Produce 48 Episode 3 - REACTION
Added 2024-05-10 09:39:11 +0000 UTCI have no words... I need a punching bag in the background for our P48 reactions so I could take breaks beating the shit out of it while reacting ๐
Comments
- Oh no, could you imagine a show like this running for 40 episodes? - Yes, that is the very same Shiroma Miru you saw on Queendom Puzzle. - A very brief glimpse of AleXa! If you didn't already know that she's in this show, you'd completely miss her because she had almost no screen time ๐ - Don't worry, I will power through this time. But it is true that Mnet goes too far with the โdramaโ on this show. Having stakes and obstacles to overcome and all that is one thing, however we must not forget that we aren't watching fictional characters. These are real people and the way Mnet portrays them has a very real effect. It's often quite manipulative and doesn't reflect reality. And the trainees suffer because of it. Think back to Girls Planet. Cai Bing was always pretty popular in the votes and then there was the episode where Mnet edited stuff in a way that made her look like a complete asshole. And there is definitive proof that sentences were taken out of context and conversation snippets were put together out of order to make it seem like stuff was said that has never actually been said in reality. There's tons of proof out there for this kind of manipulative editing. But the damage was done. Next round of votes, Cai Bing got last place and was eliminated. Mnet doesn't just โcreate tensionโ. Mnet straight up lies. And on top of that, the votes themselves were directly rigged this season. There is no defending that. - JO YURI IN F?? WTF? How does that make sense? - Ah well, she completely gave up :/ - โWhy not show the entire performance?โ Because that's oBvIoUSly not as important as the reaction shots you silly goose ๐ค - It's also really fun knowing the lineup of IZ*ONE and seeing which classes these girls are in right now :D And of course my Everglow bias Kim Sihyeon (โShi Hyunโ) and bias wrecker Wang Yiren :) - Look at Mnet using reaction videos on their show before they hit all of them with copyright strikes ๐ - Oh shit, one of the song signs broke ๐ - Alex Christine is AleXa and back then she really couldn't speak any Korean at all. She talked about it later how PD48 was super difficult for her because of that language barrier. - Lee Seunghyeon, center of that Like Ooh-Ahh team is Riina of H1-Key. She looks quite different here with much longer hair than on Queendom Puzzle and of course the name itself is completely different so I don't think you'd recognise her. And Park Haeyoon from the same team was the leader of Cherry Bullet. - Oh right, Park Minji was also in season 1. She's a member of Secret Number now. - Wait but isn't this kinda an unfair advantage for some of them to use a song by AKB48? - Am I seeing this right? Huh Yunjin is in F? - Just a lone camera man standing there like - 92 Trainees? Did four of them leave already? GFRIEND โ Love Whisper - Soyou, you're not being helpful. - The thing is, Hongki (male vocal trainer) would have identified exactly what went wrong there and then told them exactly what they can to do to fix it. And Soyou is just like โyou fuckin suckโ. Granted, this might be manipulative editing at work here but she's really not looking great now. - And despite all that, Group 1 did great! - Nayoung from group 2 is now also a member of Lightsum. - โThat's an adorable songโ Hey, I mean, the Gfriend Spotlight is right there, just waiting to be filmed ๐ jk, do it when you have the time (But the four songs you should totally do are Rough, Fingertip, Time for the Moon Night and Mago ๐๐) - Okay, right here: that's a replay I can get behind! Nako nailing the high note, YES show me that multiple times! - I think team 2 takes this round for me. - 330 votes for Nako, yeah that checks out - Alexa play Hard Carry by GOT7 because Nako did just that. Red Velvet โ Peek-A-Boo (kinda) - Ah, the Gyuri incident. I think this might have been where I stopped watching back then. - Oh my, Yiren in those boots ๐ต - Oh they absolutely are doing the Chanmi thing. Just much worse this time. - SIX. SIX GODDAMN REPLAYS. For one tiny little voice crack. An even smaller mistake than what Chanmi did two seasons ago. If you can even call it a mistake at all. And Mnet blows it up to much bigger proportions than last time. But we're not done here. This was just a preview. Mnet are gonna continue bullying Gyuri in the next episode for this. Now we just gotta move on to a completely different song for some fucking reason. This is why I hate Mnet. And why I just don't understand the Mnet apologists in the comments sometimes. How can you defend shit like this? I.O.I โ Very Very Very (annoyed that we're just skipping to this instead of finishing Peek-A-Boo) - And apparently seeing the training process isn't relevant anymore, let's just jump straight into the performance. - Or not, who the fuck knows at this point. How fucking drunk were the editors on this one? - Uhh... Okay, if memory serves me right, I did watch part of episode 4 but the editors just continue to bully Gyuri there and that was where I stopped watching. Like, what the fuck is this? Do they really think this is entertaining to watch? What kind of a person enjoys watching this mess?
