NokiMo
The Regulation Podcast
The Regulation Podcast

patreon


Best Halloween Candy Draft Poll

Who Won the Halloween Candy Draft?

Previous Draft Wins

Andrew: 3

Graysie: 1

Nick: 1

Gavin: 1

Eric: 0

Geoff: 0

Comments

Supplemental where the winner has to eat all the losing candies just to make sure they were right.

AlanW

It's between Nick and Eric with the good candy choices, but the fact that Nick hates Smarties make him the loser. Eric wins. Listen To 100% Eat

ListenTo100PercentEat

Andrew"s jar of peanut butter was wild lmao

Alexander LaCount

I wish they would add what each person selected because I always forget. Cheeky way for me to listen again.

CobWebb

Nick was so close but the smarties

connor

100 grand bar gets the win hands down

SpryLad

Eric had the best picks hands down. 100 Grand is a highlight of the Halloween season. Well done sir.

Mookey

I also have a terrible memory and had to go pull up the video and skip to the end to look at it, lol

Kanoles

Andrew lost this one sadly, I always hated carrying those big jars around.

Mr Fedora Mustache

Eric won when he said 100 grand. Most underrated candy especially fun size version

Sam

Nick had my vote until he said Smarties were the worst. I live for Smarties.

Stefanie Simpson

Are Sour Patch Kids and Reeces Pieces Halloween candies? I’ve never gotten either on Halloween. Those are definitely movie theater candies to me. Eric wins for the mini bar representation.

Nathan Pepper

I was more invested in Eric’s best picks, but with Nick picking rockets it cemented my choice since I hate them with a passion

Rolo Klassen

I was torn between Eric and Geoff, but Eric picking candy corn as the worst absolutely cemented his win in this draft. Andrew is insane for picking an entire jar of peanut butter, but his razor blade pick was funny. I would be happy to receive raisins if the alternative was candy corn. I also like Twix more than Snickers, and that also influenced my vote in this draft.

Austin Breuer

My wife hasn't but with a trip and halloween coming up and I got her to listen. I said you understand Andrew more now don't you!

Sandrocky88

You guys should post what everyone drafted on these polls. I have a terrible memory 😆

Maddy

Eric had me until Candy Corn being the worst..

Crohnenberg

This was a confusing episode as a European. Definitely voting for Gavin!

AEPSchmitt

Andrew with the win here!

Michael Mariani

Same. Love all of his first 3. But I love a smartie.

Brian Burkhardt

Nick lost it for me when he picked Smarties. Candy Corn sucks, and Eric was already close.

Brian Burkhardt

Nick had my vote until the smarties as the worst.

Leesa Austin

SHOWING THE PREVIOUS DRAFT RESULTS IS BLATANT VOTER TAMPERING

Davis Rybaski

My wife has only ever listened to snippets of the show, but she listened to the candy draft with me and was absolutely flabbergasted by the jar of peanut butter.

ScoobDrew

I am a slut for resses holiday editions it was my golden snitch so Nick has my vote.

Matthew Hughes

Eric was winning the first half but ruined it at the end Gavin was consistently pretty good

Saysi

It was close but Eric wins based on the final round. He picked an actual Halloween themed candy that is also terrible.

ErkDerkly

if Eric doesn't win this one I can't trust any of you animals - or Geoff. both valid. There is no way in hell Andrew ever received a jar of reese's peanut butter on halloween so imo he disqualified himself.

Kanoles

You’re a psycho if you think Reese’s pieces and peanut butter M&Ms are the same size

Jeffrey Saari

Reposting from the actual draft page: ... Ok, so I was so on board with Nick until the end there. But I think maybe the order of the draft fucked him. I hope that's what it was. Those we never my favorite, but far from my least. Gavin, I just can't pick because I haven't had half of that and I do enjoy Turkish Delight. Eric is too caramel heavy for me. That leaves Geoff and Andrew and, well, we all know that means I'm voting for Geoff.

Roger Flynn

I was so on board with Andrew. He was winning by a mile. But the last two picks were so wild I couldn't go with it. Had to pivot to Eric

Alex R

Nick is 100% right about the smarties. Get that out of here.

Alyssa L Miller

Andrew may have the most wins, but Graysie is undefeated

SaltiRogue

Eric nailed my candy cravings list

sugarpuss

If Andrew only knew that their peanut butter in the jar is like the peanut butter in the candy, but unknown to him and myself when I made this discovery. That peanut butter is salty like the sea. Did not realize the sweet chocolate balances the salt out and its great. Not good by itself or with jam on bread.

