I feel like if the potter’s chose Lupin, the secret keeper would still end up being Peter. Whether it’s Sirius or the Potters who suggest Lupin first, I think he would respond with “no, I’m a werewolf it’s too dangerous.” Then say they should choose Sirius, and if Sirius still thinks he’s too obvious he’d then suggest Peter.
Sarah Jane
2025-05-06 21:42:15 +0000 UTC
Here's A thought Peter goes to be the DADA professor. Was the DADA curse in effect at that time? Well at least we know Peter won't last that long as DADA teacher