What if Phoebe was punished instead of Sarah?

Mother and daughter walked back into the house, Cynthia sighed as she led her daughter straight to the dining room. Cynthia pulled out two dining room chairs and placed them in the center of the room, she indicated for Sarah to sit down on one as she sat on the other while Phoebe listened intently from her bedroom. In this universe Phoebe’s eagerness to provoke her sister caused her to leave her room as soon as she heard them sit down, she walked into the dining room with a cheeky smile “So what’s wrong with her?” she asked. Sarah shook her head in frustration as Cynthia looked over at Phoebe “They don’t know” she said out of frustration as Phoebe walked in between her mother and sister and cocked her head “They don’t know? She has been wetting the bed for three weeks and they don’t know why?” she said with a smile.

Cynthia frowned as she looked up at her daughter “Three weeks?” she asked Phoebe, Sarah looked at her mum confused “Why is she asking her that? What has that got to do with it?” she wondered as Phoebe nervously nodded “Yeah that’s right isn’t it?” she asked. Cynthia slowly nodded “Yeah but how do you know that?” she asked as Sarah’s eyes widened and she looked up at her younger sister “Yeah how do you know that? I never told you it had been three weeks and mother only found that out at the doctors!” she half shouted. Phoebe swallowed hard “I erm I mean you must have told me” she said as sweat formed on her forehead, Cynthia frowned “I know how to get the truth out of you” she shouted as she quickly took hold of Phoebe’s arm and pulled her daughter over her knee. Phoebe yelled out as she stared down at the floor while she began to shake nervously as Sarah sat in stunned silence as she watched on with a slight smile “No way she going to do this, it's what she deserves though” she thought as she watched Phoebe try to get up off her mother's lap. Cynthia held her smaller and weaker daughter down with just one hand on her lower back as Sarah shook her head knowing what was about to happen “She has spanked me and Phoebe many times when growing up especially if she knew we were lying, but she hasn’t spanked me Phoebe for a few years now. Is she really going to do it now?” she wondered. Phoebe kept perfectly quiet as she continued to try and get off her mother's lap until she brought down her hand onto Phoebe’s bum.

Phoebe let out a groan as the pain started emanating from her bum, Cynthia continued spanking her daughter with ease as Sarah watched on “I can’t believe she is spanking her but if she has anything to do with me wetting the bed for the last three weeks its what she deserves” she thought. The spanking continued until Phoebe finally shouted out “Fine, Yes I did it!” which caused Cynthia to stop and frown “You did what?” she asked. Phoebe shook her head as she let out a sigh “I made Sarah wet her bed, I would go into her room with a glass of warm water and put her hand in it every night” she said out of frustration. Sarah sprang up from her seat “You did this?!” she shouted as she balled up her fists, Cynthia nodded her head at Sarah “I understand you’re angry, leave this to me, please” she said calmly. Sarah looked up at the ceiling and shook her head “I broke up with my boyfriend because of this, I thought something was wrong with me. I’ve been stressing over this for weeks and it was her!  she shouted in her head. She took a deep breath “All I want to do is hit her but I know our mother and she will have something else in mind” she thought as she released her fists and looked down at her mother and sighed “Fine” she said.

Cynthia nodded as she patted her daughter's bottom “Good” she said to Sarah as she gave Phoebe one last swat on her behind and let her up. Phoebe stood in front of her mother rubbing her very sore bottom while looking at the floor not wanting to look at her mother or Sarah. Cynthia stood up and took hold of Phoebe’s hand and placed her in the chair she was just sitting in, she took hold of Sarah’s hand and lead her up “I need you to get something” she said. Sarah frowned “What?” she asked as Cynthia walked into the kitchen and grabbed a stein glass from the cupboard, she turned on the tap and filled the large glass up to the brim and walked back to Phoebe “Take this” she said. Phoebe looked at the large glass puzzled but took hold of it “Drink, I want it finished by the time I get back” she said as Phoebe let out a sigh and lifted the glass up to her mouth. Cynthia led Sarah back towards the front door and took her purse out of her bag as she leaned in and whispered into Sarah’s ear “I want you to go to the pharmacist and get a bag of adult diapers”. Sarah’s eyes widened as she let out a splutter “What?” she asked while shaking her head “Trust me” Cynthia said as she gave Sarah her bank card. Sarah shook her head as she took the card “Right any kind?” she asked, Cynthia smiled “Thicker the better” she said. She turned around leaving the stunned Sarah standing at the front door “Really diapers? What does she have planned? I really want to find out” she thought with a smile while Cynthia announced “Ah good you’ve finished let's get you another one”.

