THE FINAL POLL!

one piece would be cool but its the only anime that i think people should watch on their own

LIA

React to kuroko no basket ! Sport anime with best reac material

isln

yeah, came out 2 years after manga releases...and then caught up within 1 year. LOL, stupid fillers and slow pacing...painful. Which wasn't as bad as later on...

Mojira

Wit Studio has so many amazing projects. On top of AoT, you have Vinland Saga, the Ranking of kings, Spy Family, and a few other amazing shows. Also, recent Netflix animated shows like Pluto and Blue Eye Samurai were just straight-up fire. Imagine OP improved pacing with 1 hr episodes!

Mojira

Honestly, just wait for the remake lmao. I love One Piece but Toei has brought that series to a snail's pace since basically the beginning.

Chimpman

Idk guys... rewatching AGK as a grown-ass dude was just so boring and cheesy. I rarely think that about anime.

The Great Santini

I'm here for the One Piece remake news lol, this would be the perfect timing for anyone that has interest in starting the anime. Wit Studio did a fantastic job for the first 3 seasons of AOT and this is going to be on Netflix so I have zero doubt in the remake quality. Once they got the right pacing, the storytelling would kill everything. I am so excited for this.

Gill

one piece is getting remade! wait till then, HOLY SHIT I AM PUMPEDDDDDD.

Mojira

Even though I don’t agree about them start with One Piece. I knew instantly you were not being too serious lol.

Jesus Rocha

off course. every sunday first thing i do after i finish with my lunch shift in hotel is read manga and then run to youtube to see reactions :D

Cayseron

it will be a long journey that is for sure, are you up to date manga/anime?

Manuel Eduardo Diaz Cabrera

thank you. i also am looking forward to the future where they start watching one piece and we get to butt heads again in comment section of their reaction videos over difference of opinions and/or crazy theories ^_^ (and i mean that in as positive way as possible :D )

Cayseron

sorry too, I got mad by your answer and texted a angry reply, we can be cool and move along.

Manuel Eduardo Diaz Cabrera

they should watch one pace

tracee miasco

OP manga is excellent, but the anime is goddamn horrible lol

noya22

start one piece after you finish HxH, having 2 multi hundred episode shows on your plate at once is a daunting task. Your Lie In April is a masterpiece, im very excited to see how this goes:)

Ryan

lmao

noya22

thank you. my pea brain can't grasp sarcasm among other things so i apologize if i jumped the gun on the wrong thing. should have paid attention to "xd". also i do agree with sentiment behind the message now that you elaborated. i too "can't wait" for them to start the one piece journey, whenever that happens

Cayseron

I put an "xd" to make it sound less serious matter, but I expected too much from quick to judge peas brains, my bad, will be more direct into what I mean while commenting, in this case is: "I can't wait for OP to win so you can watch a masterpiece"

Manuel Eduardo Diaz Cabrera

how conceited and narcissistic one has to be to say "hey, ignore thousands of votes and do what i want" >.<

Cayseron

no lol, polls are for this sake, and im glad it ended up this way lols

MarauderLP

Bro like, forget the list and start one piece xd

Manuel Eduardo Diaz Cabrera

one piece touch some of the very heavy topics and deeper into it you get more oda force people to question their morality and to stop seeing things as black and white. it touches on government corruption, police brutality, racism, classism, slavery, human trafficking, and most importantly it is not sugarcoating anything or being vague about it. the latest backstory alone is mindblowing with how dark it is and how serious topics it touches with certain characters. even without reading it, the basic synopsis of it gives you idea that this is not a classic mary sue story considering it is "pirate" that is protagonist. Yes it is flawed, pacing of anime is bad in early stages and there are fillers. that was a norm back in the days when anime had no hope of surviving and is doomed to drop the popularity if they miss the week. each episode was covering 2 chapters of manga so anyone with basic knowledge of math understands that anime covers twice as much content as manga creates per week so it is inevitable they will catch up and run out of canon material. If production of one piece started in 2020 for example we would be getting 24 episodes a year, split in seasons and who knows how long would it take to catch up to manga. but hey, at least there would be no fillers. what i mean is that fillers are problems of old but they can easily be skipped so i dont see the point of people complaining about it. What is the appeal? Some of the most heartbreaking storylines, epic moments, good fight, psychological content and real life problems being touched upon. One piece is masterpiece that can circumvent the things in order to make you cry over most random things or make the most random quotes that sound stupid out of context have great weight behind them or become iconic. you need to watch/read in order to fully understand what i mean but without doing so at least trust me when i say it is definitely not a children anime. maybe what you talking about is 4kids adaptation

Cayseron

its aight Let's not over hype shows before they start them

Kanta

As true as this is, I highly doubt the serious topics are why a majority of people who watch one piece watch one piece lets be real here

Night Sterling

Same and I recently finish watching it with my boyfriend and he loved it and it was my 5th time watching it 😅. First my brother and then my friends and lastly I watched it again with boyfriend and here I am again watching with them.

Jesus Rocha

Yeah, sadly I highly doubt they'll ever react to MIA, which you know fair enough I don't think Carlie would be able to handle the really problematic scenes.

Night Sterling

bro im just here for the HxH, anything else is a plus

Luis Cristóbal

that sounds petty

Cayseron

The mangaka is a weirdo lmao. Season 1 was good but the pedo overtones in the series is making its popularity die out quick. As it should. Also saying this as if you're implying YLIA isn't a masterpiece is hilarious. Love seeing your bad takes and complaining on every fcking patreon reaction channel there is

Thilde

You gotta remember it's only a poll of a very very small subsection of anime fans that also are willing to pay for this specific Patreon and ALSO prefer Carlie and Ange's more 'innocent' style (for lack of a better term).

The Great Santini

i think lack of votes is testament to its lack of popularity not lack of quality

Cayseron

I don't think everyone agrees with you there.

matthew bremmer

Wow. That is insane that made in abyss is not winning. That series is a literal masterpiece in the making.

L.C.

I would say jojo is doable, albeit hard, bleach is just too many episodes to take on, as well as 70-90% of those episodes being filler doesn't help as well. But tbh both shows are a tough commitment for reaction channels...

Денис Куличенко

i am in denial? gege came out and literally made statement without any ambiguity, simple and clean declaration that inspiration behind gojo is lesser known character from naruto aka Tobitake Tonbo. his words not mine, i am not in denial at all, you are just not informed at all lmao (most obvious one haha, what a joke. if anything when it comes to random guessing urahara is not even first pick, that spot belongs to kakashi, the teacher of 3 students with white hair that covers his eye and also eye gives him power. i dont know what stupid connection are you making with urahara but it is both wrong and embarassing that you dare calling it "most obvious one" not that it matters cause there is DIRECT QUOTE FROM GEGE regarding who gojo is inspired by) . also you think yuji the physically gifted protagonist with a demon inside him is based on ichigo instead of naruto? and what does megumi have in common with ishida? what even is the connection in your mind. how are you mentioning interviews and still managing to be so wrong. are you even trying to understand what gege is saying or are you just hopelesly making headcanons in your brain every chance you get. from very interviews you are mentioning is where i know for a fact that bleach is what got gege into writing manga. that alone does not mean he based jjk on bleach, nor is anything you say true in any way whatsoever. you say zaraki is the weakest link, i am saying zaraki is only factual character that gege admited drawing inspiration for his jjk characters. and yuji/megumi are not based on bleach at all, they are based on naruto and sasuke, but i guess that also flew over your head when you allegedly watched/read his interviews? EDIT: i bet you just google some random shit like "is jjk inspired by bleach" and open first reddit page and use that to cope but you do it so much you start believing your own lies and hide behind your sloppy research full of second hand biased POVs pretending you watched interviews where all you did is read article by random nobody who thinks is a journalist so you misinterpreted their already badly worded articles. its either that or worse alternative that you actually read the source but facts are flying over your head -.-

Cayseron

If you want another sports anime guys check out Baby Steps.

Fletch

one request and ill post daily on to every other post you will be posting sooo DAY 1 OF ASKING Carlie & Ange to watch K-On! watch K-On! please!!! it is similar to Bocchi the Rock and has also inspired me to play the guitar, similar to YLIA that has inspired me to play Piano. you will definetely love it, its very wholesome and has a bit more of episodes despite the genre (36 EP) , i dont care if it comes after YLIA or not (maybe give MIA watcher the slot so i dont get hated on) but K-On is a must watch after definetely loving Bocchi the Rock. Ange in particular will absolutely love K-On i bet my shorts on that. and also hoping you have a great day, much love from germany :D

MarauderLP

Lots of clowns

Drake

Lmao, your just a joke at this point, zaraki is the weakest link between bleach and jjk. ichigo and yuji, megumi and uryu, and urahara and gojo (the most obvious one) your just in denial when bleach is deadass the formula for most of the new gen anime. If your still gonna be delusional then do your research and read lil bro cus you’ve probably also haven’t seen the interviews and frequently asked questions🤦

Chocolatedude100

typical bleach fan toxic and grasping at straws. yes gege indeed said bleach was what got him into manga business and he made character with zaraki in mind but that is as far as that goes. gege and kubo are good friends and they throw ideas back and forth but jjk is in no way "inspired" by bleach. stop embarasing yourself and actually do the research instead of throwing shade at people without any basis. or at least learn what "inspired by" means, cause clearly the definition is flying over your head

Cayseron

Crazy cope from someone with 0 knowledge from the mangaka, gege spicificly said it himself that he was inspired by the bleach manga and author kubo

Chocolatedude100

yeah thats cap. bleach inspired jjk as much as science fair inspired nuclear bomb. bleach is what inspired gege to make a manga with similar concept. the actual inspiration for jjk specifically was drawn from hxh, yu-yu hakusho and naruto. i mean the line up is copy/paste of team 7 even though gege admited inspiration for gojo was not really kakashi but another less important character from naruto. i think only jjk related "inspiration" from bleach is todo's character being inspired by zaraki.

Cayseron

Yeah I do agree the manga is better. I started to reas the manga after I finish the show. However if it wasn’t for the show itself i wouldn’t know if I was going to like it.

Jesus Rocha

its been one week, relax yall

MarauderLP

Can you guys please consider jojo and bleach, bleach inspired jjk and most of the new gen shonen while jojo is one of the whackiest shows you would watch, they’re both really entertaining with huge fanbases.

Chocolatedude100

Excited for Your Lie in April reactions!

Gianne

@Ttsukasa Saying an opinion that differs from someone's doesn't mean being against people having an opinion. It's basically just opinion vs opinion. That's the nature of free speech. If anything, you're the one having a problem with someone (me) having an opinion (when it differs from yours) because you have a problem with me saying something that is against what's written in the OP.

Astor Lefflinker

manga was amazing, anime drops the quality fast the moment they ran out of manga material and just decided to end it quickly in worst way imaginable.

Cayseron

I can say is not perfect but personally is very enjoyable. Is a quick fast paced and shocking anime and it’s good for reactions. I love the character design and it has one of the strongest and best female villains in anime.

Jesus Rocha

Akame Ga Kill is SO BAD on rewatch. It was cool when I was first getting into anime in my teenage years, though,

The Great Santini

Id love for you guys to watch Akame Ga Kill or Juni Taisen fir WTF anime 😅

Jesus Rocha

Bro want more hxh lol

the grafted

?

Κώστας Βασιλειάδης

Hxh

Rasmus Ellgaard

oh oopsie xd

Nagi

but hes spitting facts!

the grafted

they gonna watch it after they are finished with haikyuu

Cayseron

Wait, have they not watched Blue Lock yet? Ange plays football right? Am I crazy here?

OctaviusLee

u r on the wrong post bro

bebe

YES EXACTLY THAT ; THANK YOU!

MarauderLP

1. oikawa 2. tanaka 3. hinata

Nagi

Lol swing and a miss (its not super popular but was amazing and thought provoking, straight down your alley , maybe even watch on your own Ange. "Now And Then, Here And There".

Ttsukasa

Astor why are you so against people having an opinion that differs from yours? You understand that there are many people out here who are not you and have lived experiences that differ from you right? Its okay for everyone to have differing opinions but at this point you are acting in bad faith, you ask why, they give you why, you ignore their why and continue on. If it happens it happens, If it doesn't, it doesn't, you say "plenty of channels react to OP and see success", if you are that desperate for said reactions why not go there for the time being, just as many have stated that if OP becomes a main focus here, we will also go elsewhere? Sidenote question, OP and the larger anime (AOT, BIG 3, death note, Code Geass) all have so many reactions, do you not see the appeal in smaller anime getting a chance over say the 50th reaction channel reacting to OP?

Ttsukasa

it is not realistic but it is currently all the rage in sport anime genre for better or worst. it is not my favorite sport anime and football is not even sport i really like but i can see why it is so popular and it probably has everything to do with the fact they threw the "realism" out of the way and made fantasy sports anime full of hype. i dont think it was ever about realism with bluelock and i doubt it will be about realism when it comes to picking or not picking it. when youtube is a carrier you have to play by the rules and sad rule of youtube is that what is popular goes, at least we can count our blessing and enjoy it along the way

Cayseron

If they love soccer/football, blue lock is too unrealistic. Id recommend giant killing which is good too

Reynel Obordo

i really hope you'll react to Miracle In Cell No#7 in the future. it's a really heartbreaking korean movie. i haven't seen other reactors react to this and i hope you give it a chance ❣

noya22

i believe they already said they will watch blue lock once they finish haikyuu, with Ange being so involved into football/soccer it only make sense tbh

Cayseron

about 700+ patrons judging from poll alone

Cayseron

I hope you will react another sports anime. I would recommend One Outs. Its a hidden gem anime to watch for, i promise you that

Reynel Obordo

Probably gonna have to wait for them to finish hxh for that one

Night Sterling

Im in the minority that likes most, if not all, the build up, I feel like OnePace removes a little too much. I never recommend it for a first watch through only rewatches. I think the only place the 'filer' got bad was Dressrosa.

