Chapter 11: The R-word: https://www.patreon.com/posts/101672192

Chapter 12: The Beach: https://www.patreon.com/posts/101896200