The Fill in Cheerleader

Here it is! I apologize if this story feels a little rushed, I've kindaa been a mess this month. I still like this story a lot though I hope you all will too! Stay tuned for more caps I should have more time once school ends.

Michael sighed as he heard the pounds of footsteps come through his front door. He placed his hands over his eyes and groaned, how was it 3 o’clock already? It was his only day off this week and somehow it felt like it just started. Having the entire house to himself was one of his great pleasures. Michael was a 24 year old fresh out of college with an engineering degree. He had moved back in with his parents so he could save up some money. He recently got hired at a big aerospace corporation, as it didn’t take him long to find a job with his good grades and high job demand. He could definitely afford a place of his own, but he wanted to save and put a nice down payment on a house. Besides, he wasn’t dating anyone right now, so living with his parents wasn’t horrible, especially because they worked all day, so days he was off he had to himself. Well… almost, so far since moving back in, his biggest annoyance had been his 16 year old sister Kaylee. 

Michael and Kaylee got along before Michael left for college, however since he’d been back Kaylee had really evolved into the basic teenage girl. Now a varsity cheerleader with a football player boyfriend, Michael couldn’t believe the things that would come out of her mouth. The worst part wasn’t Kaylee though, it was her friends. Michael would see them almost everyday. They were all insufferable, every time he saw them he hated them more and more. He could tell how deep they had been sucked in by their high school social lives, if they only knew.

The girls B lined it up to Michael’s room as soon as they got home, “Mikey!!” Kaylee yelled barging into his room. Michael groaned, he was about to cuss Kaylee out in front of all her friends, “I need favor!” Kaylee continued, almost like she was blind and not able to see how annoyed Michael was with her. Michael pushed himself up in his bed, “What do you want Kaylee? Can I not have some peace and quiet for 5 minutes?” He complained. Kaylee continued to smile, “Well I guess not! I totally need you to cover for me cheering at the basketball game tonight!” Michael pulled the covers back over his head, “You are out of your mind freak.” He said with toxicity. This is usually when Kaylle would break down, after she doesn’t get her way, but she continued to smile. “Pleassseeee Michael! You are totally have the same face as me if you shave, you’ll easily pass as my cousin if you suck your gut in.” She and her friends giggled. Michael stood up and gave his sister a death stare, “Kaylee. Fuck. No. I’m not going to dress up as a high school cheerleader for the night because you want to fuck your boyfriend.” Kaylee sighed, “Fineeeee… I guess I’ll just tell mom and dad.” Michael glanced at her, “Tell them what?” He said shakingly, Kaylee’s voice sounded sinister. “Tell them about the money you took from them.” That sent chills down Michael’s spine, how did she know? Michael had wired a couple of hundred dollars to give to his ex girlfriend who claimed to be in trouble. He knew it was stupid, but he thought she wanted him back and he inteded to wire the money back once he got it. “Kaylee… please.” He started to beg, but he could see it in her eyes, she wasn’t going to budge.

A couple of hours later Michael found himself at the hands of his sister and her friends Jen and Mikayla. He had already endured what had felt like 6 hours of the girls brushing makeup on her face. The plan was for Kaylee to say she was sick and offer her cousin “Melanie” as a replacement. Kaylee had recently been promoted to varsity cheer and didn’t have a huge role so Michael could easily accomplish what was asked of him. After they went over the plan he felt better, but that didn’t change the fact he was being dressed up by teenage girls. Michael gulped as his sister and her friends pulled out the cheer uniform he was dreading. As Kaylee took it out it almost… lit up the room, as if it was glowing. “Kaylee why is it glowing like that?” Michael beamed at her. Kaylee shrugged, “Like, I don’t know? It’s super old! I found it in the school attic, but it looks like it’ll look perf on you!” She said handing him the white skirt. Michael wanted to break down and leave, this was going to be the worst 6 hours of his life. He couldn’t believe a 16 year old girl was blackmailing him. “Well let me change then!” He yelled at the teenage girls, agitated that they were still touching up his makeup. The girls scattered out of the room giggling. As Michael slipped the uniform up and around him, he noticed instead of the uniform hugging his body, it was like his body was hugging the tiny uniform. He was worried people might notice he was a guy, but when he looked in the mirror he was surprised at how… tiny he looked. It almost didn’t look real, he didn’t realize cheer uniforms were so high tech. When he finally got on the uniform, he walked over to his sister’s vanity and gasped, he couldn’t believe how… real he looked. It gave him some comfort but scared him at the same time.

