Uncut AOT 4 x 22
Added 2025-06-25 19:53:55 +0000 UTCComments
So I'm curious, given your thoughts, what your stance is on what should be done in response to Eren's march is. If you don't think there's a feasible alternative to the safeguarding of Paradis besides global genocide, what should the scouts do in response? What would do if you werenin Armin and Mikasa's shoes?
Mark Romero
2025-07-04 22:34:44 +0000 UTCGabi's journey, up to this point, is perfect. The way they purposedly make her mirror Eren in certain situations, from pose, to expression to attitude, all the way up to this episode when she looks at the mirror to fix her hair (in the same way Eren did in the beginning of S4) and then, on the very same episode, they make her mirror Sasha to show how the kindness/awareness in her overcame the endocrination completely and she distances herself from Eren's image. It is absolutely perfect. Also one of the points where people, if they didn't yet, see she is very phisically similar to Sasha, especially hair style and color). One of the best characters in this story.
Lemon
2025-06-30 15:53:26 +0000 UTCYeah I've said this from the start of S4 that Gabi and Eren are 2 sides of the same coin!! I'm so glad someone else sees it!
Dr Sophie Darling Reacts
2025-06-28 09:01:13 +0000 UTCYou know in that scene of Gabi tying her hair up in front of a mirror, not giving up, moving forward... she reminded me of Eren. Her arcs are extremely similar and yet here in this episode it seems they are going on opposite sides. For me Gabi is like Eren, if he was able to turn on a new page. I think Gabi is one of the most important characters thematically for AoT, so it's baffling to me that a non-insignificant part of the fandom hates her. The point of her character for me is to highlight "see, this is what war is causing. This is not as simple as just "defeating the enemy" Sasha's death is not on Gabi's fault, but this seemingly unending cycle of hate. What is the answer, the moral here? Get out of the forest; and I think the series is very explicit on that.
Gabriel Ontiveros
2025-06-27 16:59:20 +0000 UTCI think the comment you saw may have been my comment I left on Jared & Jordan’s video last year that was very similar if not identical. Took me forever thinking it up, writing, and rewriting it in my notes app before I posted haha. If so, it makes me very happy that it resonated with people that they remember it! Or if it’s just a pure coincidence and someone else posted a similar comment, then ignore me haha
Kevin
2025-06-27 16:13:30 +0000 UTCAs someone who was raised in homophobia, racism, classism, and all sorts of disgusting ideologies, ideologies that for half of my life I whole-heartedly believed to be true, I can't help but love Gabi as a character. She is incredibly realistic and well written, and I almost can't believe people completely miss this nuance, but at the same time I do, because there was a time where I myself could not see the hypocrisy and overall nonsense of the beliefs I held. I want whatever Isayama-sensei was smoking cause it's some good sh**!
Damian Angelo
2025-06-27 04:43:42 +0000 UTCIf Eren destroys only the military bases: 1. That won’t stop governments from producing weapons; it will just push them to do so in secret. Sooner or later, the nations will revisit the idea of attacking Paradis. Add to that the fact that modern technology is already on the brink of stripping the Titans of their battlefield advantage, and you have a strong argument against targeting only the bases. 2. It would force the continuation of the Titan succession, which—plainly put—condemns Historia to die young, along with her children, grandchildren, and other people on Paradis (potentially even Eren’s own friends). From this, we can conclude that no “half-Rumbling” will ever work in practice. It doesn’t eliminate the threat of external attack and forever dooms Eren’s friends. Any partial Rumbling merely kicks the problem further down the road. As Jean said, Eren’s plan is to kill everyone outside the island. With that plan, Eren opposes Zeke, whose idea was to (first sterilize and then) kill everyone on the island. Since these are the options held by the people who possess the Founding Titan’s power, resisting one basically means endorsing the other—because Jean, Mikasa, Armin, and Conny don’t have that power; only Eren and Zeke do. And, truth be told, both plans amount to genocide. Regarding diplomacy, we’ve already covered it: I don’t see a diplomatic solution as realistic, given that Eldians remain walking weapons with an imperialist past. Honestly, I wouldn’t trust the Eldians if they existed in our world. So what’s left? The profound, complete cruelty of Eren’s plan. Do I support it? Of course not. But I can’t think of a realistic alternative.
André Carvalho
2025-06-27 02:51:07 +0000 UTCI once saw a comment on YouTube about this moment with Conny and thought it was brilliant. Conny sees himself as the group’s “idiot.” From the very beginning, when Shadis is describing the recruits, he says Conny “lacks mental sharpness” or something along those lines. Throughout the entire story, Conny is there—heart on his sleeve—following his friends, carrying out whatever they decide, and letting them make the calls. He does this because, deep down, he doesn’t think he’s that smart. He trusts his friends and expects them to come up with solid plans for him to execute. But at this point in the story, what have those plans produced? Nothing but chaos, uncertainty, the Rumbling, death, and sorrow. Conny has always stepped aside in decision-making, relying on the supposedly smarter ones, and here’s the outcome: Paradis’s military has been obliterated, he and his friends have been betrayed and imprisoned. His mother still lives as a Titan, trapped in Ragako, and he’s powerless to save her. When the opportunity to rescue his mother finally appears, unlike every other time, Conny asserts himself: maybe it’s time to carry out his own “idiotic” plan, maybe it’s time to stop listening to his friends and do what he believes is right. When I look at all of this, it becomes clear just how organic these characters truly are.
André Carvalho
2025-06-27 02:21:49 +0000 UTC25:00 same!! This show tackles a lot of issues that are at the center of people’s moral compasses, so I understand I’m not going to agree with everyone, but people who hate Gabi (and people who love Floch and go “King Floch”) are a litmus to the type of person they are to me as well
My Toasty Toast
2025-06-27 00:18:21 +0000 UTCEren is The Omen Heart is Frozen If it ain’t fam’, he got no emotion
vxctorrr
2025-06-26 19:55:54 +0000 UTCAnnie being thrown back into the middle of the plot right now wearing an old-style MP uniform is gonna be so confusing for her. I guess since she's a subject of Ymir she also had Eren's daydream broadcast straight into her head too
Dagmar Makara
2025-06-26 05:47:33 +0000 UTC25:05 so well said and true. Whats hilarious is statistically almost all the people who hate on gabi and dont understand these things would be the first ones to be just like gabi IRL if they grew up in her circumstances in our world a hundred years or so ago.
david
2025-06-26 05:28:39 +0000 UTC30:00 it is and in both cases she was thrown back also love how when she finishes off nile she gets close in with about hte smae scream sasha did when she threw away her bow and stabbed that titan with her arrow
HAL
2025-06-26 04:53:33 +0000 UTC
