The Drinks Draft

I hate almost all the drinks everyone picked. I was with Gavin when he started with Coffee, and then it was all downhill from there.

Mathieu Apers

Nick is absolutely correct, those are all different drinks

Bianca Lemire

Andrew won on taste, Nick won on funny 😂

Quentin Nichols

So happy this is finally out - what a fucking absurd lineup 🤣 can't believe the turnout on the votes

Taylor Child

If coffee counts as all variations of coffee, you gotta remove the split of coke / diet coke, and honestly both soda in general and various teas could be called into question.

Keith

Please try horchata, it's really good

Austin Thomas

Gavin wins on pick one. Scoops up coffee, leaves the rest of em in shambles

Leon Browne

Honestly feel like Nick should be DQ’d, lol

Cory Mingo

Can we please get a recap of who drafted what

Ozzy Zamora

Andrew won my vote just with Barq's

PerniciousPumpkin

these polls really do need a recap of the lists... ive already forgotten who i thought won...

Packrat Princess

SoBe Nirvana is the greatest drink that has ever existed on planet Earth. I won't be taking questions

Alan Dent

Andrew was the only one I felt didn’t go against the spirit of the draft, for once surprisingly, so he got my vote.

Anthony Dewitt

I like that Geoff was just like, this is what I want to drink and some of it is weird.

Lia DeKesthler

literally none of the picks had alcohol, that was brought up multiple times during the draft…

Ryan

nah, i totally give props to Eric for that specific pick. I mentioned it originally then edited my comment down because it got way too lengthy. most of the rest of the pics just felt like personal faves though

ambrug

Well, Eric picked diet coke first even though he doesn’t like diet coke so you’re kind of completely wrong.

Tuomas L

I stand with Eric for the eggnog and Diet coke

Brooke

I liked Andrew’s list the most overall, but Geoff’s Route 44 Diet Cherry Limeade pick spoke to my soul so I had to go with him.

Collin Brown

“You think Dr. Pepper is better than Pibb?” Get him, Geoff.

Brando Marlon

I'm a soda lover, so Andrew's all-soda lineup won me over

Justice Rainz

They were all pretty poor ngl 😂

Eoin

I voted Gavin on principle. Although I agree with Eric that a PSL is functionally a different drink than coffee, while maybe not necessarily being fundamentally different. However, an Americano is too close to coffee (which I assume Gavin meant a pour over or french press)

Spoon

I wanted to vote no one b/c they're basically just choosing personal faves, not "draft" picks. like you're not trying to pick your best friend in a fantasy football league, you're picking an actual football player, right? and not a retired player? (I assume those can't win you points 🤷‍♂️) went with geoff b/c I suppose I personally prefer his, but no one choosing WATER in this draft is untenable to me tbh

ambrug

I didn't vote for it but surprised Geoff is so low

Durzy

I was definitely expecting Eric to be winning…

Maddy

Great picks all around but number one goes to Andrew.

Cirynx

It seems like the commenter's love Eric's list, but the voting doesn't reflect that.

Adam Staron

For me it’s the Eggnog

Buggy52

If I can make the Arnold Palmer with unsweetened tea and the London Fog without espresso, then it's Nick by a landslide. If I have to take them as written, it's Eric

John Hackett

Eric by an absolute long shot. Lost me with the Diet Coke; got me back with the Basic White girl PSL. Love me a PSL

Robert Spray

Now we need a non coffee & tea soft drink draft

NRay7882

Eric's list is just head and shoulders above any other list here, in my opinion. Honestly, the Horchata pick alone pretty much sealed it, but all his other picks are great as well.

Michael Truex

I'm such a sucker for PSL and we're right around the corner from this seasonal delight!

Corey R

Nick just had the nice family of caffeine and sugar

Sam

Geoff won me over on sweet tea alone

Brett Walker

Geoff won over my southern heart with those last 2 picks

Seth Curtis

Eric wins imo JUST because of Diet coke

NerdTronJJ

Im really suprised nobody chose fruit juice of any kind! Also Lilt still exists in the UK it just got rebranded to Fanta Pinapple and Grapefruit

Richard

If you assume a large percentage of the votes for Nick are just purely for Comedy, than I think Andrew is the runaway winner here, lol

Frank Allen

Idk what the fuck Vimto is but Geoff for sure won me over with sweet tea and sonic cherry lime aid.

Reese

It would help to have a linked spreadsheet or screenshot on these posts to refresh my memory. Nick usually wins for me, but not only do I hate his picks this time anyways, he simply cannot be allowed to get away with this.

Tilgare

Almost voted nick because my love for Arnold Palmer but the rest of his list sucks and only assume he's second place atm because trolling

CloudyVro

Had to vote for Geoff for originality

Tayden

Andrew but special shout out to Nick for lemonade.

Caleb Klauzer

Can't vote for Andrew. Gotta take at least one non-soda.

Adam Staron

100% agree, however I voted for Eric PSL, Horchata and Milk Punch.

Brandon Hannem

As someone who doesn't drink soda or coffee, Geoff's list was the only one I think I could at least try to drink all of, so he gets my vote.

Josh O.

Came to comment this too. Totally on his side.

Trevor

While I really want to try Nick's Fogspresso, Eric earned those big horchata points and took this one imo.