Within 2 hours Michael found himself standing on the high school football field around a bunch of screaming of high schoolers. He couldn’t believe that he was doing this, or he had gotten this far. Kaylee’s coach however didn’t question her or his role as her cousin, she completely bought his disguise. He had to give his sister and her friend’s credit, she really made him look believable. Everything from the lipstick to the ribbon in his wig. Not only that, but all the cheerleaders bought it too, 3 girls quickly introduced themselves and even called him pretty. He felt like he was in a dream, but it was more like a nightmare. It did seem weird though, the more he spent time in the uniform with the other girls, the more he felt comfortable and one of them. The 3 girls even took a liking to him as they were getting ready for the game in the locker room. They noticed how nervous he was and tried to calm him down.

Once they were out of the field however, Michael had never felt more in his element. He couldn’t explain it, he never knew he had… cheerleading in him. He found himself wanting to chant, wanting to get the crowd excited… and the crowd to stare at him. He had never felt something like this before… it was a rush. The other girls noticed too, “OMG Melanie you are amazing! How many years have you been cheering?” One of them named Ashleigh approached him at halftime. Michael would’ve been modest, but he wasn’t Michael tonight, he was Melanie. “I don’t know girl, like my entire life!” He said cheerfully back at her, he could tell Ashleigh was impressed. He wished he could impress girls like this as a dude he thought. The second half of the game Michael enjoyed even more. He definitely noticed high school boys checking him out and talking about him, but for some reason it didn’t disturb him.

Once he was finally home Kaylee and her friends were waiting giddishly waiting to hear all the details of his night. They were surprised, and all burst out laughing when Michael actually explained how he enjoyed things. Michael couldn’t describe the feeling, he knew Kaylee’s friends thought he was insane. But there was something inside of him that wanted to chase it...he had no clue what had gotten into him.

By the time the next football game had rolled around, Michael had almost shrunk a foot in height. The only people that seemed to notice was Kaylee and his parents though, Michael welcomed the changes, he thought the smaller the cuter. His face was also getting smoother, much to his pleasure. Michael’s body wasn’t the only thing going through a transformation either, the 24 year old found himself adoring everything the other girls took interest in. Everything from makeup trends to reality television, especially the cliche shows about finding love. He noticed how the girls in the show acted and dressed, the more he watched the more and more he adored the girls on show. He took in everything. He was added to a group text with the three girls Ashleigh, Lauren, and Tiffany. The way they texted was so mesmerizing to Michael, he tried to emulate them as much as possible, which is why he started watching reality television. He even sneaked into the stands of the next game, no not to watch football, but the cheer team. He wanted to get better, he wanted to impress and fit in with Ashleigh and Lauren.

The next weekend he devised a plan and asked Kaylee to let him fill in for her again. Kaylee was surprised but she agreed, she was feeling sick anyways, she didn’t like to cheer much regardless, she did it for social status. Michael giddily skipped out of her room, texted his new bffs and went to get ready. 

Ashleigh and Lauren were amazed at how different Melanie had looked from the first time they saw her. She looked a lot cuter now… and she could almost compete for cutest girl on the team. As soon as Tiffany became aware of this, she soon became a little jealous and combative, Tiffany had always been the prettiest girl on any squad she had been in. But regardless the 2nd game went even better than the first. Michael noticed more eyes on Melanie, as she was moved to more roles in the front of the squad. He absolutely loved being out there looking cute with his bffs. After the game even a couple of the players came over and congratulated him. It made him feel all warm and smiley inside. 