DandyZombie

There's something like a community poll in their discord channel where you get to comment shows that you'd like them to react to, then the admins tally those that received the highest likes (Top 3 I think) and submit them to Carlie & Ange for their consideration then it's up to Carlie & Ange if they're gonna put them in the official polls. At least that's how it was explained to me by a discord member some months ago.

Astor Lefflinker

You just gave more reasons for why they shouldn't watch it lol. Who wants to watch hundreds of OP reactions?

The Great Santini

It's really not that good.. let's relax a bit lol just because it's new doesn't mean it's the best thing since sliced bread. It's like a 7/10 overall

The Great Santini

Wait I dont remember them getting weirded out by Nezuko's adult form??

The Great Santini

My hero academiaaaaa

Gianni

Not really, you're saying OP has no deep plots and mysteries. That's just factually wrong. It is slow paced tho

Tom thom

its not actually half that if you watch it on onepace. and the expereience is just better

souma shou

as long as they watch it on onepace.com I don't see them getting stuck on it for years

souma shou

what you on about, OP is great

souma shou

first of all because its not an anime and second its kinda mid ngl

souma shou

that's gay

souma shou

you can get more people on board to get them react to a niche show. its all about demand honestly. That's how they got to the 86 reactions cause people kept requesting

souma shou

if they watch it on onepace.com its all good

souma shou

All it takes is like 5 seconds to look at YaboyRockLee's channel to see that they're reacting to a plethora of other shows and there's no indication that they're an OP channel or that they prefer it. StruckByBelz is at 1k+ episodes now but they've also been reacting to so many shows. Boldcast is also reacting to it - Carlie & Ange mentioned them, it seems like they're friends or they follow each other, and Boldcast reacts to a wide variety of shows. FreshestAnime has almost 500 episodes but that channel also has a wide variety of shows they're reacting to. Heisuten is probably the only big channel I know that clearly converted into an almost OP-only channel and I seriously doubt Carlie & Ange will go that route even if they start reacting to OP. Difference in personality and channel style is too big.

Astor Lefflinker

looking at your points, Yaboyrocklee is a reaction channel i stopped watching because of it mainly becoming a OP channel, not a "Only One Piece" Channel, but they have definetely prefered it over some other animes and brought out more content in relation to OP, which i guess everybody can do what he wants, but i disliked it so i left the channel. I dont know what they are reaction to at the moment, but at that time it was becoming annoying for me. Also to your 2nd point, you are definetely right, i chose my words incorrectly so let me correct myself. Not every channel might become a op only channel, but in my past experiences it did not end so well, which is why i am scared that it might be going to end up the same. I know how good of a show OP is so them reacting to it so would be kind of cool to see, BUT like i said i think Shonens in general arent the greatest reaction fuel if you get me, because of many fillers and sooo many episodes. If Carlie and Ange started watching OP they would need to atleast bulk 5-6 episodes at a time to even keep up, which is also a factor that goes against that because they havent been reacting to more than 2 episodes at a time. them being up to date to OP episodes would take years if they only watch 1-2 at a time. but hey whatever floats their boat, i just hope that if they start it, they dont fk it up too bad. it would also be apart of their schedule for years to come so yeahh.. i wouldnt be watching the op reactions anyways

MarauderLP

I think they will stick to things that are fairly popular. It's just how the YouTube game is unfortunately. But it's understandable for the health of the channel.

Danny

Is there any specific way for us to recommend them a show to watch ? Because i don't think the cmt section can do it. There are some very niche show and old that their popularity can't compete with current or other more generic series.

Hoa Trương

YaboyRockLee channel started watching One Piece like 3 or 4 years ago but they didn't get stuck to being an OP-only channel. They actually have so many content they're reacting to right now and that they've reacted to and a lot of them are doing well. I was subscribed to them when they only had like 50k subs like a year or so ago and now they're close to 135k. So I don't think it's true that once a channel starts reacting to OP, they will turn into a OP-only channel. Their channel growth also won't be stunted. It's completely up to the channel, and Carlie & Ange already assured people in one of their replies either here or Youtube community that if they ever start reacting to OP, they will still have time for the other shows, so I don't understand this resistance to them reacting to a great and popular show like OP.

Astor Lefflinker

One Piece lost the poll. Its locked now. The winner was Your Lie in April, which isnt a shounen. We’ll watch whatever the people want. We generally have a decent balance on the channel tbh!

Carlie & Ange

tbh Shonen in general are just bad reaction content, the most watched videos of these reactions would only be the most hyped episodes, and the other episodes would be watched by a fair minimum i guess. (not sure tho, might be wrong on that, just a prediction) i personally LOVE OP, NARUTO, other Shonens etc etc. but its the worst reaction material tbh. sorry for the banter <3 i love you guys keep doing what you are doing!!

MarauderLP

im so thankful that one piece lost, please never watch it, or you will end up as a OP only channel. literally every reaction channel that i have watched, which then started to watch OP, became a OP channel mainly. just because OP is so fkn dominant. so i beg you, never watch this as a "reaction", or you will most definetely lose some fanbase. i love what you guys are doing honestly you are the BEST react channel i have ever watched, and i watch reactions daily basis. so please dont put OP in a Poll next time, this time it lost to YLIA which i am so thankful for, but if it wins EVEN once, you are most likely stuck in the OP loop, which fks most channels up badly.

MarauderLP

You literally agreed with my points.... like your paragraph is literally my point. Its exactly what I'm saying. And as of this moment this channel is not a OP content channel, the fear is that that is exactly what will happen because "It's a lot and only enjoyable in bulk".

Ttsukasa

@Cayseron I get loving an anime and also recognizing its weak parts and being vocal in pointing those weak parts out, but I don't get being so openly against it being watched by other people and saying things that it's only for kids and that it feels like nothing is happening when you watch it. When you use those descriptions to describe a show, can you still really say that you're a fan of it? How can you be a fan of something when you're an adult and you feel like that something is just for kids and the feeling that you get when you watch it is that nothing is happening. That doesn't make sense to me.

Astor Lefflinker

I don't agree with your points. One piece is a well made story with dozens mysteries. It is maybe slow paced but most people love it. There are channels making there livelihood with only OP content. I agree it's a lot and only enjoyable in bulk but it is what it is

Tom thom

jesus christ get a life instead of typing books over here , no one gives a fuck when he see a fucking wall full of complains

Ricsson

Then you dont really know One piece. It deals with really serious topics and has incredible world building that I doubt kids care about.

SanteRip

to be devils advocate i totally believe someone can be a real fan of something and in the same time trully hate certain aspects of said thing and be vocal about it. and i believe so cause i think opposite is true. in my case i love HxH but i have so much hate for it and i can rant for days about everything that bothers me about hxh both narratively as in what is happening in anime/manga, and out of the content aka stuff with fandom, togashi, toxicity etc... same way i enjoyed DBZ and i think it is trully good anime for what it is supposed to be aka the generic shonen, the norm, the module to shape other stories upon etc... but that for me puts it in B tier. not good but not bad, just normal. not 6/10 but not 10/10 either. i think it is perfectly valid for someone to claim they are fan of one piece and that they see it in high regards, maybe even claim it is strong 9/10 and still have lot of bad thing to say about it especially if topic at hand is not about anime as a whole but specific aspect of it, in this case they are not really talking negatively about anime as a whole but the idea of people dedicating to react to every episode and effect on the reaction channels they notice forming a pattern among reaction community in you tube. i think it is valid to love and not be blind to its faults about anything, be that one piece or any other anime, or anything else in the world and life.

Cayseron

I see you've edited your comment to make it sound more polite so that people will believe that you're really a fan of the show instead of just a hater and so they should take your comment more seriously. I saw your original comment so I refuse to believe this facade you're now on lol Just a reminder, your original comment is this: "Yeah can someone tell me how in hell is One Piece winning these polls, It such a kiddie show filled with years of filler and non sense that moves at the pace of one of their snail phones and feels like nothing ever changes. I get it for the age demographic of say maybe 7-14 but beyond that what is happening? Is it just sheer number of kiddies? " That's not fluff, that's how you really feel, but you got called out on it so you changed it to fit your narrative better.

Astor Lefflinker

When you say things like: "Yeah can someone tell me how in hell is One Piece winning these polls, It such a kiddie show filled with years of filler and non sense that moves at the pace of one of their snail phones and feels like nothing ever changes. I get it for the age demographic of say maybe 7-14 but beyond that what is happening? Is it just sheer number of kiddies? " You can't blame people for seeing it as hating on the show, and for me, it really is. Describing the show as "nothing happens" and "just for kids" is really just the same as people describing Mushoku and Made in Abyss as "p3do and fan service anime". It's so oversimplified and negatively skewed. It lacks so much nuance and it's such a shame because these animes being mentioned have great stories in them and if people believe these overly negatively skewed - over simplified descriptions of anime, they'd be missing out on many great things. I'm not a fan of this kind of hating is all I'm saying. And yes I know you will deny that you're hating, and claim that you actually really are a fan, but people can read your words and people have brains my dude. We know what you're doing.

Astor Lefflinker

I dont have to explain myself to you, I want them to react to my favorite show because I love it and enjoy reactions to it.

DandyZombie

@Astror I critique the pacing and time constraints of reacting to OP without disliking the show. Similar critiques apply to DBZ, my favorite show growing up, highlighting the ability to love a show while acknowledging its pitfalls. Due to their run lengths, One Piece raises more questions than Demon Slayer, and this is common for lengthy anime. One Piece's numerous plotlines allow it to defer answers, sometimes leading to forgotten questions. While theorizing can be fun, shorter anime often provide answers sooner. In contrast, One Piece's extensive episode count means answers may come much later, even beyond 200 episodes. These comments aren't about praising specific shows. One Piece's greatness is acknowledged, especially moments like Kizaru and the Pacifista on the Sabaody Archipelago. Despite occasional drawbacks like still frames and repeat animations, the overall story carries the experience, particularly in pre-900 episodes. What are some of your favorite anime? Also based on your values above, you should watch TTGL (Gurren Laggan)

Ttsukasa

You wrote this in one of your replies to another person: "Yeah can someone tell me how in hell is One Piece winning these polls, It such a kiddie show filled with years of filler and non sense that moves at the pace of one of their snail phones and feels like nothing ever changes. I get it for the age demographic of say maybe 7-14 but beyond that what is happening? Is it just sheer number of kiddies? " And in this thread you are claiming that you're a fan of the show? Yeah, bro. Sounds legit.

Astor Lefflinker

Yeah I guess you and me are just too different. When I'm a fan of something and I actually love it, I would not be able to describe it in such a damning - overly negative way as you did with One Piece. That's why it's hard for me to actually believe that you're a fan of it, and there's nothing wrong with not being a fan of it. I personally have no problem with them reacting or not reacting to One Piece. I just really dislike overly simplified and skewed descriptions of anime and that's why I replied to this. Like when people describe Made in Abyss and Mushoku as p3do animes and just leave it at that. Your description of One Piece reminded me of those, that's why you'd have to forgive if I refuse to believe that you're actually a fan of it. But yeah, we're just different people. I just can't imagine myself describing something that I love or even just like, in such an overly negative way and preventing reactors to react to them. And if you really read or watched One Piece, you'd know that it has so much more layers and mystery compared to Demon Slayer. I love Demon Slayer, but it's very straight-forward and there's really not much theory-forming, mystery solving involved in it - and one of your reasons why Carlie & Ange shouldn't react to One Piece is because it lacks both. That's why I think your reasoning is very strange. The things that I love about Demon Slayer is the "never giving up" attitude of the characters which always inspires me, the camaraderie, the great fights, the music, the animation, - and One Piece has all that too except maybe for the animation when it comes to its much older episodes, though I never thought One Piece animation is bad. It's just different. I think you and me have a very very different view of One Piece. For the record, I've watched the anime without any cuts until the Marine Ford arc and I was never bored with it. Then life got me so busy so I lost track of the anime but I kept updated with the manga. It has a very different animation style, but I never thought the animation was lacking. In fact, most of its animation are better than some JJK season 2 episodes which were unfinished (admitted by the animators).

Astor Lefflinker

Astro Lefflinker TL:DR version: I grew up watching One Piece, Toonami, and Shounen Anime, enjoying them during a time when waiting for content was the norm. It was a different era with limited options and a unique charm. I appreciate the shows for what they were, acknowledging the time-consuming nature. Regarding accusations of bias, I clarify my intention is not malicious. One Piece and Demon Slayer are vastly different in various aspects, and opinions on them can vary. There's no right or wrong; both Demon Slayer and One Piece excel in their own ways. Demon Slayer's efficient storytelling in a short time is impressive, while One Piece's extensive character development pays off over many episodes. Addressing the popularity vote loss for One Piece, I suggest it might be due to anti-One Piece voting or a shift in the channel's demographic away from Shounen content. Different reactions could impact the subscriber base. In summary, I appreciate diverse content but recognize the unique appeal of each. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Ttsukasa

You kept watching One Piece even though it has a bazillion of episodes and, based on your post, you clearly don't like it? It reminds me of Mushoku Tensei haters that kept watching till the end of season 2 (if their claims are true) just to hate more on the show. Also, One Pace doesn't summarize the show and remove the "boring" parts. It only removes the parts that are not in the manga in order to keep in line with Oda's vision of the series. You also described the things that they love from the shows that they watched and said that One Piece has none of them, when clearly, even though it may sound cheesy, One Piece has a lot of great stories, adventures, camaraderie, adventure, and great fights - Things that they love so much about Dragon Ball and Demon Slayer. I think you forgot that Carlie & Ange has Demon Slayer, a literal shonen overload with not much layers and mystery in it (nothing wrong about that) on S tier and Dragon Ball even above S Tier. I think you're the one here who have some form of malicious intent to control the content they should react to by describing One Piece in such a skewed way to prevent them from watching it. It's no different from people using very skewed and negative - oversimplified descriptions of Made in Abyss and Mushoku Tensei to prevent them from watching those anime. Also, it's strange that you claim that putting the big 3 (One Piece, Naruto, and Bleach, if that's still the meaning of big 3 these days) will have them dominating the polls when the big 3 has lost four times to Hunter X Hunter, and in this poll you can clearly see One Piece is losing to Your Lie in April.

