I was obsessed with this show when it was originally on the air. Now re-watching it with the two of you is making me love it all over again.
Realizing that the Cylons were living their best lives not thinking about the humans until their space got invaded and finding out that may have led to the invasion and genocide was a gut punch for everyone that watched in real time. Adama’s guilt and insecurity makes him feel like a 3 dimensional character and not some cardboard cutout sci-fi commander that does no wrong and has no fear, was also very satisfying. The writing on this show was great.
All that said, you still need to hold on to your hats cause it starts to get crazy.
Enjoy.