“Melanie are you coming?!?” Ashleigh beamed across the locker room, “We are going to my house to get ready before the party!” The statement sent chills down Michael’s spine, he didn’t really prepare to have to hang out with them. What if they found out who he was? “Uh um… I have to make sure Kaylee is doing alright.” Michael said nervously back to the 3 girls. Lauren rolled her eyes, “Girl! She’s fine! Come on you deserve a little fun after that!” Lauren’s small but tight grip yanked Michael, he soon found himself in the back of Ashleigh’s luxury SUV and digesting boy gossip. Then he found himself putting on Ashleigh’s hair extensions. Then suddenly he was putting on a sparkly 2 piece silver dress at the direction of the girls… even weirder it was fitting him?

As they walked into the party the smell of cheap alcohol hit Michael’s nose immediately. Ashleigh and Lauren quickly peeled off to find the boys they were wooing, leaving Michael to fend for himself. The vulnerable short blonde stood in the middle of the living room drinking 99 cent beer when a tall guy approached him. He actually wasn’t that tall… but to Michael he seemed so big for some reason. “I noticed you were alone… that’s no fun… I’m Brad.” He extended his hand. Michael looked up and chills were sent down his spine, he immediately realized it was Kaylee’s boyfriend. “Uhh hi.” He said playing with his hair, Brad was standing really close to him, which made him nervous. But also, he couldn’t help but notice what a nice body he had. “Can I feel your muscles?” Michael blurted out, almost wanting to cover his mouth immediately. He had no clue why he said that. Brad chuckled and pulled up his shirt. Michael surprisingly and eagerly put his little hands around them. He let out a little giggle, surprised on how firm they were. Brad smiled, “You’re cute. What’s your name?” Michael was taken aback by the comment but blushed, “Melanie. You?” Brad took her hand and kissed it, “Brad. Any chance you want to get to know each other upstairs?” Before Michael could answer Brad was yanking him up the stairs

Michael didn’t really have time to think what was happening, he had always thought this kid was a tool every time his sister brought him over, now he found himself cuddling with him… alone. “The genes in your family are insane, you are even hotter than your cousin.” Brad blurted out as they felt each other up. Michael rolled over and looked at the cute guy in the eyes, he had no clue why or what was happening but he said it. “Why don’t you kiss me then?” One moment led to another, and he found Brad on top of him, pinning him down as they explored each other’s mouths.  “You should text me!” Michael smiled pulling out his phone. Brad typed his number in and then went back to kissing Michael’s soft neck. Michael giggled hysterically, he had never been into someone this much before.

Only 2 days later Kaylee came home sobbing hysterically, Brad had done it. Michael tried to act disappointed and there for his sister, but most of him wanted to run up to his room and text the cutie. He couldn’t believe bpBrad dumped his sister for him, that was like the sweetest thing a guy had ever done for him. 

The next night, Kaylee watched as her brother ran through his hands through his hair before tilting his phone and making a cute face for a selfie. “Uh Michael, you ok?” Kaylee said, turning her head back towards the baseball game, usually Michael’s eyes would be glued to the screen. Kaylee only heard tapping, she turned to see her brother cutely smirking to himself as he femininely taped on his phone, “Oh uh yeah sis!” He finally responded, not looking up. “Who are you snapping?” Kaylee said sternly, causing Michael to finally look up at her, “Oh you know, friends.” Kaylee quickly snatched the phone out of her brother’s weak hands, “Hey!” He shouted, Kaylee nearly gagged as she saw something she wouldn’t mistake. On the screen of her brother’s phone was a dick pic from Brad. “He totally just sent it to me out of the blue. It's like so disgusting!” Michael yelled trying to explain to his sister. Kaylee dropped the phone and stormed out of the room, no way any of this was happening. Michael picked up his phone and flipped her hair, he opened his messages to Ashleigh and typed, “OMG my sister is such a jealous little loser! She can’t be happy for us :(“ As Kaylee stormed up to her room, her mind raced as she could hardly comprehend the vents taking place. There was no way she could come to terms with what was happening