Dallas (leavinsanity)

Gavins list sucks but I'm voting for him because he was right

Bryan Adams

Arnold Palmer is all I drink so I had to pick who I picked but I didn’t like doing it

Steven J Norris

Eric won that draft by default, and Gavin should get the same here

Archery Contest

*shakes head*

Phoenix Edits

I’m an Eric guy

Tony Figueroa

“Coffee. Tea with coffee. Lemonade. Tea with lemonade.”

Derek Smith

So Mr. nuclear criticality has beef with a pumpkin spice latte

Chris Smith

I would have had A&W Root Beer or Timmy's Iced Cap.

Regulation Brenton

Going with Eric cause I'm a basic bitch pumpkin spice man myself. And Gav getting away with just "coffee" was asinine.

SomeRyeBread

Was an interesting one, def think gavin got screwed with coffee not being discussed

Cobra_ss

Eric deserves the W, for being the coffee guy unafraid to admit that he loves a cheeky PSL.

Merjia

Would have given it to Eric if he didn’t go with the diet variants

Courtney Powell

Andrew almost lost it for me with the Mountain Dew pick but he still gets it.

Sam

Unironically it's absolutely Eric he picked 4 absolute bangers

Evan Murphy

Hmmm. I don't drink coffee and I don't drink pop. I'm left with . . . Bovril?

Aven

All ya'll Andrew voters are basic

Roger Flynn

Voting as if this is all I could drink for the rest of my life (besides water), I'm going with Nick.

Roger Flynn

Please in the future can there be a final list so we dont have to go back into the video to remember. Also did this pop up in peoples feeds, it didn't for me I stumbled upon this post

ThatoneGuyoverThere33

100% why I went with Nick too

Erick Escobar

When you pick your membership option it tells you what you're getting? Did you miss the bullet points?

Alex C

Dylan

Dr. Pepper on Andrew's list is what tipped the scales in his favor, for me.

Austin Breuer

What I’d like to see them do a draft for is worst national anthem performances of all time cuz I know Geoff and Eric watched the home run derby and that performance was easily top 10 worst in the last 30 years

HometownHiro

🇨🇦 Canada has the best pop! Which is why Andrew made the best picks - called the picks before he said them

Joshua Smith

Also shocked that no Minute Maid fruit juice flavors made the draft. That shit is liquid crack.

Aidan Dressler

Gav because I agree with him about the coffee rule. Obviously a pumpkin spice latte is very different from a black drip coffee but it would have been a much more interesting draft if they went by Gavin's rules.

Aidan Dressler

Gav got robbed on this

Beetus

Andrew's list is just sodas! Geoff's had the best variety!

Eduardo Lopez

Andrew wins on Dr Pepper alone

Abbie

I came to my decision of Nick because if the list was the only drinks I could drink for the rest of my life, I'd be set with essentially coffee, tea, and lemonade.

kenper

Had to pick Andrew because I don’t drink coffee or alcohol

Seth Heder

Nick's draft choices were so bold and avant-garde, I have to support him.

Perfidious Fate

I need Erik to drink a Diet Coke. 😅

Marqujr

They were all not great. I chose Andrew solely because of the root beer.

EightySix SecondWin

How was Andrew not the one Salad Creaming this one??😂

Rae

Gavin plain and simple because if the Americano and Pumpkin Spice Latte debacle. But Andrew's picks most align with my own, but honestly shocked there was no gatorade/powerade/kool-aid/flavored waters *at all*. It was essentially a coffee and soda draft with a few outside the box picks...

Mike

None of you

Shignett23

I somewhat begrudgingly chose Nick 😁. Had it been me, I wouldn't have let americano slide.

Boogurt

Not a coffee drinker so Andrew's list lines up with my tastes the most, but props to Eric for the Egg Nog pick, Egg Nog's awesome. I love Dr. Pepper but I wish they still sold the cane sugar version in the US, it's so much better.

Alan Reynolds

i'm voting Gavin just because he got so hilariously screwed on the coffee pick

Stephen Galvin

If anyone had water they would win for me, but runner up was straight up coffee, so... The rest was okay, but not near coffee... Like half the list has caffeine!

Kenneth Sundby

Nick for Comedy, Andrew for top-to-bottom quality. I have no idea what Geoff was doing.

Brandon Telle

As I sit here drinking an Arnold Palmer... Nick gets my vote.

fake_account_to_patreonize

I'm with Gavin aside from Bovril because I have NO idea what that tastes like, but I'm voting Nick because I never even thought about asking for espresso with a London Fog but that sounds delicious.

Sepp

Eric and Nick are close calls but I just really hate Arnold Palmers so I gotta go Eric.

Victoria Marie

This is hard, because I want Eric to win a drink he doesn't want, Nick's list was the funniest and Gavin was kind of right about the coffee 🤔

Tereza Fraňková

I gotta go with Gavin based solely on the fact he’s got Coffee, the one beverage I drink multiple times a day besides water and Mexican Coke.

WarriorGuero

Andrew’s list is just soda, no variety. Can’t imagine anyone voting for Andrew is older than 15

PizzaCat

Eric's Horchata pick is the ultimate S tier, if it's made right, lots of places mess it up. The cinnamon and sweet condensed milk has a perfect balance. Pre made horchata is complete trash.

CybrTwo

Easy, Andrew’s list is the most solid and even includes true gamer fuel Mountain Dew

Jay ManX