Astor Lefflinker

You're aware though that the poll ended almost a month ago and that one piece lost, right? Your lie in april won, they will start posting the reactions in december.

Mimi

@Argonhta, I'm not mental in the head, I happen to have a career that requires typing and I'm an adult, I can type all of that in less than 5 minutes and as a Senior Programmer I can do so while multitasking, writing / typing isn't complicated and if you are passionate about something as I am with their content, and anime. It's not hard to try to express opinions in a nice format. Anyways I understand this comment is starting to hit the "mental" bar you have for attention spans so I'll end it here.

Ttsukasa

Just to put it out there... I'm one of those "ONE PIECE IS THE GOAT" type of fan (idc what anybody thinks)... BUT I 99% agree with this. Content that revolve around consuming and digesting other content and sharing that with an audience, in this case reaction channels, really rely on the content they would be consuming or reacting to... The problem is One Piece, and other long ass shounen anime, are built different. imagine asking a music content creator, for example, who makes reactions or discusses music to react to all of the BEATLES songs (and I mean ALL of them) or focus on one genre, that would consume an unreasonable amount of time for the creator. I believe it would be a bad move for the channel to take up a long shounen, specifically from the Big 3, not because they're bad, but because it's just too long. I don't have a gripe with those who want Carlie and Ange to see their reactions for these shows, but there are so much anime, or even other kinds of shows, out there to see their reactions to that would do great as videos. Reacting to One piece would just eventually make it stale, not for Carlie and Ange because this show is legendary IMO, but for the viewers of the channel because One piece and other Shounen are just built diff. They are meant to be consumed for a long time. P.S. If they are REALLY interested to watch these shows in the future, maybe they could watch these shows on their own as a hobby or on their spare time cuz these anime are still great.

z Mon

You're actually mental in the head for typing all of this, also couldn't be more wrong about everything and anything you said. JFC get a grip on reality.

Argonhta

Carlie & Ange can I just ask straight up, are you guys becoming a shounen channel because when you put the likes of the big 3 against anything, the fans themselves will dominate all polls and that's what you'll find yourselves reacting to for years to come. I understand the commercial success aspect of this, its why Spidermen and Elsa costumes dominate tourist spots. But It feels a bit betraying toward the roots of the channel. I know changes come and adaption is key and if you are adapting toward that direction I understand, But I'd like to ask for clarity's sake. So let me make this as clear as I can why I am here: ~Your personalities and chemistry are great when reacting to shows that are interesting to you. ~What interest you is deeper plots, theory crafting, and figuring out the behind the scenes of the story. ~You really enjoy shows with mystery and unexpected outcomes. ~You really enjoy breaking down episodes afterwards and dissecting to catch what other reactors don't catch. It is for these reasons I am a fan of your hard work. It is also for these reasons I fear "The calling of the OP". Because OP episodes are literally NONE of the above, hell they are so shallow and ignorantly paced and badly animated that THEIR OWN FAN BASE RECOMMENDS YOU TO USE A FAN RECONED episodes called "One Pace" that literally summarizes the boredom in an attempt to make it interesting. OP is 1000+ episodes long and the manga is the most popular amonst children in Japan, heart of Anime/Manga. This doesn't make it fire, this makes it popular, but in a popularity contest, it will win. If you start down the OP tree, it will be all consuming as more OP fans will flock and drown out literally any chance any "niche" anime has of ever appearing on your channel again. OP + any other shounen will probably substain your channel for a long time to come, Hell add Naruto in with it and GGWP right? But something that I think is very valuable will be lost in the process. And while I will understand your decision, I will personally leave the channel. PS: You watched the OP Live Action, from there the OP fans flocked ($$, but also they tip scales) tipped scales has OP first 44 episodes dominating the current poll out of nowhere, What do you believe will happen 44 episodes later when you make a new poll "next 44 vs some of other shit" and even more OP fans are voting? Literally the only thing that will beat said numbers are another of the big 3 shounen manga anime. Which means Most of us see the writing on the wall that once the shounen reactions start, they will be here for a VERY long time. and while the animes as a whole can be good, they are VERY poor for reaction material. HxH is literally my 2nd most favorite anime, and only 25 episodes are usually rewatched for reactions by most. Hell only 3 tbh are "peak" for reactions. HxH is MUCH more in depth storytelling than OP which literally has my lifetime worth of time to grow it's story, and utilizes about that long to do so as well. "episode 123 reaction: looks like the paint is still drying on the wall." I just think this is such an under value of your talents. And i love your channel because of said usage of your talents. Disclaimers: ~ ONE PIECE IS A CHANNEL EATER, This is an exact quote from like 4+ people above my post who are fans of OP. It begets itself. That is the fear of those who are resistant to you guys starting it. There are Fans of Anime, and Fans of Shounen, and Fans of OP. Fans of OP will turn a channel into a OP channel. Because they number that deeply. They will push the general fans of anime out and the channel will become much more specific. ~ I've watched ALL of the big three, without pacing cuts as well. Finished Naruto and Bleach. OP will never finish so who cares. ~ Personally I find the fact that other fans of OP feel the need to push for the fan cut called One Pace laughable, its like you're admitting how horrible the show is from the jump and how the only way to stomach it is through a "remix". ~ All that said, I'm a fan of shounen in general, OP included, its obviously not a terrible show, but its also not a great show. For day to day its pretty good but for reactions I think it's dogshit. The content isn't' there to react to. What made the Live Action amazing is they bottled up all the arc into only content worthy viewership, which made it awesome. ~ Since MiA obviously isn't going to win this round I just as I'm sure many others have already realized that the vote is between starting the OP saga here and not starting the OP saga and as such I will be moving my vote to YLIP, simply because it isn't OP saga. 44 episodes isn't even 1/20th of the anime, why would anyone assume you're just going to watch 1/20th of a show? Do you think the OP fans will be satisfied with that and then vote differently in days ahead? I wouldn't.

Ttsukasa

Carlie & Ange can I just ask straight up, are you guys becoming a shounen channel because when you put the likes of the big 3 against anything, the fans themselves will dominate all polls and that's what you'll find yourselves reacting to for years to come. I understand the commercial success aspect of this, its why Spidermen and Elsa costumes dominate tourist spots. But It feels a bit betraying toward the roots of the channel. I know changes come and adaption is key and if you are adapting toward that direction I understand, But I'd like to ask for clarity's sake. So let me make this as clear as I can why I am here: ~Your personalities and chemistry are great when reacting to shows that are interesting to you. ~What interest you is deeper plots, theory crafting, and figuring out the behind the scenes of the story. ~You really enjoy shows with mystery and unexpected outcomes. ~You really enjoy breaking down episodes afterwards and dissecting to catch what other reactors don't catch. It is for these reasons I am a fan of your hard work. It is also for these reasons I fear "The calling of the OP". Because OP episodes are literally NONE of the above, hell they are so shallow and ignorantly paced and badly animated that THEIR OWN FAN BASE RECOMMENDS YOU TO USE A FAN RECONED episodes called "One Pace" that literally summarizes the boredom in an attempt to make it interesting. OP is 1000+ episodes long and the manga is the most popular amonst children in Japan, heart of Anime/Manga. This doesn't make it fire, this makes it popular, but in a popularity contest, it will win. If you start down the OP tree, it will be all consuming as more OP fans will flock and drown out literally any chance any "niche" anime has of ever appearing on your channel again. OP + any other shounen will probably substain your channel for a long time to come, Hell add Naruto in with it and GGWP right? But something that I think is very valuable will be lost in the process. And while I will understand your decision, I will personally leave the channel. PS: You watched the OP Live Action, from there the OP fans flocked ($$, but also they tip scales) tipped scales has OP first 44 episodes dominating the current poll out of nowhere, What do you believe will happen 44 episodes later when you make a new poll "next 44 vs some of other shit" and even more OP fans are voting? Literally the only thing that will beat said numbers are another of the big 3 shounen manga anime. Which means Most of us see the writing on the wall that once the shounen reactions start, they will be here for a VERY long time. and while the animes as a whole can be good, they are VERY poor for reaction material. HxH is literally my 2nd most favorite anime, and only 25 episodes are usually rewatched for reactions by most. Hell only 3 tbh are "peak" for reactions. HxH is MUCH more in depth storytelling than OP which literally has my lifetime worth of time to grow it's story, and utilizes about that long to do so as well. "episode 123 reaction: looks like the paint is still drying on the wall." I just think this is such an under value of your talents. And i love your channel because of said usage of your talents.

Ttsukasa

idk how to express this so well. I love how they give in depth reactions but that will be so hard to do on these kiddie shows. its like "oooh for the 3rd episode in a row GOKU is charging up!!! what do you thing carlie? " yeah he's charging again, I wonder if next episode he will change" "yeah he's charging" ... -_- Except with OP its "oh they are running toward an island for 20 episodes...

Ttsukasa

@night sterling That sounds good until 44 episodes later a new OP poll wins and here we are for another 1000 episodes. @Merfhew It means "since most of your reactions will be to shallow ass episodes of OP because as a whole arc, OP is fire, but between episodes 5 and 35 of the arc nothing ever happens type energy and its target demographic is like age 10, your reactions will be boring, then I will have to unsubscribe until you finish the Op marathon a few years from now". Because OP will take up time, considerable time. Honestly between OP and HxH they could probably fill out entire weeks for a year.

Ttsukasa

Doesn't matter if they aren't doing all of OP, once they finish one arc another will win until 1000 episodes later...

Ttsukasa

Not if we start OP...

Ttsukasa

I'd love to understand why you want them to react to one piece and how much you want them to react to of it? it is 1000 episodes in and moves at the pace of boredom. I'm also curious what age group are you? Although I can see you found them from the live action. What do you personally enjoy about their reactions?

Ttsukasa

@Noctislolig I'm with you, its like why even poll at all if you're going to put OP in the poll. its like surface level 1 literal most popular manga in japan based on the lower age group, the numbers will overwhelm even if the material isn't deep. I was looking forward to the two choices they had originally as well and was happy when MiA won. This just feels annoying now, it sucks because Carlie and Ange give such good reviews and reactions and I just am not going to bare with their indepths of OP "Oh, looks like Luffy and gang ran for another 23 minutes to get somewhere".... "Oh look, coward boy is still a coward". The reason I only patreon a few reactors is the level of effort they put into their reactions, not the loud and "attention grabbing ones" (Kurapika!!), Or the low hanging fruit ones (dbz/naruto). I watch a few of those but yelling a bunch and reacting to the FOTM isn't as appealing to me as seeing people honestly get lost in a show, enjoy it, guessing at the future stakes and loving it as much as we do. In essence it feels like the equivalence of dressing up in spiderman/elsa costumes and running around time square to have OP suddenly on the polls after having two very much so indepth shows battling it out. Kids will love it I suppose but for the most shallow reasons. might as well just stream the show with a static image of them in the bg. I highly doubt anyone will watch for indepth reactions or commentary.

Ttsukasa

I'm curious to understand why One Piece consistently wins these polls. It seems like a show more geared towards a younger audience with a significant amount of filler and a slow pace. I get its appeal for the 7-14 age group, but I'm wondering about the broader demographic. Could it be the sheer number of younger viewers influencing the results?

Ttsukasa

Sad Made in Abyss lost, it's one of the most unique worlds and stories in anime, with an amazing OST. Maybe It's for the best. I saw another reactor mention that YT is very strict with that show when it comes to copyright stuff. Hopefully it comes in the future as a patreon exclusive to avoid those headaches.

Yefra

why not. it is a great show

Erdanxela

nahh

souma shou

You should react to wakfu you would love it

Erdanxela

They'll be starting in a few weeks! Thank you for the support!! ❤️

Carlie & Ange

Please react to Netflix's Pluto!!! Its awesome series full of emotions, and animation 10/10

Costosou

i subbed just for your lie in april reacts.

ONEEIGHTEEN

lol watching them being uncomfortable makes it funnier, I think they might be ready for that, but times will tell. Probably not for YouTube, but that's what Patreon is for I guess.

Tomer H

Hoa is right, they're definitely gonna get weirded out by the Kanna stuff.. Understandably imo

Thilde

If Carlie and Ange already feel uncomfortable with the fact that Nezuko boobs show of when she is in her adult demon form. Then they definitely won't be comfortable with Kanna. An even younger child

Hoa Trương

Yeah no, 99% of anime is not like that. I get it, fan service exist. But not in every anime and not always with obviously sexualize little girl too.

Hoa Trương

If someone finds that problematic and sexualised, then he can't watch 99% of anime, I always found it very wholesome.

Tomer H

Kobayashi is a litlle problematic though. You know, the sexsualize loli stuff

Hoa Trương

If you want some Great feel good anime I would go with Kobayashi's Dragon Maid and Yuru Camp

Tomer H

Angel Beats is amazing, but also, they're all short shows. We could have them all.