Michael’s blonde ponytail bounced as he pranced his way into the house with a handful of shopping bags. “I’m home mommy!” He yelled very affectionately. He slipped off his sandals and made his way to his sister’s room, “Kaylee! OMG! You just HAVE to see these booties I got!” Kaylee watched, stunned as her 24 year old brother excitingly showed her the white leather Steve Madden booties most sorority girls die for. “Aren’t they perfect? I’m wearing them tonight to Lauren’s party! Oh my gosh so Brad was like complaining to me earlier that he didn’t want to go, and I was like stop being such a dick I totally went to your friends party last weekend! Ugh I feel like all he wants to do is play Fortnite sometimes it’s like he doesn’t even care about Lauren’s half birthday!” Kaylee couldn’t believe anything that came out of her brother’s mouth, did she used to sound like this? “Oh wow” was all she said. Michael undid his ponytail, revealing his cute chin length blonde cut. “What do you think sis? I just got it done! Do you think the football team will like it?” Kaylee looked at the teenage girl standing in her room and smiled, “Totally sooooo cute! Now get out!” She yelled. Michael squeaked out of Kaylee’s room, letting out a little giggle, it was okay she had to call Brad anyways. 

“Brad we need to talk sweetie.” Melanie thought breaking up with someone over the phone was completely lame, not to mention that would totally be such a Scorpio move of her even though she was a Cancer. She had gotten into astrology and all that stuff recently, it was like super interesting to her! But anyways, she already felt bad for breaking up with her first bf, especially cuz he like left his girlfriend for her and all, but he was just like, not as cute as any of the starting football players. “Well now that I’m like a head cheerleader and all, don’t ya think it’d be better if we saw other people?” She could already tell Brad was a mixed of crushed and angry, “You’re breaking up with me? I’m the reason you even go to this school!” Brad yelled loudly. Melanie chewed her gum loudly, “Yeah but you’re like not that popular? Ohmygosh Dillion asked for my number the other day!” Melanie forgot who she was talking to for a second. All Brad could do is shake his head as he watched his now ex girlfriends perfect body disappear down the path.

“Michael we need to talk.” His dad said sternly. His dad busted into his room as he was Facetiming Andrew, a running back on the football team, “Umm daddy I’m kind of talking to my boyfriend!” Michael yelled at him. His dad yanked the phone out of his scrawny hands and hung up the call, “Michael look at yourself! You are a 24 year old man!” His dad’s words sent chills down his spine, he suddenly realized for the first time what he was doing. His head spun as he thought he was going to hurl, he stared blankly as his dad stared at his son in distress. Michael’s head was going a million miles per hour, but as he came out of his daze… being Michael just felt… ugh. He knew Michael wasn’t him. She knew she wasn’t Michael. Melanie looked up at her father and made a pouty face, “Daddy… I please stop being weird.” Melanie said softly at her daddy. Michael’s dad rolled his eyes, “What happened son?” Melanie stood up, “Nothing daddy! My life is just perfect! If you ruin it I’m telling mom what you did!” Melanie yelled at her father, who was stunned. He knew he was talking about his affair, but he didn’t know Michael knew. His dad stood in silence defeated, “Fine…” he muttered. The room rang with a scream, “Yay!, Thank you so much daddy!” She said giving him a big hug.

         2 months later, Kaylee woke up groggy, ready for another day of school. She had been enjoying school more since quitting the cheer team though, now she saw less of her new sister. However, mornings were always the worst part of the day, it was when Kaylee got her highest dose of Melanie. Melanie was her daddy’s princess. She could get whatever she wanted with sad eyes and a “Pleasssseeee dadddy!” Once she figured this out Melanie overhauled her entire wardrobe. She used her daddy’s card to fill her closet with the cutest shoes, skirts, and dresses. The most important thing on the new teenage princess’s mind was her looks, social life, and of course boys. Today the teenage dream sported a hot pink halter top that she paired with her favorite new white denim miniskirt. She had her now illustrious soft blonde hair in a high ponytail. Kaylee was actually jealous at how well her brother could pull off sparkly pink eyeshadow. “Do you girls need a ride to school?” Their father asked, not looking up from the newspaper. Melanie rushed to his side and kissed him on his cheek, “Nope! Dillion is going to pick me up! Thanks though daddy love ya!” She beamed as she zoomed out the door and towards Dillon’s mustang. 