Demonman187

Nick won me over with Butterfinger BBs alone - my favorite candy I'll never get to taste again D;

Shelby

Bro really said "Jar Of Peanut Butter" with his whole chest...

Jake Hoggen

Unfortunately I don't think I've had most of the candy that people chose, although everyone did have 1 candy that I liked; sour patch kids, kitkat, peanut m&ms, kinder bueno. However, all of Geoff's picks were things that I had as a kid.

Joe

Ditto. I guess I'll just have to re-watch the draft... :/

Dave Mackenzie

We seriously not giving the Jar of peanut butter a chance? 🤣😂🤣

Stephen Moreno

Eric for 100 grands!

Cameron Bass

can we have an option for not andrew?

Chris Buckley

Eric being rewarded for safe picks 🙄

AJ T

I've literally never tried a 100 Grand bar because the packaging turned me off as a kid. They were spot on

Cole

Geoff in 4th place is actually insane. Eric won over the internet with his extremely cold take on candy corn. It's like saying "pineapple pizza bad" to me lol

Cole

100% It’s offbrand peanut butter with a tiny bit of sugar, added to it

Bar One

Andrew brought the most entertainment with his draft, but Geoff has my vote. Good candy

Gorexn

I do wish they would include the picks in the poll

Jake Shidler

Gavin had elite picks throughout, and couldn't have brought a better worst pick either. Clear win

Toby Ives-Moody

100 Grand is such a sleeper pick. It's amazing

Schweet

Sour and fruity gummy’s need so much more love

Tony Figueroa

eric naming 100 grand twix and kitkat has me fucking performing a standing ovation

Alyssa Gordon

Since this draft was top 3 favorite and one worst. My draft for this is 1. Eric 2. Geoff 3. Nick 4. For the worst person’s draft to get in my halloween bag, Andrew.

Doverman

I was on the Andrew train for this one. Gotta say though, lost me in the second half.

Jeff

Nick wins by default for me with the Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkin even though candy corn is by far and away the worst real pick on that list. Eric in close second but I can't get behind Twix and 100 Grand as there are far better "best" Halloween candies out there. Andrew is as unhinged as usual.

Spencer McCormick

even though i am one of the 12 people on this earth who love candy corn, eric got my vote.

Urk Mazerloni

Is it just me or is the Reese's peanut butter in the Jar the worst peanut butter on the shelf?

Nathan Adams

Nick's 4th round pick killed his draft. Was neck and neck with Eric for me until then. Eric knocked it out of the park with candy corn, the quintessential Halloween candy

Tony Queen

Eric had KitKat and Twix. Two best candies by far!

Joshua Neditch

You should put what got drafted and not the name.

Adam Staron

I wanna know what was going through Andrew's head

Keer

Big whiff with no one picking York peppermint patties

Yusef R

Good to see Eric getting on the board

Tim Robinson

Would have sided with Nick but he has bad Smarties takes smh. This guy probably hates the sixlets candies, too.

Kat don Vee

Really, REALLY tough choice for me between Eric and Nick. Eric beat nick with Candy Corn, but Nick’s Butterfinger beats Eric’s 100g for me

Tom

I would be saying Gavin won, but Turkish Delights are delicious

Goostunny

Another Brit here, Gavin nailed it. Although I would have put Parma Violets as the worst.

John C

This was a close one, everyone had solid choices with one outlier. I’m with Nick until his worst

Matthew Tomlinson

Andrew salad creamed TF out of his!

WickedD365

Gotta agree with Gavin here. I'm British, and those were all great choices. Plus Turkish delight is just the worst.

Joe

Loved Gavin's but could not agree with him about Turkish delight. I'd sell my family for that stuff

Ross Orchard

Not enough love for the fruity/gummy category, why'd Andrew have to throw last minute 😭

Ben Kenobi

I’d have *loved* to go Nick but the smarties pick as a worst was tragic

Bop

My faves werent picked, but my worst was. I had turkish delight in 2nd grade and that was traumatic. Never again, so Gavin wins my vote

Charles O.

How is Eric winning

Kole

I can't believe how hard Andrew fumbled his last two picks. A+ entertaining.

jacob schultz

Nick - Butterfinger BBs were. The. Shit. My favorite candy of all time was Reese's bites. Same era. Poppable little balls like the BBs. They had THE perfect chocolate to pb ratio. The most perfect ever. The new Reese's cluster bites are basically Nutrageous bites - which makes them amazing - but still, nothing can beat those old bites.