Sharles Davis Kendy

See you in my 19th life. Cast by my favorite actress. She is soooo fricking good. And the little girl cast in it is also awesome. Honestly emotional

astral_

Instead of Your Lie in April, I would have much prefered Angel Beats or Clannad :(

Eric Quan

I really love your reactions, and would like to recommend the show Hospital Playlist, is such a good kdrama, and is not mucho people talk about. I will love if you guys give a chance, no matter when.

Andy Jk

your lie in april is a great show, cant wait to see you guys react to it and suffer broken hearts as we all did. Cant wait for you guys to eventually get to One Piece though since I did find you guys through the live action and have been eagerly waiting for the day you start the anime

DandyZombie

unfortunately lots of people were hating on it in the comments

Zain Tahir

@myel That's fair.

Noctislolig

@noctislolig ah yes sorry im referring to MT that was why MiA won that other poll, but my point was more people wanted variety.

myel

@myel But Made in Abyss isn't an Isekai though.

Noctislolig

Jobless reincarnation is a master piece dont let the others tell you other wise i hope to see it pop up after rezero

Noctis

Oh man, I can't believe I missed this poll, but it gives me hope that you will eventually react to One Piece.

Sanji Sama

Carlie and Ange will be reacting to RE:Zero, i think that is one of the factors as to why many people voted for YLiA. They can watch another Isekai after RE:Zero

myel

@Holorence You are wrong. At first there were only the 2 options of Mushoku Tensei and Made in Abyss with Carlie & Ange saying "This poll will only have 2 options because these two anime intrigue us the most. And yes, we are aware (and have been warned) that Mushoku Tensei can be challenging at times. But these are the two series that we have not yet covered that are not too long that we'd like to bring to the channel at some point. When these uploads start, it will only be a few episodes a week until more slots open up." But because some people apparently complained they posted an update saying "There seems to be more negative comments on this poll than usual, so we’re almost going to do a tournament style of polls across the next week 🤣 The winner of this poll will progress and verse the winners of other polls we do. This might be the best way to engage with community feedback. The other polls will involve shows that are vastly different to these." So no they were not as you said "very clear on the polling process", they changed it because people complained. So I have now learned to do so too because apparently negativity can change something and is actually encouraged. Edit: Just to be clear, I'm not mad at you or anything. I'm not even mad at Carlie & Ange, definitely a little disappointed though. I am mad at the people not mature enough to accept that not everything has to always go your way, who then complained and made this poll into something I dislike even though there was originally no outcome I would have been unsatisfied with. And I am a little mad at myself for not complaining sooner when there were polls that didn't interest me. I always thought "Too bad there's nothing for me in this poll but it will make some people happy and that's fine. Bringing unnecessary negativity into the community won't help anything". Now knowing that complaining actually changes the outcome of these polls though I will be sure to keep that in mind, which is also why I am complaining right now and will continue to do so in the future.

Noctislolig

You can dislike it as much as you want but they were very clear on the polling process that the winner would be moving to another poll competing with other picks, one of which came from a seperate poll and the other being a pick of Carlie and Ange themselves (which they have every right in doing and said beforehand they would). Not sure why you think complaining will get you anywhere when they did exactly what they said they would. Though believe me I get the frustration because I would've loved for them to watch Made in Abyss as it's also one of my favourite shows but it is what it is.

Holorence

Damn... I was so happy when I saw the poll between Mushoku Tensei and Made in Abyss (two of my favorite anime of all time). I would have been happy either way. And look at it now... Oh man, I'm actually kinda' mad now. I'm not even that mad that they lost, I'm mad that they were the only two options originally and then just retconned. I mean, there were a lot of polls without shows that interest me but did I complain about it? No. But because some people just like to complain the choices were expanded upon with shows I don't care about. I guess I'm gonna' complain about everything from now on since I now know that it will actually change something... Even though I feel like complaining about everything is unhealthy for a community, but that's the message sent here.

Noctislolig

I would love to see you guys reacting to Made in Abyss, such a complex anime, im waiting to see your approuch to it

Etienne Menard

One Piece and sooooo mid

David Salazar

cant believe one piece lost to these lol

Quadreek Jackson

as an AOT fan, one piece is a masterpiece man. don't listen to the haters. Give it a try !!

Calvren

literally nothing of what you typed in this comment makes any sense at all lmao

Argonhta

One Piece is a joke

Lufttwafe

One Piece would be a smart pick in terms of channel growth and if you do a bunch of episodes a block/week you can get through it reasonably quickly. Then again - thinking more about it - at 1082 episodes (including fillers but still) and let's say 5 episodes per block and one block a week that would be almost 4 years just to catch up. Rushing through it would still take you 1-2 years considering that you still want to do other shows and have a life. Binging it without having to create content is so much quicker I just realized lol because then you could be done within no time. Maybe it's not the best thing to do. Personally I'd advise against One Pace simply because I don't like how choppy it feels sometimes but definitely skip the filler episodes (there are lists out there). There is one entire filler arc that many like so it's up to you whether you'd skip that or not. But yeah, I've yet to see a reaction channel that didn't get a massive influx of viewers and subscribers after doing One Piece. I'd definitely do a 7th rewatch or whatever with you. The community is massive and very welcoming - you'll definitely get spoiled by a bunch of salty people or even by a rogue algorithm on YT or Instagram or TikTok or whatever. That being said, Your lie in april is one of my favorite shows of all time. I love love love when reactors do that one, even though it's a bit slow at the start for some.

Maximilian Sauer

How does a show's length impact if someone is a fan or not? :o

Fortelik

I like OP but it tends to take over a channel. Because your watching Op for years.

Luna Meow

I hope you guys dont actually start one piece, its not a good show to react to on a channel like this, also one piece has soooo much dead content, if you dont want one pace its not gonna be the perfect experience. Also the votes are extremely skewed because theres so many fans for shows like one piece due to their length.

Artur Vegis

Never do one piece please lol, I'd rather have different shows take that slot than +1000 reactions to one show

Gabriel

the best way to do One Piece is to never start it

Lufttwafe

don't even start one piece, i swear to god. That series will go on for a lifetime.

ShadowQrow

You know they can watch other anime while watching one piece right? Like they currently are

Nigel W.

I hope they don't do OP any time soon. That show is a channel-eater.

The Great Santini

I think the best way to do One Piece is arc-by-arc, with other short replacement series between each arc. While people are initially hype for the first few arcs, they'll soon remember how much of a slog One Piece really was and gradually lose interest.

Nymph

yeah but mind that it might scar you for life. Your Lie in April is to this day the most sad/devastaded i have got with a fictional series. It messed me up for a few weeks that i fail some tests in school cause didn't study cause i was too busy crying. After watching this show i got reluctant to watch more of these sobstory animes

Izaya

I feel like they are reacting too many shows I feel like they should wait at least until HXH is over.

Jesus Rocha

Nah- it's not really that close of a result, and jumping straight into OP once the next slot opens would also be a bit unfair because, in this case, OP was running against a small and specific selection of shows (short-length shows) in a tournament, it’s not like it came 2nd place in a general channel poll. There are many other highly requested shows that have lost in previous polls or have yet to make it to a poll, and fans are just waiting for their next chance to vote lol. OP is losing here fair and square, the fair thing to do would be to add it to the next poll and have it run against the other shows.

Zakki

After Mob vs ReZero it's hard to consider a difference of 1% or more close anymore 😂

KaijinGarou

wouldn't really call it close results

Soul

With these close results maybe they will find a way to do both YLIA and OP soon to make everyone happy.

Khalayx

for sure!

Rodrigo Reyes Escobar

There are more than that, here and in previous polls and reactions. I didn't pick everybody's names and neither I'm gonna start writing them here like it's a classroom blackboard but we wish they were two. There are some others who are nice, that's true.

KaijinGarou

110%, there’s definitely moments in both shows (MT and MiA) that would create unforgettable watch reactions

MrYinYang

OK nicky d too, that's a newer comment I didn't see before 😅

Callum

U say its awful but as I've said on here besides the uchiha guy being a bit rude all the other op comments are just expressing love. If there's other then pls point them out cause that's the only guy I see being rude and it's kinda annoying all us op fans getting stereotyped into a rude fanbase (sorry if this cones off rude but it's just somewhat frustrating lol)

Callum

I reckon that Charlie might not be able to handle some scenes...maybe

Rodrigo Reyes Escobar

@Nicky D -- Considering the tense atmosphere, comments like this are risky. We're seeing a lot of hate, frustration, and generalized criticism directed at One Piece fans, so I think "jokes" like this could really make things worse.

Merfhew

I'm sure not all the OP community is toxic but let me tell you the comment section of this Patreon is an awful sample of the community at the very least, with some exceptions of course.

KaijinGarou

@Sunbro - Hmm, I don't think One Piece is the issue. Any show from Toei Animation runs that risk (including Dragon Ball Super, which I don't think they've had issues with... knock on wood).

Merfhew

I don't think that's a fair statement (kinda tired of the generalization), but I'm in agreement about bringing on mods.

Merfhew

if you like slice of life, drama and music. You will love it. A great short show that live rent free in people mind every April come

Hoa Trương

While I am very sad One Piece lost, the bright side is I can watch YLiA for the first time!

Zackerex

@souma shou, no it's not. It is a FAN PROJECT. I dont think Carlie and Ange would like to profit off of unofficial sites.

myel

Sad to see Mushoku Tensei “Godfather of Modern Isekai” not make the cut this time around. Hope they get another chance to watch it in the near future. But they should be getting a proper intro into the genre with Re:Zero. Should be a wild ride for them. Also, Made in Abyss is a masterpiece in terms of sound-design, OST, and world building. Can’t wait for them to watch that someday as well.

MrYinYang

Now that it looks like this could happen I am getting kinda worked up thinking about it.

Khalayx

Man, I loved your reactions to the OP LA but I must say they've brought an "interesting" community to this channel, to say something. We're gonna need mods soon...

KaijinGarou

I may not know you other than the impression you leave with your comments, but that impression sure is you need to grow up. Just vote what you want and stop trashing other people's votes. The most recurrent reason I've seen for people not to vote for OP is it's too long or they don't want them to stop watching after one arc and they're all valid.

KaijinGarou

How many active shows are you watching. Feels like a lot. ^^

aeriss eon

Problem with that is they'll be left with nothing to keep going from Berserk. They won't react to the manga and they shouldn't watch the anime.

KaijinGarou

true and real

addrid

they can use one pace and shorten the time by half

souma shou

its legal. they can watch it and stream it, no issues

souma shou

I’m so excited that YLIA is winning! I haven’t seen One Piece and the clips I’ve seen of Made in Abyss made me feel icky lol YLIA is so beautiful

april 🍏

Not so sure, after knowing that the dude writes and draws pedo-zoophile stuff I was sure that the uneasiness I felt while watching it wasn’t for nothing lol

Cassandra Lucas Torres

Its just a cartoon bro relax.

Frozenbozo

You've got an extremely poor sense of humor

souma shou

Watch the berserk movies lol.

joshua couvertier

I’m obviously joking around about them being wrong lol get your loser ass outta here

Nicky D

Your moms a L take

Nicky D

as a one piece fan that is such an L take. let people choose what they want

souma shou

I voted for Your Lie in April but I’m devastated that MT won’t get another chance.

The Great Santini

I assume you have to have empathy for the people in the situation Hoa Truoung…

The Great Santini

Erased would have been the best pick for these guys to react to. Mystery, intrigue, sweet characters. People get really weird about anime these days. The way people tried to steer them away from MT which is one of the best anime of the last few years was wild.

The Great Santini

please one piece 🙏

Joey Loiacano

I need "your lie in april" to win so baddddd

Alejandro Garcia

Incorrect

Aaron Wright

One pace is not legal

Aaron Wright

Your Lie in April looks good

Russ

We'll go to one piece, right after they finish YLIA. Its a short Anime, and they will go through it pretty quick.

Silvers Rayliegh

CMOOOOON

falconnn

Definitely your lie in april! a rollercoaster of an anime that i typically don't see many people react to, and i do think it's something you both will enjoy ^^

Ash

Whoever is not choosing one piece is just wrong

Nicky D

Might be a unpopular opinion but I’d stay far away from one piece. Biggest reason being that I’ve seen several channels get shut down because one piece doesn’t play with copy right at all, worse than any other anime by far. Plus it will tie up the channel for a very long time and I think there is a ton of anime for y’all to get through before getting into one piece. Just my personal opinion though.

Sunbro Joe

I am horrified about them reacting to Made in Abyss, why traumatizing them ?

Cassandra Lucas Torres

I'm a huge one piece fan and I haven't said anything of the like. I know they'll more than likely get to it eventually and I'm in no rush. So I'm down for whatever they end up watching. I haven't seen the other two shows but I'm down to start them. You shouldn't put negative weight on every person from a certain fanbase. Not all of us are toxic ❤️

FatherWeeb

Ikr thank the lord indeed

Aditya Raj

Nah we good to go guys, do extra ep of haikyuu and start your lie in April and call it day 🥱

Aditya Raj

I voted for One Piece but honestly people in the comments treating Carlie & Ange like innocent little babies by trying to prevent them from watching controversial anime like Made in Abyss and Mushoku Tensei baffles me. They're adults and they're no strangers to controversial shows. It's not in their channel, but they've watched Game of Thrones, people. Made in Abyss and Mushoku Tensei are mild imo compared to Game of Thrones.

Astor Lefflinker

shut up, don’t talk like u know me, and yeah, i’m here less than a month

Uchiha With Some Gas

onepace is the way to go!!!!

souma shou

why should you change your vote based on how other are??? vote what you want

souma shou

they should definitely use onepace.com, it fixes the pacing issue which is the only drawback of the anime

souma shou

yep onepace.com is the way to go

souma shou

And isn't a legal way to view the show.