Marcel Wannieck
2024-05-10 21:22:17 +0000 UTCso yes LOL it's the battle of the East Coast Avengers led by Captain America (Sakura) against the West Coast Avengers led by Iron Man (Yujin) -the Kaeun team is not bad too Kaeun, Jurina, Yiren, Gyuri, Alexa, Bae eunyoung - there is also a lot of talent in the Chaewon team I love Moe she is very expressive and charismatic at the time Chaewon was a bit very shy and withdrawn. - yes absolutely DG it's the spirit of the show and the reason why so many trainees participate in these shows. whether they gain or lose the visibility they gain is always worth taking. because as I said half of the girls present in this show made their debut a few months or years later thanks to this experience - Lol I loved the High tension team, the nickname given to Hyunjin โKirin chanโ is so funny and cute. - the Shi hyun team with Yuri and Juri is also very good AOA short hair is a very good song I was looking forward to seeing this performance. I have seen a lot of survival shows but regarding the visuals produce 48 a an incredible quantity of very beautiful girls it is the survival show which has the greatest quantity of visuals. Yiren, Gyuri, Minju, Sakura, Sian, Kaeun, Yujin, Wonyoung, Go yoo gin, Hyewon, Chaewon, Shihyun, Miru, Juri, Eunbi, Moe, Hitomi and several others are really very pretty. - Group battles - GFRIEND team 1 their voices were so cute. Wang Ke did a good job, it wasn't easy but well done to her. GFRIEND was renowned for having one of the best 3rd generation vocalists Yuju who can compete with Wendy, Solar or Siyeon and in addition to singing very hard vocally GFRIEND had some of the most difficult and energetic choreography of the era. Noe was in his very good facial expression element. Eunchae also did a good job of leading which was not easy given her young age. - GFRIEND team 2 Nayoung is so bright I love her energy and everyone would like to have a leader like her. maybe she should have been a little stricter at the beginning but otherwise perfect she did a good job spread a good spirit in the group and the members did a good job big hand to Nayoung and Nako who are the centerpieces of this band . - honestly at the time in terms of popularity the 2 groups were quite close. the cute and absolutely adorable side of little Nako and the jovial and bright personality of Yamada Noe was very lickable. At the time I voted for team 2 because they were overall more stable vocally and seemed more comfortable. but as we see the popularity of 1 member can all change and Nako was ultra popular. frankly the 2 leaders were very cool, big hand to Eunchae and Nayoung. -Red velvet team 1 the battle of the centers between Gyuri (fromis 9) and Yiren (Everglow) frankly for me they are both perfect for the position perhaps Yiren suits more the concept of Peek a bo. afterwards for me since the song is darker and more mature I think that Kaeun would have been perfect for the center position on this song. - yes it's exactly the same thing as with Chanmi, same editing, same cliffhanger. the difference is that Gyuri was much more popular than Chanmi at the time worn by all fans of fromis 9.
fabrice maire
2024-05-10 17:34:53 +0000 UTC-At the time I felt very sorry for Gyuri even if the evaluations don't mean anything in absolute terms. seeing her moved to F even though she is a confirmed Idol who was in a fairly popular group only confirmed her feeling which was that she still had a lot of shortcomings even if for me it was just that she seriously lacked confidence in her. Same thing for Shiroma Miru who for me was one of my favorite Japanese idols. Miru who we recently saw again in Queendom Puzzle. I'm glad you noticed her DG I knew you liked her as well in QP. - you see DG you found it a bit unfair that Goto Moe got a grade of F while she had a loss of voice so she had a very good performance despite all the judges we were able to hear her voice and we adjusted are grade a C which seems fair enough to me for Moe - you recognized several DG girls which is already very good even if you still have trouble with the members of Everglow like Kim Shi hyun who is the leader say that I understand because Everglow doesn't make a lot of comebacks and you haven't done a lot of reaction on this group. - An Yujin of course my Girl received an A she a Star like Wonyoung a natural born Idol. - so many girls who are very popular idols these days I can't name them all but produce 48 has the greatest success among the trainees more than half are making their debut and in the other half several are celebrities or actresses. Honda Hitomi and Yabuki Nako like Juri, Miru or Sakura were also among the Japanese who had potential at the time. - DG I heard your argument but the bad editing does not directly affect the Girls, just the viewers. and but of course my argument about heroes who have to go through things so that we are affected by them works even more on real people. I understand your feeling of wanting