Tilgare

Eric had the best draft, no question

Andrey Chichagov

Oh my I have too many opinions on candy. It concerns me actually. Blow pop easily could have made my bad list with raisins - pulling GUM out of your Halloween bag is so disappointing. I love Cadbury flake and twirl bars after a trip to Ireland a few years ago. STRONG choice. I'm fine with candy corn, although I probably have never gotten it in a Halloween bag. Otherwise Eric's picks are some of my absolute top picks. But Nick got all the peanut/butter. Think I gotta go Nick.

Tilgare

I love a good Turkish delight, but I feel like it’d be a major let down in the Halloween pillow case

Zach Anaya

Agreed completely though I go candy corn > smarties personally so had to go Nick

Zach Anaya

As a Brit, I can confirm Gav won the draft

windyMelon

Nick won with Smarties over the tolerable/addictive candy corn as worst.

Zach Anaya

T-Bone had the most variety. Everyone else was just different versions of chocolate and peanut butter. Plus raisins suck at Halloween

Dustin

Definitely neck and neck between Eric and Nick until the hated candy round. Nick with a huge fumble at the end not appreciating Smarties.

AhriNaut

And he's totally right about Kinder Bueno. Best tasting bar on the planet.

Steve Davis

Gavin with UK bias, I literally said Turkish Delight as he did it was the clear mvp pick

Jackiswellcool

Good picks all around but Eric nailed all 4.

David Mead

No one came close to Gavin, the mere idea that anything on anyone's list can compete with TINY MALTESER THINGS is absolute heresy

Adam Watson

I was with Nick until his insane pick on hating Smarties. All in on the RatMan

Rage Fueled

My pick for worst candy is DOTS. immediate trash. Not even on my lowest days would I eat a DOTS candy

Paul Mitchell

Totally agreed with Eric until the Candy Corn as worst candy pick. BUT I must concede it's a controversial candy so he gets the win

Josie

The Reese’s Peanut Butter JAR was such an insane pick I have to choose Andrew as the winner

James Cooper

Nick gets the auto vote for butterfinger BBs. I think about them at least once a month.

Vinnie B

I am going with geoff, a solid bag of good stuff.

Lori Lindo

I should have looked here, I couldn't remember the picks so I went to the video 😆

NedSleep

Candy Corn was given to people at Guantanamo Bay Source: trust me, bro

Alann Limon

Easy Eric W

Colin

In my opinion, Geoff had the best bag mainly because I've never gotten candy corn in my Halloween bag, as was a specified parameter; plus the blow-pop balances the scales well alongside the two chocolate choices, and the raisin boxes are the superior worst trick-or-treat item

BernNotice

I don't want to vote because I don't think anyone's list was good enough. But I will. Wish there was an option to say who just lost because that was Andrew.

LawlessReaper

Gavin. By a country mile.

Christopher Callaghan

It’s Eric and it’s not even close

Sean Lane

Eric wins just because of KitKat

Tyler

My wife and I were listening to Eric's second pick and we both said "Oh it's already in the bag."

Alan Dent

Well, Andrew disqualified himself by both saying not a candy, especially not a Halloween candy or something ever actually given out on Halloween, and then something based on an urban legend and something edible at all.

Avlin Starfall

As much as it pains me Eric is just right across the board on this one. If we were voting for which list makes the best content it would be Andrew.

Sean Larmee

Andrew chose Reeses peanut butter destroyed his list. Like wtf

Sir Fishy

Andrew wins off creamy Reese’s peanut butter by default

Alex Wazlo

I almost went with Nick despite him besmirching Smarties' good name because Reese's is the ultimate Halloween candy. Unfortunately for him, Eric edged him out with some great picks that were all based in chocolate too and the most accurate worst Halloween candy. I'll take "chalky" Smarties over the waxy bullshit of candy corn thank you very much.

Mark Whitty

Nick: Reese's Pumpkin, Butterfinger BB's, M&M Peanut, Smarties Gavin: Teaser, Kinder Bueno, Cadbury Twirl, Turkish Delight Eric: Twix, KitKat, 100 Grand, Candy Corn Geoff: Snickers, Blow Pop, Mr Goodbar, Raisins Andrew: Sour Patch Kids, Reese's Pieces, Creamy Reese's Peanut Butter, Razor Blade

Colin Curtis

I stand corrected. I haven't looked up Turkish Delight in a while and thought it was more of pastry than it was.

Ardvark Man

Nick's list was so strong, but i think his imprudent impuning of the irresistible Smarties was his demise.

ComradeCrazylegs

I think the Krackle bar is missing. It's special because it just doesn't come as a full bar, you can only get it as part of a variety pack. Also I LOVE candy corn! I feel that Eric won.