Aaron Wright

I think I'd rate Beowulf, Shakespeare, Romance of the Three Kingdoms etc ahead of One Piece in terms of humanity's greatest literature

Aaron Wright

If you had been here for long you'd know people have been asking for HxH for a long time and they must really like it. I don't like it either but I deal with it. That's democracy for you. Grow up, man.

KaijinGarou

ur so damn right

Uchiha With Some Gas

I appreciate OP, but I wouldn't consider myself a die-hard fan. My focus is solely on this poll and doesn't extend beyond that. Have you checked the comments? Many are expressing their preference for YLIA because they're against OP. Considering all of this, I admit I was a bit frustrated when I wrote that comment, but I hope you can understand my perspective.

Uchiha With Some Gas

Damn people were right about OP fanbase being toxic. They'll go as far as to accuse others of imaginary plots they come up with. IDK how long you've been asking for it but I've been asking them for ATLA for almost two years now and you won't see me cry and talk shit to others like this about it. And I'm saying this even when I like OP and voted for it in this poll!

KaijinGarou

Also looking down there's like one guy being kinda rude to others bout it but that's it. I see more shit thrown as op than at the other shows so idk what comments your looking at lol

Callum

As a op fan I find it quite offensive to be called this when you don't know me just cause of a few loud people in the fandom. Kinda obnoxious of yourself to assume all in one group are the same

Callum

I gotta be honest - Made in Abyss is one of my favorite animes of all time, but I feel like it's not a match with your personalities. It's dark, and gross, and weird.

Aaron Griffin

Allow me to just address some things, last time I was quite open to other people's opinions and I still will be and remain somewhat neutral Simply put, if you think one piece is too long that is perfectly fine and it is true, that being said there is a website called One Pace and that cuts down all the useless filler people keep complaining about, yes, it might still be long but you should expect that from a 20 year+ anime but that also allows it to be fairly well made if it has stayed strong for 20 years. Next thing, I think everyone arguing over which anime is better and what not is just stupid, everyone has different taste and what not you don't need to argue amongst yourselves over it since you're all part of the same fandom that just want to see the creators react to your favourite show, treat others shows how you'd like yours to be treated. Lastly, stop trying to argue over what carlie and ange will do and not do, that's simply not up to you (I don't mean what they're going to watch, I mean how they're going to pace one piece if they ever do watch it) Carlie and Ange are both adults that can pace themselves and not be bullied into watching something for more than they want to, I simply suggest stop speaking for them. Lastly, I hope your favourite anime does one day get reacted to no matter what it is since we all just want to share our interests with others, its why we're here watching reactions of others because we live vicariously through them and see them express the same joy we did when we saw those shows. Just chill.

Addi

No way YLIA is winning 😭🙏 thank the Lord, what an unexpected turn of events, but a welcome one fs

LuciusArtoriusCastus

Imagine having a generalized opinion on a group of people base on one thing they like. Maybe the obnoxious one is in the mirror?

Just_James

Yeah, it’s true. I haven’t seen that poll where OP came out on top, to be here. Maybe they were mixed in with some ‘mid’ anime, I don’t know. But I’m getting tired of this community. In that poll where HxH won, both Naruto and OP lost to MHA. It’s just baffling. I never thought it was possible. It feels like this community has a bias against the big 3…

Uchiha With Some Gas

I mean, I think its pretty obnoxious and rude to generalize an entire fanbase, but hey, that's just me.

Toodles

What? you think a show is good just because it's really popular? bruh It's popular because of the goofy style of the show so the kids loves it and because alot of people grew up with the show, that is why. There are alot of shows that are much better then OP for sure. Look at the best rated shows out there, where is OP? nowhere to be seen. Not hating on the show but the big 3 are highly overrated. Popular games like cod, fifa, madden, assassins creed are super popular even thoe it's the same bad games every year that comes out.

Nasty

I honestly haven't seen any of these anime so I'll just throw out a suggestion for next time... Noragami is pretty top tier. Funny, action, mythology. Not a biased opinion at all.

AttackRunRepeat

Seriously, I don't want to generalize an entire fanbase but the amount of obnoxious arrogance in these comments from some of them.. Yikes

Thilde

Agreed. I have never seen your lie in april but I will happily vote for it over one piece.

r.s.

Because one piece fans are obnoxious and rude. Every commenter on here is "one piece is the best and all other animes are dumb" like grow up

Eric Chandler

what amazes me is that they also managed to create some visual as beautifull and emotionnal as the music they play.

Matthias

Yeah but the point for me is how did OP even make it into this poll in the first play. When they were choosing a long anime to react to it was litterally LAST in that poll and they went wIth hunter hunter. It was clear that most of this community didnt wanna see OP in the first place

Tae Kellz

The music is SO GOD DAMNED GOOD.

Sharles Davis Kendy

and ill rally after you !!! hope they got into it :<

myel

I’d love you guys to watch your lie in April not trying to spoil anything but it has comedy , romance and Ange might particularly enjoy it since there’s music involved 👀

Alejandro Garcia

I love that you’re doing one piece a saga at a time.

Harlee M

@ Kiki Varas - I love your profile picture... Jooha < 3

Taekom

@Uchiha with some gas - Very nice of you to apologize, very mature of you. :) High five.

Taekom

oddly enough when i watch grave of the fireflies i don't really feel sad at all. Just feel like it something as it is because yeah.. it's war.

Hoa Trương

i am pretty much aware of it already

zdravko georgiev

Right? I can't believe Your Lie is pulling ahead. 5 more days!

Sharles Davis Kendy

I voted for Your lie in April but i'm sad that Dororo or Erased weren't picked...

Rubie

u’ve to read the comment section to understand

Uchiha With Some Gas

maybe my other comment weren’t good, i was just triggered, so sorry if i offended u

Uchiha With Some Gas

it’s not, it’s still open

Uchiha With Some Gas

K bye

Chrisiyyi

OnePace exists

Chrisiyyi

Hello, OnePace has been made for this, thanks for my TED talk

Chrisiyyi

OnePace is the solution... people just dont know about it

Chrisiyyi

If you wanna watch one piece watch it with one pace website, it makes the show very good. Its funny to see negative reactions about OP being boring and long, this was exactly what i was thinking before i started the journey, yes the series has some flaws, but thats why OnePace exist that cuts out those flaws. The series is fantastic and has moments that make you cry, make you hyped and make you laugh, the world is fantastic.

Chrisiyyi

Weird way to vote ngl

Chrisiyyi

One piece🙌🙌🙌

Kiki Varas

so 3 years ? that is if they binge it. If they add break let add 1 more year.

Hoa Trương

😕 trying to vote for one piece but it won't let me is it over ?

Donna

I'm quite new on the patreon and i dont know how you guys pick the next shows you will watch but i have to start the Ranking of Kings propaganda here you will love it im sure

François Jeannin

they can watch it at onepace.com which fixes the pacing issue and technically you use half the time than you would have actually used

souma shou

what in the mumbo jumbo are you on about?

souma shou

Watch grave of the fireflies for true sadness

Chrisiyyi

Luffys devil fruit is cartoony the anime isn't. It covers very dark themes including slavery, cannibalism, suicide, tyranny, racism, death, child abuse and child experimentation, rape ect wayy more. This proves the anime isn't cartoony, the main character and the art style may be but the show itself isn't. Its the best piece of fiction every created and the most highest selling manga for a reason.

Zain Tahir

you're the only one being toxic here. let be honest

Hoa Trương

You should start with popular ones like AOT, DS, or JJK to get people interested in your content. But let’s face it, they’re not as famous as DB and the Big 3. I don’t like that the main complaint is that they’re long. That’s actually one of the reasons they’re great and always will be. The excitement when things are revealed after a lot of buildup is amazing, don’t you think? So, being long isn’t a problem, it’s a good thing.

Uchiha With Some Gas

1000 episodes & dude still isn't a pirate king LOL. I will get marry have kids my kids will have kids my kids kids kids will have kids & dude will still not be pirate king.

remvrk

One piece is amazing but it is cartoony, I mean the whole point of luffy is that he's a cartoon character that bend the rule of the more "serious" and strict world around him. That was true at the start and this is even truer now.

Matthias

you guys should make another channel maybe just for one piece content? lots of reactors are doing that. I think you guys would really love one piece.

kiwi

small and unpopular show ? you realize that all show they react to are actually highly popular shows right ? I mean maybe besides bocchi who's a little more niche and overlooked since it's shorter all other shows are incredible heavy hitter in term of popularity (H x H, SNK, DBS, Haikyuu, FMAB ). No one is agaisnt the big 3, it's just that they are so long and frankly for naruto and one piece it's better to read the manga than watch the anime. I mean the day this community will vote for stuff like gurenn lagan, mahoutsukai no yome, lovely complex or psycho pass who are shows that are rarely cited and reacted to plus are for most older and not known by a lot of the anime comunity then we can talk about smaller less-popular show.

Matthias

Is that your genuine belief? I’ve never seen OP at the bottom of the poll in my life. It might have to do with their community. I joined recently and it’s quite distinctive, both the creators and patrons. So, I honestly think they’re really not into the big 3, I mean in terms of subscribers. It’s like all the fans of smaller and less popular shows are gathered here. I can’t come up with any other explanation.

Uchiha With Some Gas

Absolutely, out of all the reactors I've watched over the years these guys just have the most comfortable and friendly atmosphere to be around 😀. Also yeah people need to chill sometimes lol

Callum

Please watch one piece on onepace.com. they fix the pacing issue which is the main complaign people have with the anime, and each episode is shorter so you can react to more episodes in a similar time frame

souma shou

I'd love to see you guys watch One piece. It's my favorite piece of fiction, Been following it for over half my life.

Joe B

Oh god I can't wait for you two to one day do Made in Abyss, that'll be an interesting ride to say the least.

Noirium

@ImZeat - Oh I didn't know that iShinobi has started One Piece. 1 year and 9 months for the mid point of the series, that's pretty good, actually ! 2 episodes in one video is not enough but I agree with you, 3 or even 4 (it depends if it's relevant or not) could be a good idea. It will also reduce the number of videos per week, as you said. :) I don't know if there are a lot of fillers ( I've read that One Piece has a lot less fillers than Naruto) but skipping them (obviously) + doing multiple episodes per video (more than 2 would be great) could solve a lot of "issues" that some people have with the show. I also just wouldn't them to use all their recording time for One Piece videos and leave other shows behind. Wouldn't it be better to wait until they are caught up with Hunter x Hunter to start One Piece ? So that they can focus on one long shonen animé at a time... ? They are going to increase the number of uploads for Hunter x Hunter so they'll be caught up soon. Also, when is One Piece going to end, haha ? I'm not saying it in a mean way, but maybe it's high time to conclude the story... I mean, I don't even know the story, so I shouldn't say anything. Pokémon went on for 25 years, after all. But I would hate for the fans of One Piece to live another "Berserk" situation. :'(

Taekom

I'd love to see you react to those episodes of One Piece! It really is an amazing anime. Since you enjoyed the live action, you're definitely going to fall in love with the anime as well ! Even if it doesn't win this poll, hopefully you'd both watch it eventually! Also can we all stop the hate in the comments? It would be nice to see Carlie and Angelo react to something they want to react to for once! Either way, I can't wait to see what you both watch next! :D Watching your reactions makes it feel like I'm watching these episodes with a friend, it's really nice. Thank for taking the time to do these videos for us <3

Hannah

One piece is mid. The only people who think one piece is the best are people who watch one piece. It's not that great and it's like 1000 episodes. Ylia is much better than some whacky rubber pirate man.

Eric Chandler

I agree they should watch one piece eventually. But i'd prefer after HxH. I'd rather the channel have some variety right now instead of a bunch of shonen every day. That's just my opinion though.

Danny

Wouldn’t be a fan of OP reactions. Most of it isn’t worth even reacting to. Other two definitely want to see more than

Unholy

@Taekom I would take the example of the channel iShinobi. He started One Piece 1 year and 9 months ago and already managed to reach the mid point of the series (when the 2 years time skip happens). Granted he uploaded a 2-3 episodes reaction every 2-3 days, but I feel that, if they would skip the filler and have a 3 episodes reaction (so the length of a Live Action episode) every 4-5 days. it would be a fair rythm to be able to catch up without spending 4 years on this (cause let's be real they are of course spend multiple years on this). They could even take like 1-2 weeks break inbetween each saga (first one being East Blue Saga from episode 1 to 65). Since this rythm requires an upload (about) only one every week, I don't feel like it would overflow the channel. Let me hear you thoughts on this idea!

ImZeaT

Thats the problem tho. I agree it is a good series, but even if they watch an episode a day (while skipping filler, if thats what they choose) itll take nearly 3 years. And they do 3-4 episodes per week at max for shows. It would take them half a decade at least.

Derek

@ImZeat - I see what you mean but I still think it's not fair to be like "I didn't ask for this, so it doesn't count" as we both know why they watched the show... If it were a Live Action of, let's say, another shonen, they (probably, surely) wouldn't have watched it. They know that a lot of their audience like One Piece and it was a way to be like "We've heard you, we are going to check this first and see what comes next". It's still One Piece content. You still got their thoughts and got to see them discover some of the numerous characters of the show. Granted, it wasn't exactly what you guys asked for (I understand where you're coming from) but I feel like it's a good way to make you wait until they start the actual animé. I still think the final poll isn't fair in the sense that they put shows that are too different together. It's then easier for those said anti-One Piece voters to choose. But if the shows were different and more in line with One Piece, then it would be a different story (maybe...?). Though, the real question would be : if they decide to watch One Piece, how will they manage to do it without overflowing the channel (even arc by arc, that's a loooot of videos, even with double-episodes videos) and without taking years and years to be caught up? As a One Piece fan, if you have any ideas, I'm curious to know as I don't really watch reaction channels that react to One Piece. I know that for Naruto, they skip the fillers (which is easy since there are a lot of them) and there are a lot less episodes of Naruto than of One Piece. Still, I get very impatient (as a Naruto fan) when a reaction channel starts Naruto because I know that it'll take them years to finish the show.