Sarah walked into the house carrying the bag of diapers “I hope these are what she wants, I had no idea there were so many different ones but these comfidry’s should be right” she thought as she closed the door behind her. Sarah walked into the dining room and was surprised to see Phoebe drinking from the stein glass “That her second?” she asked her mother who was standing over her with her arms crossed. Cynthia shook her head “Her sixth drink” she said with a smile as Sarah’s eyes widened “Wow” she said as she placed the diapers on the table. Phoebe choked on the water at the sight of the bag of diapers “What the hell are they?!” she shouted out, Cynthia turned to Sarah and smiled “Thank you for getting these Sarah, now can you go to your room for a while, me and Phoebe need to have a talk” she said calmly. Sarah swallowed as she nodded and turned towards the hallway that lead to her bedroom “What does she have planned? Why did she make her drink all that water? Is she going to make her wear the diaper? Is she going to make her wet the diaper? I’m so glad I’m not her right now” she thought as she entered her bedroom.

Sarah was lying on her bed a great weight had been lifted from her shoulders as she watched the office on her TV “Right I need to get Ben back, on Monday after work I will go and get a new phone and get in touch with him and arrange to meet up. Hopefully everything will be alright” she thought when there was a knock on her door. “Come in” she said and the door opened, her mother stood in the doorway with a smile “You’re safe to come out now, I’ve made sandwiches, I really think you would want to have them in the living room” she said. Sarah frowned “OK?” she questioned as she got up from her bed and followed her mother down the hallway “What has happened? What has she done to Phoebe?” she wondered as she followed her mother into the dining room where her sandwiches were waiting. She picked up her food “Do I really want to see what has happened? I kinda do, even if it's her in diapers. Hell it could have been me if she hadn’t blurted out her secret” she thought as she continued into the living room. Sarah entered the living room and noticed from the corner of her eye Phoebe sitting on the sofa, she turned to look at her and stood perfectly still, an involuntary laugh escaped her as she stared at her younger sister. Phoebe was pouting as she sat on the sofa wearing the largest diaper Sarah had ever seen. Sarah shook her head “That can’t be one?” she blurted out, Cynthia smiled “Nope, she is wearing six. One for every stein she finished” she said cheerfully. Sarah shook her head in disbelief as she slowly walked towards her sister when she noticed tape wrapped around her waist, layers and layers of black duct tape were covering the diaper “Why the tape?” she asked. Cynthia nodded “That’s to stop her taking it off, I might use something else if this becomes more permanent” she said as Phoebe’s eyes widened and she shook her head in disapproval.

Sarah woke up and smiled as she lay in her bed “Yes it's the weekend, a day of relaxing and then off to see Ben tonight” she said to herself as she rubbed the sleep from her eyes. She looked over at her clock and raised her eyes “Wow 11 am I really must have needed that sleep” she said as she removed her sheets revealing her black pajama shirt and short black and white striped shorts, she looked down at her shirt that read ‘Let me sleep’ and smiled “Well I definitely did” she said to herself. She got out of bed and stretched while letting out a groan “I’m starving” she said as she turned to leave her room. She walked down the hallway to the dining room when she heard the familiar sound of rustling coming from the living room, she shook her head with a smile as she watched Phoebe waddle out from the living room carrying an empty bowel. Sarah looked at her sister wearing her black shirt with the large fairy tail logo on it and the pink plastic panties that were locked around her waist. Phoebe frowned as she waddled towards her “What you looking at?” she asked Sarah smiled as she shook her head “Nothing” she said as she walked into the kitchen and pulled out a bowel and poured herself some cereal while Phoebe washed her own bowl in the sink. Phoebe waddled back towards the living room with Sarah following behind, she looked down at Phoebe’s large padded bum and frowned as she got a whiff from its contents “When are you going to change out of that?” she asked while shaking her head in disgust. Phoebe signed as she entered the living room and looked at her mother who was sitting on the sofa “When am I going to change out of this?” she asked. Cynthia shook her head “Not for a while, it will teach you a lesson not to waste them and to only remove your diaper after you have used it” she said firmly.

Phoebe sighed as she slowly sat down on the sofa, grimacing the entire time she lowered herself onto her messy bum, Sarah sat on the opposite sofa beside her mother and began to eat her cereal. She looked up at her diapered sister and shook her head “It’s been two weeks today since she was first put back into diapers, I can’t believe it was only meant to be for that day but our mother didn’t think Phoebe had learned her lesson so she extended it to three weeks. The same amount of time she tricked me into wetting the bed. I feel a little bit sorry for her, she has to wear and use a diaper at all times, it must be so embarrassing for her but I wonder if mother will extend it now that she removed her diaper before she used it, that’s why she is now wearing the locking panties to make sure she doesn’t do that again. I wonder if she has learned her lesson and won't try something like that again? I still don’t know what she was trying to accomplish with doing it and I probably will never know” she thought as the small family watched TV.