Travelinmatt76

The people voting for Andrew are not voting in the spirit of the draft which bugs the hell out of me

TheDoopster

It’s tough because i have fond memories of loving candy corn as a kid…even though I can’t eat as much as I used to, I still enjoy a couple when they’re available. that all being said, everyone always forgets about 100 Grand when, in reality, it is VASTLY underrated. Considering Eric’s other picks are just as stellar, I gotta go with him even if his candy corn hatred is a little extreme for me

Kat

Andrew’s fake accounts voted for him

Patrick

geoff and eric tied in my scoring. I ultimately chose geoff because I would be happier to get his lineup of candy in a handful of trick or treat goods. mr goodbars are actually pretty slap. blowpops are AMAZING and snickers is just the cream of the crop staple. erics lineup was too basic and safe for me but apparently it paid off.

laul

Americans voting have never had anything on Gav’s list

TheDoopster

Just hearing the words Butterfinger BBs reminds me of hours of toothpicking in my youth. Ahhh memories.

ComradeCrazylegs

What non-candy did Gavin pick? Teasers, Kinder Bueno, Twirl and Turkish Delight? They're all Halloween candy/confectionery items

nick hemley

I despise peanut butter and chocolate so any picks of that just went straight to the bottom of my list. Actual peanuts in snickers & peanut m&ms is great though. Drafting a flipping JAR OF PEANUT BUTTER as a halloween candy is actually deranged

nick hemley

On the technicality that Nick downplayed Smarties and Eric and Geoff chose two old people candies, I’m going with Gavin. I know everything he chose is gonna be tasty despite the fact that I haven’t tried one of them.

Mvs

It's tough where I would normally go with Eric full stop, but the candy corn opinion really has me thinking

Chaz Surfboard

Eric's list is objectively the best, but I will not stand for candy corn slander. Peanut M&M's are vastly overrated and pumpkin Reese's is too much peanut/chocolate ratio, so Nick is out. Geoff's list is lukewarm and I have no idea what Gavin picked, so Andrew is the clear winner here.

Rigdab

Andrew really had such a strong 1 & 2 and then just absolutely threw it away

Kevin Farmer

This rules

Joe

I hate that I still have to give this one to Nick even with his egregious slander of Smarties.

Mitchell Goodwin

I like candy corn but i have to go with Eric for the rest of his picks. Only guy who didn't really pick peanut butter for everything besides Gavin

ryan mehan

Eric and Nick are the only two not disqualified. Everyone else picked non-candy items. Edit: I'm dumb, Turkish Delight is more of a gummy than I thought it was. Thanks Nick.

Ardvark Man

Eric wins and it isn't even close

Emily Burnside

Like all his candy, gavin has this in the bag!

Ryan Haayer

Normally I'm voting for the memes, but damn, Eric has me on this one.. The man just knows. Hope I can sleep tonight with this vote cast...

Zachary Lapp

Eric winning this is crazy. Gav picked best by a country mile.

Flailing Pariah

I was all for team Nick until the rockets/smarties slander. Eric FTW

julesiax

Eric getting his first ever win TODAY

Jacob Collier

How Andrew has ANY votes here is an utter mystery. Anyone who votes for that abomination of a draft needs a full psych evaluation. A tie between Eric & Gavin would be perfect

nick hemley

I cannot vote Eric. Candy corn gets hate for no reason.

Elijah

Almost went with Nick cause the pumpkin Reese’s are that good, but I gotta give it to Eric overall.

Nicholas Esposito

As an Englishman, Gavin’s picks were 100% spot on

Ryan Bennett

I actually love smarties and candy corn, otherwise it would've been Nick for me

Deweyc0x

Good of Andrew to let one of the others win this one

Willsy

The peanut butter and razor blade picks through it for me. Andre was 100% win until then.

TheJoseph123

Nick had my vote until he picked smarties as the worst candy

Rebekah

Andrew's last picks were unhinged and I love it. Not enough to choose him as winning the draft, but he really went for it!

GlazedMcGuffin

Easy Gavin win here surely

Tom Scott

The Brits are stuffing the ballot box for Gavin! We cannot allow this!

Craig

So... We're just voting for Andrew for the lulz now? A jar of peanut butter..... No....

Stryix

Andrew is normally so anal about picking stuff that pertains to what their drafting, and then picks 2 things that aren’t candy

PizzaCat

I was so with Andrew until the tub of peanut butter

Atoms_Asunder

Gavin. No contest

Jonathan Hegney

Early congrats to Eric on the W

Icky Tickler

Voting for Andrew here is unacceptable

Blake

Never thought I'd vote for Eric but here we are

Benjamin Zmyewski


Related Creators