Taekom

@Taekom yes of course but, without being ungrateful, nobody asked them to watch the Live Action. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad they did becuase now they are heavily interested in watching the show, but what people have been asking for the longest of times was for them to react to the anime, not the Live Action, you see what I'm saying? But honestly I am 100% onboard with that idea, if they see the massive support One Piece has on the channel, it would be cool if after they've watched Your Lie in April if it wins (i highly recommend the show if you haven't watched it), they still go back to One Piece because the poll was so close, I think everybody could be happy with that! (though I still thinks that a part of the YLiA voters are not necessarily enjoyers of the show but rather anti-One Piece voters, based on some of the comments, but who knows)

ImZeaT

Yeah because they don’t want to see it. If it were that popular with their Patreons it would’ve won, just like many other shows much less popular have won polls before.

this is one long ass username

It’s not the that deep friend😭 I love one piece but this take is crazy

beannieswife

@Uchiha with some gas - Haha come on, let's not be ungrateful, they watched the Live Action because they were genuinely curious about it but also to please the One Piece fans. To make you happy. ** I understand your frustration as a fan (even though you are not a hardcore one) but I wouldn't worry about One Piece if I were you. The One Piece community is so BIG that C&A will eventually watch it. That's for SURE. When, I don't know... But sooner than you think. I think that they should make another poll with bigger and longer animés to give One Piece a better chance. A poll with Naruto, One Piece and so on. The "it's too long" or "too many fillers" arguments won't be acceptable, then.

Taekom

i get what r u trying to say about live action, but i don’t consider its fair thing to say, i wasn’t asking them to react to it, i never even watched it myself. how many shows they have to react to watch one piece? when there is no good shows left? why does any other show have to get chances, before OP? i would understand if it was a few, but at this point point, y’all going to prevent it until the end… And just so u know, i’m not big op fan, but it’s the goat, i just don’t get all this people in the comments, which r just hating on it, for stupid reasons and preventing them from watching it

Uchiha With Some Gas

@Uchiha with some gas - They've already reacted to the One Piece Live Action series -it was a complete surprise and One Piece fans loved it-. You already have some content One Piece related on the channel. In all fairness, I think that it would be cool to give other shows a chance. Don't you think so ? And then come back to One Piece later...

Taekom

Well I thought one piece was gonna win, seems like its not what a bummer. Anyways I think if your gonna watch one piece u guys should watch the whole thing instead of just episodes 1 to 44. Bcuz it actually gets better from there.

Joey Sabishii

really? that’s what u came up after reading my comment? did u read it or what?

Uchiha With Some Gas

yeah seriously its that weird mentality people have on the internet of oh I don't like this thing therefore no one else should like this thing.

Frozenbozo

I think berating people because they have a different opinion than you is undignified and shameful

Orochimaru has a giant snake 😳

haven’t u read the comments, they’re voting against op, not for the other shows

Uchiha With Some Gas

What are you talking about? People just vote for what they want to see, it's not that deep

Shade1410

Hey, short shows deserve attention, but so do long ones. Let's avoid favoritism.

Uchiha With Some Gas

bro, come back and make ur vote relevant, please. mia is not going to win

Uchiha With Some Gas

i’m bringing, because i’m not good at english, this way i can express my opinion better, but still, all of this comments shitting on one piece, just gets me mad, why when someone does that towards op, nobody is seeing, but whenever op fan does this, it’s childish and toxic?

Uchiha With Some Gas

they are inferior to one piece, let’s be real here

Uchiha With Some Gas

This community is just jealous because One Piece is more popular and gets more attention than their favorite show. They're all ganging up on it. It's annoying when people get envious. Have they no dignity? Such behavior is just shameful.

Uchiha With Some Gas

They wouldn't stop at 44 eps. They will continue to watch the rest eventually. They'll add break between each arc to react to other things but that'll make it even longer. So if OP win, it will stay on the channel for 7 years if they want to catching up. A bit tired for non OP fans

Hoa Trương

i would say that about op, not ylia

Uchiha With Some Gas

Oh my god. I was the biggest YLiA stan, but One Piece has my heart. Goated.

SunnyhuunS

for some reason this pole is hating on one piece but i know for a fact you guys will become huge fans even the viewers will. its not cartoony its incredible inshallah one piece will win the pole

Zain Tahir

The poll only says they'll watch 40 episodes.

Ghost Meep

I think being passionate about a show is fine but you don't have to bring other shows down.

Ghost Meep

It is. But I feel like it’s inevitable since so many people are passionate about these shows. All we can do is just not add to it :)

Floch

I would still wait on one piece for a while there is still so many shows you haven’t watched yet

TomNook

It's a bit sad to see that polls like this always turn toxic so quickly... Anyway, I personally hope that you give Made in Abyss a chance at some later point, because it is truly an excellent show and based on what you've enjoyed so far I think that you'll like it. And I always hope to see One Piece coming to your channel. This show just has so much heart and it is this popular for a reason.

AiraKT

They aren't "beginners" though, and made in abyss is a fucking rollercoaster

Jacob Svensson

Your Lie in April is my vote, it was the 2nd anime to make me ugly cry and is more "beginner friendly" than made in Abyss. Im a huge One Piece fan, but I just can't vote for it, its just too long, even if they managed to release 3 episodes a week consistently thats 360 weeks or almost 7 years to catch up to today, even longer in the future. And who knows what would happen on those 7 years, the chances of finishing the series is not that high.

NanoPIX

I also agree with what has been said, One Piece should be put in another poll with other long animés - just like you did before.

Taekom

I voted for Made in Abyss but changed it for Your Lie in April. :) Your Lie in April is short so it will free a slot more easily and faster than OP (even though they said they would only watch 44 episodes, I'm pretty they'll eventually do a lot more).

Taekom

Oh god. One piece on this list as another long anime means its gonna take over a year to finish hunter hunter. Also how did one piece even make it on this list when it was litterally last on the long anime poll?

Tae Kellz

I voted for OP but then changed to YLIA yesterday even though I've never seen it before because some of the OP fans in the comments are just rude and annoying. From the percentage it seems like others did the same thing too. Went from 18%/41%/41% to 17%/43%/39%

Orochimaru has a giant snake 😳

yes, one piece its absolutly good, but im not rooting for only east blue saga. If we are gona have one piece i would like the full experience including all the sagas

shion333

@SomeoneElse To say that there are barely any filler episodes in OP is to be in extreme denial. I love it, I voted for it, but the anime is riddled with fillers. There's a ton of characters that do not even exist in the manga. It's up there with Naruto when it comes to filler/non-canon content.

Astor Lefflinker

Well yes, but it's only the east blue saga. Looks like it wouldn't be the whole thing (at least for now) and made in abyss a fantastic show

Mikestrike

It's almost like One Piece is the second best selling comic in the world and the anime was most watched show in the world in 2022 or something 🤔

SomeoneElse

Pacing only become a problem like 500 episodes in lol and there are barely any filler episodes in OP. There are no fillers between episode 1-44 which is what they plan on watching

SomeoneElse

One Piece fo sho. It would keep me subscribed 😁 Don't underestimate the One Piece community getting behind big reactors when they jump on the anime. EXPONENTIAL GROWTH BAYBEY. We are ravenous For your own sakes tho, I'd only do One Piece if you did at least 3 episodes at a time, which would equal the length of a Live Action episode assuming you skip the openings and endings after you've seen them once or twice If you do Your Lie, you could always react to One Piece openings in the meantime, and an amazing fan made video called "The Breath Taking World of One Piece" which is like an art show basically. A lot of reactors have reacted to it. Just if you want to keep the One Piece flame alive while you're watching another series. BUT spring boarding off the Live Action and watching the East Blue saga in the anime would be a pretty good idea for keeping that audience. I typed too much

SomeoneElse

I voted for Your Lie in April for more variety!! Since you're gonna start Re:Zero pretty soon. I dont want you to get overly saturated by recurring themes. One Piece is good only if you binged it. Bc there are episodes that nothings really to comment about.

myel

Your lie in april must watch

remvrk

Not sure if you all are talking about me, I've never written a sentence about one piece before this, and I think I approached my comment here pretty cautiously. I haven't said anything bad about one piece, I'm just saying it's a skewed poll.

StackCanary

Don’t know about harassing but I’ve seen you under alot of comments spewing shit about One piece fans, One piece is easily my favorite manga except maybe Berserk, but I understand if they don’t want to commit to such a long anime. Still hoping thou, because i’m certain they’ll love it based on how they liked the LA, dragonball, hxh

johan wejdin

I subscribed to this patreon bc of one piece live action😭. More one piece please🙏

THanaaa Krit

I would love to see you guys react to One Piece more than any other show! Maybe after YLIA 😢

Philipp Scheuer

Also yay to extra Haikyuu!!

Meg

Almost missed this poll cos I hadn't realized my patreon payment hadn't gone through. Glad I noticed and made it in time!

Meg

well, I'm not going to sit here and say I don't see the appeal to the show and how people would like it as i too still somewhat enjoyed it (8/10 anime). I've just stated my experience with it I just found myself having to force my way through alot of episodes. (it doesn't help that the main story doesn't progress for 11 episodes on a 24-episode anime...) and the main reason for that is the show really only provides enough content for a film yet stretches it so far. the music and art were very amazing, the characters are likable but unrelatable, I don't even want to talk about the monologue. and the show has a better conclusion than ALOT of other anime's it's just the journey to get there takes away from it in terms of a reaction channel. but an 8/10 recommendation from me to them as a personal watch. lastly OP is just very, and I mean very well done in its purpose and only does it better with time. I do have criticism for it but not much. and with this system that Carlie and Ange have come up with works very well as they are doing polls per OP arc which gives room for other people's favorites when needed.

Gabe Ibitoye

bruh made in abyss wouldve been so good fark

Redback

Yeah this is why I'm not too desperate to see the long shows rn as much as I love them cause eventually people will run out of the great small anime to give them lol

Callum

Did you know that Oda sensei really likes Your Lie in April. You guys should checkout Your Lie in April. It's really good but not many reactions so you'll sort of monopolize it . In the 150k special, you each said you like good characters and good plot so I think One Piece will really be good because those are the definitely 2 things One Piece excel at. On the other hand the pacing might be the problem, but hopefully the positives outweighs the negatives like it did for me. I think you should start YLIA first because you should expand to the various genres of your channel a bit more and then you should start One Piece.

SoySauce

Absolutely, if they want to try it let them. Like if they have interest in something and are willing to check it out we should be letting them (I mean sure they could also just watch of camera if like no one wanted reactions lol) but some just straight up saying don't watch you won't enjoy is ridiculous really cause we all enjoy different things after all. It's the same with the people telling them to not go into op or naruto cause they're long and boring, which I also got told before watching and now they are some of my favourites

Callum

Opinions are fine yeah but some can be just straight rude about it.

Callum

Because they already watch the LA, wouldn't be much interesting to watch the arcs all over again even with some different here and there in anime version. Other niche series deserve to shine more. More diverse option for viewer to choose since we already has some similar genre going on with HxH.

Hoa Trương

Your lie then made in abyss after

Omg y'all are so annoying. I literally said IF it wins, why are you still here complaining when it's losing, I thought that's what you wanted. Noone cares that you don't like OP😭.

emma

Wow, I’m sorry, I didn’t think people were this intense about it.

Doron Ross Tuvia

i actually agree lmao

Nymph

Your Lie in April pleeeeeease! so incredible and perfect for you two with the musical focus!

Toidleboy

The fact that Made in Abyss is so far behind blows my mind.

Mikestrike

Exactly. People just freaking out about the child shit. Like they are grown adults let them watch stuff like MIA and MT and decide if it's for them or not.

Frozenbozo

What're you talking about ? YLIA was good from start to end. It's OP that mid in most of it episode and sometime has the hype and peak of each arc.

Hoa Trương

YOOO your lie in April is leading 0.0

Hoa Trương

Having a different opinion is hate now ? Damn, no wonder Your lie in April is ahead

Sam Brown

You are harassing every people who has a different opinion than yours, you are literally one of the reason people are going to NOT vote for One Piece and you’re not realizing it yet lol.

Sam Brown

This is not a good look for One Piece votes. Bad arguments and spitting at others people face just because they have a different opinion. That’s why Your lie in April is ahead now.

Sam Brown

the only argument I see for one piece people are going for is for more quantity over quality which doesn't really make sense to me when each arc would be reentered in a poll like any other anime, they are not doing all 1000eps obviously and your li in is good but its only good for its ending I wouldn't even watch the 23 decent episodes just for the 1 good one.

Gabe Ibitoye

big difference between a ton of sales and the most all time.

Gabe Ibitoye

Oda credits Dragon Ball as his biggest inspiration in creating One Piece, I think you guys will love it.

PepsiMan

Just saying if they can watch a dark shows like Attack on Titan they should be able to handle Made in Abyss after all it's a good show.

paladar blade

your lie in april pretty please

shion333

Transformers makes a ton of money at the box office. Best movies ever I guess.

Elli

Please One Piece. Not sure why there is so much hate in here for it.

Doron Ross Tuvia

I don’t watch OP but this comment is so wholesome. A actual OP fan right here.