Melanie gripped her books against her chest as she giggled with her girlfriends as they made their way down the hallway of Highlands High School. Her cute butt moved perfectly in the tight denim skirt. With her bubbly personality and cute looks, Melanie quickly found herself as one of the queen bees of the junior class. Everyone either knew Melanie, or who knew who she was, for various reasons. “So Tiffany was like you can’t be in my cheer Tik Tok and I was like… Girl if this is about Dillion…. please. He never even liked you!” Melanie was talking Ashleigh's and Lauren’s ears off as they arrived at their lockers. “So I was like… fine so I untagged her from all my Insta pics.” Melanie flipped her hair, proud of herself as Ashleigh and Lauren giggled, egging her on. Melanie yanked open her locker, using the mirror on the door she made a kissy face and giggled to herself. She’d never admit it but she loved staring at her reflection. As she started to go on about how her skin wasn’t soft enough she felt a tap on the back of her shoulder, she turned around to see star running back and 5 star recruit Dillion Mckepper standing in front of her. The 18 year old senior was already bigger and taller than most fully grown men, “Hey you!” Melanie gushed as she wrapped herself around her boyfriend. Dillion wrapped his arms around his girl, of course grabbing her cute butt, they were by far the hottest couple in the school. Melanie wouldn’t settle for anything less. “Can’t wait for tonight babe.” He said nonchalantly. Melanie was standing in her tippy toes, she had her arms wrapped around her boyfriend’s head, “Samsies! Ohmygosh daddy, like you will not believe this outfit I found! I can’t wait to show you!” She gave one of her golden smiles at her boyfriend, nearly making his knees buckle. “You look cute in anything” He smiled back, biting his lip. Melanie stood up on her tippy toes even higher, getting as close to his face as possible, “Aww you are just the sweetest.” She said softly before she quickly found Dillion’s tongue in her mouth. Not that was something to complain about, he was so passionate. Passing students laughed, some were envious as the big football player slammed the cheerleader doll lightly against the lockers. Melanie got lost in Dillion for a second, forgetting where she was as she slightly moaned as Dillion rubbed his hands around her ass. That’s when the romantic moment was rudely interrupted by their history teacher passing in the halls, “Cut it out you two!” He yelled at them. Dillion immediately got off and put his hands up, “Won’t happen again sir.” Melanie giggled at her boyfriend, he was such a cutie.

Of course it was a big night, it was the couple’s month anniversary, which was big for Melanie, she had never intended on being with a guy for more than a week before this. It was just like, so much fun to date different people. But Dillion was just so hot, his body reminded her of her celebrity crush, Zac Efron. She also loved dating the star football player, it was always like, being the center of attention, which Melanie died for. Ashleigh and Lauren came over to help her get ready. Kaylee even helped with her hair at one point. After more preparation most girls would take on their prom night, the beautiful blonde teenage princess stood breathtakingly in a sexy pink sequin dress. She paired the look with her favorite white cut out heels her daddy had gotten her for her birthday. When Dillion saw her he stuttered to get words out of his mouth. And there was no doubt he was all over Melanie all night. 

At the end of the night Melanie found herself in Dillon’s bed, spooning with him as they watched the office on Netflix. Melanie had the night most girls would dream of, Dillon was a perfect gentleman, and not to mention how cute he looked in khaki’s. As they laid on the bed Dillon reached his hand over the Melanie’s fragile shoulder, using his fingers to lift her bra up, placing his hand on her breast and rubbing it around. Melanie didn’t hesitate, she reached her hand back, and slid them through her boyfriends pants. As she felt the roughness around his shaft she felt it getting harder and harder. She pushed herself harder into Dillon, getting more leverage as she grabbed his big rod. She turned around, switching hands as she wrapped the other around her boyfriend’s head as they made out. She lifted Dillion’s shirt, pressing her mouth up his chest to his neck and sucking as Dillion took in the sensation. As Melanie continued Dillion whispered, “Careful baby I have a game tomorrow.” Melanie put her head up and giggled, “I know daddy I can’t wait!”