to protect the girls, I am not as insensitive as I let it appear. but my vision of things is that the world is very hard and particularly for idols if they cannot withstand the pressure of a survival show they will have a lot of difficulty making a career. some idols succumbed to the pressure and gave up, others even committed suicide. I think it is better to confront them with pressure before the start of their career so that they are prepared for it. Being too nice will only bring them occasional comfort. Sakura is among the worst today because she withstood this pressure and nothing can touch her anymore. The proof is that the criticism she received from Coachella did not destabilize her that much. . - my god I no longer remembered that Jo Yuri had gone from A to F -I completely agree with you DG I think seeing all the girls' dance performances would have been cool. even if it's one minute per girl and there were a lot of girls who were in class A but as I've said several times MNET focuses on certain girls because like many I think Mnet had these favorites and a pretty precise idea of the concept they wanted for IZ*ONE I think that's why they focused on certain girls like Yujin, Sakura or Kaeun (I'll come back to kaeun in other episodes) I love it this girl. - the moment where Sakura is crowned the center of the Pick me performance is a great TV moment for me, all of Mnet's editing of the previous 2 episodes is done to make this moment count. If we had not given the impression that the Japanese did not have the level this moment would have had no interest we would have simply said cool Sakura is the center we move on. but the fact that the Korean trainees also vote for Sakura and that they are recognized for their potential is very touching. that Kaeun, who is an idol who also already made her debut at the time with a very popular group like After school, congratulates her also gives weight to this consecration. Sakura, who was already an inspiration for many Japanese people, will also become one for many Koreans. - yes the presenters of Mcountdown at that time were Lee daewhi from Wanna one, Binnie and Seunghee from Oh my girl. - my god Yujin chose monsters from the beginning that members that I adored Yena, Wonyoung, Hitomi, Nako, Miru, Goeun for me even if Sakura's team was not bad the real Avengers team was the Yujin team. with Goeun and Nako they had very good vocalists, with Yena, Hitomi and Yujin very good dancers. and a very beautiful visual line. - of course Sakura was going to choose a Red Velvet song, she is a big fan of the group and her favorite group. At the time, meeting the members of Red Velvet was a dream
fabrice maire
2024-05-10 15:46:06 +0000 UTC- "For every girl arriving here in A, the chances that someone has to leave will be higher". So, effectively making every arriving girl even more unwelcome... ๐ซฃ - Yeah, sure there needs to be some adversity, but there's a limit to how much I can handle ๐ฌ (that's why I never was able to finish watching Grave of the Fireflies). Also, fabricated adversity is something I can do without. - Jo Yuri going down from A to F? Well, looking forward to her resurgence ๐ฅ - Although I agree that I also would like to have seen more of the performances by the A girls, it might also be a little unfair to the non-A girls in terms of camera time. - I can confidently say that she isn't Yeonjun from TXT ๐ - I really like the maturity of Ka Eun - F are the "backup" dancers. I'm not sure how that works exactly but it's funny imagining the center (Sakura) getting "backed up" by an F ๐ - "Wasn't that the girl from Oh My Girl?". Yup, that was Hyojung. - When I heard "random draw" I was happy that it finally was gonna be done fairly. But because only 1 member is random and the rest is basically picked by strength, it's not random at all ๐ก - The race thing again? ๐ซฃ Just because nobody has gotten injured by it yet, doesn't mean it's not dangerous. - We really needed a "center" counter in this episode ๐ - So we already are getting centers Yiren (Everglow), Seung Hyun (H1-key Riina), Yun Jin (Le Sserafim), Juri (Rocket Punch), Wonyoung (IVE) ๐ - Did you just say that the Boombayah team should just go out there and perform it As If It's Your Last? Smooth ๐ - A group with IVE, Le Sserafim, Purple Kiss and Yena? Damn G-Friend - Love Whisper - Seeing you enjoying the beat and the electric guitar pretty much confirms my prediction that you're gonna love G-Friend ๐ I mean, they're often called the light side to Dreamcatcher's dark side ๐ - Not only did Nako sing so well, I also really liked her tone. Red Velvet - Peek-A-Boo - What is happening with the editing??? I think they are doing this very weird cut so they can repeat Gyu-ri's mistake even more times ๐ซฃ So far, it's not even that big of a mistake really. I.O.I. - Very, very, very - They found a way to make previews even more annoying by not letting you know it's a preview ๐ก
crispy chicken
2024-05-10 15:11:00 +0000 UTC