ChmpagnShadw

I agree that this fan edit is better. But parts of it aren’t done yet so they’d have to swap back and forth to watch some of the main arcs. Though they could be done editing Arabasta by the time they get to those episodes.

Josiah Hutchinson

This poll is going to be such a rollercoaster lol.

Danny

They had us in the first have not gonna lie 😅

Danny

Anything but one piece.

Matt Rhinehart

LETS GO YLIA TOOK THE LEAD!! There are still 6 days left tho so it’s gonna come down to the wire.

Floch

If you're going to watch One Piece, would it be possible for you guys to watch it from One Pace website instead? I know it's sailing the high seas technically but the problem with One Piece anime is that it has so many fillers (stuff that wasn't on the manga) and a lot of them were merged in with canon episodes. One Pace removes those fillers with good editing that it feels seamless.

Astor Lefflinker

It’s literally one of the biggest shows on the planet and it’s struggling to beat a pretty good older drama/romance anime. If there was other shorter shounen on here it would probably get crushed. Only hardcore One Piece fans think it’s remotely a good idea for a channel to be stuck watching that horrendously paced show for like a decade.

greenb3ar

Also probably just people trying desperately to keep OP from happening. I watched Bleach beat it h2h on another channel and that’s purely just because channels starting One Piece sucks for pretty much everyone that isn’t a One Piece fan. MiA is easily my favorite here, but no way am I voting for that now.

greenb3ar

Sucks no Made in Abyss truly a fantastic piece of media. Sad to see people pressure you guys out of it because others cant separate fiction and reality. Some people just don't understand stories can and will make you feel uncomfortable or disgusted or feel hatred towards a character, Its the Authors intent. Are there off putting moments in Made In Abyss yes but they are also just moments rarely spread throughout the series that are 99% of the time a throw away joke. Also just wanted to remind yall you will never ever make everyone happy it is what it is. Just do what you wanna do, don't worry if it pisses people off.

Frozenbozo

One piece isn't a short series if you wanna watch it i say do so after HXH at least then you wouldn't have 2 of your slots taken up for a long period of time and still be able to watch more variety of anime. Just saying i'm picking quantity over quality in this sense, I AM NOT saying that Your lie in April or Made in Abyss are inferior it's just they don't have as many episodes so you'll be able to watch both series and even a 3rd or even 4th series rather then say watching 2 seasons of just One piece.

paladar blade

I may have a little bias as I've followed one piece since I was a child (10 years or more) but I truly think they'll enjoy one piece, it just takes a while--I understand both POV's as it is a stupidly long anime but the fact it's long makes it very well made since as everyone says, even the side characters have amazing depth and backstories and the world building really is just that good, one piece gets my vote but I respect any opinion anyone here might have--I just think seeing carlie and ange reacting to my favourite anime gives me a load of excitement, my own opinion tho

Addi

no

Kevin T

It is!

Lapisstories

Im not too keen on one piece tbh

Frida BØ

I want them to react to one piece at the end when there’s no much more anime left to watch so that way they’d have years of content

Jesus Rocha

BRUHH this is so hard holy shit

Zana

The One piecee is reaaal!!

SanteRip

what didn't you like about it?

ST Deville

You might think its boring, but the sales don't lie.

Eric Quan

i actually voted for made in abyss and its so sad its left so much behind. Its sad cause its incredibly worth it

zdravko georgiev

Y’all just gotta watch Made in Abyss. There’s really nothing else out there like it

SolarOnion

Your lie is so much shorter and so worth it. Do an anime other than the action that is all over the place. Not a lot of people reacting to your lie

Eric Chandler

@Hoa Trương yeah so you shouldn't be mad if One Piece wins the poll, because people that pay money for the subscription voted, right?

ImZeaT

so disingeneous of you @CornCobBob to compare One Piece (9% filler for 1070 episodes) to Naruto (41% filler for 220 episodes)/Naruto Shippuden (41% for 500 episodes) and Bleach (45% for 366 episodes), just to fit a narrative. Like these are NOT the same numbers AT ALL

ImZeaT

One Piece is the greatest story ever told, so it's good to watch it. TBH, however, you would need to do it daily. 😅

Mojira

They literally expressed THEMSELVES how they wanted to check out the show after watching the Netflix Live Action. Why do you want to prevent them from watching it, and, since they said they liked it, why would they not like the anime version and prefer the other shows? "Not their style of show"? Dragon Ball is one of their favorite franchise, what are you talking about...

ImZeaT

Having watched One Piece, and then rewatched using One Pace, I would HEAVILY recommend that you DON'T use One Pace. It is REALLY NOT a good option.

ImZeaT

There are a lot of people wanting to see One Piece on the channel, and they clearly expressed their interest on watching the series after watching the Netflix Live Action adaptation, hence why they added it to the poll. There would still be other series on the channel, I don't see why you would be against the idea.

ImZeaT

Was this written by a 10 year old? Lmao

Thilde

Very toxic comment. 😬

Floch

not even close

Hoa Trương

Nope. Oda is conveniently friends with what, 4-5 different people that have been sent to prison for pedo shit. Including Nobuhiro Watsuki. A friend doesn't make you who you are, but when your friends keep happening to be pedos it's hard to ignore.

Elli

not one piece broo

aubrey !!

Btw shouldn't the East Blue saga end at ep 53 which includes Lougetown Arc 🤔

Aizen

usual brats response

Uchiha With Some Gas

Ok kid

Cratto

everybody who is whining that one piece is long, shut tf up, y’all need to realize that op is better than any of ur fav anime, it’s the best selling manga for a reason, and as fans of Carlie n Ange, u should wish them best, not preventing it n being all over the place

Uchiha With Some Gas

what y’all preventing them from watching it? it’s the best selling for a reason, don’t u wish them best?

Uchiha With Some Gas

shut ur ass up, tf is this? y’all need to chill. it’s one of the best, so they will definitely watch it eventually, so stop whining, just cuz u dislike it

Uchiha With Some Gas

it’s already bombarding, so it’s kinda irrelevant

Uchiha With Some Gas

it’s mainstream for a reason

Uchiha With Some Gas

You guys are correct I dismissed that they’ll only watch the first 40 or some episodes. That obviously changes my opinion on the matter and in that case I’d have zero complaints.

this is one long ass username

I think YLIA is the better choice by far. hope it wins

Thilde

I think you're mixing up One Piece with Rurouni Kenshin.

Merfhew

Anything but one piece. It’s boring even before you know the creator is a pedo.

Elli

Definitely biased as a one piece fan but I’d really like to see y’all’s opinions on the anime compared to the live action and what they changed

Matthew P.

W POLL ONE PIECE TIME

Quadreek Jackson

YLIA is peak tier anime and it's only 24eps

Kevin T

imagine if they make this poll in April LOL.

Hoa Trương

come back here and make your vote actually count LOL sinec MIA clearly have no hope anymore anyways :')

Hoa Trương

We can only hope.

Danny

That's what I'm saying. We need to have a meeting about this 🤣

Danny

Please, not another Mob vs Rezero! 🤣

KaijinGarou

Exactly. You underestimate how intense one piece fans can get. Once they get a taste. 40 episodes won't be enough. And then everything they post will just be bombarded with comments asking when they are gonna continue one piece 😂

Danny

Let's Go Your Lie in April GANG. This about to be a Roller-coaster

KRIS DOMSKI

I am not that into OP now, but got really hooked for the first 550 eps. This show gives me some big emotional moments and one of my favorite anime characters. It would be the best if you would like to try, but I’m also good if you wish to drop nor never start it. The thing I do care is that if you decide to start, you might need to watch more episodes than any of your current shows per week, or it would take too long and got actual issues with your channel contents.

Gill

YLIA might get a chance, we're only 1% less vote right now. Who know ? i sure hope YLIA win though

Hoa Trương

We all know what’s gonna win 🥲

Алта

honestly, your lie in April is able to go neck and neck with OP like this is already show just how much of a good show it is. Only 24 eps and it's on pair with a 1000+ eps big mainstream anime

Hoa Trương

If they decide they like OP (if it wins) and want to continue watching it, I think it should absolutely be up to them. At the end of the day it's THEIR channel and THEIR time, and I think it should be spent with a show they enjoy watching (again, IF they like OP). You made the point of money, and I agree to a certain extent, BUT noone is forcing you to pay. Should they actually start OP, they would probably lose patreons but gain some as well. Additionally, I think taking breaks between arcs and replacing the OP slot with shorter shows is a great idea. I actually like it more than other channels that just binge OP leaving no slots for other shows, because it would still bring variety to the channel (and I'm saying this as a OP fan). All in all, yes, patreons have the power to influence decisions regarding what shows they watch, but the final say should always come from C&A.

emma

Let's hope so <3

Ghost Meep

OP fans are hardcore don't you know XD

Hoa Trương

Why not put one piece in polls with other big animes like you did in the past with hxh? Obviously other shows don’t stand a chance

Алта

All you 18% voting for Made in Abyss, please come back here and make your vote actually count, we need y’all to sort this out 🤣🤣

Zakki

I’ll go for one piece, tho this one will have a totally different pacing (pretty sure that you are aware of it due to the 1000 eps here lol). Your lie is April is also god tier. Both will be great journeys for you.

Gill

I support this! 🤣🤣

Zakki

Sad that made in abyss us doing so bad

RunAwayCloak

@Patrick - It sounds like they'll be pacing themselves. Instead of continuously watching the show until they caught up, they'll take breaks between arcs. I'm not sure if each arc will need to separately win a poll, or if they'll bring the show back when it's convenient for the schedule, but I understand your concern.

Merfhew

this is a poll, so it's not entirely their decision since people pay money for the subcription. So we do have some certain right in choosing a content to watch. Also, they replied in one of my cmt said that if they end up watch OP. They would take a short break after each arc and add other show in that short break. And then come back to OP for another arc and keep going. So OP content will flooding the channel for the next few years whether we like it or not.

Hoa Trương

Hmmm. If you want them to watch 40ish episodes of One Piece (at least for now - they'd be watching future arcs at a later date), great. If you'd rather they skip One Piece entirely, that's fine too. However, I'm a bit perplexed by the "fans will pressure them into watching more" argument that some of you are making. How is that any different from what we're seeing right now? If you're a paying Patron, you have a voice. It's that simple.

Merfhew

I would be very suprised if they stop once they start, the demand will be massive after they start.

Patrick Dawson

Damn, this poll is so tight LOL

Hoa Trương

@Sharles - I'm not sure I understand what "ignore a portion of this channel for years to come" means. Are you saying you watch every single reaction video they drop, but that would change if they watch One Piece?

Merfhew

Nah One piece would be such a comfy chill vibe

Gin T

@Danny - If people are being respectful, I see no issues with anyone supporting or opposing any show (no matter how many episodes).

Merfhew

Hehe the gateway drug worked, ONE PIECE LETS GOOO

DemoniCross

@greenb3ar - To be fair, they already have to deal with OP fans. Pandora's box was opened the moment they watched the live action.

Merfhew

Yoooo, this is neck and neck, guess I should grab my popcorn 🍿

Zackerex

Keyword: eventually. And even if they get stuck watching it, it‘s their decision.

emma

literally says they'll only be doing 44 eps not all 1000+, i don't think they would even want to do all them at once themselves. also as they have stated many times now to you guys using the "taking up slots excuse" they do way more than 1 show at a time so there is still a bunch of variety. if you hate one piece that's fine just watch their other content :)

Callum

Literally scroll down, they’ve already commented that they would still be watching all of it eventually. Do you really think they’d watch one arc then never watch it again? Once they start it they will likely be stuck watching it until this channel probably doesn’t exist anymore.

greenb3ar

Yeah he's got a point. I think one piece started animation in the mid 90's and the animation quality is rough. Not to mention all those filler episodes that they used to put in there to bloat it like Naruto and Bleach.

CornCobBob

I don't know if you know what you're doing to yourself.

CornCobBob

I don't think you came off as douchy at all, but I'm curious to know if your opinion is dependent on how much OP they watch. It specifically says "Episodes 1 - 44," which I assume means they only want to see what the live action covered. Their opinion could change after those 40ish episodes, but for now at least, I don't think the commitment would be too taxing. I understand where you're coming from though.

Merfhew

ikr these guys complaining about it taking up years even tho it clearly states that lol y'all need glasses

Callum

They aren’t going to stop there. HxH is like 10x shorter than OP. It’s longer than most shows I’d prefer, but they still aren’t even comparable. There is the added issue with this plan of having to deal with One Piece fans when an arc ends…

greenb3ar

From what I see, One Piece and YLIA are neck and neck.

Merfhew

Really rooting for OP, I hope you can't resist pausing but understand if you do, but it's gonna be real hard. One piece have the most heart of any show you will probably see :)

johan wejdin

I wish people knew how to read lmao. It literally says 1-44.

emma

@greenb3ar -- Your opinion is absolutely valid, but I think you're exaggerating. It would certainly depend on how they pace themselves, but I don't think 100+ episodes of HxH and 40+ episodes of OP will take them a decade.

Merfhew

Right, but the poll option says Episodes 1 - 44.

Merfhew

Nah we don't 😅 respect to one piece but nahhh

Carlos Cantu

I’m going to be honest here, I believe for us the viewers AND for you two getting into One Piece at this stage is a terrible decision. The show is WAY too long and will suffocate many of us and also the many many slots it will take up due to how long it is. It hasn’t aged all too well and will only be enjoyable for One Piece die hards. Most of the other people will sit and wait for the more "hype" or emotional episodes and it’s basically a big waste of everyone’s time (and in some of our cases even money, rudely speaking). Please reconsider this poll guys and sorry if this came off as douchy.

this is one long ass username

ugh,i got the feeling one piece gonna win this one.. :/

zdravko georgiev

I don't want to shit on one piece, it's one of the most popular anime of all time. But I don't think this is a fair poll, considering how mainstream one piece is it's bound to win over two more niche shows. I genuinly think you would enjoy both the other alternatives more, it's more your type of show, and it's something you can actually complete a watchthrough of, as opposed to a long long long running show like one piece.

StackCanary

Ugh another channel I like potentially being dragged in to the abyss of the stupidly long old shounens with their horrendous pacing. None of them are so good that they should block other amazing things from being watched for like a decade.

greenb3ar

I'd love to see you guys watch Made In Abyss at some point

Jesus

One piece!!!! Plss

Joey Sabishii

Not terribly enthused about losing a slot to one piece for the next 10 yrs tbh

Patrick Dawson

Okay now I'm getting nervous. We need one piece to win 🥹🥹🫠

FatherWeeb

As one who is currently on Marineford Arc trying to catch up, One Peak definitely has my vote.

Zeli

And MiA... is there I guess

Lio

Going into YLiA blind is def great, but I feel like watching One Piece as close to the LA as possible makes more sense.

Lio

Come on guys you know Your lie in april is such a rollercoaster u can not miss that

Amanda Sugatadasa

if one piece wins i recommend "one pace" its pacing is a lot better!!

karin をに

It was very sweet and I also liked it way more than I expected to, but I'm not sure they'd like it that much tbh

Lio

Agreed. I hope they can make time to watch it eventually. It'll be interesting to see their reactions to the ecchi scenes lol

Daisuke

I would love to see you both watch Made In Abyss and Your Lie in April. They're both really good animes with a great story and very different vibes...with maybe some similarities... HOWEVER, this time, for this poll YOUR LIE IN APRIL PLS

Daisuke

somehow it doesnt feel right to have such a long show run along with two other short shows imo, however, the three of them would be nice !! so hopefully at some point even if OP wins you get to watch the other two :D

Lauraa Rodríguez

If possible, I also recommend watching the One Pace version. You won't have much of a problem with fillers at first, since you can easily skip the standalone filler episodes, but around episode 300+ you start to get filler mixed with the arcs themselves (like Naruto) and that's when One Pace really shines, since it keeps the manga's rhythm. This is a really special show and one of the greats, so I think it pays off to have an ideal first watch. One Pace is just an edited version of the original show, so maybe you won't have a problem copyright-wise, since it's practically the same thing, but with even LESS scenes. But again, none of that will be much of an issue for a long while, so you can just dive in with Crunchyroll or whatnot at first I fkn love One Piece

ST Deville

As much as I love one piece. It's too long. And let's be honest the fans would riot and try to pressure them to keep going once they get to episode 44

Danny

Watching One Piece in arcs and then taking a break would be pretty interesting. It’d get unreasonable the further it went on though, some arcs are like 100+ episodes themselves and FEEL like it.

ThaDoubleB

if only for ep 1-44 its a fun way to compare it

Chrisiyyi

nty, sub is just the way, and OP has very serious parts

Chrisiyyi

As someone who was afraid of starting OP for the same reason (I can't commit unless I'm immediately interested), OP got me invested in episode 1. Without spoiling (since the OPLA did remove a lot), you'll most likely get hooked around the 5-8 episodes you mentioned.

Bee

your lie in april is soo good esp for ange w his music background

alexis ♡︎

I hope we can circle back around to my dress up darling some time. It was a lot better than I expected it to be

Crayonz

Voted MiA for the shock value but here's my OP take as a long-time fan: * Don't skip East Blue. Live Action was great but there's enough cuts/changes to make the anime a different watch. * Don't use One Pace. It's not necessary until like episode 337, and even then they like DBZ so maybe the pacing won't bother them. :P * I know typically you wait until finishing a series to react to OP/EDs but given the length of the series you might want to consider something different there. The first OP is pretty special to a lot of fans.

Robert F

Let's be real here guys, you really want to watch One Piece and now after LA it kinda seems like an ideal time to get into it. If you decide to stick with it, I'd probably look into One Pace project as other recommended, it vastly improves the pacing of the original, by cutting out all the fluff, that serves no purpose other than make episodes longer, because it spent most of it's runtime caught up to manga.

Sydonis

Keep up the amazing content guys!! 😁

Nick

I voted for one piece even though i don't like it because i think you guys may like it. It's too cartoonish for me but I think you guys will find that fun. BTW I recommend watching or at least trying it in DUB because a lot of the english VA's are from DBZ and ange is such a fan.

Orochimaru has a giant snake 😳

Yeah

rayan .hamdan

I'm pretty sure they'd only be watching until ep 44 for now.

KaijinGarou

One piece is good but to start on this now when you got so much other stuff to react to. Thats going to be at least a 3 year journey taking up a slot

Hertog

Damn I disliked tje OP live action so much I really want them to get the original one piece experience but Shigatsu wa kimi no uso is actually such a profoundly beautifull and emotionnal anime. I am deeply torn.

Matthias

OMG ONE PIECE😭😭😭❤️

rayan .hamdan

Oh no, please skip east blue lmao you got the gist of it from live action. Start ONE PIECE at the arc AFTER that

MrOuijaII

just watch all of them.. i cant decide man !!!

nikito1

We’d probably take small breaks in between and cover some shorter anime in between the arcs! Something like that

Carlie & Ange

THIS

Hoa Trương

YES!!!

Lauraa Rodríguez

Made in abyss fans. Join our fight against one piece and I pledge my vote to you in the next poll 🙏

Danny

GOOOO~~ your lie in April fans, we're even with OP now. Keep pushing !!!

Hoa Trương

100% agreed

Hoa Trương

big chance they would get curious to know the next plot and keep watching. Or from the pressure from a large amount of OP fans want them to keep going would make them do it, i don't think the fans would let them stop at ep 44. Besides, i think it'll be better if they can watch more diverse genre of anime. Keep thing fresh, they have too many same type actions, shounen anime on their schedule right now. Ange would appreciate another anime that focus on music like YLIA.

Hoa Trương

YOUR LIE IN APRIL

Fixtures .

They’ll probably do another arc later on possibly after hxh

Night Sterling

Only doing 44 episodes

Night Sterling

I mean I’m just going based on what they put on the poll and the fact they said they want a “shorter” series for now presumably because they’re also watching hxh which is 100+ episodes by itself.

Night Sterling

Ange and Carly would have such a big whiplash if they watched OP when they had watched so many awesome anime with smooth butter animation @@

Hoa Trương

Oh nooo, those are all good anime shows. But I'm choosing One Piece in hopes that you'll continue watching after Ep 44. Though I agree with another comment, that maybe you could start One Piece after HxH because it's still a bit longer than other shows

Juri

It's not really the number because I've watch naruto and other long animes, it's just that I'm not really hooked after the 5-8 first eps so my brain don't want me to continue even though I'm sooooo sure I will like it so much if I just keep watching 😭. (sorry for my English I'm french)

Dr. Charlotte

One piece is simply the GOAT. I will never not vote for it

Trent Claycomb

I think this is the perfect place to stop the poll 😂😂😂

FatherWeeb

Damn, onepice? Sad, way too long and boring. 1000 episodes of the smae stuff. MC cant become king of the pirates in 1000 episodes?

Ratticus Earl

You think they would just stop after that ?

Hoa Trương

Interesting to go for one piece when you just watched the live action but could be fun to see your reaction to the “differences” between live action and animated

Night Sterling

Yeah, the thousand episode thing just means I'll have to ignore a portion of this channel for years to come.

Sharles Davis Kendy

Damn, I was really hyped when Your Lie in April won the vote. Would’ve loved to see Ange’s reaction to it.

Sam Brown

They said its gonna be 2 eps an upload so 22 total uploads.

Night Sterling

Oh my god — One Piece! ❤️ I’m so excited! I know a bunch of people already recommended it, but definitely watch One Pace (it cuts out filler/episode recaps that made sense back when binging wasn’t a thing 😂). I haven’t watched it myself, but I heard it’s good ☺️

Katherine Claire

Agreed

iJonShuffle

There are gonna be people who pick OP just so MIA doesnt win my dude 😂

Night Sterling

Made in Abyss is so much better than One Piece imo

Daamon

NOOOO, not OP. Isn't this poll supposed to choose a quick series ? OP is too long and time consuming. Rather give other great niche series a chance than the mainstream stuff like OP. Don't get me wrong, OP is a great shounen manga. But the anime quality is not that good. The slow pacing, drag out fight scene with still image and annoying sound effect @@ they animation only increase to be better recently. Before that it was so hard to watch.

Hoa Trương

I extremely hope your lie in April wins this! Cmon guys vote for it!!

Floch

bro, stop whining, for those reasons there is One Pace

Uchiha With Some Gas

Alice in borderland (Netflix) Pleeeeeeeeeeeease

Black Knight

Watch One Pace the pacing is much much better both reactions(on our side) and your guys enjoyment.

Pruthvi Choudary

it's one of the best, there is no way u wouldn't enjoy it, if u afraid of the number of episode's, i will suggest watching One Pace, it significantly shortens that number

Uchiha With Some Gas

One day people to have taste and see OP is mid and is just loads of poorly paced filler

Aaron Wright

They aren't doing all of op just the first arc

Callum

Omg yes yes yes ye sues yes yes yes yes yes yes yes one peice let's go

Callum

Anything better than mid piece

Aaron Wright

Sadly I have no interest in these long form shounen, specially one piece. I’ll probably dip once 86 is done l, since that’s all ya seem to be doing now

Aaron Wright

don't tell me ur really surprised, it's was in inevitable

Uchiha With Some Gas

Bro why One Piece. It's a good show but NOT as good as the others for a reaction series. It's a slow show so nothing hype or super interesting happens for a while between the climax episodes which is not a bad thing if you're watching a show. One Piece doesnt really have 10/10 episodes but the arcs watched as a whole when you bingewatch is what makes it a 10/10 experience.. But is soooo boring for reaction content imo. I dont want to wait multiple episodes until we get to the good parts. Made in Abyss is short and gets to good episodes fast and Your Lie in April has something worth reacting practically every episode. (Specially with Ange's music background)

Lixien

Absolutely anything but Mushoku is great.

Nymph

Nice! Yeah the arcs are so nicely wrapped up that the story could easily be enjoyed in chunks that way. Hoping it wins so y’all get to experience it 🙏🏽

Daniel Molina

I am willing to bet they get to 44 and then will have the urge to continue

Storm King

Damn you're giving me hope Emma 🤣! I really really really want to watch it 💪

Dr. Charlotte

Let's go, I've been wanting one piece. Be sure to watch more than 1 episode at a time tho

Koirakissa Otsoarvi

The plan would be to react to 2 eps per video, so it would be 22 uploads which is in line with some of the other options. And we loved the live action and the idea of reacting to the anime in parts!!

Carlie & Ange

Just do 1 long series at a time. FInish HxH before starting OP. Better choose from MiA or Your Lie in April. Just my opinion though.

Kaito

Bro ofc one piece will win you talking about the largest manga ever🤣 only a new gen banger would beat it on a poll

Daniel Peedah

This was me, but after I watched OPLA I breezed through east blue so fast. 😭

emma

There's an amazing fan project called "One Pace" that pretty much cuts all filler content from one piece and edits everything to keep it more in line with the Manga. It might be worth checking it out, although I'm not sure all the sagas are finished yet, it's a LOT faster to watch this way (and you miss pretty much nothing as the pacing gets much better) This project is kind of a blessing actually

NikoCat11

i know but my heart just wants another confirmation lmao

bebe

omg i can't choose between your lie in april and one piece😭

beannieswife

Please consider watching the One Pace recut of One Piece if possible, it cuts out a lot of unnecessary time consuming stuff

arual tu'cliist

It says they’re going to try implementing it

emma

like see the options for the poll because they wanted some lighthearted ones

bebe

Voting for OP because I hope that'll help me watch it. I'm so sure I could like it but I have trouble starting it 😭. My adhd is a pain in the ass for things like this!

Dr. Charlotte

I’d like to see you guys watch and react to Hell’s Paradise in the future or Tower of God

Jesus Rocha

Dang, no way One Piece doesn’t take this poll in an absolute landslide (even if made in abyss and Your Lie are both great shows)

FTN Chicken

Sheesh one piece winning over MiA?

WeightOfTheWorld2049

Grosssssss one piece is winning 😔😔

Carlos Cantu

Carlie and Ange: “we are looking for a short show to start” Also Carlie and Ange: “but one piece is calling” LETS GOOO 😂🔥

Daniel Molina

r u only committing to the first 44 eps of One Piece? Or will u possibly be watching beyond that afterwards?

Allan Samano

ONE PIECEEEEE

emma

I want Made in ABYSS to win however the other options are really good too hahaahah :c

OGthekila

One piece is way too long. Your lie in April is just perfect 😭

falconnn

Oh my gosh! Please don't tease me with the east blue! AAAHHHHHHH

FatherWeeb

Advice : watch One Pace. That Toei animation pacing 20 years ago was mad annoying, I’m saying this for your mental health

Salahadine Abaine

Haikyuuu

Iosua Valean

ofc one piece would slap those other shows, what r u expecting? 💀💀💀

Uchiha With Some Gas

One piece for sure

Storm King

your lie in april plss!!!!

Aditya Raj

THE ONE PIECE IS REAL!!

Tristan Scholtens

Omg One Piece!!!!

Zackerex

One piece!!!! 🍊☠️

Jesus Ascencio

oh so sad, i was ready to vote for more eps ahahaha but please tell me we do will get more right??? 🌝

bebe